Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Golden Compass


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]A children’s fantasy film that stars Nicole Kidman and features a little girl on a quest to kill God has some Christian groups upset over what they believe is a ploy to promote atheism to kids.[/quote]

[url="http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,305487,00.html"]http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,305487,00.html[/url]

I have never read the books, so I cant say that much about it, but have any of you read them? What do you think about the books, the controversy, and all that?

Posted

The movie looks so good. It's a shame the morality doesn't register.

Posted

I agree, the movie looks so good, and I think that people just dont want the books to be picked up by the movie, since the book is what has all the objectionable material, not the movie.

Posted

There's still objectionable material present in the movie, no matter how negligible. It's the same story, and whether or not they tone down the blatant anti-Catholicism in the movie, it will still promote the same message. That's the point of the story...it wouldn't be the same story without it. They can't remove the objectionable material completely without changing the entire story.

I am boycotting this movie and I encourage everyone else who upholds moral values to do the same. There is nothing redeeming about this story.

Personally I don't think the movie looks all that great anyway.

Posted

catholic league is up in arms over it.....rightly so

Posted

[size=1]On facebook I joined the "I do not Support the Golden Compass" group, and alomst the very day after, a friend decided he would take the opportunity to write a nice two post message on my wall about how stupid it was the boycott the movie.

Here are some of his arguments:[/size]
[quote]Claire, do you really think Golden Compass will be evil? I mean first of all Nicole Kidman (the star) has said she wouldn't in good conscience, as a devout Catholic, join a film she found bashed God.[/quote]
[size=1]Yeah, cause claiming to be catholic in Hollywood really means anything these days.
[/size]

[quote]Did you also know that the "god" that the characters in the book are battling is merely an impostor who only claims to be God. This "God" has deceived the church in many worlds and has taken a somewhat dictatorial control. The purpose of the film is the drive to regain control so the people can worship the real God![/quote]

Posted (edited)

This series is in direct rebuttal to C.S. Lewis's Narnia series IMHO. the author is a known atheist.

They depict God as a fraud, and establish a "Republic of Heaven". After destroying the original of course.

nice.

Just because Nicole Kidman is in it, does not mean that she made it fully aware that the series is in direct opposition to her faith. She may have a fashion advisor, but something tells me a religious advisor isn't necessarily employed by top notch actors.

besides, [url="http://www.aceshowbiz.com/movie/chronicles_of_narnia_prince_caspian_the/"]Prince Caspian [/url]is coming to theaters!!!!

Edited by jmjtina
Servant of the Secret Fire
Posted

I also am debating whether or not to boycott it. My initial instinct was to do so, but I'm beginning to wonder. I've had a couple of people point out to me that I went to see the Da Vinci Code, but I don't feel this is quite the same. I reckoned that it would be easier to debunk Dan Brown's conspiracy theories having read the books and seen the film. With Pullman's work however it seems to me there aren't so many specific things to refute - it's his whole atheistic worldview that is the problem.

I suppose we need to be careful to how we respond, as the "religion" he attacks is really the worst of what we sinners can make of religion (oppressive, truth-censoring, abusive ...) and it could be all too easy to provide him with more ammunition and lead people further away from the Christ. Indeed I have seen a few people comment on the net on the tragic irony that on some moral themes he does speak the truth, all the while denying the existence of Truth Himself.

Of course the other thing is that the atheistic theme is not clear in the 1st book and apparently they have toned things down further in the film. I assume Nicole Kidman has not read the 2nd and 3rd books. Sad, she may well get a shock.

Posted

the Da Vinci Code was an adult film.

This film's main audience is children. I don't know about you, but when it's a wolf in sheeps clothing presented to and for children, it's an easier decision for me to make. Good intentional parents may totally be unaware and take thier children, see the movie and buy the books for further reading. (Go to Barnes and Noble and even Wal-Mart to see evidence of the promotion)

At least the people I encounter will be aware of why I am against this movie. And then they will decide for themselves. good Christian parents don't want to expose their children to something so blatantly Anti-Christian.

Posted

I'm going to boycott it, but not by holding up signs along the road and near the movie theater and wearing sandwhich boxes to work or anything. I'm just not going to see it and if anyone asks me about it, tell them why. The director of the film outright said "I'm actually glad that people are boycotting it, because that will encourage more people to come and see it."
Unfortunately, the preview looks pretty cool and exciting and rather like the "Narnia" trailer...At the library where I work, the "Golden Compass" book has been circulating like crazy. :sick:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='azaelia' post='1424599' date='Nov 25 2007, 01:42 PM']There's still objectionable material present in the movie, no matter how negligible. It's the same story, and whether or not they tone down the blatant anti-Catholicism in the movie, it will still promote the same message. That's the point of the story...it wouldn't be the same story without it. They can't remove the objectionable material completely without changing the entire story.

I am boycotting this movie and I encourage everyone else who upholds moral values to do the same. There is nothing redeeming about this story.

Personally I don't think the movie looks all that great anyway.[/quote]

I must say, I did want to go see it, untill I found out it had anti-christian material in it. It's sad, because I love fantasy, and I also loved the polar bears as well, lol.

I am going to boycott it as well.

[quote]besides, Prince Caspian is coming to theaters!!!![/quote]

Awesome! ^____________^

Edited by Selah
Posted (edited)

[quote name='jmjtina' post='1424624' date='Nov 25 2007, 03:49 PM']besides, [url="http://www.aceshowbiz.com/movie/chronicles_of_narnia_prince_caspian_the/"]Prince Caspian [/url]is coming to theaters!!!![/quote]

I watched the teaser trailer linked to on that site, and I have to say, I'm not that excited... I realize it was all computer graphics rather than the real footage, because its early, but still... Then again, Prince Caspian was probably my least favorite of the books, so maybe its that... ?

