Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Thief's Conversion.. Baptism Of ____?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Now my question would be, people from Scripture who lived all kinds of life styles good and bad, with their circumstances, they are placed in a postition to die for the faith. one particular person comes to mind is the thief's conversion on the cross, now most likely 99% likely, he was never baptized with Water yet Jesus said to him, that You will be with Me in Paradise. now I take it, the thief on the cross had the attention of being baptized if he could, ethier by water or by blood, or by desire.


[b]My question is did the Thief receive the baptism of desire or baptism of martyrdom? assuming if he wasn't already baptized outside of his crucifixion?[/b]

I mean ethier way, Jesus said that you will be with me in Paradise to that particular thief who repented on the his cross next to our Blessed Lord dying on His Holy Cross. Its not a question of if hes in Heaven or not, the question is what type of baptism did he receive?

I have to say this is evidence in the Sacred Scriptures that it appears to be that is, this is a different kind of baptism one out of the ordinary, now I'd like to believe this to be true, however I'd like to know if this is the Church's prepsective on it.

Edited by White Knight
Posted

baptism of desire. he didn't die for his faith, he died for his crimes. he said to the other theif "you and I deserve this punishment, He does not"; and thus, by accepting this as a just punishment, earned expiation for the sin of his crime (no purgatory was needed, his execution was his just punishment and purification, because he accepted that as his punishment and thus, in undergoing it, was brought towards perfection)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='White Knight' post='1418040' date='Nov 12 2007, 12:22 AM']Now my question would be, people from Scripture who lived all kinds of life styles good and bad, with their circumstances, they are placed in a postition to die for the faith. one particular person comes to mind is the thief's conversion on the cross, now most likely 99% likely, he was never baptized with Water yet Jesus said to him, that You will be with Me in Paradise. now I take it, the thief on the cross had the attention of being baptized if he could, ethier by water or by blood, or by desire.
[b]My question is did the Thief receive the baptism of desire or baptism of martyrdom? assuming if he wasn't already baptized outside of his crucifixion?[/b]

I mean ethier way, Jesus said that you will be with me in Paradise to that particular thief who repented on the his cross next to our Blessed Lord dying on His Holy Cross. Its not a question of if hes in Heaven or not, the question is what type of baptism did he receive?

I have to say this is evidence in the Sacred Scriptures that it appears to be that is, this is a different kind of baptism one out of the ordinary, now I'd like to believe this to be true, however I'd like to know if this is the Church's prepsective on it.[/quote]
In a way, baptism by blood is often a form of baptism of desire...just a lot more potent...and dramatic...and often gruesome. You get washed clean and are given a martyr's crown in one go. So for the most part, there is an overlap, especially in the case of Dismas, the good thief.

We, as a human race, are guilty of sin and the punishment is death. As such, our sufferings and deaths are not meritorious, it is that we testify in the midst of fear, suffering, and death that makes the baptism of blood, and martyrdom in general, so powerful.

Dismas, the Good Thief, testified in the midst of all his pain and humiliation to Christ. Dismas testified to the righteousness of Christ even against his friend and cohort, Gestas. By doing so, he made his rightful execution a martyrdom in the eyes of Christ. Let this be a source of encouragement to us all. We who are called to testify to Christ in the midst of our small discomforts aught look to Dismas, who gave up everything he had left to Christ on that last day.

P.S. The story of the Good Thief is very powerful for me, which explains a few things.

Edited by Dismas
Posted

Baptism of Blood is only applicable when one dies for their faith. There isn't an overlap, St. Dismas did not die for his faith, he died for his crimes. He admitted that he and the other theif deserved the punishment for their crimes, but Christ did not. He was not baptized by blood, though he was made more perfect through his suffering because he accepted it as the justice he truly deserved.

it wasn't a martyrdom, though. martyrdom specifically refers to those who died because of their faith. both Dismas and Gestas died for the same reason, one had faith and the other did not, but both died; it is clear, then, that Dismas was not a martyr, he and Gestas died for the same reason and because Gestas was not a martyr, neither was Dismas, in the proper sense of the term.

I'll never understand the tendency to try to make martyrs out of people who are simply saints and victims... seems to cheapen martyrdom to me. Martyrdom is when you die because of your faith, it is a special and distinct thing; simply having a holy death and a redemptive suffering and witnessing to the faith while you die does not make you a martyr, it just makes you a saint; to be a martyr, you must die because of your faith.

Posted (edited)

To say it another way. A martyr must have the option [i]not[/i] to die.

EDIT: Oops! Too simple. Somebody can get shot in the head with no questions asked just because they did something Christian a month ago.
Also, Father Damian is probably a martyr even tho there came a point where he would die either way. Or another complication, he wasn't necessarily going to contract leprosy when he went to Molokai the first time.

Edited by Paddington
Posted

yeah,, that's not exact,, though there is a bit of a point in that; even in the exceptions you listed, the person would have the option not to die by renouncing his Christianity; it was just that the danger of doing the Christian thing was a more remote danger; but by chosinng to act as a Christian every believer theoretically takes a risk; the risk was laid out by Christ; He told us they would persecute us, He told us they would kill us if we did what He commmanded of us. So we chose that, we took that risk, and those who get killed for it could have chosen not to take that risk.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...