Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

People Who Mock Christianity...


Recommended Posts

PapaHilarious
Posted

[size=3][b]Pasta theology: Scholars mull Spaghetti Monster[/b][/size]
By Justin Pope, Associated Press

[img]http://i.usatoday.net/news/_photos/2007/11/16/spaghettimonsterx.jpg[/img]
[size=1][i][University of Florida students draw cartoons of God getting a wedgie][/i][/size]

[size=2][quote]BOSTON — When some of the world's leading religious scholars gather in San Diego this weekend, pasta will be on the intellectual menu. They'll be talking about a satirical pseudo-deity called the Flying Spaghetti Monster, whose growing pop culture fame gets laughs but also raises serious questions about the essence of religion.

The appearance of the Flying Spaghetti Monster on the agenda of the American Academy of Religion's annual meeting gives a kind of scholarly imprimatur to a phenomenon that first emerged in 2005, during the debate in Kansas over whether intelligent design should be taught in public school sciences classes.

Supporters of intelligent design hold that the order and complexity of the universe is so great that science alone cannot explain it. The concept's critics see it as faith masquerading as science.

An Oregon State physics graduate named Bobby Henderson stepped into the debate by sending a letter to the Kansas School Board. With tongue in cheek, he purported to speak for 10 million followers of a being called the Flying Spaghetti Monster — and demanded equal time for their views.

"We have evidence that a Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe. None of us, of course, were around to see it, but we have written accounts of it," Henderson wrote. As for scientific evidence to the contrary, "what our scientist does not realize is that every time he makes a measurement, the Flying Spaghetti Monster is there changing the results with His Noodly Appendage."

The letter made the rounds on the Internet, prompting laughter from some and vilification from others. But it struck a chord and stuck around. In the great tradition of satire, its humor was in fact a clever and effective argument.

Between the lines, the point of the letter was this: There's no more scientific basis for intelligent design than there is for the idea an omniscient creature made of pasta created the universe. If intelligent design supporters could demand equal time in a science class, why not anyone else? The only reasonable solution is to put nothing into sciences classes but the best available science.

"I think we can all look forward to the time when these three theories are given equal time in our science classrooms across the country, and eventually the world; one third time for Intelligent Design, one third time for Flying Spaghetti Monsterism, and one third time for logical conjecture based on overwhelming observable evidence," Henderson sarcastically concluded.

Kansas eventually repealed guidelines questioning the theory of evolution.

Meanwhile, Flying Spaghetti Monsterism (FSM-ism to its "adherents") has thrived — particularly on college campuses and in Europe. Henderson's website has become a kind of cyber-watercooler for opponents of intelligent design.

Henderson did not respond to a request for comment. His website tracks meetings of FSM clubs (members dress up as pirates) and sells trinkets and bumper stickers. "Pastafarians" — as followers call themselves — can also download computer screen-savers and wallpaper (one says: "WWFSMD?") and can sample photographs that show "visions" of the divinity himself. In one, the image of the carbohydrate creator is seen in a gnarl of dug-up tree roots.

It was the emergence of this community that attracted the attention of three young scholars at the University Florida who study religion in popular culture. They got to talking, and eventually managed to get a panel on FSM-ism on the agenda at one of the field's most prestigious gatherings.

The title: "Evolutionary Controversy and a Side of Pasta: The Flying Spaghetti Monster and the Subversive Function of Religious Parody."

"For a lot of people they're just sort of fun responses to religion, or fun responses to organized religion. But I think it raises real questions about how people approach religion in their lives," said Samuel Snyder, one of the three Florida graduate students, who will give talks at the meeting next Monday along with Alyssa Beall of Syracuse University.

The presenters' titles seem almost a parody themselves of academic jargon. Snyder will speak about "Holy Pasta and Authentic Sauce: The Flying Spaghetti Monster's Messy Implications for Theorizing Religion," while Gavin Van Horn's presentation is titled "Noodling around with Religion: Carnival Play, Monstrous Humor, and the Noodly Master."

Using a framework developed by literary critic Mikhail Bakhtin, Van Horn promises in his abstract to explore how, "in a carnivalesque fashion, the Flying Spaghetti Monster elevates the low (the bodily, the material, the inorganic) to bring down the high (the sacred, the religiously dogmatic, the culturally authoritative)."

The authors recognize the topic is a little light by the standards of the American Academy of Religion.

"You have to keep a sense of humor when you're studying religion, especially in graduate school," Van Horn said in a recent telephone interview. "Otherwise you'll sink into depression pretty quickly."

But they also insist it's more than a joke.

