Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Essence Of Liturgical Reform


Recommended Posts

Posted

The Holy Father says in the letter accompanying "Summorum Pontificum" that "the use of the old Missal presupposes a certain degree of liturgical formation and some knowledge of the Latin language; neither of these is found very often." This seems to be the essential inspiration of Liturgical reform (before and during the Council), to reconnect the people with the Liturgy. I'm curious how this could be done while keeping the 1962 Missal intact. It seems to me that the most important thing would be to educate the laity. This could be done in easy ways (e.g., having classes every few months for basic Liturgical formation). I think the language barrier with Latin would not be as much an issue if the people know what is happening in each part, so that it's not as important to know exactly what is being said, but how they should be participating. For example, at the prayers at the foot of the altar, the most important thing is to know that they are asking for God's mercy and grace to celebrate the rest of the Mass. The Council wanted the substantial retention of Latin, but allowed the vernacular where it could be useful. In the future, maybe the vernacular could be used at the beginning of the different parts of the Mass, so that the people know where they are, and then Latin could be used for most of the prayer. For example, the Priest could begin by saying in English, "I will ascend to the altar of God..." and then continue in Latin. Any other thoughts on how to make the Liturgy more accessible while not taking away its mystery?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1421587' date='Nov 18 2007, 04:48 PM']The Holy Father says in the letter accompanying "Summorum Pontificum" that "the use of the old Missal presupposes a certain degree of liturgical formation and some knowledge of the Latin language; neither of these is found very often." This seems to be the essential inspiration of Liturgical reform (before and during the Council), to reconnect the people with the Liturgy. I'm curious how this could be done while keeping the 1962 Missal intact. It seems to me that the most important thing would be to educate the laity. This could be done in easy ways (e.g., having classes every few months for basic Liturgical formation). I think the language barrier with Latin would not be as much an issue if the people know what is happening in each part, so that it's not as important to know exactly what is being said, but how they should be participating. For example, at the prayers at the foot of the altar, the most important thing is to know that they are asking for God's mercy and grace to celebrate the rest of the Mass. The Council wanted the substantial retention of Latin, but allowed the vernacular where it could be useful. In the future, maybe the vernacular could be used at the beginning of the different parts of the Mass, so that the people know where they are, and then Latin could be used for most of the prayer. For example, the Priest could begin by saying in English, "I will ascend to the altar of God..." and then continue in Latin. Any other thoughts on how to make the Liturgy more accessible while not taking away its mystery?[/quote]
You are correct that the 20th century liturgical movement (which culminated in [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i] in many respects) could be described as fundamentally concerned with [i]liturgical piety[/i], to use the movement's phrase.
In the early 20th century there were monasteries which were the center of the liturgical movement and the idea was to bring something of the rich liturgical life that these monasteries enjoyed to the parishes. The monastery at Solesmes was one such center particular noted for its renewal of the Gregorian chant repertoire. Pope Pius X's famous motu proprio on sacred music was in many respects a tip of the tiara to the work of the Solesmes monks.

What needs to be made very clear is that the movement was not about a scholarly reconstruction of the liturgy for "pastoral reasons"; the very idea of a "new Mass" was something unthinkable to the movement as a whole. If the authentic aims of the 20th century liturgical movement had been realized Catholics today would have a deeper appreciation for, and spiritual formation in, the traditional Roman Catholic Mass. The fact that most Roman Catholics today would perhaps see the traditional Mass as something foreign and inaccessible is a testament to the fact that this movement did not merely flop, but was completely destroyed.

