Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Alright, as promised in my debate table thread, I said I would start some dialogue with formulating an argument/a presentation for my youth ministry peers concerning music in the mass: that is, taking out the praise and worship music from the mass setting (can't stress this point enough. I don't care about any other time), and including some stuff along the lines of the traditional style, which is simple (to start). Basically, what I want to do here is remove the debate element, and focus on giving something that could be said in about 5-10 minutes, over-viewing what 1: church documents say and 2: talk on musical aesthetics. I think I'd best start with some documents because it's straight forward. What I ask is for some resources primarily, and then for the latter half of my argument, maybe Philip and all those who are in support of my work help come up with a bit of a friendly argument? Now, disclaimer about the second part: I have no authority to preach, so I want to stay away from going all out on my friends. I suggest that we come up with some basic reasons to go down this beaten path that is traditional music (even though no one in my group 'cept me can read music), and we could also study possible rebuttals. Thanks. I hope this is clear enough.

God bless.

Posted

If do a search for threads by Cam42 about sacred music, you'll find a lot of citations from Church documents

Posted

Thanks, but I'm sucky at using the search engine, and I was sorta hoping to get a hand w/ this with some people. But in the mean time, what key words should i use?

Posted

here's a pretty good thread. I'll try to find more. [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=32401&st=0&start=0"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...t=0&start=0[/url]

Posted

This also might be of help:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=49508&st=0&p=916793&#entry916793"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...mp;#entry916793[/url]

  • 2 weeks later...
Guest KevinSymonds
Posted

I would love to be of some assistance in your endeavor.

A rough outline usually begin as follows:

Pope Pius X's Encyclical "[i]Tra le Solicitudini[/i]." Almost ALL discussion on liturgical music goes back to this foundational document. It paved the way for every pope up to [b]and including[/b] Vatican II.

Pope Pius XII is the next big authority. He had, or wrote it himself, a document on Sacred/Liturgical music in the early to mid 1950's. It depends upon Pius X.

Chapter 6 of Vatican II's "[i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i]" deals exclusively with Sacred/Liturgical Music. It upholds Gregorian Chant as having pride of place in the Roman Liturgy. Reading it carefully, one can clearly see it builds upon Pius X through using his language and even quoting from it.

Pope Paul VI's "[i]Musicam Sacram[/i]." He upholds the sacrality of the Chant and that it must continue but also goes further to discuss how modern needs require some adaptation.

John Paul II's November 2003 "Chirograph" on Pius X's "[i]Tra le Solicitudini[/i]."

Pope Benedict XVI has given important directions on Sacred Music. See his June 24th 2006 comments to Domenico Bartolucci. I believe they are available on the Vatican's web site. The remarks created quite a stir last year and he continues to make even more as time goes on.

Also, if you want a decent outline of the historical problems we face with the state of Sacred Music today, there is an excellent essay written by Msgr. Richard J. Schuler. It is entitled "A Chronicle of the Reform" and published in the book "Cum Angelis Canere." It is reproduced online: [url="http://www.ceciliaschola.org/pdf/chron.pdf"]http://www.ceciliaschola.org/pdf/chron.pdf[/url] I should give you fair warning. This essay is earth-shattering and you will not think the same way about modern music and the Liturgy ever again.

Funny, but I hadn't learned Msgr. Schuler died on April 20th of this year. I am sure the man went straight to heaven with all the suffering he did in this life. He was one of the greats who kept alive the flame of common sense regarding Liturgical Music.

-Kevin Symonds

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Kevin,

Thank you! I own a copy of that essay by Msgr. Schuler and I can't think of a better resource for getting the low down on the sacred music. Excellent!

Peace.

Guest KevinSymonds
Posted

It is truly a wonderful reference. May he rest in peace.

-KJS

Posted

Thank you so much for that outline. I'm going to work heavily on it for the next couple of days and I will post it here. I hope that you and L_D (and Phillip if he has time) could critique it. I have pretty much set in stone that I am presenting something on traditional music this Thursday at our meeting, and I hope that people will listen. Some seem interested now that the word is out, but I know people have different expectations. I hope to surprise but bring interest. I want to be charitable and truthful. Please pray for me. This is crucial stuff, and I am quite passionate about this. I totally want solemn masses, and I am willing to teach my peers the music. It will be good practice for university anyways :P. I hope to get into a career in music teaching.

Posted

[quote name='KevinSymonds' post='1417882' date='Nov 11 2007, 08:46 PM']...
Also, if you want a decent outline of the historical problems we face with the state of Sacred Music today, there is an excellent essay written by Msgr. Richard J. Schuler. It is entitled "A Chronicle of the Reform" and published in the book "Cum Angelis Canere." It is reproduced online: [url="http://www.ceciliaschola.org/pdf/chron.pdf"]http://www.ceciliaschola.org/pdf/chron.pdf[/url] I should give you fair warning. This essay is earth-shattering and you will not think the same way about modern music and the Liturgy ever again.
...[/quote]
Yay, now you got me exited in reading it.