Indeed, the tale of the Flying Spaghetti Monster and its followers cuts to the heart of the one of the thorniest questions in religious studies: What defines a religion? Does it require a genuine theological belief? Or simply a set of rituals and a community joining together as a way of signaling their cultural alliances to others?

In short, is an anti-religion like Flying Spaghetti Monsterism actually a religion?

Joining them on the panel will be David Chidester, a prominent and controversial academic at the University of Cape Town in South Africa who is interested in precisely such questions. He has urged scholars looking for insights into the place of religion in culture and psychology to explore a wider range of human activities. Examples include cheering for sports teams, joining Tupperware groups, and the growing phenomenon of Internet-based religions. His 2005 book Authentic Fakes: Religion and American Popular Culture, prompted wide debate about how far into popular culture religious studies scholars should venture.

Lucas Johnston, the third Florida student, argues the Flying Spaghetti Monsterism exhibits at least some of the traits of a traditional religion — including, perhaps, that deep human need to feel like there's something bigger than oneself out there.

He recognized the point when his neighbor, a militant atheist who sports a pro-Darwin bumper sticker on her car, tried recently to start her car on a dying battery.

As she turned the key, she murmured under her breath: "Come on Spaghetti Monster!"[/quote][/size]

PapaHilarious
Posted

editor's note: i refuse to speculate on the possible embellishment of the picture caption :detective:

Posted

well here's my suggestion go smack them upside their head. then again they seem to laywers so they probably gonna end up like in hell any ways. no worries thought those who are week will question those who are strong in faith will laugh and move one. besides and pasta loving ppl would have ate the monster by now i know i would so let the monster come near me.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

The whole thing is stupid anyway. No one ever claimed, for instance, that God tinkers with the rules of the universe in order to avoid detection by science, as this satire seems to claim.

The problem I have is not so much that people dislike or disagree with religion (that is a bad thing, but ignorance prevails). The problem I have is that they use straw man fallacies to do so. None of these people ever seem to know what religion, particularly Christianity, actually teaches.

For that, I find the whole thing ridiculous.

  • 5 months later...
Posted

No amount of laughter, no amount of insults or threats will bring me to disbelieve in God.

Posted

People are just running out of ways to antagonize Christians. I really do wonder why they bother? I kind of think that they are just so envious of what we have in our lives and because they don't know how to get it, they have to attack it. Oh well, they will be gone soon enough but, the church will live forever.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1420341' date='Nov 16 2007, 06:00 PM']The whole thing is stupid anyway. No one ever claimed, for instance, that God tinkers with the rules of the universe in order to avoid detection by science, as this satire seems to claim.[/quote]

Some fundamentalist Christians who don't accept the theory of evolution claim that God planted the fossils on earth as a test of people's faith. That might be what these people are driving at.

I find [i]The Gospel of the Flying Spaghetti Monster[/i] quite funny. Not laugh-out-loud hilarious, but quite funny. I don't think that the creators of this were trying to mock Christians, merely to make a parody a particular way of thinking. I have satirized atheists before now (the kind of atheist who believes that simply being atheist confers an extra 90 IQ points on you, salivates over Richard Dawkins in a sycophantic way, and insists that anybody who isn't atheist is stupid) and I don't object if people satirize Christians too. Satire is healthy and it has the power to provoke some serious thought.

JesusIsMySuperHero
Posted

[quote name='Deb' post='1525632' date='May 12 2008, 09:15 AM']People are just running out of ways to antagonize Christians. I really do wonder why they bother? I kind of think that they are just so envious of what we have in our lives and because they don't know how to get it, they have to attack it. Oh well, they will be gone soon enough but, the church will live forever.[/quote]

Since I understand the world of the occult better than must here, I know exactly why 'Atheists' are doing this croutons.

If a group of Occultists who want me dead give me a Stroke on Dec 27th, 2007, and I called upon God to defend me and bind their evil powers to the bottomless pit, then they can't handle Christianity. They don't want anybody to believe, and so they will ridicule us so we will deny! Problem is, the fact I am on this level of warfare, denying God will be a very foolish thing for me, as if I deny the Son and the Father, they will deny me, and therefore the next time someone wants to take a shot at me, I'm pretty much dead! I hope others have it in their mind never to deny either.

Oh, on the fossil thing, if billions, upon billions gallons of water all of a sudden ripped up the ground, and moved everything around, don't you think there would be lots of fossils of dead animals! The flood explains everything of why there is a lot of things!

HisChildForever
Posted

I never understood how many athiests preoccupy their time with bashing religion, particularly Christianity. If they don't believe in it, why are they wasting their time? Especially since they think Christianity is a waste of time. (So they're wasting their time on a waste of time? :huh: ) It's like they're obsessed with disproving it.

