Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Given all of the angst over people calling Catholics "real men," perhaps this will be a good thread for people to discuss what femininity vs. masculinity ought to be about.

Dudes tend to be taller than the gals.
Women tend to be better at pretty much anything involving children under the age of 7. Or 12. Or maybe 30. But at least 7.
The first man was made out of dirt. The first woman was made from the side of a rational human being. :mellow:

Posted

Ok. What is femininity and masculinity? I have to shake my head when I see sites like the "Ladies Against Feminism" website. Quite a little gem of mis-information.

[quote]Dudes tend to be taller than the gals.[/quote]

But, that's biological. Femininity and masculinity aren't inherent qualities pertaining to biology.

Posted

Touche. Just trying to get the ball rolling.

Posted

I know, I wasn't being argumentative. Good topic anyway.

Posted (edited)

[size=1]"If there is anything disagreeable going on, men are always sure to get out of it."
- Jane Austen
:)
[/size]

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1416958' date='Nov 10 2007, 10:34 AM']Given all of the angst over people calling Catholics "real men," perhaps this will be a good thread for people to discuss what femininity vs. masculinity ought to be about.

Dudes tend to be taller than the gals.
Women tend to be better at pretty much anything involving children under the age of 7. Or 12. Or maybe 30. But at least 7.
The first man was made out of dirt. The first woman was made from the side of a rational human being. :mellow:[/quote]


Men deal with children under 7, 12, and well ok not 30.

The thing is that there is definatly a differnce, both atomically and rollalicly (did work out so well, lets just say in their role) between men and woman. Speaking as a man, I have to say a real man is one who is not afriad to take up his call wether that is as a spiritual or biological father. I guess you could say a real woman is a woman not afriad to take up their call to either religious or motherhood.

Other things that invole being a real... would be:

The courage to take up ones cross
putting God first, even before family, etc

you guys and finish the list

Posted

I don't know generally, but with my husband and I, he seems to be much less fussy about hygiene. It's not that he doesn't care, he just can't seem to see or notice the same kinds of things, especially in the bathroom. We were married for 6 months before he noticed that I was ironing his dress shirts. He did adapt really quickly, and now fusses over his new shirts and ties. He just needed some good old fashioned henpecking.

Posted

[quote name='Lena' post='1417005' date='Nov 11 2007, 02:46 AM']Ok. What is femininity and masculinity? I have to shake my head when I see sites like the "Ladies Against Feminism" website. Quite a little gem of mis-information.[/quote]
Not necessarily. Not all Catholic women are interested in using the word "feminism" to describe the Church's stance on womanhood. Referring to it as "the f-word", they point out that its cultural definition is completely the opposite of the Church's and feel the need to point that out much more strongly than their counter-parts like yourself who are perfectly happy to "baptize" (in a certain sense) the word. It's not that these women [i]don't[/i] believe that the teachings of the Catholic Church fulfil their womanhood, it's just that they have a different evangelist style.

Back on topic, the problem with creating threads like these is that some uni-sexist always comes on and tries to tell us that the sexes are the same, and any saying there is difference other than genitals is just another way men oppress women, and blah, blah, blah. I have a tendency to roll my eyes frequently in topics like these.

Look, men and women are not alike. There are traits that come naturally to men, and then there are traits that come naturally to women. This does not mean that the sexes are ONLY capable of their respective traits. They can be taught the other sexes traits as well. Additional both sexes have their extremes that will eventually destroy a society if followed upon cultural wide. The solution is to teach respect for traits of BOTH sexes, and try to learn from each other instead trying to say that one is the end-all-be-all of what humanity should be.

In my view the sexes were made to complete each other. Maybe we should try that instead of constantly holding up one on our pedestal.

Posted

And Man and Woman He created them.....

Excelsior1027
Posted (edited)

God made Adam and said, "I can do better than that." Then He made Eve.

Please forgive me if I'm annoying people who are taking this seriously. :hehe:

Edited by Excelsior1027
missionseeker
Posted

The difference between men and women encompasses both the physical and psychological. It is an essential difference. A woman's essence is different than that of a man's. It follows, then that because of this essential difference, the ultimate purpose of men and women, though the same (to get to heaven) would be achieved in different ways. These differences are not so much that one sex is better than the other, as that one sex is nothing without the other. Men need women and women need to men in order to reach their full potential as human beings.


Humans are composite beings (matter and form- i.e. body and soul). Differences in form -the intellective soul, the part that deals with how a person reasons, thinks, and responds to the world- are expressed in the matter (the body). The differences in the matter are expressed in the form. This does not necessariraly mean that the physical and mental capabilities of one sex are better or superior than the other's, it means that they are different.