Guest KevinSymonds
Posted

Liturgical music, while not my field of study, happens to be a particular interest of mine. I would be glad to read what you write.

I should warn you though, I am a straight-shooter when it comes to these things. It isn't personal but I just speak right to the point.

-KJS

Posted

Wow. I finished the essay. That was amazing. It was difficult to read in one sitting cause it was painful to read of the decay of all the work that was put into previously. I really found it interesting about the paradox though, that, as how Mnsr. Sculler put it, 'by saying all music is sacred does not make the music sacred, but makes all music unsacred' (paraphrase). It's sort a Chesterton paradox. Well, I have my work cut out for me. I think I will take up this cup and try and bring some tradition back. Good thing is I'm not alone, and my diocese is good for tradition, because they're getting an older friend of mine to go in and teach our "discerning gentlemen" (ie those in our house of discernment program) Gregorian chant. These guys can't sing now, but it can be practiced. I try to encourage them to do this stuff. They are the future. I am part of the future. My fellow youth ministers are part of the future. We gotta start now.

Posted

Okay, so here is my presentation in all of it's (or absence of) majesty. Here's the scoop. I've only been given 15 minutes cause apparently they wanna get into their guitar stuff w/ some "former" music director so I'm giving a brief history, and mentioning some councils, then I'm just goona pile homework on them. Also, in between I'm going to play some chant and polyphony so they know exactly what I'm talking about. No missconceptions. Btw I'm presenting this tomorrow evening. Okay, here we go...

----------------------------


Greetings and salutations everyone. I am presenting to you a talk about traditional sacred music, namely some background and history, and what the Church says concerning it’s use. Before we delve into this vast subject, I ask that we pray first. In the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, amen. Lord Jesus, thank you for bringing us together this evening, and thank you for revealing to us your truth. I ask that you may open our hearts and minds tonight in this discussion on sacred music, and that we do your will, and follow what your bride, Holy Mother Church has to say on this matter. I ask that you bless us all with graces, especially humility, love and zeal. Amen. St. Cecilia, pray for us In the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, amen.

The first thing I want to talk about is the history of Gregorian Chant, “plainsong” or “plainchant” (deriving from the old French “plein chant”, meaning “full singing”). The concept goes back before the church, originally coming from Jewish worship in the synagogues. The music developed and became prominent in the 6th century, when Pope Gregory the Great had all of the chant repertoire compiled together. It became an essential part of monastic life, where chants were composed, memorized and developed for the liturgies. Eventually, chants were written down on this early staff system [refer to a handout], which is the ancestor of our modern musical staff. Gregorian Chant is a vast field of music, thus will take another talk to explain, but I will briefly go over uses of plainsong. Aside from the Liturgy of the Hours, plainsong is written for the Holy Mass. In the Holy Mass, there are two types of chant that occur there: the Proper and the Ordinary. The Proper consists of chants written specifically for each feast day, therefore covers the Introit, Gradual, Alleluia, Tract, Sequence, Offertory and Communion. The ordinaries are fixed chants, meaning they do not change during the liturgical year. The Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus, Benedictus and Agnus Dei are the chanted ordinaries. Now I’m going to play some Gregorian chant sung by the Benedictine Monks of Santo Domingo de Silos. Take note of the style of the music, that is the fluent movement of the notes, the absence of a regular pulse like our modern music, giving a continual feeling to the music.

The next type of traditional music I want to talk about is sacred polyphony (polyphony meaning there is more than one important melody happening at once in a piece). Sacred polyphony has its roots in Gregorian Chant due to musicians improvising harmonies underneath the melody. A prominent school of this early polyphony was from the Notre Dame Cathedral in France dating about the middle ages. about the 16th century, polyphony was at it’s height, with the leading composer being Palestrina. Polyphony was adapted for the mass, mainly the ordinaries, as well as other bodies of work. The thought behind the whole movement of polyphony was that the multiple voices coming in at different times represented the chorus of angels singing their unending praise to God. That is what composers had in mind when the wrote the music.