Posted

It's all a joke. These people are poking fun at deism, not just Christianity. They are trying to make fun of organized religion as whole. It's really no big deal. I know a bunch of people who "believe" this stuff and they aren't loonies or whackos, just people who are part of the movement which aims at creating conversations about religion. Overreacting and getting all fundie-Christian about this only proves one of their misperceptions: that people of faith are irrational, uptight wads.

[quote name='JesusIsMySuperHero' post='1525641' date='May 12 2008, 11:25 AM']Oh, on the fossil thing, if billions, upon billions gallons of water all of a sudden ripped up the ground, and moved everything around, don't you think there would be lots of fossils of dead animals! The flood explains everything of why there is a lot of things![/quote]

:crazy:

Dude...

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1525748' date='May 12 2008, 01:44 PM']I never understood how many athiests preoccupy their time with bashing religion, particularly Christianity. If they don't believe in it, why are they wasting their time? Especially since they think Christianity is a waste of time. (So they're wasting their time on a waste of time? :huh: ) It's like they're obsessed with disproving it.[/quote]

Again, I don't believe their intent is to attack Christianity but all theistic religions.

Posted

They just picked something to mock and it is religion. I guess if you have time to waste, why not?
I know I don't want to be an uptight wad. Whatever that may be. Sounds painful.

Posted

[quote name='Deb' post='1525798' date='May 12 2008, 03:00 PM']They just picked something to mock and it is religion. I guess if you have time to waste, why not?
I know I don't want to be an uptight wad. Whatever that may be. Sounds painful.[/quote]

Haha. When you are deprived of attention and what to be witty and funny, you occupy your time with such things.

And no, uptight wads are no good. I guess it's not something said outside of my neighborhood!

Posted

It is more than a simple jest, they are trying to sway people's opinion to 'theiside' just like chrisians and partakers of other religions a trying to obtain converts. In this point we are at least similar.

However, they do so in a most disrespectful way at times, and although this satire in itself is not directly offensive, upon talking to atheists it often becomes quickly obvious that their general opinion of those who hold beliefs of God is none too charming to say the least. Hence the source of most peiople's frustrations on this thread, including my own.

This kind stuff is underlined with insults although not readily apparent. I would sooner engage in a conversation with muslims than engage atheists.

CatherineM
Posted

It's the Florida heat. It's done fried their brains.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1526334' date='May 12 2008, 10:02 PM']It's the Florida heat. It's done fried their brains.[/quote]

It didn't start in Florida...

From the article:

"An Oregon State physics graduate named Bobby Henderson stepped into the debate by sending a letter to the Kansas School Board. With tongue in cheek, he purported to speak for 10 million followers of a being called the Flying Spaghetti Monster — and demanded equal time for their views..."

[img]http://www.wayodd.com/funny-pictures2/funny-pictures-foot-in-mouth-tlu.jpg[/img]

CatherineM
Posted

Wow that looks like a real foot.

Posted

I fell asleep while reading this thread, and must have scrolled down during my brief slumber. Imagine my surprise when I woke up to see that man with a foot in his mouth :lol: :shock:

Galloglasses
Posted

I'm pretty sure that alot of the 180 or so 'guests' who are constantly flicking through Phatmass but aren't posting are either athiests or liberal minded people who would follow this line of flying-spaghetti-monster shiznat, how else, on the polls regarding to morals such as "Are you Pro Life?" and whatnot, we get like 40 votes for "I'm Pro-Choice" yet NO posts stating a user as such? What i'm getting at here is, if athiests are hovering around the site hoping to confront religiously-minded people, why aren't they attacking? What are they waiting for? A post with a weak arguement they could easily refute, swoop down like a vulture and ravage a weak body in a desert?

I've had fun with such minded people on my Sheezyart account, on one of my Religious artworks a poster tried convincing me "Jesus is Dead", to which I replied light heartedly. So on, and so forth, he eventually tried the 'Da Vinci Code' possibility on me, to which I gave him two lines of simplified theology which refuted it as an illogical fallacy on God's part, which would be impossible. May not have been a terribly exciting dialogue, but it gave me the immense pleasure of taking the viciousness out of someone's 'fun'. The Catholicism on my page is so evident in fact, asides from this one guy, almost none of SA's 85% Athiest population try to tackle me on my hometurf. (Altough they seem more then willing to attack Christianity as 'the source of all evil and lies' on SA's general forums. No, they genuinely think that, [url="http://www.sheezyart.com/forum/15/"]see for yourself![/url])

Needless to say, I don't go on the general forums anymore.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...