Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Proof: Existence Of God


Recommended Posts

Guest kkerwin
Posted

Hello friends,

Quick question. With maybe not so quick an answer. :)

How do I reconcile these two statements:

(1) Our God is a loving God that has gifted us with Free Will to choose to love Him or not.
(2) The Catholic Church teaches that man can arrive at the existence of God by reason alone, guided by observation of the natural world.

Explanation of my question:

I am operating under the premise that as love requires knowledge, the converse is also true: knowledge of a perfect Almighty requires love of Him. Statement (2) requires that knowledge of God be self-evident based upon the natural world; [i]id est[/i]: based upon what we see of the world around us, belief at least in the existence of God is incontravertible, assuming that our intellects which were wounded at the Fall can conceive of such a proof. Ergo, according to my premise, this knowledge requires love of God, which seems contrary to statement (1).

I have a feeling that this premise is likely incorrect: the Devil and his Demons (read: fallen Angels) have perfect knowledge of the existence of God as do all Angels, yet choose not to love Him in spite of it. Still, I think that there is some merit to the [b]spirit[/b] of the question.

I think that my question lies more along the lines of what is meant by the words "knowledge" and "proof". Do we mean by these words that "knowledge" is truly meant as incontravertible? That by "proof" we mean that one can logically rule out the possibility of God's non-existence? Or do we mean simply that one can demonstrate the [b]viability[/b] of belief in God. That is, can we no more than show that it is not illogical to believe in God's existence, and that God will leave the final decision that we make up to us as a matter of faith?

Posted

[quote name='kkerwin' post='1425565' date='Nov 27 2007, 02:11 AM']Hello friends,

Quick question. With maybe not so quick an answer. :)

How do I reconcile these two statements:

(1) Our God is a loving God that has gifted us with Free Will to choose to love Him or not.
(2) The Catholic Church teaches that man can arrive at the existence of God by reason alone, guided by observation of the natural world.

Explanation of my question:

I am operating under the premise that as love requires knowledge, the converse is also true: knowledge of a perfect Almighty requires love of Him. Statement (2) requires that knowledge of God be self-evident based upon the natural world; [i]id est[/i]: based upon what we see of the world around us, belief at least in the existence of God is incontravertible, assuming that our intellects which were wounded at the Fall can conceive of such a proof. Ergo, according to my premise, this knowledge requires love of God, which seems contrary to statement (1).

I have a feeling that this premise is likely incorrect: the Devil and his Demons (read: fallen Angels) have perfect knowledge of the existence of God as do all Angels, yet choose not to love Him in spite of it. Still, I think that there is some merit to the [b]spirit[/b] of the question.

I think that my question lies more along the lines of what is meant by the words "knowledge" and "proof". Do we mean by these words that "knowledge" is truly meant as incontravertible? That by "proof" we mean that one can logically rule out the possibility of God's non-existence? Or do we mean simply that one can demonstrate the [b]viability[/b] of belief in God. That is, can we no more than show that it is not illogical to believe in God's existence, and that God will leave the final decision that we make up to us as a matter of faith?[/quote]

I'm not 100% sure on your first premise, that love requires knowledge, though this seems correct. However the converse seems to me to be incorrect. If love then knowledge =/= If knowledge then love. I think you're problem lies there.

Guest kkerwin
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1425652' date='Nov 27 2007, 11:33 AM']I'm not 100% sure on your first premise, that love requires knowledge, though this seems correct. However the converse seems to me to be incorrect. If love then knowledge =/= If knowledge then love. I think you're problem lies there.[/quote]

Agreed. But what are your thoughts on the last paragraph of my OP? When the Church says that man may come to know God through the light of reason alone, to what standard are we holding this word "knowledge"?

Posted

[quote name='kkerwin' post='1425565' date='Nov 27 2007, 02:11 AM']I think that my question lies more along the lines of what is meant by the words "knowledge" and "proof". Do we mean by these words that "knowledge" is truly meant as incontravertible? That by "proof" we mean that one can logically rule out the possibility of God's non-existence? Or do we mean simply that one can demonstrate the [b]viability[/b] of belief in God. That is, can we no more than show that it is not illogical to believe in God's existence, and that God will leave the final decision that we make up to us as a matter of faith?[/quote]
I'm going out on a limb here, but I think the knowledge spoken of is more than just viability of existence of God. Your last sentence... If you can show that God's existence is not illogical, then it must be logical. The Church teaches that existence of God can be demonstrated by reason alone; I would assume that demonstrate means a little bit more than simply probable or viable.

