XIX Posted November 26, 2007 Posted November 26, 2007 1) I confess my sins. Nothing strange so far. 2) Instead of an act of contrition, we say the Our Father. 3) He absolves me of my sins without giving me a pennance. But he did say "I absolve you of your sins." 4) I ask if he gave me a penance. He says "No, I didn't. I did say that you should contemplate the fact that God is always with you. It's not really a penance so much as it is a reminder to walk with God." 5) I decide to sit in the chapel for 15 minutes and contemplate what Father brought up in the confessional. Was the confession valid? If so, was it licit? If not, shouldn't I get back to confession and confess everything again? Thanks.
CatholicCid Posted November 26, 2007 Posted November 26, 2007 (edited) As the Absolution was apparently given correctly, your Confession is valid. The Penance is given to help remind us of the seriousness of the sins we confessed. Not recieving a Penance will not effect the validity of the Sacrament either. I do not know about licitity, but it was def. a valid Confession. I do not believe an Act of Contrition is required for a licit Confession as well. It also would not make the Sacrament invalid. Edited November 26, 2007 by CatholicCid
Mateo el Feo Posted November 26, 2007 Posted November 26, 2007 #4 & #5 sound like a penance, albeit a pretty light one. I don't really know what to say about the substitution of the Our Father instead of an Act of Contrition. Just, that I'm not a fan of priests who improvise the sacraments.
PopeClementI(MorClemis) Posted November 26, 2007 Posted November 26, 2007 Your confession was perfectly valid. The Sacraments are not laws to be beaten with, and priests have the leeway to adjust to individual cases to some extent. Don't worry, your absolved! Congratulations! Think of Confession as medicine for your soul, everyone doesn't always need vancomycin, sometimes penicillin does the trick..
Resurrexi Posted November 27, 2007 Posted November 27, 2007 [quote name='PopeClementI(MorClemis)' post='1425222' date='Nov 26 2007, 03:18 PM']Your confession was perfectly valid. The Sacraments are not laws to be beaten with, and priests have the leeway to adjust to individual cases to some extent. Don't worry, your absolved! Congratulations! Think of Confession as medicine for your soul, everyone doesn't always need vancomycin, sometimes penicillin does the trick..[/quote] No priest has the authority to change the sacraments and all are under grave obligation to impose a penance which fits the gravity of the sins committed, according to [i]Moral Theology[/i]. A priest is also required to have the penitent make an act of contrition as the contrition of the penitent and his firm resolution to sin no more are part of the matter of the sacrament, but if the penitent did have contrition and the firm resolution, it does not affect the validity of the sacrament if he doesn't make the act of contrition for the priest. So you're confession was valid but illicit through no fault of your own, so don't worry about it.
Justin86 Posted December 6, 2007 Posted December 6, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1425510' date='Nov 27 2007, 02:13 PM']No priest has the authority to change the sacraments and all are under grave obligation to impose a penance which fits the gravity of the sins committed, according to [i]Moral Theology[/i]. A priest is also required to have the penitent make an act of contrition as the contrition of the penitent and his firm resolution to sin no more are part of the matter of the sacrament, but if the penitent did have contrition and the firm resolution, it does not affect the validity of the sacrament if he doesn't make the act of contrition for the priest. So you're confession was valid but illicit through no fault of your own, so don't worry about it.[/quote] That was a very long, detailed, way of saying "You're forgiven."
cathoholic_anonymous Posted December 6, 2007 Posted December 6, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1425148' date='Nov 26 2007, 07:29 PM']1) I confess my sins. Nothing strange so far. 2) Instead of an act of contrition, we say the Our Father. 3) He absolves me of my sins without giving me a pennance. But he did say "I absolve you of your sins." 4) I ask if he gave me a penance. He says "No, I didn't. I did say that you should contemplate the fact that God is always with you. It's not really a penance so much as it is a reminder to walk with God." 5) I decide to sit in the chapel for 15 minutes and contemplate what Father brought up in the confessional. Was the confession valid? If so, was it licit? If not, shouldn't I get back to confession and confess everything again? Thanks.[/quote] The Our Father surely counts as an act of contrition. The prayer doesn't have to follow the pattern, "O my God, I am very sorry for having offended you..." in order to be a prayer of true contrition. There is repentance in the Our Father, and homecoming, and acknowledgement of need and forgiveness, so I can't see why it wouldn't 'count'. I don't know anything about your personal life, of course, but I know that priests often give light penances if they think that you're being overscrupulous and need to relax a bit.
