Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Sin Earns Hell But Doing Right Doesn't Earn Heaven.


Recommended Posts

Posted

I think that's what you all believe. :idontknow:

1. Is it?
2. What is the explanation?
3. Protestants often say that [i]one[/i] sin earns Hell. Your thoughts on going to that extreme, please.
4. Your favorite color.

Peace,
Paddington

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1427516' date='Nov 30 2007, 09:35 PM']I think that's what you all believe. :idontknow:

1. Is it?
2. What is the explanation?
3. Protestants often say that [i]one[/i] sin earns Hell. Your thoughts on going to that extreme, please.
4. Your favorite color.

Peace,
Paddington[/quote]

Well, I'm not a theologian, but since this isn't in Q&A I'm going to go ahead and give it a shot...

Going to Heaven or Hell ultimately is not about what you do, but whether you accept or reject God and His love. What you do is a [i]reflection [/i]of that acceptance or rejection. Sin itself doesn't "earn" Hell, but sin is a turning away from or a separation from God, and by doing that enough you reject Heaven.


And, depends on my mood but right now I'd say blue. Dark blue.

Posted

When I was a Prot Christian, I told my campers that there is no such thing as somebody who is only a little sinful and not to pay any mind to that "one sin is enough" stuff. Other camp counselors were teaching the "one sin is enough" thing.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Paddington' post='1427562' date='Nov 30 2007, 09:58 PM']...that there is no such thing as somebody who is only a little sinful and not to pay any mind to that "one sin is enough" stuff.[/quote]

That comment seems contradictory. If you are inferring that one can't be a little sinful versus a lotta sinful, wouldn't that imply that the amount of sin in irrelevant and thus one sin IS enough?

1) Works are a natural byproduct of Faith. Sin is an unfortunate "work" of rejecting that Faith.
2) If one chooses to turn his back on God, sin is the result. I think the Catholic understanding of mortal versus venial sin is important here as a sinful action is not always the result of a conscious choice to turn from God. (1 Jn 5:16-17)
3) In the case of a mortal sin, I believe once is enough without a conscious action to turn back to God through sacramental Confession.
4) Stole Purple ;)

Edited by esmith818
Posted

[quote name='esmith818' post='1427567' date='Dec 1 2007, 12:47 AM']That comment seems contradictory. If you are inferring that one can't be a little sinful versus a lotta sinful, wouldn't that imply that the amount of sin in irrelevant and thus one sin IS enough?[/quote]

ESmith818,

:)

Okay, I think I understand your comment now. It took me a while. I wrote a bunch of stuff before I understood it. I don't want it to go to waste either.

I agree with you that some sinners sin more than others and that some sins are worse than other sins.
Yet somehow the mortal/venial distinction isn't 100% okay with me and I'm too ill-prepared and tired to try to get into that one now.

Some more stuff that you might agree with that relates to what I was trying to relate from my camp counseling experience......
My comment had in mind that the least sinful sinner still has a lot of sins. They should not think "I've sinned one or more times, therefore I need Salvation." I wanted them to think of their many sins to see why they needed Christ. We got very specific together going through the 10 Commandments and various applications of each one and how one sin can include other sins. That gives a picture of a sinner. If somebody says "of course I have sinned at least once, let me be saved now without the chastising of God's Law," then that is a poor picture of sinfulness.

I can't get myself to say that one sin is enough. There are many people holier than me who are Christians unlike me, and yet I see them do many of the same things. They lose battles to their sinful tongues, their vanity, their insensitivity, their self-seeking and, once in a while, they can demonstrate ill-will in an instant.

When that is the state of mankind, then why even mention that "one sin is enough." Even if it is true, it is in a super-mysterious-way and could be a stumbling-block if not treated very carefully.

Anywho.....I'm about to hit the sack.

Peace,
Paddington

Posted (edited)

I think putting a quantity on your sins in analogous to a teen asking "how far is too far?" in regard to chastity. If one sin is not enough, how many are? I believe each of us sins on a daily basis (some, perhaps, more gave than others) so the concept of a single sin damning us to hell is rather moot.

Paddington states in his OP that "Protestants often say that one sin earns Hell." While this may be true for some Protestants, I think there is also a school of thought that believes in the "once saved, always saved" idea which suggests that your actions are either overlooked, forgiven (despite your contrition), or that God somehow gives you the grace to sin no more (I wish!).

I believe we both agree that man is incapable of getting to Heaven without the mercy of God, and that we need to recognize that need, and seek His forgiveness at the end of each day regardless of whether we committed one sin or one hundred!

Edited by esmith818
Posted

My thoughts on the whole subject were that Doing right doesn't earn heaven because doing "right" is what we're made to do. Chris Padgett once made the analogy of a pen... we don't praise the pen for writing, it's what it's supposed to do! So we don't really deserve reward/praise for doing good, we're supposed to do good. Evil merits hell because it is turning away from one's duty, thus degenerating the being's capacity for being in the presence of ultimate good. This is a gradual process, ie, there is gradation involved, meaning, venial and mortal sins...

'aight I hope this is connected enough, Pad. I'm tired, and so I'm hitting the sack too. 'Night

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...