Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

When I saw the story, and heard she got a kidney from her twin, I started thinking about the ethics of her surgery. If abortion is wrong, at even the microscopic level, isnt' killing a parasitic twin wrong? Comments?

Posted

I am shocked to every think a thing.

Posted

not sure what you meant by that last reply.

As a mom, I totally would have done the same thing--don't get me wrong!

It just occured to me, as a RC with the ethics I believe in for a)the unborn, all the way to a one-celled unborn and the b)infirmed- no matter what their function, with this pro-life stance, where does an embedded parasitic twin fit in to the pro-life stance?

Posted

Is there a link/article which discusses the circumstances in a little more detail?

Posted

here is the link

[url="http://www.comcast.net/providers/fan/popup.html?v=594006627&pl=594004747.xml&launchpoint=Cover&cid=fancover&attr=default_headline&config=/config/common/fan/default.xml"]http://www.comcast.net/providers/fan/popup...fan/default.xml[/url]

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

As far as I understand the biology (with my embryology limited to only one course), the "parasitic" twin died in the womb and essentially would have been miscarried, but the other twin absorbed the limbs.

I could be wrong, though. In any event, the principle of double effect probably applies here, so long as the intention itself was not evil.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1418774' date='Nov 13 2007, 04:21 PM']here is the link

[url="http://www.comcast.net/providers/fan/popup.html?v=594006627&pl=594004747.xml&launchpoint=Cover&cid=fancover&attr=default_headline&config=/config/common/fan/default.xml"]http://www.comcast.net/providers/fan/popup...fan/default.xml[/url][/quote]
link doesn 't work.

Posted

sorry about the link-- it is from my comcast video thing, maybe only works on my home page.

I will try to find the story...

try this [url="http://news.aol.com/story/_a/eight-limbed-girl-has-successful-surgery/20071106081709990001"]http://news.aol.com/story/_a/eight-limbed-...106081709990001[/url]

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1418790' date='Nov 13 2007, 01:36 PM']As far as I understand the biology (with my embryology limited to only one course), the "parasitic" twin died in the womb and essentially would have been miscarried, but the other twin absorbed the limbs.[/quote]

this is my understanding of the story, too. the fact that the one baby absorbed the other body parts shows that the second child had died.

quite sad. but it'll be very interesting to see the followup now after the surgery.

Posted

Yes, she is a beautiful little girl, too. How scary for that family to face such a risky surgery. I hope her rehab goes smoothly...

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

I dont see how this could be abortion? I thought the twin had died naturally in the womb and became a part of the girll and never fullly developed. Andwhen they say they are using tissues from the twin, it is what was already given/grown on the girl already.

Posted

Man... That is one beautiful girl!!

Posted

Ok, I am just being difficult here, but how is the parasitic twin any different than a person who is on life support, does not interact, but is not terminal?


Please understand, I am just probing the ethics here, not being critical of what was done, and truly have compassion for the family and the little girl.

But the residual twin's body was alive, and although she wasn't communicative, wasn't she THERE?

Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1418756' date='Nov 13 2007, 04:02 PM']When I saw the story, and heard she got a kidney from her twin, I started thinking about the ethics of her surgery. If abortion is wrong, at even the microscopic level, isnt' killing a parasitic twin wrong? Comments?[/quote]

The parasitic twin already was dead--no head was formed. Thus the "extra limbs" on little Lakshmi. No killing involved.

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1418835' date='Nov 13 2007, 02:27 PM']Ok, I am just being difficult here, but how is the parasitic twin any different than a person who is on life support, does not interact, but is not terminal?
Please understand, I am just probing the ethics here, not being critical of what was done, and truly have compassion for the family and the little girl.

But the residual twin's body was alive, and although she wasn't communicative, wasn't she THERE?[/quote]

see the discussion above about the twin...

it seems pretty clear that the one baby had died. if you've read something that says otherwise, though, please do post it for us to discuss.

Posted

I guess by the nature of it the twin was not dead--the twin's body was alive, hence the ability to transplant the kidney. The little girl was life support for the twin's body. If the twin had 'died' in utero, there would have been no body attached.

So, if we go to conjoined twins, how do we define 'alive'?? Is a person who is brain damaged, unresponsive and on life support 'alive'??? Technically the parasitic twin was alive and growing.

Posted

here are pics that are very graphic

[url="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=491757&in_page_id=1770"]http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/arti...in_page_id=1770[/url]

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1418858' date='Nov 13 2007, 02:58 PM']I guess by the nature of it the twin was not dead--the twin's body was alive, hence the ability to transplant the kidney. The little girl was life support for the twin's body. If the twin had 'died' in utero, there would have been no body attached.

So, if we go to conjoined twins, how do we define 'alive'?? Is a person who is brain damaged, unresponsive and on life support 'alive'??? Technically the parasitic twin was alive and growing.[/quote]

isn't it true, though, that there was no developed head?

this seems to be a bit of a stretch to imply the second twin was still alive just because some of the parts were there. we can keep human parts "alive" after someone dies after all, to be transplated to other people.

Posted

There was no brain on the parasitic limbs. It was a body that had been absorbed. It was not alive because it had no brain.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...