Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

On Joining Or Remaining In The Church


Recommended Posts

Ash Wednesday
Posted

A recent thread got me to thinking about a question I've had for some time, related to an experience with a friend of mine in the past, and now that I'm remembering it I thought I would ask it here.

If someone is considering joining the church but they indicate certain disagreements on issues, what is the best way to handle that? Are they supposed to be denied joining the church if they don't agree with all the teachings, or would it be the case of having to answer to God for turning away a soul from the church?

Or in the case of someone that is in the church, disagrees on one or more issues and is very angry and resentful about it, is it better that they are honest with themselves and leave?

Of course the ideal would be for someone to come to an understanding and embrace the teachings and join/remain in the church faithfully, but I ask about scenarios where this isn't the case.

Posted (edited)

I would say they should never join. The Sacraments shouldn't be given loosely and carelessly, especially those of Initiation.

Edited by Justin86
Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

It was really quite astonishing the large number of heterodox that were initiated into the Church during the couple of times I sponsored people joining. And from what others have said about RCIA, it sounds pretty common.

I don't think I will ever sponsor anyone ever again. Not if my experiences are anything like what they were in the past. Basically it was like they just needed a Catholic with a pulse there to put your hand on their shoulder, and generally it was the case where people weren't really informed explicitly of the need to adhere to hard teachings. More like "God is love! Now let's have some punch and cookies." It's left me really disillusioned with the RCIA process and I've decided I want no part of it unless it's some extreme circumstance that I'm the last person available and they are totally orthodox.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

Sad. I've never actually asked people in an RCIA Program what they think, so I really have no idea if that's a problem at the parishes I've been to.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

And the thing is, if you are concerned about orthodoxy or the way people were being initiated into the church in these kinds of situations, you're branded an intolerant and unreasonable person that "judges" people. Holier-than-thou. But I guess that isn't just the case with RCIA.

I guess it helps me understand how a lot of (faithful) traditionalists feel at times, and I've never considered myself a "trad" ... just plain ol' kaflik.

Archaeology cat
Posted

If someone disagrees with Church doctrine/teachings, then I don't see why they'd [i]want [/i]to become Catholic. Just the opinion of a convert. . . :)

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I guess they are attracted to the mystique of the bells and smells.

Posted

If someone opposed Church teaching or doesnt understand it, it should be addressed before confirmation. Once confirmed this can be sticky issue.
I am sponsoring my brother this year and he will be received at Easter vigil 2008.
I tell him that if he has an issue with ANY teaching, to please ask.

The Church cannot possilby teach everything to a candidate before confirmation, especially to those who are "away for a while and have come back to get my remaining sacraments".

One does not come to the table already full.
One must come to the table prepared with an appetite.


Love all.

Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1424022' date='Nov 24 2007, 07:22 AM']If someone opposed Church teaching or doesnt understand it, it should be addressed before confirmation. Once confirmed this can be sticky issue.
I am sponsoring my brother this year and he will be received at Easter vigil 2008.
I tell him that if he has an issue with ANY teaching, to please ask.

The Church cannot possilby teach everything to a candidate before confirmation, especially to those who are "away for a while and have come back to get my remaining sacraments".

One does not come to the table already full.
One must come to the table prepared with an appetite.
Love all.[/quote]
Yes, but if one doesn't even have an appetite for what's at the table to begin with, why would they want to show up to the feast?

thequeensindian
Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1424036' date='Nov 23 2007, 05:58 PM']Yes, but if one doesn't even have an appetite for what's at the table to begin with, why would they want to show up to the feast?[/quote]

They may have reasons. Maybe pressured by a spouse or other family member, which I can relate to. But I agree that if a person does not "believe and profess all that the Catholic church believes and teaches to be true," they probably shouldn't join or remain.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1424036' date='Nov 23 2007, 04:58 PM']Yes, but if one doesn't even have an appetite for what's at the table to begin with, why would they want to show up to the feast?[/quote]

Sometimes they're just coming as someone's "date".

Posted

the RCIA situation here is pretty, um, loose :mellow:

so i totally feel your pain.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1423913' date='Nov 23 2007, 01:40 PM']It was really quite astonishing the large number of heterodox that were initiated into the Church during the couple of times I sponsored people joining. And from what others have said about RCIA, it sounds pretty common.

I don't think I will ever sponsor anyone ever again. Not if my experiences are anything like what they were in the past. Basically it was like they just needed a Catholic with a pulse there to put your hand on their shoulder, and generally it was the case where people weren't really informed explicitly of the need to adhere to hard teachings. More like "God is love! Now let's have some punch and cookies." It's left me really disillusioned with the RCIA process and I've decided I want no part of it unless it's some extreme circumstance that I'm the last person available and they are totally orthodox.[/quote]

So why don't you sponsor and make it mean something?
A girl I knew just a little asked me to sponsor her last year. We had weekly meetings with the RCIA program (it was optional for me to go I think), and the RCIA in our parish was pretty good... but even if it hadn't been, I think we would have been ok. Because first thing, I suggested we have weekly lunches together because I didn't want to sponsor her without knowing her better. Sometimes we'd just have a light, friendly lunch; other weeks we would get into deeper discussion about the Church and Her teachings. It was nice because it not only helped her learn about the Church on a more personal level, but it also helped me see the Church from the eyes of someone just learning about it for the first time, which was really interesting. It helped me make sure I was recommending someone to the Bishop who was completely in line with the Church.

Edited by Romans1513

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...