The reasons for such a dramatic shift are pretty clear to my mind. Particularly after World War II we find a convergence of historical critical disciplines which lead to the emergence of liturgiology as a distinct field of study. It was the interaction between the historical critical study of the liturgical sources, coupled with the dimension of the liturgical movement that might have "pastoral liturgy" as its slogan, that resulted in a concrete agenda to substantially revise the liturgical rites.
During the pontificate of Pope Pius XII we can see this new impetus being present as a real danger. This is part of what prompted Pius XII's encyclical [i]Mediator Dei[/i] which stresses the authority of the Pope over and against tendencies toward liturgical tinkering which were not approved by the Church. The Pope also strongly warns against tendencies which are destructive of the authentic liturgical tradition such as archaeologism or antiquarianism.
During this pontificate the Church realized the importance of some degree of restoration and enrichment to the liturgical rites themselves, but a substantial revision could only be seen as an attack on the organic nature of the liturgical tradition and a danger to faith. The Holy Week rites underwent some minor changes and the question of some vernacular in the liturgy was seriously addressed.
In the late fifties, contemporaneous with the Holy Week experiments, Father Annibale Bugnini, who was editor of [i]Ephemerides Liturgicae[/i] at the time, composed a provocative questionnaire on his own initiative which he then sent to many of the leading liturgists and historical scholars of the time. The provocative questionnaire can be summed up as a request for opinions as to how these scholars might reengineer the liturgy if they were given power to do so. Since this journal was perceived as being the somewhat official voice of Rome the impression was given that Rome was open to a radical revision of the liturgical rites.
Decades later Bugnini would speak of this "daring move" on his part by wryly commenting that "fortune favors the bold." I consider this to be a pretty important moment in the history of the movement because it began a stir of discussions which set in motion pressure on Rome to open up the liturgy to a wider kind of liturgical revision at the hands of scholars.

And yet still at this time the idea of new liturgical rites on the scale of what followed the Council was unthinkable. A book published after the Council had been announced and preliminary schemata were being drafted and discussed, [i]Bringing the Mass to the People[/i], which represents the more "progressive" voice of that time makes it clear that what was envisioned as the hoped for fruits of the post-conciliar liturgical reform was not at all the striking departure from the traditional liturgy that we later find. It is even safe to say that what the Council voted on, and what the resulting constitution represents, was not the radical revision of the Church's rites that was constructed by scholars in the years that followed (largely driven by the controversial figure of Bugnini whose reputation as an iconoclast was well known).

There are countless factors and events that could be expounded upon in trying to adequately describe the dynamics of all this, but I cannot hope to achieve such a comprehensive presentation in posts.
One thing at least, that I consider to have been detrimental to the original aims of the movement is that the link between private devotion/spiritual formation and liturgical worship was diminished. An attitude emerges which seems to suppose that by introducing substantial ritual changes the sought after liturgical piety would almost follow of necessity. I won't over-simplify the matter by suggesting that this is the whole problem, far from it, but it is one of many symptoms of a shift in mentality that has only served to detract from the original spirit of the movement. I must stop here for now, but if you would like to hear more of my take on the liturgical movement I'd be happy to share more of what I believe.

Peace.

Posted

Thanks for the post, there's a lot to chew on. I guess this is my larger question: if you could go back in time before the reform, in what ways could you have reformed the 1962 Missal without major revision of the Missal itself. What practical changes could be made so that the Liturgy is more accessible to the people, but still the same Missal with the same prayers, etc.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1422335' date='Nov 19 2007, 05:36 PM']Thanks for the post, there's a lot to chew on. I guess this is my larger question: if you could go back in time before the reform, in what ways could you have reformed the 1962 Missal without major revision of the Missal itself. What practical changes could be made so that the Liturgy is more accessible to the people, but still the same Missal with the same prayers, etc.[/quote]
Well, in my honest opinion I think the problem is that things have been seen too much in terms of activism, or things that we can do to “force” a greater liturgical participation. It is my opinion that the movement may have been guilty of a lack of patience which contributed to the fact that much of what resulted was too hasty and at times reckless (and I’m not just talking about the ICEL translations hehe).
Liturgical piety is ultimately a cultural change in consciousness or heart. I think the initiatives and directives that had already been in place prior to the Council would have been sufficient in bringing about the sought after renewal in an organic way but it would have demanded perseverance and time. The conciliar constitution was a good step, but there were already dangers in the air that threatened to undermine the authenticity of this call to renewal. In the end it was distorted into a pretext for all manner of “progressive” license. I will at least produce a few line items to speak to your specific question.