Now, this is all great stuff, but what does the Church say about it’s relevance? Pope Pius X wrote an encyclical on the instruction of sacred music in 1903 called Tra le Sollecitudini. This was written partly because there were musical abuses in the church, in the form of Operatic style music in Italy, and medocracy in composing other bodies of work such as hymns. In the encyclical, he outlined that Gregorian chant is “the Chant proper to the Roman Church... which she has jealously guarded for centuries in her liturgical codices” (Tra 3). He also praised polyphony, especially the work of Palestrina, which “agrees admirably with Gregorian Chant, the supreme model of all sacred music” (Tra 3). Concerning instruments, the Pontiff had mentioned organ as the preferred, but “the singing should always have the principal place, the organ or other instruments should merely sustain and never oppress it” (Tra 16) Pius X did mention some restrictions, such as, “The employment of the piano is forbidden in church, as is also that of noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells and the like” (Tra 19). In article 20, the encyclical goes on to say that wind instruments and bands are forbidden in the church, unless the local Ordinary says otherwise, and it seems to speak of an extraordinary circumstance. Pope Pius XII dealt with liturgical music as well, but mainly relied on what Pius X had said 50 years earlier. Pope Paul VI’s instruction on music in the Roman liturgy, Musicam Sacram (written in 1967) points out that chant should be given “pride of place” (Mus 50a) in the liturgy. Although the document does support the use of the vernacular, it also mentions that pastors should take care to have the congregation sing or speak the ordinaries in Latin (Mus 47). Pope John Paul II wrote a Chirograph on Pius X’s Tra le Sollecitudini in November 2003. Pope Benedict has been making statements about the importance of traditional music. Being a musician, he has given his insights on the details and emotion of music along with the theological aspect.

I have just given small snippets of what these documents say. I strongly urge you all to do some reading if you have any doubts or are interested in learning more. I barely scratched the surface of what has been said over the last hundred years on sacred music. I just want to conclude with a challenge, that we as young people–the future of the Church–will work together to rediscover the treasures of the Church which She guards dearly as a way to praise and honour Her Bridegroom, the Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you.

Guest KevinSymonds
Posted

Not too shabby S.M.M. I realize the time constraint you are under so I will only get a couple of points in.

First comment: I feel for you with the whole get their guitar stuff going on. I read that and I wanted to gag.

Second comment: I have taken the liberty of showing my remarks on your text by fixing them in the text from the quotation below. It makes it easier on this phorum media to remark that way. Please take no offense. I noted these changes throughout with italics and put them in bold.

Third comment: I deleted the word 'traditional' after the prayer because it creates a severe ambiguity with sacred music. Sacred music is what sacred music is. The adjective 'traditional' makes it sound like there is sacred music elsewhere and you don't want that confusion running rampant as it sets a bad tone for the rest of your presentation.

Fourth comment: I centered the prayer so as to underscore its importance. While your audience won't see that, visual aids like this help us to rivet ourselves into the prayer by seeing it stand out. That, in turn, is communicated to your audience and they'll be more apt to listen to you.

Fifth comment: Thank you for connecting Gregorian Chant with the Synagogue chant. I worked on this point during my M.A. studies in college.

Sixth comment: I began a new paragraph with the word "Aside." It seemed to fit better for organizational methods.

Seventh comment: Pius X did not forbid wind instruments. His quote was, "limited in number, judiciously used..."


----------------------------
Greetings and salutations everyone. I am presenting to you a talk about sacred music, namely some background and history, and what the Church says concerning it’s use. Before we delve into this vast subject, let us pray.
[center]
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Lord Jesus, thank you for bringing us together this evening, and thank you for revealing to us your truth. I ask that you may open our hearts and minds tonight in this discussion on sacred music, and that we do your will, and follow what your bride, Holy Mother Church has to say on this matter. I ask that you bless us all with graces, especially humility, love and zeal. Amen. St. Cecilia, pray for us In the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, amen.[/center]

The first thing I want to talk about is the history of Gregorian Chant, “plainsong” or “plainchant” (deriving from the old French “plein chant”, meaning “full singing”). The concept goes back before the church, originally coming from Jewish worship in the synagogues. The music developed and became prominent in the 6th century, when Pope Gregory the Great had all of the chant repertoire compiled together. It became an essential part of monastic life, where chants were composed, memorized and developed for the liturgies. Eventually, chants were written down on this early staff system [refer to a handout], which is the ancestor of our modern musical staff. Gregorian Chant is a vast field of music, thus will take another talk to explain, but I will briefly go over uses of plainsong.

Aside from the Liturgy of the Hours, plainsong is written for the Holy Mass. In the Holy Mass, there are two types of chant that occur there: the Proper and the Ordinary. The Proper consists of chants written specifically for each feast day, therefore covers the Introit, Gradual, Alleluia, Tract, Sequence, Offertory and Communion. The ordinaries are fixed chants, meaning they do not change during the liturgical year. The Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus, Benedictus and Agnus Dei are the chanted ordinaries. Now I’m going to play some Gregorian chant sung by the Benedictine Monks of Santo Domingo de Silos. Take note of the style of the music, that is the fluent movement of the notes, the absence of a regular pulse like our modern music, giving a continual feeling to the music.

