ardillacid Posted November 30, 2007 Posted November 30, 2007 [url="http://media.www.dakotastudent.com/media/storage/paper970/news/2007/11/16/Opinion/Showing.Some.Respect.To.Those.Of.Us.Who.ont.Hunt-3107657.shtml?reffeature=recentlycommentedstoriestab"]http://media.www.dakotastudent.com/media/s...entedstoriestab[/url] [quote]It's getting to be that time of year again; the leaves are gone, the wind is getting stronger, and the air is getting colder. Fires (or electric base-board heaters) are roaring, and my roommate is starting to drink hot chocolate on a regular basis. Christmas music has even started playing in department stores, though it's a whole other column to go into how it's too soon for that. And, people are heading outdoors to shoot animals. Hunting is something I can't and won't understand. How can any self-respecting person venture out to the beautiful world of nature to destroy it? How does a civilized human being get their jollies from murder? It's beyond me, really it is. But let's say, for the sake of argument, that killing is something that you do enjoy. I'd like to lay down some "courtesy ground rules," if you will, that will keep this sad season at its most tolerable for those of us who prefer wildlife to be alive. 1. Don't boast loudly during class about the deer (bird, buffalo, kitten, baby, whatever) that you killed at some place that had this many points and weighed that many pounds. And definitely don't boast about how its head is now dripping blood in your garage, or mounted on your living room wall. I don't think that recent, senseless carnage is really a good topic for the classroom. 2. Don't wear your hunting gear to class. Are you going back out to the killing fields so soon that you can't even bother to stop at your house and change after your school day? On a Tuesday afternoon, I highly doubt it. That bright orange color is extremely offensive to the eyes, and wearing shirts that have grass and deer printed all over them is ironic only in a sadistic sense. For those of you who wore that kind of thing all the time to high school, so you keep doing it now, I say: you're in college now. You're supposed to be on your way to being a more educated, ethical person. And Grand Forks is bigger than your hometown of 100-3,000 people, and there are actually people here who'd prefer you keep your brutal habits to yourself. 3. If you have just come from an all-night spree of gunfire and beer, change your clothes before you show yourself in public. Having animal blood all over your pants is neither a fashion statement nor particularly healthy. 4. For those of you who do it for only for food, not sport, and to keep deer "off your car hood," fine; at least your intentions are honest. I don't like the beef industry, either; I'd much rather all animals have a free life before they become dinner. And I get that there are a lot of deer out there causing car accidents. But that's what happens when we destroy all their natural predators, stupid. That said, though, please pick the weakest of the herd, and make it a quick end. You think the deer of future generations are going to be able to get out of the way of your speeding vehicle any faster if you kill off their best genetic lines? You're really shooting yourself in the foot with that one, or rather, shooting your children and grandchildren in the foot. Also, all of the above rules still apply to you. In conclusion, try to keep your dirty habit to yourself. I don't want to hear about it, and I don't want to see it. You have not gained my respect for "conquering" the wilderness with your down jackets, thermal underwear and heat packs; nor will you ever gain my respect for taking the lives of animals that have no defense from you.[/quote] It's caused quite a stir around here, am interested what you guys think.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 30, 2007 Posted November 30, 2007 I'm not for wasteful hunting and I'd generally agree with the author's comments about not wearing hunting gear around everywhere, especially if it's still bloody or something...it's just unbecoming, if nothing else.
MissScripture Posted November 30, 2007 Posted November 30, 2007 Funny, seeing as how hunting is increasing in popularity in ND. We have profs. who bring their pictures of deer and pass 'em around the classroom. And Bis is bigger than Grand Forks, so this person can just get off it as far as Grand Forks being "bigger than your hometown." Sorry, Grand Forks ain't no big city! If the author of this is so horrified by hunting, seriously, leave the midwest. It is WAY too big of a deal here.
