Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Husband-wife Domestic Confessional Model


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1429945' date='Dec 5 2007, 02:16 AM']see... I don't know, personally I think people need to move away from a mindset that makes such a thing so hurtful. maybe I'm just an idealist.

I was watching Home Improvement one time, and they were having these troubles in their marriage... after umpteen years of marriage, there was this big deal about Jill actually finding another man attractive, and they had to work it out like some big problem.

to me, I found that absolutely ridiculous that they finally came to this conclusion after umpteen years of marriage when some guy hit on Jill (who happened to be a great granite guy, which only made it worse, lol). I think it should be made absolutely clear to both spouses from the start that they are human beings who will have attraction to other people other than their spouse. seems to me that it would only make for a stronger marriage if the two spouses understood this and knew about this and shared this fact. It should be re-affirming to the one spouse when the other confesses "I had lustful thoughts about someone (don't even have to mention the name so long as it was just thoughts)... so I came back to you to confess this to you, I am renewing my choice of YOU instead of that person" you know? to me, it'd be even more of a reinforcement of love, especially if the person was someone who my wife theoretically could have if she wanted to, because to me, if she came to me and said "I had lustful thoughts about Leonardo DiCaprio" it's like... wow, and you've chosen not to run off on me for him! halleluja! lol... but then if it's like "I had lustful thoughts about hunky John Q. OurFriend, who has always liked me"... I'd be like... wow, and you came and told this to me? that's love.

but I'm sure many who know me on here realize that I am an idealist, and you're all probably waiting for me to get crushed by reality (though as I have said, I intend to never give up on my ideals as a thing to be approximated, even if reality makes them difficult to actually realize)[/quote]

Al,
I think idealist are wonderful gifts. Keep us focused on the high road.
I am a pragmatist.....it is very, very ingrained in me. I come from a very long line of pragmatic women. I always ask myself when confronted by an idea, how practical is this?
Although I "know" the ideal would be to see these confessions as for the greater good and not intended to hurt feelings, it would be very difficult to be as objective about them as your model would require. I think this an inherently feminine reaction. Emotions are not so easy for us to seperate from logic. Think of Eve....satan played on her emotions. But on the positive side think of the great gifts of these emotions....a mothers great love for her unborn child(well most women anyway) etc...
My point? I'm getting there....Although ideally this would be cool, to have a sort of formal time to apologize for transgressions against a spouse, in practicality when you are dealing with emotions it may not be so easy. Even if you could emotionally seperate yourself from the more hurtful confessions(And I am sure they would not all be hurtful although isn't that what sins are...hurting God and your neighbor?), you would always remember them. That is one of the beauties of sacramental Confession....even if the priest remembers your sins they don't directly affect him. He is not hurt by them(well, he is because our sins hurt all of our brothers and sisters, but you know what I mean). There are some transgressions it is just best not to share with your wife, imho.

Posted

There could certainly be a line drawn, varying from couple to couple, which allowed for some confessions to be made or withheld based on what was expedient to tell; though in an ideal marriage, an ideal which ought to be approximated as much as possible, everything could be shared.

Personally, when it comes to attraction/lustful thoughts about others, I think every healthy relationship should have already discussed that and come to an understanding that it will happen, and when it does it is not the end of the world; that the point is not that you're never attracted to anyone else, but that you always choose against anyone else and for your spouse. Any relationship which has not already discussed this is weak in this regard and will face a crisis when it eventually does happen (unless it is always kept super secret, in which case I question the healthiness of that, hiding the fact from your spouse that you feel attraction for someone else only sustains the possibility that you might want to start some clandestine affair with them in secret).

But I could see potentially there being one sin or another which shouldn't be told because the reaction of the spouse would just be too much, that the spouse's emotions would preclude their understanding, but I'd suggest that the couple always be working to make their relationship strong enough that they would both understand each other so well that nothing would need to be held back.

but also: think of the deterrent factor!... if some people find themselves not sinning because they don't want to have to tell the priest, imagine if they would have to explain it to their spouse! and someone with a well-informed strong conscience could very well find himself in that predicament, where he knows that as soon as he has committed the transgression he will be regretful and consider it necessary to confess it to his spouse, so he would have to not do it in the first place if he did not want to tell his spouse about it.

Posted

I do have to disagree with you that lustful thoughts will happen. It takes a conscience effort to entertain a lustful thought. You have to look at or see someone and think"That person is attractive" [i]then[/i] you have to entertain the lustful thought. I don't think that that should be something to exspect. Thinking someone is attractive is a natural thought. Choosing to think lustfully is not. If a spouse chooses to entertain the thoughts they are making an effort to do so. [i]That[/i] is what is hurtful....the choice to reject your spouse in order to willfully entertain the thought.

This hypothetical example is just one of the many ways we can sin against the spouse. So I don't want to beat it to death. I do want to point out that as we are growing in holiness together as a Christian couple there are things that can be more harmful than helpful....full and complete honesty can be very harsh. It is sometimes a very wise thing to know when not to admit to a pernicious thought or action to your spouse. That is what Sacramental confession is for. Perhaps if there is something that your spouse can aid you in overcoming than it could be shared but an idealistic across the board let it all hang out, I'm a sinner approach could actually be a sinful thing in that it could add more pain and suffering. KWIM?

The deterrrent factor was not something I thought of, though I'm not sure being afraid of being caught is the [i]ideal[/i] when it comes to the desire not to sin<wink>.

photosynthesis
Posted
:blink:

all I can say is: I'm sure there's a good reason why this practice never developed organically in 2,000 years of Catholic tradition.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...