Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ron Paul Supports "freedom" For Brothels


Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

[mod]Warning: there are explicit images at the second link, so viewer beware. --Era Might[/mod]

[url="http://hotair.com/archives/2007/11/27/video-ron-paul-on-brothels"]http://hotair.com/archives/2007/11/27/vide...aul-on-brothels[/url]

[url="http://www.breitbart.tv/?p=8629"]http://www.breitbart.tv/?p=8629[/url]

Posted

St. Thomas Aquinas agrees with him, please direct your complaints in prayer form to:

The Angelic Doctor, 123 Scholastic Heavenly Mansion Dr., Heaven.

"prostitution is like a sewer system, despicable but necessary." -St. Thomas Aquinas

"those who are in authority, rightly tolerate certain evils, lest certain goods be lost, or certain greater evils be incurred: thus Augustine says (De Ordine ii.4): "If you do away with harlots, the world will be convulsed with lust." Aquinas quoting Augustine

KnightofChrist
Posted

[url="http://romancatholicblog.typepad.com/roman_catholic_blog/2007/11/ron-paul-supp-1.html"]SOURCE[/url]

[quote]I am aware that St. Thomas Aquinas tolerated the evil of prostitution, but it must be stressed that his tolerance never involved intending the sin of prostitution.

See: A Thomistic Case for Tolerance by Maria Fontana Magee

Quote:

...those who are in authority, rightly tolerate certain evils, lest certain goods be lost, or certain greater evils be incurred: thus Augustine says (De Ordine ii.4): "If you do away with harlots, the world will be convulsed with lust." (ST II-II, q. 10, a. 11)

This passage occurs in response to the question of whether the rites of certain unbelievers (such as the Jews) should be tolerated, which Thomas answers in the affirmative:

"Hence, though unbelievers sin in their rites, they may be tolerated, either on account of some good that ensues therefrom, or because of some evil avoided." (Ibid.)

Even in this passage, however, Thomas has reservations about tolerating those rites of unbelievers which are neither true nor spiritually valuable. He only allows for such rites to be tolerated "in order to avoid an evil, for instance the scandal or disturbance that might ensue, or some hindrance to the salvation of those who if they were unmolested might gradually convert to the faith."(Ibid.) To return to the brief statement about prostitution, it is especially striking because it shows Thomas' willingness to tolerate a serious evil for the sake of civil order. Surely, this is a case of more than limited tolerance!

Thomas locates the need for tolerance in the eternal law itself. Advocating that human government should imitate the divine rule, Thomas reminds us:

"Now although God is all-powerful and supremely good, nevertheless He allows certain evils to take place in the universe, which He might prevent, lest, without them, greater goods might be forfeited, or greater evils ensue." (Ibid.)

This was the principle which Thomas invoked to justify the toleration of harlots. It shows that his belief in tolerance is not merely a pragmatic one, but is deeply embedded in his view of man as one who participates in the eternal law.

Interesting reading, no?

Bottom line: Listening to Ron Paul's response to an endorsement from sex trade "workers", it's clear that Ron Paul is no St. Thomas Aquinas. His principles are rooted in the desire to keep government (particularly federal government) from interfering in people's lives and keeping with federal powers in check (which are generally good policies), but going so far as endorsing prostitution as "freedom" in the name of libertarianism is not consistent with Catholic morality.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428657' date='Dec 3 2007, 02:34 PM']St. Thomas Aquinas agrees with him, please direct your complaints in prayer form to:

The Angelic Doctor, 123 Scholastic Heavenly Mansion Dr., Heaven.

"prostitution is like a sewer system, despicable but necessary." -St. Thomas Aquinas

"those who are in authority, rightly tolerate certain evils, lest certain goods be lost, or certain greater evils be incurred: thus Augustine says (De Ordine ii.4): "If you do away with harlots, the world will be convulsed with lust." Aquinas quoting Augustine[/quote]

In a sense I dont agree with Augustine or Aquinas here. Saint Pius took harsh action to eradicate prostitution in Rome. But I am thinking in ideals, and this world is anything but ideal, so in a sense I agree with Aquinas and Augustine.

Posted

No, Aquinas's position even as explained there is EXACTLY Ron Paul's opinion. This is also St. Thomas's argument, as he says that government ought to mimic God's governance of the world by tolerating evil.

"Now although God is all-powerful and supremely good, nevertheless He allows certain evils to take place in the universe, which He might prevent, lest, without them, greater goods might be forfeited, or greater evils ensue."

This is what Ron Paul is saying; as God grants free will and does not interfere in it, so government respects free will and does not interefere in such freedom.

This blogger is being ridiculous. Aquinas wants to tolerate evil as free will is tolerated by God, but when Ron Paul proposes the same thing he is convinced that he is of some sinister opinion. The only thing Ron Paul wants to do is decriminilize prostitution at the federal level: this is exactly what Catholic principals of government DEMAND.