goldenchild17 Posted November 30, 2007 Posted November 30, 2007 I have no problem with hunting, or talking about it. I am not comfortable with hunting as sport alone. But if one is going to put the meat and hide to good use then I think it is not only fine, but good and even a responsible thing to do. Animals do not have rights equal to humanity. They are here for us. We are most certainly called to treat them kindly and to not waste them on frivolity (I am against fur coat linings and things like that etc.). But I find hunting to be far more humane than supporting the big business meat market which treats their animals far more cruelly and puts them in far more inhumane living situations. Wild animals can live a full free life on their own, and then usually are killed with a simply gun or bow shot. Am I saying that's painless? No, but I find it far more humane than what most animals in the meat market are put through. My dad hunts regularly and brings home fresh natural meat every year sometimes twice a year and I've never once considered it to be bad, and at the very least not worse than meat from most market venues. I think the points 1-3 that the author makes are somewhat exaggerated. Though I don't live in a hunting town such as that may be so I can't comment. If there are people who where their bloody hunting clothes all over town or to school then I think that's just a little wierd, but admit it's possible. And "Don't boast loudly during class about the deer (bird, buffalo, [b]kitten, baby[/b], whatever). Come on now, neither compares in any way. A baby in no way compares to any animal of any kind. And nobody kills kittens for food or for true hunting sport. Anyone that does so is either to put a suffering kitten out of its misery, or for pure sadistic pleasure.
WillT Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 Ha. This person should visit the south sometime. My high scool had "camo day" every homecoming week and at least 90% of the students showed up in hunting gear for it. Almost everyone had pictures etc. of their most recent kills and deer sausage/jerky/whatever was common at class parties. A friend of mine even came to school with a couple of nice doves in his trunk because he didn't have time to go home before coming to school.
Lena Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 [quote]I find it far more humane than what most animals in the meat market are put through.[/quote] That's very true! Good point. As long as the deer meat is used and not just killed for fun, then I don't see a huge problem with it. Hunting isn't pretty or "nice" so I can see why it offends people though.
Ash Wednesday Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 I agree with some points she has -- there are certain things that are rude to do in public. But I find the "poor Bambi" syndrome to be pretty tiresome. So long as the animals being hunted aren't endangered species, I don't really have a problem with it. (Though I am REALLY allergic to venison. I get fever and barf like nobody's business.) The thing I've been thinking about is the fact that with the advent of modern amenities and electricity, there are certain survival skills that we don't have that our ancestors once had, and that makes me feel uneasy. Last year I was in a really bad storm and power was lost for days. For some people, weeks. Luckily I was staying at a house that had a wood stove so we could cook what food we had and heat the house. But it really made me realize how dependant we are on electricity. There were people calling into the local a.m. radio hiding under blankets, living in fear, and trying to stay warm because they were heated by electricity. People were dying from carbon monoxide poisoning because they were using barbecues indoors to try to stay warm. But anyway, it's really easy to get all self-righteous about vegetarianism and nature when you live on electricity and have no need to hunt. But what would people do if something went wrong? As in REALLY wrong? Unless you're growing beans on your own farm or something, maybe then hunting might not look so "evil" after all. All the power to people that still take an interest in maintaining skills for living off the land and doing "barbaric" things like hunting and outdoorsmanship. They might be the ones that could someday help people out in need.
Lil Red Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 [quote]That said, though, please pick the weakest of the herd, and make it a quick end. You think the deer of future generations are going to be able to get out of the way of your speeding vehicle any faster if you kill off their best genetic lines? You're really shooting yourself in the foot with that one, or rather, shooting your children and grandchildren in the foot. Also, all of the above rules still apply to you.[/quote] he's full of carp.
CrossCuT Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 (edited) [size=1]Yeah!!! Take that you sad, sadistic, and brightly-clothed animal killers! You smell nobody loves you! [/size] Edited December 1, 2007 by CrossCuT
hoosieranna Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 I don't hunt, and personally want nothing to do with it. I don't have ethical problems with it. I just get queasy. I teach, and it [i]is[/i] distracting if a student comes in wearing their gear. The orange draws the eye. Understandable in the forest, but in an intro geography class? Sure. I don't want to see pictures of the buck, and don't particularly care whether they use a bow or firearm. Hunt freely, but leave me out of it.
