Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Birth Control Question


Recommended Posts

Guest otto_matic
Posted

My understanding of the Catholic Church's teaching on abortion is that there are certain circumstancs (specifically when the mother's health would be in danger if she carried the child to term and/or delivered the child) in which abortion, although regrettable, is morally acceptable. Is there a similar teaching regarding birth control? In an instance where the mother's health would be in danger if she were to conceive, does the Catholic Church teach that the use of birth control could be considered morally acceptable? I am dating a non-Catholic who takes anti-depressants and needs heavy medication to sleep. She wants to use birth control as a means to ensure that she is not taking these medications, medications which could hurt a developing fetus, while she is unknowingly pregnant. Going off these medications completely would serisouly effect her health. Are there any special dispensations for such a case? Thank you in advance for your advice and cousel.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='otto_matic' post='1421075' date='Nov 17 2007, 01:33 PM']My understanding of the Catholic Church's teaching on abortion is that there are certain circumstancs (specifically when the mother's health would be in danger if she carried the child to term and/or delivered the child) in which abortion, although regrettable, is morally acceptable. Is there a similar teaching regarding birth control? In an instance where the mother's health would be in danger if she were to conceive, does the Catholic Church teach that the use of birth control could be considered morally acceptable? I am dating a non-Catholic who takes anti-depressants and needs heavy medication to sleep. She wants to use birth control as a means to ensure that she is not taking these medications, medications which could hurt a developing fetus, while she is unknowingly pregnant. Going off these medications completely would serisouly effect her health. Are there any special dispensations for such a case? Thank you in advance for your advice and cousel.[/quote]

This topic is often very misunderstood, so I must speak firmly and clearly. Please forgive me if this sounds stern.

Abortion, in all circumstances, is evil and immoral, without exception. A good intention does not excuse an objectively evil act, which abortion is.

However, Catholic moral theology does allow for what is called the principle of double effect. Every act has an object (what is actually being done), and intention (why it is being done), and circumstances (things surrounding the act which may make otherwise moral actions immoral; bathing, for instance, is moral...bathing in public is not). The principle of double effect states that, even if bad things may result, when the object of an action is good in itself and the intention is also good, an act may be done, so long as the circumstances do not allow for a better option to be chosen and so long as the good effect of the action follows at least if not more immediately than the bad effect of the action.

Applying this moral principle, there is one well-known medical condition which can be operated on and would result in the death of a child. Tubal-pregnancy, when the child implants in the fallopian tubes, will in all cases eventually lead to the death of the mother and the child. To have an abortion would be immoral and unacceptable because the object of the action (abortion) is itself evil. However, if the doctor removed the entire fallopian tube, the object of such an action would simply be to remove an endangered organ which will rupture and lead to death. Given that the intention is not to kill the child, but to avoid the death of the mother, both the object and the intention of the action would be good. Since the safety of the mother and the death of the child would directly result, the bad effect and the good effect are both equally immediate. Finally, since there is no sufficiently well-known method which could save the life of the mother and the child in a given set of circumstances, those circumstances prevent a better option.

Some Catholic theologians call this an "indirect abortion," but that is misleading terminology. Abortion is never permitted and is gravely evil, to the extent that anyone who takes part in an abortion is automatically excommunicated from the Catholic Church.

Artificial birth control is also not permitted, since it keeps sexual intercourse from having the ability to be fruitful. While the circumstances making a person consider using birth control are understandable, artificial birth control simply cannot be an option. First, I would try to find a doctor who will find medications which would not harm a developing child. Second, I would be very clear that most birth controls are to some degree or another abortifacient, meaning that they intentionally lead to miscarriage (the pill, for instance, is supposed to stop ovulation, but also contains a back-up drug which weakens the uterine wall, making it difficult or impossible for an embryo to implant, and the embryo dies and leaves the woman's system). Third, I would try to get in touch with the Pope Paul VI Institute, which may have experience with moral difficulties like this (http://www.popepaulvi.com).

God bless,

Raphael

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...