I tend to be a little too rationalistic and believe in more "incontravertible" proof.

Posted

[quote name='kkerwin' post='1425565' date='Nov 27 2007, 03:11 AM'](2) The Catholic Church teaches that man can arrive at the existence of God by reason alone, guided by observation of the natural world.[/quote]

Have you looked at St. Thomas' proofs on the existence of God?

Guest kkerwin
Posted

[quote name='goldbug16' post='1426344' date='Nov 28 2007, 01:53 PM']Have you looked at St. Thomas' proofs on the existence of God?[/quote]

I have, yes, but don't believe that they are philosophically viable because they are not done [i]a priori[/i]. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anselm's_argument"]St. Anselm's proof[/url] is stronger because it is done without the benefit of empirical evidence, and thus, any truth obtained from the argument is self-evident and not dependant on observation.

However, I am not interested in proving the existence of God. Instead, I am interested in the (closely related) philosophical question of if a "proof" for the existence of God was incontravertible, if that would remove human choice from believing in God's existence.

Guest kkerwin
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1426276' date='Nov 28 2007, 12:33 PM']I'm going out on a limb here, but I think the knowledge spoken of is more than just viability of existence of God. Your last sentence... If you can show that God's existence is not illogical, then it must be logical. The Church teaches that existence of God can be demonstrated by reason alone; I would assume that demonstrate means a little bit more than simply probable or viable.

I tend to be a little too rationalistic and believe in more "incontravertible" proof.[/quote]

I'm going to reply to this later. Too much work to do, but I definitely want to continue this discussion. :)

Posted (edited)

The dogma this thread refers to has always been most compelling to me. If there is an irrefutable, unbeatable, rock-solid and objective proof for the existence of God, I have yet to find it.

Edit: This is, of course, not to say that I don't believe there are valid arguments for God's existence. I merely have not discovered an argument that completely shuts up any atheist. Theoretical sciences (like the branes of M-Theory) propose answers to many of the stronger arguments (causality, time and contingency, etc).

Edited by Ziggamafu
Guest kkerwin
Posted

Bump. Still looking for help, here!

Posted

[quote name='kkerwin' post='1428201' date='Dec 2 2007, 02:46 PM']Bump. Still looking for help, here![/quote]

Kkerwin,

would you mind restating your question? Is it basically how convincing is something like an Ontological Argument in the light of the Church's teaching on knowledge of God's existence?

You caught me in the middle of finals week, so I won't be able to devote much time to this, but I'd like to try.

Posted

[quote name='kkerwin' post='1425565' date='Nov 27 2007, 02:11 AM']Hello friends,

Quick question. With maybe not so quick an answer. :)

How do I reconcile these two statements:

(1) Our God is a loving God that has gifted us with Free Will to choose to love Him or not.
(2) The Catholic Church teaches that man can arrive at the existence of God by reason alone, guided by observation of the natural world.

Explanation of my question:

I am operating under the premise that as love requires knowledge, the converse is also true: knowledge of a perfect Almighty requires love of Him. Statement (2) requires that knowledge of God be self-evident based upon the natural world; [i]id est[/i]: based upon what we see of the world around us, belief at least in the existence of God is incontravertible, assuming that our intellects which were wounded at the Fall can conceive of such a proof. Ergo, according to my premise, this knowledge requires love of God, which seems contrary to statement (1).

I have a feeling that this premise is likely incorrect: the Devil and his Demons (read: fallen Angels) have perfect knowledge of the existence of God as do all Angels, yet choose not to love Him in spite of it. Still, I think that there is some merit to the [b]spirit[/b] of the question.

I think that my question lies more along the lines of what is meant by the words "knowledge" and "proof". Do we mean by these words that "knowledge" is truly meant as incontravertible? That by "proof" we mean that one can logically rule out the possibility of God's non-existence? Or do we mean simply that one can demonstrate the [b]viability[/b] of belief in God. That is, can we no more than show that it is not illogical to believe in God's existence, and that God will leave the final decision that we make up to us as a matter of faith?[/quote]



I think you are right that your premise is incorrect. Knowledge of God does not require love of Him. There have been and always will be people who have been convinced of God's existence who don't love Him. Sin, afterall, is choosing not to love that who is Love. We do it all the time. If, for instance, you could convince an atheist incontavertably that God exists he still would not be required to love Him. That is free will. Free will isn't a gift we can return. It is given to us as part of our very nature.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...