SaintOlaf Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 I am from Michigan, the #1 state for white-tail deer hunting in the US. I am a hunter, I realize this may offend some people, but here are my thoughts on the article. /rant on [quote]1. Don't boast loudly during class about the deer (bird, buffalo, kitten, baby, whatever) that you killed at some place that had this many points and weighed that many pounds. And definitely don't boast about how its head is now dripping blood in your garage, or mounted on your living room wall. I don't think that recent, senseless carnage is really a good topic for the classroom.[/quote] I can get behind this point. As a hunter, I make every effort to not offend people with my "gory stories of rampage in the woods up north". I do not go out of my way to make sure that people hear that I shot an animal that weekend, or that day. In fact, I know few hunters that do, most will be relaying a story to a friend or acquaintance and be overheard by someone else in the class who gets overly offended... when they weren't in the conversation to begin with. [quote]2. Don't wear your hunting gear to class. Are you going back out to the killing fields so soon that you can't even bother to stop at your house and change after your school day? On a Tuesday afternoon, I highly doubt it. That bright orange color is extremely offensive to the eyes, and wearing shirts that have grass and deer printed all over them is ironic only in a sadistic sense. For those of you who wore that kind of thing all the time to high school, so you keep doing it now, I say: you're in college now. You're supposed to be on your way to being a more educated, ethical person. And Grand Forks is bigger than your hometown of 100-3,000 people, and there are actually people here who'd prefer you keep your brutal habits to yourself.[/quote] This is simply ridiculous, what I choose to wear is what I choose to wear. If I was out in the field hunting the morning before my class (hey it's happened to me!) I don't bother to change my clothes, there's absolutely no need. My blaze orange jacket, or camo cover-alls are no less acceptable in society than your expressive shirts or bumper stickers etc... I agree, if the clothing is bloody then it should be changed but, if I shoot a deer an hour before I'm supposed to be at class, chances are I'm not making it to that class anyway. As for the remark about being "a more educated and ethical person" and my "brutal habits", I make every attempt possible to execute a clean kill. This means I do not use an under-powered firearm (or overpowered for that matter), I shoot to kill, not to maim or wound, and I am proficient with my weapon, meaning that I am confident that I can make a near-perfect shot and take the animal with as little pain as possible. [quote]3. If you have just come from an all-night spree of gunfire and beer, change your clothes before you show yourself in public. Having animal blood all over your pants is neither a fashion statement nor particularly healthy.[/quote] Someone has been watching too much TV. Every [b]responsible[/b] hunter and firearm carrier know that alcohol and firearms do not mix. I'll admit to enjoying a beer or 2 after a long day out in the woods, but that is only after my gun has been cleaned and locked back up in it's case, responsible hunters and firearm owners do not play around with their weapons, they are treated with the respect that they should be, given their power. [quote]4. For those of you who do it for only for food, not sport, and to keep deer "off your car hood," fine; at least your intentions are honest. I don't like the beef industry, either; I'd much rather all animals have a free life before they become dinner. And I get that there are a lot of deer out there causing car accidents. But that's what happens when we destroy all their natural predators, stupid. That said, though, please pick the weakest of the herd, and make it a quick end. You think the deer of future generations are going to be able to get out of the way of your speeding vehicle any faster if you kill off their best genetic lines? You're really shooting yourself in the foot with that one, or rather, shooting your children and grandchildren in the foot. Also, all of the above rules still apply to you.[/quote] I don't do it solely for the meat of the deer (though that is a great part of it). I thoroughly enjoy being out in nature, enjoying the splendor of God's creation, and marveling at all the little creatures he has created. But as was alluded to in the article, deer can be a real problem in the country as far as traffic is concerned, I have family that lives in the country that hits 3-4 deer a year. A much larger problem is disease, we have it in parts of Michigan already from overcrowding. By keeping the population low, you lower the risk of diseases running rampant throughout the herd, which would call for a culling of the entire herd to eliminate the disease! Through responsible and ethical harvesting of the herd we can keep disease under control, and out of the herd. [quote]In conclusion, try to keep your dirty habit to yourself. I don't want to hear about it, and I don't want to see it. You have not gained my respect for "conquering" the wilderness with your down jackets, thermal underwear and heat packs; nor will you ever gain my respect for taking the lives of animals that have no defense from you.[/quote] /end rant
KnightofChrist Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 Boy tellya what I should write this guy the story of the time I shot a group of annoying squirrels cause they scared off a TEN POINT Buck, yeah thats right, points. Squirrels can be good eaten. All seven of their cute wee heads are mounted on the wall. But seriously squirrel meat can be good, bambis mom made delicious deer burgers. And as for the article why can't Men be MEN anymore without some cry baby whiner throwing a temper tantrum? [img]http://www.oldtexican.com/shop/images/43_th.gif[/img]
Dreamweaver Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 Hunting is great! I don't hunt, but many of my relatives live in prime hunting land, hunt, and everyone in my fiance's family also hunts. It isn't just about the meat (which is awesome), it is getting to know your roots in the wilderness. There's a lot of stereotyping and false assumptions with that letter also. Grand Forks smells of elderberries, go Fargo!