st-annes Posted December 6, 2007 Posted December 6, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1430536' date='Dec 6 2007, 11:01 AM']The Our Father surely counts as an act of contrition. The prayer doesn't have to follow the pattern, "O my God, I am very sorry for having offended you..." in order to be a prayer of true contrition. There is repentance in the Our Father, and homecoming, and acknowledgement of need and forgiveness, so I can't see why it wouldn't 'count'.[/quote] Huh? I didn't know we were allowed to substitute something because of the personal meaning we might take from it. I was never told to say the Our Father as the prayer in Confession; only the Act of Contrition. The reason I learned "the new one" (i.e. the slightly different phrasing) was because that's what they were teaching everyone my age, at the time-- I guess it was the post-Vatican II version. Still, I never used any other prayer, even though there are many which are indicative of repentance. If the substitution was given because the person hadn't been to confession in a long time, that could be the priest's reason-- it's a special situation. However, if we're talking about the time when the person is still at the confessional, I think we are normally expected to use the Act of Contrition-- or else why is it there?
PopeClementI(MorClemis) Posted December 6, 2007 Posted December 6, 2007 The 'Act of Contrition' is fulfilled by using one's own prayer as well.. the formal/traditional prayer is available and of course one can use it, but there is certainly nothing wrong with using one's own words. Remember that this isn't a legalism.. you do this and this and God forgives you. God's forgiveness is pure mercy and grace, we bring a contrite heart, how we express that contriteness is up to us - as long as it is genuine and honest. [quote name='st-annes' post='1430543' date='Dec 6 2007, 10:19 AM']Huh? I didn't know we were allowed to substitute something because of the personal meaning we might take from it. I was never told to say the Our Father as the prayer in Confession; only the Act of Contrition. The reason I learned "the new one" (i.e. the slightly different phrasing) was because that's what they were teaching everyone my age, at the time-- I guess it was the post-Vatican II version. Still, I never used any other prayer, even though there are many which are indicative of repentance. If the substitution was given because the person hadn't been to confession in a long time, that could be the priest's reason-- it's a special situation. However, if we're talking about the time when the person is still at the confessional, I think we are normally expected to use the Act of Contrition-- or else why is it there?[/quote]
Resurrexi Posted December 7, 2007 Posted December 7, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1430536' date='Dec 6 2007, 09:01 AM']The Our Father surely counts as an act of contrition. The prayer doesn't have to follow the pattern, "O my God, I am very sorry for having offended you..." in order to be a prayer of true contrition. There is repentance in the Our Father, and homecoming, and acknowledgement of need and forgiveness, so I can't see why it wouldn't 'count'. I don't know anything about your personal life, of course, but I know that priests often give light penances if they think that you're being overscrupulous and need to relax a bit.[/quote] The Lord's Prayer is manly a prayer of petition, and does not explicitly say the four qualities of true contrition (i.e. that it must be interior, universal, supernatural and sovereign) and would therefore does not count as an act of contrition (n.b. an act of contrition need not be a memorized prayer as long as it displays the four qualities of contrition).
cathoholic_anonymous Posted December 7, 2007 Posted December 7, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1430825' date='Dec 7 2007, 11:06 PM']The Lord's Prayer is manly a prayer of petition, and does not explicitly say the four qualities of true contrition (i.e. that it must be interior, universal, supernatural and sovereign) and would therefore does not count as an act of contrition (n.b. an act of contrition need not be a memorized prayer as long as it displays the four qualities of contrition).[/quote] I think you are focusing too much on the sound of the prayer and not enough on the sense. Those four qualities are definitely present in the Lord's Prayer, and a lot more besides. It's a very rich, deep prayer. Remember that this is not a ticklist or a shopping list we are reciting.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now