What, ought he to refuse the support of prostitutes? I know of a certain God-man who dined with them and accepted their support once upon a time.

What would you say to the quotes from Aquinas (namely the sewer one) and Augustine which speak of prostitution in the same type of pragmatic way Ron Paul speaks of it? "If you do away with harlots, the world will be convulsed with lust." seems like a pretty pragmatic view to me. But Ron Paul's principals of limited government are indeed right on line with Aquinas's principals and the principals of subsidarit.

I suggest someone show where Ron Paul's position differs from Aquinas; that blogger just blew a bunch of hot air insinuating Ron Paul was too enthusiastic about getting support from a brothel or something... but Ron Paul's message of freedom is about exactly mirroring the way God tolerates all the effects of free will, so that he thinks government ought to tolerate all the effects of freedom.

Posted

I don't know the specifics of Ron Paul's position on this matter, so I can't comment on that, but regarding the legalization of prostitution, St. Thomas lived in a different world. Prostitution was a vice that was confined out of view from society. There are a lot of sins that we tolerate for the same reason. For example, we don't arrest people for the sin of fornication.

Prostitution today would not be hidden from society. Legal prostitution would be major business, and would erode society in the same way as pornography and contraception. There would be advertisement and enticement to sin all over society, something St. Thomas would not approve. The analogy with a sewer system is appropriate, because a sewer system is underground. It is not seen in society, and that would not be the case today with legalized prostitution.

Posted

Ron Paul's position is solely to de-criminalize it at the federal level, allowing states to decide whether to legalize or illegalize it (I know Nevada has it legalized currently, but I believe heavy federal pressure is exerted against states legalizing it, that is what Ron Paul would stop.

I do not agree with the concept that legalizing it now would deteriorate society any more than it did in Aquinas's time. It seems to me that Augustine's saying still applies: get rid of the harlots and the whole world will be engulfed in lust; ie enforce morality this strongly (as part of a puritanical society) and you will breed increasing paganism and hedonism.

In any event, Catholics are free to hold that prostitution ought not to be illegalized at the civil level, and probably ought to hold that it shouldn't be done at a federal level based on subsidarity, and Ron Paul is still not holding any position which would invalidate him as a candidate according to Catholic principals, whereas basically every other candidate is, ranging from the inherent evil of torture, to the inherent evil of potential pre-emptive nuclear strikes (or nuclear strike in general, which are inherent evil) (they pledge to not take anything off the table), to the inherent evil of legalized abortion. supporting the decriminization of prostitution at the federal level is not a position forbidden for a Catholic to hold.

KnightofChrist
Posted

All that said, Sin is not freedom, it is slavery to Satan which God allows for the sake of freewill. Ron Paul takes the money from Prostitutes and Pimps aka strippers and strip club owners.

Posted

note that I was very theologically presice and referenced it as the CONSEQUENCE of free will; the consequence of free will is the possibility of evil.

Jesus dined with prostitutes.

prostitutes are citizens of our country, same as homosexuals, adulterers, and every other type of sinner in the country who also donate to campaigns. so if an owner of a brothel wishes to support a political candidate monetarily, he is free to do so, and there is no reason a candidate should reject that simply because the man owns a brothel.

so the brothel owner wants to be able to legally take part in the business that is happening anyway everywhere else in the country, so he supports Ron Paul's beleif in freedom which would tolerate his evil edeavor, then what is so wrong with that?

anyway, this entire issue is full of puritan style hypocrisy; trying to disqualify paul because he doesn't spit in the face of prostitutes who are citizens of the country and thus have a say in its governance? garbage. does no one remember our Divine Lord and Savior who dined with prostitutes? He didn't support their sin, nor does Ron Paul, he simply follows a philosophy of government which does not criminalize it as a civil matter.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428740' date='Dec 3 2007, 06:03 PM']note that I was very theologically presice and referenced it as the CONSEQUENCE of free will; the consequence of free will is the possibility of evil.

Jesus dined with prostitutes.

prostitutes are citizens of our country, same as homosexuals, adulterers, and every other type of sinner in the country who also donate to campaigns. so if an owner of a brothel wishes to support a political candidate monetarily, he is free to do so, and there is no reason a candidate should reject that simply because the man owns a brothel.

so the brothel owner wants to be able to legally take part in the business that is happening anyway everywhere else in the country, so he supports Ron Paul's beleif in freedom which would tolerate his evil edeavor, then what is so wrong with that?

anyway, this entire issue is full of puritan style hypocrisy; trying to disqualify paul because he doesn't spit in the face of prostitutes who are citizens of the country and thus have a say in its governance? garbage. does no one remember our Divine Lord and Savior who dined with prostitutes? He didn't support their sin, nor does Ron Paul, he simply follows a philosophy of government which does not criminalize it as a civil matter.[/quote]

There is no freedom in evil, only slavery to Satan. Christ did dine with prostitutes but also preached to them they where slaves to sin and Satan because of there sins. Christ never said prostitutes had the "freedom" to sin, far from it, He says there is only freedom in Him.