Justin86 Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 [quote]It's getting to be that time of year again; the leaves are gone, the wind is getting stronger, and the air is getting colder. Fires (or electric base-board heaters) are roaring, and my roommate is starting to drink hot chocolate on a regular basis. Christmas music has even started playing in department stores, though it's a whole other column to go into how it's too soon for that. And, people are heading outdoors to shoot animals. Hunting is something I can't and won't understand. How can any self-respecting person venture out to the beautiful world of nature to destroy it? How does a civilized human being get their jollies from murder? It's beyond me, really it is. But let's say, for the sake of argument, that killing is something that you do enjoy. I'd like to lay down some "courtesy ground rules," if you will, that will keep this sad season at its most tolerable for those of us who prefer wildlife to be alive. 1. Don't boast loudly during class about the deer (bird, buffalo, kitten, baby, whatever) that you killed at some place that had this many points and weighed that many pounds. And definitely don't boast about how its head is now dripping blood in your garage, or mounted on your living room wall. I don't think that recent, senseless carnage is really a good topic for the classroom. 2. Don't wear your hunting gear to class. Are you going back out to the killing fields so soon that you can't even bother to stop at your house and change after your school day? On a Tuesday afternoon, I highly doubt it. That bright orange color is extremely offensive to the eyes, and wearing shirts that have grass and deer printed all over them is ironic only in a sadistic sense. For those of you who wore that kind of thing all the time to high school, so you keep doing it now, I say: you're in college now. You're supposed to be on your way to being a more educated, ethical person. And Grand Forks is bigger than your hometown of 100-3,000 people, and there are actually people here who'd prefer you keep your brutal habits to yourself. 3. If you have just come from an all-night spree of gunfire and beer, change your clothes before you show yourself in public. Having animal blood all over your pants is neither a fashion statement nor particularly healthy. 4. For those of you who do it for only for food, not sport, and to keep deer "off your car hood," fine; at least your intentions are honest. I don't like the beef industry, either; I'd much rather all animals have a free life before they become dinner. And I get that there are a lot of deer out there causing car accidents. But that's what happens when we destroy all their natural predators, stupid. That said, though, please pick the weakest of the herd, and make it a quick end. You think the deer of future generations are going to be able to get out of the way of your speeding vehicle any faster if you kill off their best genetic lines? You're really shooting yourself in the foot with that one, or rather, shooting your children and grandchildren in the foot. Also, all of the above rules still apply to you. In conclusion, try to keep your dirty habit to yourself. I don't want to hear about it, and I don't want to see it. You have not gained my respect for "conquering" the wilderness with your down jackets, thermal underwear and heat packs; nor will you ever gain my respect for taking the lives of animals that have no defense from you.[/quote] So in summary: MEAT IS MURDER I would challenge that. Meat tastes good. Meat is good for you. There are nine amino acids that the body needs for survival that it does not produce. All of these are conveniently found in meat. You can get them in vegetables if you want to eat certain quantities of particular types, but really its just more practical to have some meat with your food. MEAT IS GOOD
MissScripture Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 [quote name='SaintOlaf' post='1427651' date='Dec 1 2007, 12:47 AM']I don't do it solely for the meat of the deer (though that is a great part of it). I thoroughly enjoy being out in nature, enjoying the splendor of God's creation, and marveling at all the little creatures he has created. But as was alluded to in the article, deer can be a real problem in the country as far as traffic is concerned, I have family that lives in the country that hits 3-4 deer a year. A much larger problem is disease, we have it in parts of Michigan already from overcrowding. By keeping the population low, you lower the risk of diseases running rampant throughout the herd, which would call for a culling of the entire herd to eliminate the disease! Through responsible and ethical harvesting of the herd we can keep disease under control, and out of the herd. /end rant[/quote] There's also the fact that they WILL starve to death, which I would think is a far harsher fate than a shot taking them out. It's a lot longer sort of death, and a complete waste! [quote name='Dreamweaver' post='1427721' date='Dec 1 2007, 08:10 AM']Hunting is great! I don't hunt, but many of my relatives live in prime hunting land, hunt, and everyone in my fiance's family also hunts. It isn't just about the meat (which is awesome), it is getting to know your roots in the wilderness. There's a lot of stereotyping and false assumptions with that letter also. Grand Forks smells of elderberries, go Fargo![/quote] Fargo is the epicenter of evil snow storms that keep me from getting home or getting back to school!
