Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group Ă—
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm doing an argumentative speech on how safe sex is a joke.

My question pertains to condoms, which I really don't know too much about. Do any condoms have warnings on them regarding their lack of giving full protection? Do any of them say something like Warning: This product does not guarantee full protection from HIV, HPV or whatever? Just wondering. I don't wanna get up in front of everyone and say something along the lines of "The condom companies don't even warn against the fact that these things aren't really that safe..." and then have someone be like, "uhhh, yeah they do come out and warn ya on the label..."

anyways, I hope I'm makin sense. If anyone could help, that'd be great...

Posted (edited)

i'm pretty sure it does say something to the effect of

'does not protect fully..."

Edited by rachael
farglefeezlebut
Posted

Here in the UK they are legally obliged to print such warnings (although they can probably get away with doing this in really tiny print, unlike warnings on cigarettes, which have to cover a certain percentage of the packaging - I think it's 25%, but could be wrong). I don't know about the law elsewhere.

However, the thing about "safe" sex is that even when condoms work (and in fairness, they do the majority of the time) is that it's only "safe" physically. It's not safe emotionally. It's not safe psychologically. It's certainly not safe spiritually and morally. I think you should focus on what sex "education" programmes largely or completely ignore - the wellbeing of the "participants" (beyond their physical health.) For example, masturbation is sometimes actively encouraged because it's "safe".

It is important not to be disengenous (sp?) So you should probably point out that advocates of "safe" sex do provide some discussion pf emotional and psychological issues. However, from what I've experienced, read and heard about, this is usually limited to someone telling you that you shouldn't have sex if you don't want to. Sometimes, they talk about your right to insist the other person respects you ( I have NEVER heard of any sex "education" programme, other than faith-based chastity programmes, which even mentions your obligation to respect the other person.) Love is usually treated as an "optional extra" rather than the reason for the act.

Posted

i agree with everything you're saying, and I wish I could go into that much detail, but unfortunately I only have 5-7 minutes to cram this into, and so I was thinking about hitting the cold hard scientific facts, e.g. 3 or so STDs one could get even if they used a condom in normal 'protected' sex. I wish I could cover masturbation and other sex acts as well as the psychological effects and sex education, but I'm really limited on time.

The main reason why I chose this topic is because I'm starting a pro-life group on campus, and I want to start showing the reasons why real pro-lifers save themselves for marriage, so I know for sure I don't want to change my topic, but one of the things I was going to compare condom consumption to was cigarettes, and like you mentioned, how cigarette companies are obliged to tell the absolute truth on their cartons and packs, but condom companies can hide it so they can sell more sex.

The other way to compare the two is through the fact that we rarely hear or see any cigarette commercials anymore (at least not in the US) but anytime you wanna hear condom promotion, you can just turn on MTV or another station delving in the culture of death...

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1423751' date='Nov 22 2007, 11:52 PM']i agree with everything you're saying, and I wish I could go into that much detail, but unfortunately I only have 5-7 minutes to cram this into, and so I was thinking about hitting the cold hard scientific facts, e.g. 3 or so STDs one could get even if they used a condom in normal 'protected' sex. I wish I could cover masturbation and other sex acts as well as the psychological effects and sex education, but I'm really limited on time.[/quote]

Condoms provide protection against HIV 97 per cent of the time. (That does not apply to the poorer quality, heat-weakened condoms that are handed out in sub-Saharan Africa.) The figure is quite a bit lower for other STDs.

However, 97% is a strong figure. Your opponents could easily argue that it is better to have some protection than none at all, and bring in the argument that not every person who uses birth control has had multiple sexual partners and picked up a host of diseases. They will talk about people in monogamous, long-term relationships who use contraception, and point out that the 'safety rate' is much higher in these circumstances. If you make it sound as though the chance of contracting an STI is significant whenever people use condoms, your argument may be dismissed as ill-educated scaremongering.

Mention the dangers by all means, but I think your primary focus should be on the negative attitudes that come with contraception - for example, the temptation to see sex as a right and not a gift, even in faithful long-term relationships; the increase in psychologically damaging casual sex that was spawned by the wider availability of birth control; and the subsequent tendency to reduce it to a mere biological need, on a par with eating food or excreting. You also need to give your audience a sense of what sex can and should be like, and I think that this will be best achieved through taking this approach.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

They say "effective against pregnancy," like it's a disease or something.

Posted

FULL protection from HPV?? They give basically NO protection from that OR Herpes because both are not on the penis.

AlterDominicus
Posted

This is cool because we just had a talk at Church on Sunday from Pen Stenzel. Listen carefully.

Condoms protect you from getting pregnant, NOT from STD's. There are 100 strains of HPV - there is a medicine that ONLY protects FOUR of those strains.

Just a little fact and for those of you arent aware there are 40 STD's.

Posted

[url="http://rockforlife.org/know_contraception.php"]http://rockforlife.org/know_contraception.php[/url]

towards the bottom they talk about condoms

allis-challmers
Posted

the only safe sex is no sex. there is no controception that is totally effective.

Posted

You could go to a condom maker's website and see if they have any discalimers or warnings there.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[img]http://www.newmediaist.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2007/06/defective-condoms1.jpg[/img]

These say "Be safe, not sorry." No joke.

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1423755' date='Nov 23 2007, 12:06 AM']However, 97% is a strong figure.[/quote]

95% is considered statistically significant, so 97% more so.

[quote name='allis-challmers' post='1423804' date='Nov 23 2007, 04:16 AM']the only safe sex is no sex.[/quote]

Life isn't solely about staying safe.