Reformed liturgical formation of seminarians. In times past there was a great deal of emphasis on the rubrics but very little in terms of the deep spirituality and theology of the liturgy (not to suggest that things are better today). Also Gregorian chant as a normative aspect of seminary formation (something the Church does in fact call for to this day). This also includes a better approach to homiletics. If the priests have been formed in liturgical piety and understand what this means this will trickle down to the people in the pews.

Sacred music as the preeminent vehicle of actual participation by the faithful. This includes initiatives (official and grassroots) to answer the Church’s call in establishing groups and even institutions dedicated to preserving and furthering the sacred music tradition.

The introduction of the vernacular (not to be confused with “vernacularism” which is what seems to be the norm these days).

Ritual changes (restorative and/or enriching) that accord with the principle of organic development. To some extent the introduction of the vernacular belongs to this category but I’m thinking more of other things such as: enriching the lectionary (which is different than what followed the Council since the traditional lectionary that is the fruit of development stretching back to the early Church has been discarded in favour of a calculated scholarly redaction); restoring the second reading on Sundays and feast days; the restoration of the catechumenate; although quite arguable I would say the restoration of the offertory procession; increasing the number of prefaces by restoring traditional prefaces that have fallen out of use or composing new ones that are truly proper to the genre; et cetera. I say “et cetera” because the list could go on and on of ritual adaptations that may be apposite to the question of enriching the liturgical life of the Church. The fundamental issue though is that the liturgy is authentically understood before such questions are put on the table. I think that [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i], understood in context, along with a thorough understanding of the Church’s historical teachings and policies pertaining to liturgical reform makes clear that this kind of endeavor is not to be a revolution from the ground up (a rupture if you will). This is why I must set aside the particular questions to some extent because it is ultimately a question of what the liturgy is and thus the nature and scope of what liturgical reform actually means. This is why the orientation of my response to your question would seek to depart from a mentality that assumes that external ritual reforms are the primary topic (or even necessary topic) in the question of promoting liturgical piety. To my mind the impetus of authentic liturgical reform ought to be fidelity to the liturgical tradition and the truth of the liturgy, not sociological manipulation based on externals.

As an aside I must mention my view that when one examines the host of figures who were involved in the creation of the new Mass it is clear that a discussion of the liturgical movement alone is not adequate in explaining all of the dynamics involved. The post-conciliar reform was in many respects the product of a convergence of movements. One would have to examine the interaction with the biblical movement, the ecumenical movement, et cetera, to get a fuller picture of what was going on.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1422370' date='Nov 19 2007, 05:14 PM']This is why the orientation of my response to your question would seek to depart from a mentality that assumes that external ritual reforms are the primary topic (or even necessary topic) in the question of promoting liturgical piety. To my mind the impetus of authentic liturgical reform ought to be fidelity to the liturgical tradition and the truth of the liturgy, not sociological manipulation based on externals.[/quote]
I agree, I put education of the laity first in my proposals because I think that is the heart of the problem. The Holy Father has said this as well:

[quote]And so, I think we have to restore not so much certain ceremonies, but the essential idea of liturgy – to understand in liturgy, we are not representing ourselves, but we receive the grace of the presence of the Lord with the Church of the heaven and of the earth. And the universality of the liturgy, it seems to me, is essential. Definition of liturgy and restoring this idea would also help to be more obedient to the norms, not as a juridical positivism, but really as sharing, participating what is given to us from the Lord in the Church.[/quote]
If the laity understand what Mass is, and truly understand what is happening and how they are participating, then that resolves a lot of things such as not knowing Latin. I think the Byzantine Liturgy has the advantage in this regard because it is more concretely accessible to the people. It's in the vernacular, there is more prescribed participation, etc. I don't think the Roman Rite has to be the Byzantine Rite, there are legitimate differences. But I think we have to work extra hard to make sure that the laity understand what is happening. If they don't, then I think that is the root of the problem, they are disconnected from the Liturgy, and if we believe as we pray, then it is easy for them to become disconnected from the faith.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1422444' date='Nov 19 2007, 06:57 PM']I agree with this. That's why I put education of the laity first in my proposals, because I think that is the heart of the problem. The Holy Father has said this as well:
If the laity understand what Mass is, and truly understand what is happening and how they are participating, then that resolves a lot of things such as not knowing Latin. I think the Byzantine Liturgy has the advantage in this regard because it is more concretely accessible to the people. It's in the vernacular, there is more prescribed participation, etc. I don't think the Roman Rite has to be the Byzantine Rite, there are legitimate differences. But I think we have to work extra hard to make sure that the laity understand what is happening. If they don't, then I think that is the root of the problem, they are disconnected from the Liturgy, and if we believe as we pray, then it is easy for them to become disconnected from the faith.[/quote]
Amen Era. The only thing I might qualify is that Latin is an indispensable part of our liturgical tradition and it is tragic that the introduction of the vernacular has often been couched in a disdain for this aspect of the tradition. It should be kept in mind that this kind of thing is not entirely unique to the Latin liturgical tradition. The use in Eastern rites of liturgical Greek, Slavonic, Aramaic, Arabic, etc. along side the vernacular is hardly uncommon and is certainly laudable. I generally define [i]vernacularism[/i] as that mentality which sees Latin as intrinsically hostile to "active participation" which is an attitude that is not consistent with the true nature of the liturgy or with our tradition. The introduction of the vernacular does not mean the end of Latin, Greek or Hebrew in our liturgy. On the contrary Latin is very much an important and indispensable part of our living liturgical tradition as the teachings of the Church make clear. In my opinion, far too much weight is put on the use of the vernacular as if it is the magic formula for authentic actual participation. I believe that the past 40 years testify to the fact that this attitude is pretty far off the mark. As I see it, an important aspect of what liturgical piety ought to achieve is an appreciation of Latin in our liturgy. This does not mean that the vernacular is a no-no, certainly it can be quite valuable, but the introduction of the vernacular does not imply that Latin is a disposable or superfluous element of our rites.

Posted

Yah, I didn't mean to say that because the vernacular has its advantages in the Byzantine Rite that therefore there shouldn't be Latin in the Roman Rite. An analogy in the Byzantine Rite is the iconastasis. If a layman doesn't understand why it's there, and just thinks that he's not supposed to know what's going on, then that misunderstanding affects his participation in the Liturgy. It doesn't mean the iconostasis should be removed, just that he should be catechized about why it's there. An average layman may just see Latin as a dead language left over from the middle ages. He has to be catechized about its theological and spiritual meaning. I think this has to happen on the parish level, because we can't expect that everyone will read documents from the Holy See.

I think I read that the Popes in the early 20th century wrote against concert-style music in the Liturgy, do you know anything about this? I think they preferred more simple forms of chant so that the people could follow along. This seems like an example of something practical where the Church doesn't allow the Liturgy to become too lofty that the people can't relate, but still retaining the beauty of chant.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1422483' date='Nov 19 2007, 07:34 PM']Yah, I didn't mean to say that because the vernacular has its advantages in the Byzantine Rite that therefore there shouldn't be Latin in the Roman Rite. An analogy in the Byzantine Rite is the iconastasis. If a layman doesn't understand why it's there, and just thinks that he's not supposed to know what's going on, then that misunderstanding affects his participation in the Liturgy. It doesn't mean the iconostasis should be removed, just that he should be catechized about why it's there. I think it's obvious to you and me what the purpose of Latin is, and the theological and spiritual benefits of it, but an average layman who may not read much theology wouldn't necessarily make that connection unless he is catechized.[/quote]
Amen bro.

