CatholicCid Posted November 1, 2007 Posted November 1, 2007 (edited) A little background on the Poll please? Do some Eastern Catholics not acknowledge such things? They seem kind of open questions... IE - The last poll question could be taken to mean Faith in general or the use of the Filoque in the Creed (Which, to my knowledge, some Rites do not include it, yet believe, which is allowed.) Or, the "Consecratory power of the Words of Institution", which I do believe reading an article where I believe one Eastern Rite uses a formula where parts of the Eucharistic Rite may be slightly different, but is allowable by Rome. I'd have to research for that one. Edited November 1, 2007 by CatholicCid
aalpha1989 Posted November 1, 2007 Posted November 1, 2007 On the consecration, I always thought Eastern Catholics believed that consecration actually happened during the epiclesis (if i spelled it wrong don't hurt me). i'm no authority on the subject.
Resurrexi Posted November 1, 2007 Author Posted November 1, 2007 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1412745' date='Nov 1 2007, 02:07 PM']A little background on the Poll please? Do some Eastern Catholics not acknowledge such things? They seem kind of open questions... IE - The last poll question could be taken to mean Faith in general or the use of the Filoque in the Creed (Which, to my knowledge, some Rites do not include it, yet believe, which is allowed.) Or, the "Consecratory power of the Words of Institution", which I do believe reading an article where I believe one Eastern Rite uses a formula where parts of the Eucharistic Rite may be slightly different, but is allowable by Rome. I'd have to research for that one.[/quote] Some Eastern Christians who claim to be Catholic do not acknowledge the doctrines mentioned in the poll. And in the poll, I mean faith in general, not whether it is acceptable to not say the word "Filioque" in the Creed.
Resurrexi Posted November 1, 2007 Author Posted November 1, 2007 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1412778' date='Nov 1 2007, 03:49 PM']On the consecration, I always thought Eastern Catholics believed that consecration actually happened during the epiclesis (if i spelled it wrong don't hurt me). i'm no authority on the subject.[/quote] No Eastern Catholic [i]should[/i] believe that the Transubstantiation happens at the Epiklesis.
CatholicCid Posted November 1, 2007 Posted November 1, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1412782' date='Nov 1 2007, 03:54 PM']Some Eastern Christians who claim to be Catholic do not acknowledge the doctrines mentioned in the poll. And in the poll, I mean faith in general, not whether it is acceptable to not say the word "Filioque" in the Creed.[/quote] Are they Eastern Catholic lay people? I'm sure there would be documents out there really stating these things clearly, most likely from the time each Rite that was away from the Church returned to communion with the Church. Of course, some have never broken so I would think that would be a clear stance on this positions to these issues.
Resurrexi Posted November 1, 2007 Author Posted November 1, 2007 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1412796' date='Nov 1 2007, 04:25 PM']Are they Eastern Catholic lay people? I'm sure there would be documents out there really stating these things clearly, most likely from the time each Rite that was away from the Church returned to communion with the Church. Of course, some have never broken so I would think that would be a clear stance on this positions to these issues.[/quote] Yes, there are. Most of the Council of Florence is one of them. There are also various ones from the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries, but recently there has been a move by some Eastern Catholics to deny many Catholic truths which have been believed by all Catholics, Eastern and Western, since time immemorial.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 5, 2007 Posted November 5, 2007 Since most of us are not eastern catholics we are not the people to answer this. I suggest you join an eastern catholic baord or consult an eastern catholic priest or theologian and find out.
Resurrexi Posted November 6, 2007 Author Posted November 6, 2007 I already know the answer... it's pretty simple and found in almost all documents of the magisterium on the matter.
-I---Love Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 (edited) The answers seem obvious so is there something I'm missing here? Edited November 6, 2007 by -I---Love
cmotherofpirl Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 [quote name='-I---Love' post='1415140' date='Nov 5 2007, 11:57 PM']The answers seem obvious so is there something I'm missing here?[/quote] Never trust the obvious at phatmass...
Resurrexi Posted November 8, 2007 Author Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='Oik' post='1415756' date='Nov 7 2007, 01:23 PM']The first two questions are worded wrong. Fin[/quote] how so?
