Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

To Deny Being A Christian Is A Sin.


why do polls need titles?  

33 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

See the topic title and the poll. I have a hard time getting a lot of people to take me seriously about pretty much ANYTHING at all once they find out that I'm Catholic. I'm getting tempted to just start calling myself a plain "christian" to those who ask. Maybe there's a decree on this subject that I'm not aware of.

And questions that cannot be answered by poll -

If you answered "yes", what might you suggest be said to convince the other party to still take you seriously? Also, why did you answer yes?

p.s. - I know Catholics are not technically a denomination.

Posted

I understand that---if I do tell people I'm Catholic, I hear a lot of negativity. Like, they want to enlighten me on everything Catholics have done "wrong"... I've never considered [i]not[/i] saying I'm Catholic though.

I've met a lot of non-denominational Christians, and to me it's almost like a pick-and-choose kind of deal (though I don't mean anything disrespectful about that).
Slightly off topic, but a very devout girl I know does not celebrate Christmas for example---some strange reasoning. I'm still puzzled.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

I can't identify with your situation since none of my friends (or pretty much anyone else I meet for that matter) seem to care that much that I'm Catholic. This is including a lot of Baptists. They know that I'm a Christian and love God, and to them, that's more important than my affiliation. I can't see how blatantly denying that you're Catholic will be prudent since they'll eventually find out you lied about the one thing you're trying to show them is dearest to you. However, there are times when I'll simply say I'm a Christian if they don't ask for anything more specific than that and the situation doesn't seem to necessitate it.

However, the other day this girl who lives next door stopped by because she knew me and my roommates are Christians and wanted to ask us some questions for some class project. So I decided to be a smart alec and jokingly stated, "Well, I'm not a Christian, I'm Catholic." I guess she didn't get that I was joking (she didn't come across as having a sense of humor, but I didn't detect that until after trying to make a joke), so I attempted to explain that it's just a joke because some people think Catholics aren't Christians. Turns out, she's one of those people... first time I met someone like that who wasn't a Baptist seminarian. She informed me that she grew up Catholic (she's from France) and sternly corrected me that there is a difference between Christians and Catholics. So she asked me whether I'm Christian or Catholic, and I told her I'm both. Needless to say, she didn't ask me whatever questions she had for her project. :)

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Lena' post='1425622' date='Nov 27 2007, 10:59 AM']I've met a lot of non-denominational Christians, and to me it's almost like a pick-and-choose kind of deal[/quote]

Hmm... they sound like Catholics.

Posted

I like using the term "Christian" as a synonym for "Catholic"... my opinion is that one should do this as often as possible to the point where the person listening becomes confused and is in need of an explanation.

for example: "yeah, as a Christian, it's so cool to know that the Pope can speak infallibly" lol... but maybe even more subtle than that.

"Christian" should be synonymous with "Catholic"... protestants are seperated Christians, Christians without churches, Christians in ecclesial communions which are seperated from the Body of Christ, materially heretical Christians. it is they that ought to need an adjective to define themselves, not us. Sadly, however, you often hear people, even though they are not explicitly anti-Catholic, seeing there being a distinction between "Catholic" and "Christian", with "Christian" meaning "protestant"

Posted

Well, I wasn't sure about your question... if someone asks you directly "Are you Catholic?" and you say no, thats a sin- lying. If someone asks you what you are open-endedly, I don't think it would be wrong if the situation calls for it to use "Christian" as a synonym for "Catholic" as Al said. Even better, tell them you're "Catholic Christian." I don't know your situation, and though I have experienced anti-Catholicism, I don't think I've ever been in a situation like yours... but I think it would be best that they know you are Catholic and then learn from you that a Catholic can be taken seriously.

Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1425525' date='Nov 27 2007, 02:02 AM']If you answered "yes", what might you suggest be said to convince the other party to still take you seriously?[/quote]

Could you give a sample situation? Are these people you meet in high school/college/work/etc.? What kind of conversation would it come up in?

But I think the "Catholic Christian" could work for that aspect too... if it makes them want an explanation, and then they realize you know what you're talking about...

Posted

An example? sort of.

I'm debating online often and people are dialogging with me. I'll make some points, provide some bible verses, and my "opposition" listens and acknowledges the points I say and even admit that I'm right about things on occasion. But as dialog continues, they are often prompted to ask "What's your denomination?" To which I respond "Catholic". This, more often than not, prompts my opposition to completely discredit everything that I've said. All the points that I've made suddenly become irrelevant and my scripture quotes become twisted to support my own messed up agenda. Even the places in which I had changed their mind, they revert to their original stance.