[quote name='Era Might' post='1422483' date='Nov 19 2007, 07:34 PM']I think I read that the Popes in the early 20th century wrote against concert-style music, do you know anything about this? I think they preferred more simple forms of chant so that the people could follow along. This seems like an example of something practical where the Church doesn't allow the Liturgy to become too lofty that the people can't relate, but still retaining the beauty of chant.[/quote]
Yes! The monastery at Solesmes that I mentioned, along with Mont-Cesar (home of Beauduin who is often called the father of the modern liturgical movement) and others were in many respects acting to reform the crisis in liturgical music that was inherited from the classical and romantic era. This is precisely the context in which to understand Pope Pius X's motu proprio [i]Tra le Sollecitudini[/i] which I highly recommend reading.
The understanding here is that sacred music is a genre that was born within the liturgy itself and goes back to apostolic roots and indeed it is the very musical language of the liturgy itself and is intrinsic to the liturgy. The operatic or concert style Masses of that time were seen as an encroachment of the profane and as detracting from the liturgy's authentic spirit. The issue was not that the liturgy would become "too lofty" but that its spirit would be undermined by secular forms of music or a showy atmosphere that serves to detract from participation in the liturgical action (sort of a show with the Mass as a backdrop).
It is true that the simpler forms of chant were encouraged for those parts of the Mass that call for the singing of the entire congregation, but in no way were the more ornamented and complex forms of chant and polyphony altogether discouraged. These can be most appropriate, particularly on solemn feasts, for adding solemnity to the Mass. But you are correct that sacred music is seen at this time as having pastoral value and indeed this is part of the context in which Pope Pius X coined the famous phrase "active participation" (which I think is better translated as "actual participation"). :cool:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Another currently active thread has given me the desire to mention that our current Pope has repeatedly called for a new liturgical movement. I consider his book [i]The Spirit of the Liturgy[/i] to be something of a manifesto for such a movement.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1421587' date='Nov 18 2007, 04:48 PM']This seems to be the essential inspiration of Liturgical reform (before and during the Council), to reconnect the people with the Liturgy. I'm curious how this could be done while keeping the 1962 Missal intact. It seems to me that the most important thing would be to educate the laity...Any other thoughts on how to make the Liturgy more accessible while not taking away its mystery?[/quote]
I must say that I assist at Mass almost exclusively according to the Missal of 1962 and by comparison I find the ordinary form (as it is most commonly celebrated) to create a great deal of distraction and disconnect with the Mass. One thing that I think is important to your question is that authentic sacred music affords full, conscious and actual participation in the liturgical action whereas liturgical singing in the mainstream scene these days appears to be limited to superfluous hymns or jingles that have little or nothing to do with the Mass. I truly believe that this is one of the crucial areas to be focused upon by any new liturgical movement (as it was with the original movement).
As always, there is some diversity from parish to parish, but in my limited experience this is something where even the extraordinary form parishes could be greatly improved. My parish has a superb schola, but I have the impression that the better part of the congregation doesn’t understand their role in singing the parts of the Mass that pertain to them.
The post conciliar reform was, in my opinion, a remarkable occasion in which to address these and other problems which was, I dare say, squandered. The "prayers of the faithful", for example, is today most often a lay person who gets up on the mic with some amateur composition of prayer intentions to which the congregation responds by simply saying "Lord, here our prayer" (or something similar). Based on the historical practice that was hoped to be restored I think that the current practice of the Eastern Churches would have been a more authentic model (the litany of fervent supplication for example); certainly more in keeping with the spirit of the liturgy. A fixed, or mostly fixed, litany of profound and truly liturgical prayers - the tradition affords a wealth of prayers that could have been restored or used as inspiration - intoned by the priest or deacon with the congregation responding in song (as an aside an objective glance at our tradition on this subject raises a number of questions about the placement of the [i]Kyrie [/i]in the "reformed" Mass). Indeed, I have reason to believe that the Consilium itself (the group that created the new Mass) intended the Mass to be substantially intoned and that the singing of the ordinary and propers would be the core musical participation by the faithful in the Mass and not a haphazard series of jingles that really serve to replace praying the Mass. I am certain that this was the intention of Pope Paul VI.
Anyway, I don’t want to spew forth another treatise so I’ll just leave it at that. Cheers!

