Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholics Tithing? :gasp:


Wonder of Wonders - Do Catholics tithe?  

38 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Groo the Wanderer
Posted (edited)

I am asking this because my pastor was joking in the homily this week that if his parish every started tithing, we would have to call the Bishop and ask for a new priest...because he would die from the shock. Then we would have to call the Pope and ask for a new bishop because HE would die of shock upon hearing about a Catholic parish tithing.


Twas funny, but it made me wonder a bit.

PLEASE - do not leave comments about how much you give. This is NOT a pat-self-on-the-back/Pharisee thing. Also, tithing is a faith journey in itself - it is scary at first and hard to get there. The effort and the journey are to be applauded and encouraged.

Edited by Groo the Wanderer
Posted

I didn't vote in the poll because I think asking the question "exactly how much" question shouldn't be asked even privately.

For the record I do contribute to the Church fiancally. Isn't a sin not to if you're capable?

Spamity Calamity
Posted (edited)

Heh Heh, my finaces baptist mother thought that the Catholic church did tithing. I was like "ummm...No." and she was like "but the mormons do it" :huh: . I dropped the conversation because I was scared to think she might honestly think Catholics and Mormons were similar and I wouldnt know what to do with her if that was true.

Edited by Spamity Calamity
Posted

Around in these parts tithing is 10% of your income given to the church.
And no I do not do so. I do not find churches make very good use of their money and give only a small portion to my church.
At my friends parish they just built a new rectory, cost more then a million dollars. Large screen tv's, leather furniture and marble bathrooms do not equate with living a life devoted to Chist to me. All this for ONE priest. I find charities who effectively reach the causes I believe in.

Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1411034' date='Oct 29 2007, 08:11 AM']I am asking this because my pastor was joking in the homily this week that if his parish every started tithing, we would have to call the Bishop and ask for a new priest...because he would die from the shock. Then we would have to call the Pope and ask for a new bishop because HE would die of shock upon hearing about a Catholic parish tithing.
Twas funny, but it made me wonder a bit.

PLEASE - do not leave comments about how much you give. This is NOT a pat-self-on-the-back/Pharisee thing. Also, tithing is a faith journey in itself - it is scary at first and hard to get there. The effort and the journey are to be applauded and encouraged.[/quote]

At one of my old parishes the pastor suggested giving 5% to the church, 1% to the diocese and 4% to other charities.

kenrockthefirst
Posted (edited)

My wife and I contribute both financially as well as our time and talent (admittedly, she's the talented one who contributes her time).

When I was in the "born again" world, tithing meant 10% of your income. Net or gross was never made clear, and I vacillated between the two. In the Catholic world, 10% - net or gross - isn't even on the radar. When we lived in Ireland, folks would give maybe IRL£1 in the collection basket on a Sunday, and the bishops had to beg people to give €2 when Ireland cut over to the Euro since €1 only equaled IRL£.78.

Edited by kenrockthefirst
Posted

Does having student loans and no current job make one's income negative?

I don't pay attention to percentages... I try to give a little every week. Or for example this past summer when I did have a job I think I realized that I hadn't given anything since I started working so I put in a little more than usual.

:idontknow:

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

I do give financially, but I was never a particularly dedicated or methodical donor until I started going to Mass at the student chaplaincy. We have a tiny chapel where the Blessed Sacrament is reserved and a dusty, drab, brown-brick old hall to have Mass in on Sundays. No pews. Just plastic chairs. An altar on wheels so it can be moved in and out of the little chapel easily. For years it's been hard enough just to keep the chaplaincy afloat - the value of the place is in the people. I've never been part of such a joyful Christian community before. Being with these people has inspired me to want to give more money and to feel excited about the possibilities for that money: as a result of our appeal, soon we won't have to hire the hall out to traders during the week any more and one day we will have a proper church on that site.