The next type of traditional music I want to talk about is sacred polyphony (polyphony meaning there is more than one important melody happening at once in a piece). Sacred polyphony has its roots in Gregorian Chant due to musicians improvising harmonies underneath the melody. A prominent school of this early polyphony was from the Notre Dame Cathedral in France dating about the [b]M[/b]iddle [b]A[/b]ges. about the 16th century, polyphony was at it’s height, with the leading composer being Palestrina. Polyphony was adapted for the [b]M[/b]ass, mainly the ordinaries, as well as other bodies of work. The thought behind the whole movement of polyphony was that the multiple voices coming in at different times represented the chorus of angels singing their unending praise to God. That is what composers had in mind when the wrote the music.

Now, this is all great stuff, but what does the Church say about it’s relevance? Pope Pius X wrote an [b]E[/b]ncyclical on the instruction of sacred music in 1903 called [i]Tra le Sollecitudini[/i]. This was written partly because there were musical abuses in the church, in the form of Operatic style music in Italy, and medocracy in composing other bodies of work such as hymns. In the [b]E[/b]ncyclical, he outlined that Gregorian chant is “the Chant proper to the Roman Church... which she has jealously guarded for centuries in her liturgical codices” (Tra 3). He also praised polyphony, especially the work of Palestrina, which “agrees admirably with Gregorian Chant, the supreme model of all sacred music” (Tra 3). Concerning instruments, the Pontiff had mentioned organ as the preferred, but “the singing should always have the principal place, the organ or other instruments should merely sustain and never oppress it” (Tra 16) Pius X did mention some restrictions, such as, “The employment of the piano is forbidden in church, as is also that of noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells and the like” (Tra 19). In article 20, the [b]E[/b]ncyclical goes on to say that wind instruments and bands are to be "limited in number, judiciously used" in the church and with the local Bishop's consent.

Pope Pius XII dealt with liturgical music as well, but mainly relied on what Pius X had said 50 years earlier. Pope Paul VI’s instruction on music in the Roman liturgy, [i]Musicam Sacram[/i] (written in 1967) points out that chant should be given “pride of place” (Mus 50a) in the liturgy. Although the document does support the use of the vernacular, it also mentions that pastors should take care to have the congregation sing or speak the ordinaries in Latin (Mus 47). Pope John Paul II wrote a [i]Chirograph[/i] on Pius X’s [i]Tra le Sollecitudini[/i] in November 2003. More recently, Pope Benedict has [b]made[/b] statements about the importance of traditional music. Being a musician, he has given his insights on the details and emotion of music along with the theological aspect.

I have just given small snippets of what these documents say. I strongly urge you all to do some reading if you have any doubts or are interested in learning more. I barely scratched the surface of what has been said over the last hundred years on sacred music. I just want to conclude with a challenge, that we as young people–the future of the Church–will work together to rediscover the treasures of the Church which She guards dearly as a way to praise and honour Her Bridegroom, the Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you.

Posted

Thanks a million for the help on this. It's exactly what I was hoping, that is, that someone would help fine-tune some words in order to get my point across. I realise wording is very important because we had a discussion about that once at a youth ministry meeting in regards to personal testimonies (which I still have to write :pinch:). An example is someone put the term "suicide" in his/her testimony, which was a nono, so it had to be changed before presenting, only because the word can be a trigger for some people (either of fear, etc). Anywho, I hope this goes over all right. I wanted to say as much as I could without going on to long, and without directly accusing them of doing something wrong and bringing shame upon all of them (ha). I want to keep everyone on the same side as me, so we can get into sacred music. Oh, should I mention in there something about "the profane" being excluded from the mass? That is, secular stuff... oh that might actually take up all night arguing that P&W has something secular about it. I guess prayer is in order....

Posted

thanks for the work! definitely a great start to build one's foundation on the subject, especially in the style of apologetics.

i would also be interested in something geared towards teenagers and younger adults, or "baby christians". personally i enjoy the psychological, biological, and spiritual approach, ala Fr. Groeschel, but i'm open to whatever is most practical to getting the message across to our youth.

Posted

Well, looking back to OP, I see that I didn't actually talk about aesthetics, but it might come up in my discussion tonight! Pray for me!

Guest KevinSymonds
Posted

Profane does have its proper meaning but it is often misunderstood in today's English.

P&W music--in the order of charismatic--IS profane music and completely unsuitable for the Sacred Liturgy.

On a side note, I despise, abhore and denigrate that term "praise and worship" music.

As if Gregorian Chant and Sacred Polyphony don't praise and worship God?

We're becoming Protestant......Kyrie eleison!

-KJS

Posted

Yes indeed, I even noticed that when I started the debate thread... some go, "yes, praise and worship belongs in the mass. the [protestant] style of music? no."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...