Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mothers Working Outside The Home?


Working mothers?  

75 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Vote in the poll, and have a [i]calm[/i] discussion below.

photosynthesis
Posted

I voted "not the ideal but sometimes necessary." I think it's more important for children to grow up in a household with a stay-at-home mom than a household where both parents work but make more money.

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted (edited)

I chose "not the ideal but sometimes necessary."

Personally, if I were a mother I would prefer to be home with my kids... but if money were tight I definitely would not have a problem with working enough to make ends meet.

Edited by xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

Much depends on the specific situation. For example, school teachers are able to spend significantly more time with their kids - espcially school-aged children - than trauma surgeons.

Nothing can replace quality family time. In the situations where both parents work, it is important to at least (and I mean bare bones minimum) eat dinner together every night.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

A stay at home mum is the ideal, but sometimes the dad simply cannot make enough money to take care of his family. I worked night turn and had to take care of my kids during the day when they were little and it almost killed me.

Posted (edited)

I may be sticking out like a sore thumb here, but if my mom was able to do it (and she did a fine job of it!), then why can't I? Then again, we're both extremely ambitious people.

Edit: Then again, a mom can't be away from home all the time. A reasonable balance is good. So, the best response to me would be "It's fine as long as the mom puts her children first and discerns that it is best for the family." :)

Edited by rachael
Posted

Wow. There are 3 responses that are appropriate there, and maybe even 4!! hmmm...

Posted

I voted "It's fine as long as the mom puts her children first...."

My mom worked and I never seemed to miss out on whatever it is I was supposed to be missing out on. Dinner was always on the table at 6, and my dad took me to school on the days she worked (part-time). Day-care was more fun in the summer as opposed to being home, as all my friends were there.

That said, every situation is different. Children should always come first--if being a stay-at-home mom is the way you want to go, that's fine. If you want to work (or need to work) and you still have your kids as top priority, that works too.

I know I plan on working no matter what, as my mom has always told me (thanks mom) never depend on a guy for it all.

Posted

"It's fine as long as the mom puts her children first and dicerns that it is best for the family."

I think that of women who are called to be mothers, some are called to careers and some are not. I know my *very general* vocation (little-v) career-wise, but if my Vocation (big-v) is to be a mother, my career could be full-time, part-time, or volunteer... we'll wait and see what God has in store for me.

Posted

Financial concerns really do dictate this. Not many can afford to live above the poverty level with just one spouse working.
A mother can work and also be there for the kids. It takes teamwork and cooperation. Sadly, the jobs fall mostly to the Mom to clean the house, raise the kids, work a full time job etc. Most husbands I know do little around the house, dont spend much time with their kids. It certainly is their loss.
Plus, some woman have a wonderful career. There is no need to completely give it up. There are many alternate schedules to work.
I am neither a wife nor a mother, so really don't have much of a say here, but always do have an opnion!

Posted

Definitely not, unless it's really necessary.

Posted

[quote name='Lena' post='1419483' date='Nov 14 2007, 07:32 PM']I know I plan on working no matter what, as my mom has always told me (thanks mom) never depend on a guy for it all.[/quote]
Love it.

Posted (edited)

I think it is the ideal for the mom to stay home, yet I don't think it should be the 11th commandment. Fathers are participating more in the nuturing aspect of child-rearing, which is a good thing. I don't necessarily think the 1950's model where the father worked, was the primary disciplinarian, but was emotionally distant and did not lend a hand with the chores, while the mother did ALL the housekeeping and child-care is necessarily the right model either. Although I'd prefer to stay home, I'd rather work than see my husband too exhausted from working to emotionally connect with us.

Edited by friendofJPII
Posted

I think it's fine. Different familes have different needs, who knows, maybe the dad stays home.

Posted

Not ideal but sometimes necessary.

Posted

If the mom has to work to put food on the table, fine, or if her kids are older fine. I think it is a situation by situation thing.

Posted

Obviously if you're going to be out on the street w/o both parents working, then it's unfortunate but necessary... or maybe, if mom can earn more than dad, dad can stay home. What is really sad are the "latchkey" kids I went to school with, who would get off the bus, unlock the front door of their nice big suburban house, and sit down to an after-school snack... alone. :sadder:

Posted

Interesting positive replies... I voted "it really depends on the situation" etc...

I’m a working-away Mum, and at the moment I’m the main earner- not by choice, but financial circumstances can and do change quite unexpectedly and drastically- even when you’re the best of budgeters and minimalists. I am thankful that I can support my family.

I do battle with feelings of guilt at having to leave my children. Even though they are in the good, capable hands of my mother in law and husband- there’s nothing quite like a mother’s care (and only Mama can braid hair for sure). It’s all the little things they say and do that are so huge, and crucial that you miss out on. :sadder:

There are a few days a week when I travel quite far from home and have to set off before they wake up and return when they’re in bed already (well, 3 of them- the baby is up almost all night). :sadder: They can only tell I’ve been home because their clothes are ironed by the bedside, their lunches have been made, and there are post-it reminders for Daddy to know what’s what. I try to make the most of the days I am working from home- I volunteer at their school as well to be close to them. I don’t believe in setting apart “quality time”- all time is quality. Even the times we struggle. They know everything I do is for them, well I hope so. :unsure:

At work most people I meet don’t know I have four kids- some talk down to me like I haven’t got their responsibilities. :ohno: I think mothers do excellently in their work and have more patience than most people. Me, I’m not great at the balancing act and things often go pear-shaped.

Recently I was at a meeting with a police officer present, and he noticed a car outside, and became suspicious...a Black male in a banger car circling around the building…. I looked out of the window and realized to my horror that it was my husband with my youngest crying in her car seat. He had texted me that the baby wasn’t taking to the expressed milk and could I pop out of the meeting for a sec and feed her? Not easy when you’re doing a presentation…It was quite embarrassing, but I had to explain quickly before they got the wrong idea. People ere in stitches laughing...

So yeah, that’s what it’s like for me…

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Dearie, your kids should be so proud of you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...