P.S. In support of my above conjecture pertaining to the Consilium I shall reproduce an excerpt from Notitiae 5 [1969] p. 406, that I encountered recently. It is a response from the Consilium to an inquiry about whether vernacular hymns were permitted in this new Mass. I must note that later legislation differs from this statement (for a complex host of reasons) but all I am trying to support is the assertion that the current practice is a departure from the intention of those who created the Mass.

[quote]That rule [permitting vernacular hymns] has been superseded. What must be sung is the Mass, its Ordinary and Proper, not “something”, no matter how consistent, that is imposed on the Mass. Because the liturgical service is one, it has only one countenance, one motif, one voice, the voice of the Church. To continue to replace the texts of the Mass being celebrated with motets that are reverent and devout, yet out of keeping with the Mass of the day amounts to continuing an unacceptable ambiguity: it is to cheat the people. Liturgical song involves not mere melody, but words, text, thought and the sentiments that the poetry and music contain. Thus texts must be those of the Mass, not others, and singing means singing the Mass not just singing during Mass.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1422499' date='Nov 19 2007, 06:47 PM']Amen bro.


Yes! The monastery at Solesmes that I mentioned, along with Mont-Cesar (home of Beauduin who is often called the father of the modern liturgical movement) and others were in many respects acting to reform the crisis in liturgical music that was inherited from the classical and romantic era. This is precisely the context in which to understand Pope Pius X's motu proprio [i]Tra le Sollecitudini[/i] which I highly recommend reading.
The understanding here is that sacred music is a genre that was born within the liturgy itself and goes back to apostolic roots and indeed it is the very musical language of the liturgy itself and is intrinsic to the liturgy. The operatic or concert style Masses of that time were seen as an encroachment of the profane and as detracting from the liturgy's authentic spirit. The issue was not that the liturgy would become "too lofty" but that its spirit would be undermined by secular forms of music or a showy atmosphere that serves to detract from participation in the liturgical action (sort of a show with the Mass as a backdrop).
It is true that the simpler forms of chant were encouraged for those parts of the Mass that call for the singing of the entire congregation, but in no way were the more ornamented and complex forms of chant and polyphony altogether discouraged. These can be most appropriate, particularly on solemn feasts, for adding solemnity to the Mass. But you are correct that sacred music is seen at this time as having pastoral value and indeed this is part of the context in which Pope Pius X coined the famous phrase "active participation" (which I think is better translated as "actual participation"). :cool:[/quote]
This is the sort of thing I've been discovering as of recent, due to the great suspicion over the last year or so of the lack of solemnity in music in the liturgy. Sometimes I think I must be crazy to take this on, especially when trying to "reform" a youth ministry containing energetic youth who are miraculously giving up their weekends for all night adorations and are willing to stand up and talk to other young people about God. I almost feel like a liturgical prude by having the idea (no matter how sincere or whatever I may be) that "hey guys, I know you're all feeling close to Christ in this music, but it's not good enough. We should learn chant 'cause the Church says so". Maybe I'm taking to much for granted, maybe I'm lacking trust in the Lord. But hey, the way I see it is we gotta reform the liturgy by putting Latin back in it somewhere, before we decide anything about the old Rite, etc. This is a really sucky position we're in right now, cause one one hand people emphasise "ooh noes we can't cause division within our own church! That's seeds of the devil!". On the other hand, there is "profane music and the so called vernacularism [if I may, L_D] is invading the liturgy! This is the blight of evil!". It seems like a death trap either way. I have hope, but I'm just saying what seems to be out there.