A woman's body is potentially capable of carrying a child and giving birth. This is reflected in her intellective soul. The way she thinks is dictated by the fact that she has the potential to be a mother. It is in the nature of a woman to be a mother. This does not mean she must have a child to be a woman, or even that she must actually be physically capable of motherhood. There are women who give up physical motherhood for the good of others and have been for thousands of years. This does not make them less womanly.

So feminity is the embracing of motherhood (whether one is a mother or not). It is realizing that this is why we think the way we do and not fighting against it.



I wrote that a while ago. I meant to go back and edit it, butI never did. It's not good, nor an essay. just random thoughts.

Posted

in war we're tough and able
quite in-de-fa-tigue-able
though oftentimes
we're given rhymes
that are quite unsingable

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1417234' date='Nov 10 2007, 11:50 PM']Not necessarily. Not all Catholic women are interested in using the word "feminism" to describe the Church's stance on womanhood. Referring to it as "the f-word", they point out that its cultural definition is completely the opposite of the Church's and feel the need to point that out much more strongly than their counter-parts like yourself who are perfectly happy to "baptize" (in a certain sense) the word. It's not that these women [i]don't[/i] believe that the teachings of the Catholic Church fulfil their womanhood, it's just that they have a different evangelist style.

Back on topic, the problem with creating threads like these is that some uni-sexist always comes on and tries to tell us that the sexes are the same, and any saying there is difference other than genitals is just another way men oppress women, and blah, blah, blah. I have a tendency to roll my eyes frequently in topics like these.

Look, men and women are not alike. There are traits that come naturally to men, and then there are traits that come naturally to women. This does not mean that the sexes are ONLY capable of their respective traits. They can be taught the other sexes traits as well. Additional both sexes have their extremes that will eventually destroy a society if followed upon cultural wide. The solution is to teach respect for traits of BOTH sexes, and try to learn from each other instead trying to say that one is the end-all-be-all of what humanity should be.

In my view the sexes were made to complete each other. Maybe we should try that instead of constantly holding up one on our pedestal.[/quote]

I've always loved this article in attempting to answer the big question about femininity and Catholicism. I find it interesting.

[url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/feminism/fe0025.html"]Catholic and Feminist: Can One Be Both? [/url]

But, I do think the term "feminism" really creates a strong connotation of everything that it [i]isn't[/i], which overpowers everything it is. Don't get me wrong, feminism has had a hand in mass cultural change for good and bad. And that is one of the reasons it creates so much controversy. Although, I don't know what you mean by me "baptizing" the word.

I don't think the sexes are the same, obviously, and yes each respective biology does reflect on a cultural viewpoint that creates what we perceive as gender. However, there aren't inherent traits that come naturally to women--=for example, we [i]learn[/i] how to be mothers, and different methods of learning are employed in each culture. Just because I have a womb doesn't mean I know [i]inherently[/i] how to care for a baby. For men, especially American men, they are taught to resemble the ideals of masculinity in Western culture--such as being a "strong caregiver" or more "aggressive." Why do you think girls are given dolls (in part, to learn about mothering) and boys are encouraged to participate in sports (which creates independence, and in many cases encourages aggressive behavior, such as in football)?

There is a culture, in which I studied and can't find the article link currently, I'm pretty sure it's in Africa, that participates in cross-gender. That person then identifies, and the entire group identifies and accepts, that person as being a female or male (even if their biological sex doesn't "match" according to Western viewpoints). Really interesting to study.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='1417409' date='Nov 11 2007, 03:44 AM']The difference between men and women encompasses both the physical and psychological. It is an essential difference. A woman's essence is different than that of a man's. It follows, then that because of this essential difference, the ultimate purpose of men and women, though the same (to get to heaven) would be achieved in different ways. These differences are not so much that one sex is better than the other, as that one sex is nothing without the other. Men need women and women need to men in order to reach their full potential as human beings.
Humans are composite beings (matter and form- i.e. body and soul). Differences in form -the intellective soul, the part that deals with how a person reasons, thinks, and responds to the world- are expressed in the matter (the body). The differences in the matter are expressed in the form. This does not necessariraly mean that the physical and mental capabilities of one sex are better or superior than the other's, it means that they are different.
A woman's body is potentially capable of carrying a child and giving birth. This is reflected in her intellective soul. The way she thinks is dictated by the fact that she has the potential to be a mother. It is in the nature of a woman to be a mother. This does not mean she must have a child to be a woman, or even that she must actually be physically capable of motherhood. There are women who give up physical motherhood for the good of others and have been for thousands of years. This does not make them less womanly.