Oik Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote]Is it necessary for Catholics of the Eastern Churchs to hold the docrines dogmatically defined by the last fourteen Oecumenical Councils and by the Supreme Pontiffs?[/quote] [quote]Then, therefore, must Eastern Catholics believe in such doctrines as the primacy of the Roman Pontiff and the infallibility of the same, the Immaculate Conception and Assumption of the Mother of God, the consecratory power of the Words of Instiution, and the procession of the Holy Ghost from the Father and the Son as from a single principle?[/quote] Do you have an agenda or a point to prove here? Just say if you do.
Apotheoun Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='Oik' post='1416172' date='Nov 8 2007, 10:11 AM']Do you have an agenda or a point to prove here? Just say if you do.[/quote] As a "traditionalist" in the Latin Church, his agenda is to force Byzantine Catholics to accept Western doctrinal formulations.
Apotheoun Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote]Is it necessary for Catholics of the Eastern Churchs to hold the docrines dogmatically defined by the last fourteen Oecumenical Councils and by the Supreme Pontiffs?[/quote] As a Byzantine Catholic I do not accept the fourteen Latin Church councils as ecumenical.
Apotheoun Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 (edited) [quote]Then, therefore, must Eastern Catholics believe in such doctrines as the primacy of the Roman Pontiff and the infallibility of the same . . .[/quote] As far as the primacy of the bishop of Rome is concerned, I accept the doctrine of primacy as it was "formulated and lived in the first millennium" [Joseph Carinal Ratzinger, [u]Principles of Catholic Theology[/u], page 199], while I reject the modifications to that doctrine that have arisen in the West over the course of the second millennium (including the teaching of the First Vatican Council). [quote]. . . the Immaculate Conception . . .[/quote] No man, in Eastern theology, is born with a stain of sin upon his soul; and so, there is no need for an "immaculate conception" in Byzantine theology. It is important to remember that Eastern Christians do not accept the Augustinian view of the nature of the "original sin", which is ultimately the source of the Western theory of the "immaculate conception." [quote]. . . Assumption of the Mother of God . . .[/quote] The Dormition (i.e., the falling asleep) of the Holy Theotokos and her Assumption into heaven are accepted as pious theologoumena in the Eastern Churches. [quote]. . . the consecratory power of the Words of Institution . . .[/quote] The Eastern Churches (both Catholic and Orthodox) have never accepted the Western theory which holds that the words of institution consecrate the Eucharistic elements offered during the divine liturgy into the body and blood of Christ; instead, the East holds that the whole Eucharistic anaphora, and in particular the epiklesis, is consecratory. [quote]. . . and the procession of the Holy Ghost from the Father and the Son as from a single principle?[/quote] The idea that the Father and the Son are a single principle in the existential procession ([i]ekporeusis[/i]) of the Holy Spirit is a form of the Sabellian heresy, and as such it is unacceptable to Eastern Christians. In Byzantine theology the Father alone is the source ([i]pege[/i]), principle ([i]arche[/i]), and cause ([i]aitia[/i]) of the hypostaseis of the Son and the Spirit. Edited November 8, 2007 by Apotheoun
CatholicCid Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1416230' date='Nov 8 2007, 03:14 PM']The Eastern Churches (both Catholic and Orthodox) have never accepted the Western theory which holds that the words of institution consecrate the Eucharistic elements offered during the divine liturgy into the body and blood of Christ; instead, the East holds that the whole Eucharistic anaphora, and[b] in particular the epiklesis[/b], is consecratory.[/quote] If I may ask, why do you say the bolded? If if the whole prayer is seen as consecratory, why put 'emphasis' on a single part of the prayer? God Bless. Edited November 8, 2007 by CatholicCid
Apotheoun Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1416233' date='Nov 8 2007, 12:25 PM']If I may ask, why do you say the bolded? If if the whole prayer is seen as consecratory, why put 'emphasis' on a single part of the prayer? God Bless.[/quote] I say that because in Byzantine theology it is the Spirit (who has been called down upon the gifts) that changes the elements into the body and blood of Christ, just as He caused the conception of the God-man in the womb of the Theotokos.
CatholicCid Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1416242' date='Nov 8 2007, 03:40 PM']I say that because in Byzantine theology it is the Spirit (who has been called down upon the gifts) that changes the elements into the body and blood of Christ, just as He caused the conception of the God-man in the womb of the Theotokos.[/quote] So, would it be accurate to say that, in Byzantine theology, that the Holy Spirit descends on the gifts at the point of the Epiklesis during the prayers of Consecration? God Bless.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now