Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

So the coat of arms for Benedict XVI contains a hybrid of the Triple Tiara and a mitre. However, such a head peice does not currently exist. I think one should be created and that they should resurrect some form of the papal coronation but use this instead; best of both worlds.

Though ultimately, I'd rather see the tiara itself resurrected.

Posted

Yeah that would be really cool. Someone should design it. But who has the time? :lol:

Posted

Are there Papal coronation rites of 1962? I wonder if they're allowed under Summorum Pontificum. :lol:

Posted

they were never abrogated ;)

Posted

I think all that coronation stuff should be sold, and the money given to house the poor. I can't imagine St. Peter appearing like that.

Posted

there was an archaeological find in Rome of a Roman mansion; inscriptions inside indicated that it had been donated by a rich Roman convert to be used at St. Peter's residence in Rome.

this is like the expensive oil, it was Judas who reprimanded her, Christ said "the poor you will always have with you..."; the coronation stuff gives glory to Christ and His Church by adorning it with the best mankind can offer; those who donate these things do so happily, and it does not take away from potential help to the poor. We could sell all these pricely bits of art and tradition, these things which are sacramentals and show visibly the established Kingdom of God within the Church for all the world to see, but it wouldn't really make a dent in poverty, the poor would remain as they were and the world would have lost a precious peice of art giving glory to God.

it is not Christian to want to sell these things for the sake of the poor; that's modernism, not Christianity; and it's not what Christ wants for His Church. Mother Theresa made sure every parish in India had gold chalices.

The Tiara is a symbol, and a sacramental at that, and adorning the office of the papacy with that beautiful symbol, offering the very finest mankind can muster to adorn that which we value the most (our Church, our Faith), that is priceless. That goes at the end of the mastercard commercial after we list the money value of the tiaras.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1420010' date='Nov 15 2007, 06:41 PM']I think all that coronation stuff should be sold, and the money given to house the poor. I can't imagine St. Peter appearing like that.[/quote]

So that it can collect dust in the collection of some rich man's collection or sit on the shelf of some obscure museum?

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

Then every piece in every museum should be sold off. The Met, the Louvre - each and every one of them. All that ancient Egyptian stuff, cave paintings, the lot of it.

"I thought that you'd want what I want,
Sorry my dear
But where are the clowns?"

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1420010' date='Nov 15 2007, 06:41 PM']I think all that coronation stuff should be sold, and the money given to house the poor. I can't imagine St. Peter appearing like that.[/quote]

Posted

Sorry, I'm still not convinced that the church needs that stuff. When I was in the 3rd grade, our church burned down, and we didn't have enough insurance, or it had lapsed or something like that. We had mass outside, in the school cafeteria, and in a local gym at times for over two years. We grew during that period, and that was a time that people were leaving the church in general in droves. I'm not talking about selling every church and chalice. I'm talking about the trappings of royalty. When it comes to art or even documents for that matter, I like to think that we are preserving those for future generations. I don't think art work or antiquities of any kind should have a price on them. Mother Theresa may have made sure the churches had gold chalices, but she appeared in a plain sari.

Posted

well, I do believe they did attempt to sell one of the papal tiaras at one point; some rich American Catholic bought it and donated it back to the Church and it is now on display at the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception.

Instead of seeing the tiaras as symbols of immense wealth, you should see them as what they are: donations to the Church; with each pope there would generally be a new tiara, usually donated by that pope's home town. It's a beautiful thing.

It's not like the Church ever went around purchasing tiaras, they were gifts from the faithful; maybe that would help you to understand the beauty of them more.

But as I said, the Church really couldn't get rid of the tiaras if they tried.

And it would be a terrible insult, of course, to all those who had gotten together to donate the tiara if the Church decided to sell it. It is not the magisterium's to sell, it is not the pope's to sell, it belongs to the faithful as their gift to the Church, because they want it to show forth visibly that glory that they have found it already showing invisibly.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1419777' date='Nov 15 2007, 12:37 PM']So the coat of arms for Benedict XVI contains a hybrid of the Triple Tiara and a mitre. However, such a head peice does not currently exist. I think one should be created and that they should resurrect some form of the papal coronation but use this instead; best of both worlds.

Though ultimately, I'd rather see the tiara itself resurrected.[/quote]

Hmm... I'd rather see a society that cared for mothers so they would never consider abortion a realistic option. Or see Catholics joyfully following the Church to such a degree that other Christians actually took notice.

But tiaras are easier.

Posted

but what's that got to do with the price of tea in China? those things are great, but spending time discussing tiaras does not detract from time accomplishing those things; they're unrelated topics which both deserve our attention.

here we were discussing the great taste of apples, and you come in talking about how much you like oranges ;)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1420316' date='Nov 16 2007, 10:59 AM']but what's that got to do with the price of tea in China? those things are great, but spending time discussing tiaras does not detract from time accomplishing those things; they're unrelated topics which both deserve our attention.

here we were discussing the great taste of apples, and you come in talking about how much you like oranges ;)[/quote]
True... True...


I like the use of the old tea in China expression. :cool:

Posted

Yeah, that was a classic move. I haven't heard that one in years.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...