Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Sing And Pray At Mass If You Can't Receive?


Recommended Posts

Posted

If one can't receive the Eucharist because of sin and not getting to Confession on time, does he still sing and pray like the people who are receiving do?

Also, imagine 2 Catholics in that situation. One of them has a reason for missing Confession that makes you sympathetic and the other has no good reason.

Peace,
Paddington

Posted

Also, what does being temporarily out of communion mean for everyday prayer life?

Thanks,
Paddington

Posted (edited)

Sing and pray?

Well, as one who walked into Church last week too late for Confession (every blessed red light, I swear :ohno:), I still sang and still prayed. Just because I couldn't receive Him didn't mean I wasn't there to worship Him regardless, you know?

As for every day prayer life, I guess it depends. There are some times where not having the Eucharist to build me up can be really crippling; however, in other situations it actually kicks my prayer life into gear, believe it or not. Knowing I cannot receive makes me long for it, for redemption...so when I do end up confessing, I'm on fire and appreciate Mass more!

Heh. Guess who's going to Confession today?

Edited by MissyP89
Sister Rose Therese
Posted (edited)

Yes, you should still sing and pray, even if you cannot receive communion.
Communion really is an amazing privilege not a right. For most of church history, people did not receive daily or even every Sunday, even nuns. I remember reading in the lives of St. Maria Goretti and St. Rose of Lima that they were granted the privilege by their confessor to receive daily. We almost take that for granted nowadays.
Certainly it would be much better to receive if you are properly disposed. But it would be far worse to receive if you are not.
Even if you can't receive though, there is still the Sunday obligation, and what would be the purpose of that if you weren't going to pray. Perhaps you can think of the repentent tax collector in the parable who would not even raise his eyes to heaven, but still prayed for mercy.
Hope this makes sense.

Edited by Sister Rose Therese
Posted

[quote name='Sister Rose Therese' post='1424262' date='Nov 24 2007, 03:19 PM']I remember reading in the lives of [b]St. Maria Goretti[/b] and St. Rose of Lima that they were granted the privilege by their confessor to receive daily.[/quote]

Do you mean The Little Flower or someone else? St. Maria Goretti died at the age of 12 and had actually just recieved First Communion a year or so before her death.

Posted (edited)

Back in the Middle Ages most laypeople received Holy Communion only thee times per year (Easter, Pentecost and Christmas if I recall correctly). When the Eucharistic Fast was from midnight many people who assisted at late afternoon Masses would not receive. The obligation to assist at Mass does not include the obligation to receive Holy Communion, which one is only obliged to do once a year (though frequently receiving Holy Communion worthily and devoutly is a very good thing which Christ and His Church greatly desire for the faithful).

If one commits a mortal sin he should promptly make an act of perfect contrition with a firm resolution to sin no more and a desire to receive Penance. Then his prayer life would continue as it normally would, though he would not be able to receive Holy Communion until he was absolved.

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

As I understood, it is acceptable to attend Mass even if you can't receive Communion. Praying, singing and contemplating are what (I was told) one is supposed to do, and the next time one is able to receive Communion, one can do so (presumably the following week, and/or after Confession). :))

Sister Rose Therese
Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1424276' date='Nov 24 2007, 03:02 PM']Do you mean The Little Flower or someone else? St. Maria Goretti died at the age of 12 and had actually just recieved First Communion a year or so before her death.[/quote]


I was pretty sure it was St. Maria Goretti. If I remember correctly her confessor was very impressed with her spiritual maturity at such a young age. But then again, my memory isn't so great. It might have been another saint. I'll have to check that out.

Sister Rose Therese
Posted

[quote name='Sister Rose Therese' post='1424584' date='Nov 25 2007, 11:51 AM']I was pretty sure it was St. Maria Goretti. If I remember correctly her confessor was very impressed with her spiritual maturity at such a young age. But then again, my memory isn't so great. It might have been another saint. I'll have to check that out.[/quote]

Ok, just checked. It was St. Maria Goretti, but it wasn't daily communion, it was only special permission to receive each of the next few Sundays.
Read [url="http://www.catholicism.org/goretti.html"]http://www.catholicism.org/goretti.html[/url]
It is about half-way down the page.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...