So feminity is the embracing of motherhood (whether one is a mother or not). It is realizing that this is why we think the way we do and not fighting against it.
I wrote that a while ago. I meant to go back and edit it, butI never did. It's not good, nor an essay. just random thoughts.[/quote]
This is really good. It may be obvious, but it's not. One thing to add, though. There is that drive to be a "mother", but becoming one is probably a path of learning, just sort of like what it's like to be a "father" of some kind.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='1417409' date='Nov 11 2007, 02:44 AM']The difference between men and women encompasses both the physical and psychological. It is an essential difference. A woman's essence is different than that of a man's.

. . . .

Humans are composite beings (matter and form- i.e. body and soul). Differences in form -the intellective soul, the part that deals with how a person reasons, thinks, and responds to the world- are expressed in the matter (the body). The differences in the matter are expressed in the form. This does not necessariraly mean that the physical and mental capabilities of one sex are better or superior than the other's, it means that they are different.

. . . .

A woman's body is potentially capable of carrying a child and giving birth. This is reflected in her intellective soul. The way she thinks is dictated by the fact that she has the potential to be a mother. It is in the nature of a woman to be a mother.[/quote]

Missionseeker, asserting that there is an "essential" difference between women and men may bring about some soteriological difficulties--these questions have been raised by such feminist theologians such as Rosemary Radford Ruether who inquired whether a male savior can save women.

An argument against such essential claims is that 1) if we posit an essential difference between men and women; and 2) follow the patristic dictum that "what is not assumed is not saved" (from Gregory of Nyssa); and 3) believe that God became incarnate as a male human being; then, the conclusion seems to be that something essential about female human beings is not redeemed because it remains unassumed by Christ.

It may be that you are thinking of "essence" in a different way than I am--but you do seem to connect it with soul and nature. I'm pretty sure that we don't want to make the argument that there is a male and a female nature that are distinct from each other because it leads into the soteriological problems I just mentioned.

Personally speaking, I do not wish to collapse the differences between the sexes. However, I am very cautious about what those differences are, how they arise, and whether--and in what cases--they might be considered normative.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Men and women are alike when they stand before God. After living with a husband and sons, the rest of the time I'm not even sure men are the same species. But without the differences, life would be pretty boring.

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Thumper' post='1417697' date='Nov 11 2007, 03:43 PM']Missionseeker, asserting that there is an "essential" difference between women and men may bring about some soteriological difficulties--these questions have been raised by such feminist theologians such as Rosemary Radford Ruether who inquired whether a male savior can save women.

An argument against such essential claims is that 1) if we posit an essential difference between men and women; and 2) follow the patristic dictum that "what is not assumed is not saved" (from Gregory of Nyssa); and 3) believe that God became incarnate as a male human being; then, the conclusion seems to be that something essential about female human beings is not redeemed because it remains unassumed by Christ.

It may be that you are thinking of "essence" in a different way than I am--but you do seem to connect it with soul and nature. I'm pretty sure that we don't want to make the argument that there is a male and a female nature that are distinct from each other because it leads into the soteriological problems I just mentioned.

Personally speaking, I do not wish to collapse the differences between the sexes. However, I am very cautious about what those differences are, how they arise, and whether--and in what cases--they might be considered normative.[/quote]

They both have the same human essence. But the nature of men and women ARE different. I'm think of essence as "the act of being" - the act of being what you are- the limitations on the act of being, really. You cannot be both a man and a woman, you are limited by the essence of womanhood or manhood. (Not limited necessarily in a negative connation- just a binding one).

I can see what you're saying though. But I don't think that it's rational to say that because Jesus was a man women can't be saved.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='1417770' date='Nov 11 2007, 05:42 PM']They both have the same human essence. But the nature of men and women ARE different. I'm think of essence as "the act of being" - the act of being what you are- the limitations on the act of being, really. You cannot be both a man and a woman, you are limited by the essence of womanhood or manhood. (Not limited necessarily in a negative connation- just a binding one).

I can see what you're saying though. But I don't think that it's rational to say that because Jesus was a man women can't be saved.[/quote]

I agree that we shouldn't deny the salvation of both men and women through Jesus Christ. Feminist theologians offer the argument that I reproduced precisely because they want to be able to affirm that Christ is savior of both men and women. They are simply noting the logical soteriological outcome of positing [i]essential [/i]differences between men and women.

I still think, though, that describing men and women in terms of different "natures" is problematic, at least with regard to my understanding of that term. Christ had two natures: divine and human. There is only one human nature, which Christ assumes, and is thereby redeemer of both men and women.

What word might we use in place of "nature" to indicate the differences between men and women in a non-essential way? To be honest, I don't really know, but I'm happy to hear suggestions.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...