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1423755' date='Nov 22 2007, 06:06 PM']Condoms provide protection against HIV 97 per cent of the time.[/quote]

So statistically speaking, one is at severe risk at least once out of every 50 times one uses a condom during sexual activity.

to really heed this stat, which even the Alan Guttmacher Institute uses, one should limit the number of times they have sex to less than fifty times in their entire life, lest they contract HIV and live with it the rest of their lives.

Posted

[quote name='RandomProddy' post='1423943' date='Nov 24 2007, 03:28 AM']Life isn't solely about staying safe.[/quote]
Life isn't solely about sex either.

Condoms just encourage people to have sex thinking it's always successful againist STDs and pregancy however that's NOT the case. There is no 100% effective method againist either. I find it sad and disheartening that every time someone wants to point that out they immediately get belittled and demeaned as if they are either stupid for believeing it or is a compltely irrelevent point.

What about respect for our potential to be mothers and fathers? What about valuing our future children enough to wait till we're married and can bring them into a stable family?

CoffeeCatholic
Posted

93% of condoms tested had a seriously high level of n-nitrosamines, a chemical which caused a massive recall of baby bottles and the such. It's found in rubbery things, and it relatively safe EXCEPT when it comes in contact with bodily fluids. Then, for whatever reason, it releases a highly carcinogenic compound.

After the study was completed, the condom companies that were among that 93% bribed the research company in Germany to keep their mouths shut as to which ones where dangerous because it would not be cost effective for those companies to completely redo the recipe for their condoms.

Posted

How about someone actually tests them??

Posted

[quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1424356' date='Nov 24 2007, 08:09 PM']93% of condoms tested had a seriously high level of n-nitrosamines, a chemical which caused a massive recall of baby bottles and the such. It's found in rubbery things, and it relatively safe EXCEPT when it comes in contact with bodily fluids. Then, for whatever reason, it releases a highly carcinogenic compound.

After the study was completed, the condom companies that were among that 93% bribed the research company in Germany to keep their mouths shut as to which ones where dangerous because it would not be cost effective for those companies to completely redo the recipe for their condoms.[/quote]

is there a place i can cite for this? this is some juicy material...

CoffeeCatholic
Posted

I'd have to find that for you- it's deep in the files of food not condoms. And honestly, i haven't really updated anything there in forever. Here's the blog post i wrote about it awhile back. If you can't find the research by googling, which is how i found it, let me know and I'll search deeper.

[i]In 2004 a study was released from a well respected German research company that had been studying the components of condoms. The results of the study were simple, but profound. Nearly all condoms studied (including all major American brands) contained high amounts of a toxic chemical known as N-Nitrosamine which has been proven to cause cancer. This carcinogen was banned from all children's toys and some other appliances, causing massive recalls in the late 1990's. It is responsible for helping the latex in the condom stay elastically and is often found in elastic-like material. "If it's so toxic," you ask, "then why is it found in so many materials but banned from others?" The answer is simple. N-Nitrosamine is only able to enter your body through contact with your bodily fluids (i.e. saliva, mucus, blood, semen, and vaginal discharge). So products that contain N-Nitrosamine but are never intended to be in contact with these substances are allowed. However, the big stink over this chemical came when it was banned from baby toys because there is no way to limit which toys an infant puts in her mouth, thus causing concern. The only other product that was ever considered were kitchen appliances, like spatulas and rubber spoons. With condoms only purpose being to come between 2 people and prevent the passage of bodily fluids, shouldn't they be considered for the chemical ban? The FDA said no, but only after testimony by big business condom makers like Durex and Trojan about how much money they would loose from such a ban.

Now our culture is at a cross-road. Much of our energy and resources goes towards fighting diseases like Cancer, which is a major killer of people world wide. But we are also constantly promoting the concept of "Safe Sex" which undeniably includes the consistent use of condoms by all sexually active people. They are given out for free in many places, including college health centers. But with this study we are forced to decide between what seems like two bad options. Either we must quite using condoms in order to prevent getting cancer, but risk contracting STD's like Herpes or AIDs from our sexual partners, or continue using the carcinogenic condom and theoretically protect ourselves from other diseases. It's a choice between 2 (or more) equally as gruesome fates.

Or is it? There is always a third choice! The third choice in this case would be to stop using condoms, which lead to cancer and may lead to other health problems, and stop having sex with multiple partners! As counter-cultural as that seems, isn't that the only way to prevent the spread of HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases anyway? If everybody on this planet decided today to stop having sex with more than one person, and only had one sexual partner for the rest of their life, then in approximately 3 generations all Sexually Transmitted Diseases would be functionally wiped out! And then there would be no need for condoms to begin with.

"But that'll never happen" you say. To that, we reply that it'll never happen if you never do anything about it. Perhaps it will take more than 3 generations, but the more people who have more than one sexual partner, the less spread of disease will occur. Most specifically, if you stop having sex with multiple partners and wait for your "one and only", you will have almost 0% risk of contracting an STD.
One last note: The researches in this study refused to release the information to the public about which brands of condoms fell in the highly toxic category, and which did not. Why? Because they are afraid of big companies like Durex and Trojan suing them for their well-done research which exposed their product's flaw. The big companies think that what we don't know won't hurt us, but that is a lie. No matter what, a condom that contains carcinogens will still give you cancer, whether you knew about it or not. Don't play Russian roulette with your life by hoping that the condom you're using is part of the 7% who passed…. Be smarter than that![/i]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1424382' date='Nov 25 2007, 12:36 PM']How about someone actually tests them??[/quote]
They do, otherwise we wouldn't have the stats.

Edited by Justin86

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...