Btw, I'm honoured that L_D sorta reccomended me to hop on board with this thread. I'm into reform, but I've got a lot to learn about what is supposed to be first. I'm only 18, but I guess I gotta start some time. I gotta work on my music stuff meanwhile... things are complex in my life, in youth ministry life and so fourth. Anywho God bless you all in your endevours.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1423312' date='Nov 21 2007, 04:51 PM']This is the sort of thing I've been discovering as of recent, due to the great suspicion over the last year or so of the lack of solemnity in music in the liturgy. Sometimes I think I must be crazy to take this on, especially when trying to "reform" a youth ministry containing energetic youth who are miraculously giving up their weekends for all night adorations and are willing to stand up and talk to other young people about God. I almost feel like a liturgical prude by having the idea (no matter how sincere or whatever I may be) that "hey guys, I know you're all feeling close to Christ in this music, but it's not good enough. We should learn chant 'cause the Church says so". Maybe I'm taking to much for granted, maybe I'm lacking trust in the Lord. But hey, the way I see it is we gotta reform the liturgy by putting Latin back in it somewhere, before we decide anything about the old Rite, etc. This is a really sucky position we're in right now, cause one one hand people emphasise "ooh noes we can't cause division within our own church! That's seeds of the devil!". On the other hand, there is "profane music and the so called vernacularism [if I may, L_D] is invading the liturgy! This is the blight of evil!". It seems like a death trap either way. I have hope, but I'm just saying what seems to be out there.

Btw, I'm honoured that L_D sorta reccomended me to hop on board with this thread. I'm into reform, but I've got a lot to learn about what is supposed to be first. I'm only 18, but I guess I gotta start some time. I gotta work on my music stuff meanwhile... things are complex in my life, in youth ministry life and so fourth. Anywho God bless you all in your endevours.[/quote]
I think it is so cool that you're doing this. This is somewhat tangential but I think a lot of liturgical abuses have originated in so-called "youth Masses" and similar settings which often involve an inordinate emphasis on the horizontal. As far as I can tell right now, the fad of [i]versus populum[/i] celebration may have originated in Masses associated with various youth movements in the 1920's and beyond (the Hitler Youth being a famous example). In this country a lot of strange practices have come and gone that were related to the hippie movement and similar fads. I think it is often analogous to the music issue in that more often than not there is a degree of secular or profane encroachment in the liturgy and too great an emphasis put on the particular community that is "gathered together." The liturgical assembly, the synaxis, is first and foremost the Saints in heaven who are united to Christ - that great cloud of witnesses who have resisted to the point of shedding blood - and vast armies of unimaginable and terrifying angelic beings who are prostrate in praise and adoration of the Most Holy Trinity. We are the church militant who come as unworthy pilgrims to partake of Holy Mysteries that far transcend the particular group of people gathered together to celebrate the work of our hands by sharing a cup of spiritual drink with a soundtrack of corny jingles and perhaps even a laugh track. The heavens are truly opened, the Lamb is slain in our midst, and the very cosmos is deified. Surely our frail liturgical actions cannot do justice to the realities that unfold in the liturgy, but they ought to at least express recognition of the fact that God is really the one acting (and in the [i]whole[/i] liturgy, not just the "moment of consecration"). Profane banality and haphazard, warm and fuzzy horse manure are about as far from appropriate to the Mass as a three ring circus. - End rant.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Era,

I just came across the seminal work of the 20th century liturgical movement back in print!

[url="http://www.theabbeyshop.com/product_info.php?cPath=21_29&products_id=376"]http://www.theabbeyshop.com/product_info.p...products_id=376[/url]

I'm definitely going to be scooping this one up and I thought you might be interested in it too. :cool:

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

L_D

From this and other threads I've read, you've got some pretty interesting things to say on the liturgy and I myself am coming to examine and question the current liturgy and the old liturgy. I certainly accept Vat. II and the 1970 Mass to be valid and legit and all, but I can't help but question some of the things in the 1970 mass that just don't seem right:

-Offeratory
-Sign of peace basically turns into a big talk "hey hows it going" fest (especially with youth masses) as Christ is sitting there on the alter- It always makes me cringe
-Even the verses populum vs. ad orientem question
-How the mass of 1962 seems so drastically different from the mass of 1970.
- Possible Horizontal emphasis instead of vertical/sacrificial emphasis

Putting aside the facts of poor implementations of the 1970 liturgy (liturgical abuses) and poor ICEL translations, which have nothing to do with the validity of the liturgy itself, how much are we allowed to question certain aspects of the new mass and reconcille that while being true to the authority of the Church and Vatican II (ie not going off the "Rad-trad/ SSPX" cliff)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...