Ash Wednesday Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 I'm still laughing about the author's insinuation that Grand Forks is big city living and you're going to get culture shock upon arrival.
MissScripture Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1427787' date='Dec 1 2007, 12:39 PM']I'm still laughing about the author's insinuation that Grand Forks is big city living and you're going to get culture shock upon arrival.[/quote] Me, too! Especially since Bismarck is bigger and it's STILL not as large as my hometown area, which was NOT that big. I went to NYC with a girl from out here. Um, WOW. I do not consider myself a big city person at all, but she had NO clue how to handle that! (Granted, I'd spent a week in London, so I had a small idea as to what to expect in a big city, but WOW. I would not recommend traveling to places like NYC with people who go crazy when they get to go to the Twin Cities.)
SanctitasDeo Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 (edited) That article is one of the silliest things I have ever read on the subject. Being queasy about hunting and so forth I can understand. If people honestly go around boasting about the blood and gore that splattered from the last deer they killed, I can somewhat understand the vitriol. However, at least where I grew up, in Texas, where hunting is absolutely everywhere, no one boasted like that at all. People could where camo to school, just like they could wear anti-hunting shirts to school. Frankly, I expect that the hunters that the author of that piece describes and degrades have done more for conservation efforts than he has, merely through hunting. In Texas, we actually have problems with deer overpopulation. If we didn't hunt them, the herds would expand way beyond what the land can support, they would strip the land of food, and then they would all die off. No more deer. If we hunt, that doesn't happen. Second, all those fees that hunters pay for the mandatory gun and hunting safety classes and licenses go toward conservation efforts, at least in Texas. I would be surprised if that was not true in most or all states. Before he complains, especially in such an obnoxious, hyperbolic way, he should figure out what he can do that would actually help the environment, instead of trying to self-justify his own self-righteous indignation. Edited December 1, 2007 by SanctitasDeo
MissScripture Posted December 1, 2007 Posted December 1, 2007 [quote name='SanctitasDeo' post='1427810' date='Dec 1 2007, 01:22 PM']That article is one of the silliest things I have ever read on the subject. Being queasy about hunting and so forth I can understand. If people honestly go around boasting about the blood and gore that splattered from the last deer they killed, I can somewhat understand the vitriol. However, at least where I grew up, in Texas, where hunting is absolutely everywhere, no one boasted like that at all. People could where camo to school, just like they could wear anti-hunting shirts to school. Frankly, I expect that the hunters that the author of that piece describes and degrades have done more for conservation efforts than he has, merely through hunting. In Texas, we actually have problems with deer overpopulation. If we didn't hunt them, the herds would expand way beyond what the land can support, they would strip the land of food, and then they would all die off. No more deer. If we hunt, that doesn't happen. Second, all those fees that hunters pay for the mandatory gun and hunting safety classes and licenses go toward conservation efforts, at least in Texas. I would be surprised if that was not true in most or all states. Before he complains, especially in such an obnoxious, hyperbolic way, he should figure out what he can do that would actually help the environment, instead of trying to self-justify his own self-righteous indignation.[/quote] It's the same in ND. This year there are a LOT of deer, too. Driving home for Thanksgiving, ever couple of miles you saw bloodstained freeway, and a deer carcas just a little ways off. I couldn't believe the number dead deer I saw. And in October when I went home for Fall break, I had four deer cross in front of me --the last one almost ending up on my hood, because I didn't expect a fourth one. There were so many that I know a lot of people who got buck tags got doe tags, too, sometimes a couple. I'm pretty sure all the money goes to environmental causes, as well, here and in MN. And quite honestly, the most environmentally friendly people I know are hunters. My uncle is an Endangered species Wildlife Biologist and he hunts deer, turkey, grouse and pheasant!
Lena Posted December 2, 2007 Posted December 2, 2007 [quote]I had four deer cross in front of me --the last one almost ending up on my hood, because I didn't expect a fourth one.[/quote] the golden rule I've learned with deer crossings---where one is, more are sure to follow!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now