The church in my home parish is so breathtakingly beautiful that it's hard for me to picture the basic living costs (heating, lighting, maintenance, etc.) in my head. This makes me much less enthusiastic about giving. I have to remind myself that even a church with stunning marble floors and a Pellegrini crucifix has quite significant everyday costs to meet.

Posted

The poll doesn't work right. You can't not select something for the second question. So, for someone who votes "no" for the first one, they have to "lie" for the second one.

Posted

My dad once said that Catholics aren't expected to tithe like the Protestants because we have more kids to support. I think we give about 3% to the church another 3% to other Catholic Charities, and the rest of our tithe comes from time and talent.

Posted

I put a few dollars in the basket. My mommy taught me. :mellow:

No, seriously, I agree with Alice that in many situations, the money isn;t used properly. If I had the funds (thanks, college!), charity sounds like a better idea.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1411034' date='Oct 29 2007, 10:11 AM']I am asking this because my pastor was joking in the homily this week that if his parish every started tithing, we would have to call the Bishop and ask for a new priest...because he would die from the shock. Then we would have to call the Pope and ask for a new bishop because HE would die of shock upon hearing about a Catholic parish tithing.[/quote]

Did he offer any teaching on tithing (besides the fact that you're supposed to do it) or anything about related matters, like financial management?

Got a feeling the lame jokes ain't gonna change anything.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

No. He mentioned it in passing. It was not the main part of the homily.


I would recommend Dave Ramsey (google him) for a solid Christ-based financial planner.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

No. He mentioned it in passing. It was not the main part of the homily.


I would recommend Dave Ramsey (google him) for a solid Christ-based financial planner.

Posted

My parish does the tithing thing.

By the way, tithing is off of gross not net income.

Posted

I remember when I was growing up that the parish envelopes had a statement requesteing one hour's wages. Of course, the parish collected a "pew fee" as well every week.

Although 10% is a good round number that is also a good goal, please be aware that in the NT there is a part in 2 Corinthians that talks about something to the effect of how what you give should not make somneone else rich while impoverishing you.

Additionally, I think part of the problem is that people don't go to Mass every Sunday and Holy Day like they are supposed to. Increase attendance, and you should see an increase in the amount in the collection plate.

Birgitta Noel
Posted

We're paying off bills right now so we give less to the "Church" than we "should". Just for the record I don't consider giving to the Church to be limited just to giving to one's parish. There are many other ways to support the work of the Church. For example, we support a particular religious community who we know uses funds carefully and the Archdiocese for the Military.

Our old parish let you do an auto-deduction from checking or use a credit card set up on an auto charge. I really liked that as it meant our money went into the collection regardless of WHERE we attended mass that weekend due to our schedules. Our new Church only does auto-deduction. I'm not as big of a fan but still do it as it saves the Church from printing envelopes -- Which I understand are quite pricey!

Posted

[quote name='The Little Way' post='1411334' date='Oct 29 2007, 09:12 PM']We're paying off bills right now so we give less to the "Church" than we "should". Just for the record I don't consider giving to the Church to be limited just to giving to one's parish. There are many other ways to support the work of the Church. For example, we support a particular religious community who we know uses funds carefully and the Archdiocese for the Military.

Our old parish let you do an auto-deduction from checking or use a credit card set up on an auto charge. I really liked that as it meant our money went into the collection regardless of WHERE we attended mass that weekend due to our schedules. Our new Church only does auto-deduction. I'm not as big of a fan but still do it as it saves the Church from printing envelopes -- Which I understand are quite pricey![/quote]
that's what we do too! ^_^

ps the envelopes are pretty expensive

Posted

i don't like how the time/talent is EITHER to the financial. its supposed to be all three <_<


they all count, and everyone should give in all areas to the best of their abilities.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted
:clap:

yay! you are absotootly correct Kateri! It should be all three. My personal opinion (note: not a magesterial teaching) is that if you do not have the means or the will to do the full 10%, make it up with time and talent. The Lord needs many, many workers in His vineyards.....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...