In short, they literally refuse to believe a single thing that I type, no matter what I do.

Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1425816' date='Nov 27 2007, 07:27 PM']An example? sort of.

I'm debating online often and people are dialogging with me. I'll make some points, provide some bible verses, and my "opposition" listens and acknowledges the points I say and even admit that I'm right about things on occasion. But as dialog continues, they are often prompted to ask "What's your denomination?" To which I respond "Catholic". This, more often than not, prompts my opposition to completely discredit everything that I've said. All the points that I've made suddenly become irrelevant and my scripture quotes become twisted to support my own messed up agenda. Even the places in which I had changed their mind, they revert to their original stance.

In short, they literally refuse to believe a single thing that I type, no matter what I do.[/quote]

Wow... thats awful! .... not sure what to tell you on this one...

Mary'sBaritone
Posted

In your situation, I don't think it's a sin. Technically, the two words are synonamous. We are Catholics, the universal Christians, right?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1425816' date='Nov 27 2007, 06:27 PM']An example? sort of.

I'm debating online often and people are dialogging with me. I'll make some points, provide some bible verses, and my "opposition" listens and acknowledges the points I say and even admit that I'm right about things on occasion. But as dialog continues, they are often prompted to ask "What's your denomination?" To which I respond "Catholic". This, more often than not, prompts my opposition to completely discredit everything that I've said. All the points that I've made suddenly become irrelevant and my scripture quotes become twisted to support my own messed up agenda. Even the places in which I had changed their mind, they revert to their original stance.

In short, they literally refuse to believe a single thing that I type, no matter what I do.[/quote]

That's unreasonable behavior, and in that situation, I would quit debating with them. How ya gonna reason with unreasonable people? :)

What sites are you visiting, anyway?

An alternative to answering the question is asking about their reasons for wanting to know. If you can begin by confirming everything they believe is essential to the faith (and outside of things like Sola Scriptura and Sola Fide, most Protestant theology is compatible with Catholicism), including salvation from God alone by grace alone, the Incarnation, physical death and resurrection of Christ, etc., and only after confirming all those things, also reveal that you're Catholic... but who knows. The only other message boards I visit are at Relevant Magazine, and there are several Catholics, including a newly ordained priest, who frequent there. One of the regulars there even converted to Catholicism thanks to another Catholic on the boards.

Another thing to keep in mind is that on message boards, your audience isn't just the few people you're actually conversing with, but also the many lurkers who rarely -- if ever -- say anything. As long as you're modeling a Christian attitude, you're being a witness to everyone there that there's at least one Catholic in the world that gets it. If you can simply bring people to recognize Catholics as fellow Christians, even if they don't become Catholic themselves, you've knocked down some huge hurdles in bringing up greater Christian unity.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1425935' date='Nov 27 2007, 08:23 PM']What sites are you visiting, anyway?[/quote]Godtube, youtube, and facebook groups. On godtube, I'm actually being silenced in multiple places - my posts are just deleted, even when correcting someone on a non-doctrinal issue.

[quote]Another thing to keep in mind is that on message boards, your audience isn't just the few people you're actually conversing with, but also the many lurkers who rarely -- if ever -- say anything.[/quote]Which is why I really don't like to just stop debating. If someone just ups and leaves a debate, the lurkers can pretty much only conclude that the last comment made couldn't be responded to.

Posted

Well, whether or not this is a sin would have to come down to intent imho. If it is not your intent to deceive but to avert perhaps it is not a sin. I wouldn't blatantly lie if you were asked directly 'are you a Catholic?" If they ask your denomination you can put them off with a little humor. If you lie and then later say you are Catholic that would reflect poorly on your character. If someone shuts you out because you are Catholic you can't really do anything about it....it's hardness of heart. You could be just hope you have planted some seeds for the Holy Spirit to sow.

Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1425816' date='Nov 27 2007, 05:27 PM']An example? sort of.

I'm debating online often and people are dialogging with me. I'll make some points, provide some bible verses, and my "opposition" listens and acknowledges the points I say and even admit that I'm right about things on occasion. But as dialog continues, they are often prompted to ask "What's your denomination?" To which I respond "Catholic". This, more often than not, prompts my opposition to completely discredit everything that I've said. All the points that I've made suddenly become irrelevant and my scripture quotes become twisted to support my own messed up agenda. Even the places in which I had changed their mind, they revert to their original stance.

In short, they literally refuse to believe a single thing that I type, no matter what I do.[/quote]
That doesn't necessarily mean that your testimony won't keep them up at night...