/hijack

Edit: I watched the other one, and it had some real footage, with Susan in it, and it looked a little better. ok.

/hijack again

Edited by Romans1513
Lioness For Christ
Posted

he called himself an anti-C.S. Lewis... And I once picked up the book because it looked interesting (I didn't know a thing about it) and found issues with the first chapter.. Small things but it was enough for me.

Posted (edited)

In the book they: 'give the "GIFT" of death to God'... They equate God to basically a small rodent.

Not only am I going to boycott the movie, every actor that I've seen in the preview is now on my boycott list. None of my money will go to it or anyone in it.

Edited by ironmonk
Posted

I'm boycotting this movie.

[url="http://catholicleague.org/release.php?id=1361"]http://catholicleague.org/release.php?id=1361[/url]

One of the many news articles the Catholic League has posted. Just look on their main page or in the archives.

Posted

Sad. The movie looks so exciting. OF course, I am not going to go though.

Prince Caspian, however, :woot: I can't wait!!

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

The books definitely have an anti-Catholic flavour, but I don't oppose them. I gave my reasons [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=73469&hl=philip+pullman"]in a different thread[/url]. Here is my original post:
[quote]They are brilliant books. I loved reading them. They didn't turn me into an atheist. They are well-written and with a fascinating storyline, and while atheism has a prominent part in the plot, the trilogy isn't solely (or even mostly) about the death of the Authority. (The Authority is an aging angel who seized power over the heavens and the earth with the aid of strong band of angelic supporters.) These books have won a sweeping array of literary prizes - prizes that aren't awarded for destruction of the Christian worldview, but for terrific writing.

I've read a lot of extremely good literature which is at odds with Catholic teaching, and it hasn't hurt me - I don't automatically start believing whatever I read. I don't know anything about the film, and I won't go to see it as I don't really like the cinema, but by urging people to avoid Pullman's work we are actually propagating the very stereotype of the Catholic Church that he presents in the books. The Church of those books is out to prevent people from sampling new ideas or reading anything that differs from its teachings, and when people question this they are told, in the soft-voiced melodic tones of Mrs Coulter, that it is for their own good and protection.

These are teenagers' books. Catholic teenagers need to be well-read and we need to be able to engage intelligently with viewpoints that are at odds with our own. His Dark Materials can even be used as a springboard to talk about the nature of God: Pullman's concept of 'god' is truly pitiful and bears no resemblance to the Holy One we worship. I could see this even as a fifteen-year-old, when my theological knowledge was a lot more impoverished than it is now.

Don't try to crush this. Engage with it. If Pullman were writing atheist potboilers in the style of Hitchens and Dawkins, I would heave a weary sigh and turn away - that sort of book has already ben rebutted enough times and it's a tired genre. But Pullman isn't doing that. He has ideas, he writes well, and he needs to be taken seriously - for our sake as well as for the sake of atheists. True evangelism means listening to the other person's ideas (however unpalatable you may find them) and responding creatively and with sensitivity, not stuffing reams of cotton wool down your earholes. And true growth in faith involves challenges. Young Catholic readers can't be closeted forever - and their faith would be as pitiful as Pullman's 'god' if they were.[/quote]

kenrockthefirst
Posted

If Pullman wants to take on CS Lewis, let him work away. My money's on CS Lewis.

Posted

[i]"In "Compass," the curious 12-year-old protagonist, Lyra, stumbles on an adventure very close to home when she overhears talk of an amazing substance called Dust, which can unite the world but is so feared that many are scrambling to eradicate it."[/i]

Sweet.

Theologian in Training
Posted

The following was sent to all of us in the diocese...it is pretty enlightening.

Dear Pastors, Administrators, Principals and Colleagues,

There has been a great deal of hype and controversy about "The Golden Compass" an alleged children's adventure film which debuts December 7, 2007. Here is a media analysis including quotes from the author of the original book. I hope you will be able to use all or part of it in the parish bulletin before the premiere.

MEDIA ALERT


As some of you may know New Line Cinema premiers The Golden Compass their big budget fantasy film on December 7th 2007. It could be the first in a trilogy. It has been advertised as a children's adventure. So now is the time to say Caveat Emptor - Buyer Beware!

Unlike the beloved Chronicles of Narnia, The Golden Compass has a very different message. In an interview with the Washington Post the author Philip Pullman says: "I am trying to undermine the basis of Christian belief."

The film is based on the first volume of Mr. Pullman's trilogy HIS DARK MATERIALS originally written as adult fantasy science fiction. This film is thinly veiled hate mail for God and Christian beliefs and it uses children. Quoting Pullman: "My publishers' decision to publish the trilogy as children's literature was a brilliant trick and has them flying off the shelves. I doubt that they would have done as well on the adult shelves with so much competition in the genre."

The Dark Force throughout the trilogy is called the Magisterium. Investigating all sorts of dictionaries and encyclopedias yields only one real life definition for that word - "the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church." Magisterium equals dark force is a great message for our children.

In the film, children begin to disappear. The dark forces kidnap them and perform harmful experiments upon them. Other children seek them out to their peril. Now there is a nice Christmas film for Catholic families. The film is the hook for the less benign books, video-games that debut in time for Christmas!

The children's triumphal moment of the book trilogy occurs when they open a "jewel" containing the fraudulent fallen angel calling himself God and he dies. The children liberate everyone creating an atheistic heaven on earth.

The film is rated PG 13. Pullman and New Line are hoping to cash in on the trendy fantasy film genre. Whatever New Line Cinema waters down -- however they spin the hype -- this media alert is designed to inform you about the real product content before you buy a ticket, a book or a game.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...