Posted

[quote name='Dismas' post='1427790' date='Dec 1 2007, 12:41 PM']That doesn't necessarily mean that your testimony won't keep them up at night...[/quote]When I see them elsewhere a week later posting the exact same misinformation, it makes me highly doubt that.


Oh, and to all who voted. What a wonderful help thats been, seeing as how there is no obvious conclusion. :annoyed: :topsy: :rolleyes: But seriously, thank you.

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

What annoys me is the people who respond "oh, me too!" to my answer that I'm a Catholic, and then turn out to be Union of Utrecht ("old-Catholic"), Catholic Apostolical, or some of the other splinter groups who hijacked our name (but, we didn't exactly copyright it, did we?)...

...although it does give one the chance to say "Catholic. [i]Roman[/i] Catholic." in a very cool way (before shooting the grip hook out of your watch into the ceiling and swinging behind the steering wheel of your car which you just remote-controlled to the right place and speed off into the sunset).

Seriously, being European, I don't have as many problems as people who live among the more aggressive prots seem to have. Although I must admit I was kind of shocked when my roommate (who turned from nothing to Evangelical a year ago, when she'd known me for three years) said she wasn't sure I was a Christian. That kind of hurt.

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

What annoys me is the people who respond "oh, me too!" to my answer that I'm a Catholic, and then turn out to be Union of Utrecht ("old-Catholic"), Catholic Apostolical, or some of the other splinter groups who hijacked our name (but, we didn't exactly copyright it, did we?)...

...although it does give one the chance to say "Catholic. [i]Roman[/i] Catholic." in a very cool way (before shooting the grip hook out of your watch into the ceiling and swinging behind the steering wheel of your car which you just remote-controlled to the right place and speed off into the sunset).

Seriously, being European, I don't have as many problems as people who live among the more aggressive prots seem to have. Although I must admit I was kind of shocked when my roommate (who turned from nothing to Evangelical a year ago, when she'd known me for three years) said she wasn't sure I was a Christian. That kind of hurt.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='VeniteAdoremus' post='1430510' date='Dec 6 2007, 01:06 PM']Seriously, being European, I don't have as many problems as people who live among the more aggressive prots seem to have. Although I must admit I was kind of shocked when my roommate (who turned from nothing to Evangelical a year ago, when she'd known me for three years) said she wasn't sure I was a Christian. That kind of hurt.[/quote]

I know what you mean. I'd never encountered truly aggressive evangelicalism before I went to university, and it came as a distressing shock. One girl pretended to invite me to a Bible study when what she really wanted to do was ask me questions about Catholicism. She had a list of questions and a selection of Bible quotations ready on a sheet of paper, so that she could refute my answers easily (or so she thought). At the end she hugged me and said, "Oh, Vicky, I just wanted to share my faith in Jesus with you."

As if I did not have any faith in Him myself and needed hers - which she demonstrated to me by lying about the reason she wanted me to come to her room.

I do not regret telling her that I am a Catholic. She tried to tell me about Truth, but couldn't even give me truth with a small 't', so what does that make her? In most cases I would be honest with people about who I am - even people who look badly on Catholics. If they start to discredit what you say, write, "Two days ago you were agreeing with me. On hearing the name of my church, you immediately look at what I've written in the light of who you believe I am. And in reality I don't match up to the picture in your head. Abandon your preconceived notions about whho I am and what I believe, and then I will talk to you." Then give a list:

Catholics don't worship Mary.
Catholics don't believe that the pope is perfect.
Catholics don't pray to statues.
Catholics don't believe that priests can forgive sins.

And so on. The list tactic works well, because it makes people unsure of their footing. A lot of people who oppose the Church accept these things as matter of course, so to see you deny them so starkly will come as a puzzling surprise. Don't give reasons - yet. Let the list sink in. Then explain what we really believe.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Great tips, CA. I'll keep that in mind for University.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

I came from a predominantly Baptist area of the country, and there were actually kids that wouldn't play with me when they found out that I was Catholic. There were times that I hid, and I promised myself that I wouldn't anymore. I try to stay in mostly Catholic places because I have found that you just can't debate theology with people who are anti-Catholic. I'm working on my masters in theology right now at a Catholic seminary, the one that trains most of the priests in Western Canada, and was just jumped on by one of my classmates. We were talking about the importance of studying the biblical origins of the church in Ecclesiology. I mentioned that Scott Hahn and a Baptist minister that I knew, had both talked once about how studying the writings of the early church fathers had led in part to their conversions. One of my classmates is Lutheran, and jumped on me for talking about their joining the "true church." I had to apologize and promise to be more politically correct even if it is counter to the church's teachings. My husband has a meeting with the archbishop in a couple of weeks, and I'm hoping he mentions it to him.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...