Ron Paul is quoted as saying there is "freedom" for sexual sins, and willfully takes dirty money from unrepented strip clubs that is support. Which is not in line with the teachings of Christ.

Edited by KnightofChrist
KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428740' date='Dec 3 2007, 06:03 PM']anyway, this entire issue is full of puritan style hypocrisy; trying to disqualify paul because he doesn't spit in the face of prostitutes who are citizens of the country and thus have a say in its governance? garbage. does no one remember our Divine Lord and Savior who dined with prostitutes? He didn't support their sin, nor does Ron Paul, he simply follows a philosophy of government which does not criminalize it as a civil matter.[/quote]


I've never said Ron Paul should spit in anyones face. Of all the sinners on Phatmass I am the greatest. Prostitution is not a freedom for prostitutes to support. NAMBLA is also made up of citizens of the country do they also have a say in it's governance? Once we give "freedom" to one sexual sin why not all?

Posted

I dont know what the big deal is. He's a politician, they all have dirt on their hands to one degree or another.

Besides whether we like it or not Hilary is going to win. Mark my words.

Posted (edited)

I saw a clip of Ron Paul addressing this on CNN. He received a record breaking 5 millions dollars worth of donations in 24 hours, his crew could not screen that many people to see who they are and determine whether it's worth accepting their money. Basically if someone wants to donate to his campaign freely, he'll accept no matter who they are. He did mention however that he never heard of the bunny ranch, and so I don't think he is targeting such sponsors. What's happening here is that the media is trying to suggest a bunch of corrupt people have contributed to Ron Paul's race for president, and if such people finance him perhaps he reflects some of their corrupt views. Overall he seems like an honest Christian candidate, and far better than the others that are running.

Edited by mortify
Posted

[quote]Besides whether we like it or not Hilary is going to win. Mark my words.[/quote] she's behind Obama in the polls now; I think it's very likely she will crash and burn without the nomination, actually.

Sin is a consequence of true freedom, of course it is not a freedom in itself; my statements have been clear and philosophically nuanced, yet you refuse to listen. Ron Paul is not talking moral philosophy here, but political philosophy, and on it he is absolutely in sync with Aquinas who suggested that just as God tolerates evil for the sake of free will, a government ought to tolerate evil for the sake of freedom (this is the "freedom" which he talks about). The question of where to draw the line becomes a question of which evils ought to be considered civil crimes and which evils ought to not be considered civil crimes... the Church leaves open the possibility that prostitution not be considered a civil crime; though pedophilia certainly ought to be a civil crime. But Ron Paul's position doesn't even go this far into it, it simply says that the federal government should not say one thing or the other on the issue, as it is a matter for states to decide; which, of course, any Catholic ought to support because we're supposed to support things being done on lower levels based on the principal of subsidarity; and seeing as this is not something considered to definitively be a civil crime according to Catholic Teaching, there is therefore absolutely no justification in Catholic Teaching for spreading the criminalization of it through centralized big government.

pedophilia is considered a civil crime because it is an assault of one party against another. prostitution is not considered a civil crime because it is the choice of two people with free will to engage in a sexual sin; the government has no place attempting to stop consensual sexual sins through legislation, and there is absolutely no justification in Catholic teaching for the government to play such a role. it may only play the role of stopping assaults; and it may define that a minor is by definition considered assaulted because they are not of the legal age where they are considered on an equal playing field to give consent.

Again, I'd ask for you to show, based on an actual quote of Ron Paul, where he differs from Aquinas's position. I have not seen that, all I have seen is an attempt to smear him by associating him with prostitutes.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 08:17 PM']she's behind Obama in the polls now; I think it's very likely she will crash and burn without the nomination, actually.

Sin is a consequence of true freedom, of course it is not a freedom in itself; my statements have been clear and philosophically nuanced, yet you refuse to listen. Ron Paul is not talking moral philosophy here, but political philosophy, and on it he is absolutely in sync with Aquinas who suggested that just as God tolerates evil for the sake of free will, a government ought to tolerate evil for the sake of freedom (this is the "freedom" which he talks about). The question of where to draw the line becomes a question of which evils ought to be considered civil crimes and which evils ought to not be considered civil crimes... the Church leaves open the possibility that prostitution not be considered a civil crime; though pedophilia certainly ought to be a civil crime. But Ron Paul's position doesn't even go this far into it, it simply says that the federal government should not say one thing or the other on the issue, as it is a matter for states to decide; which, of course, any Catholic ought to support because we're supposed to support things being done on lower levels based on the principal of subsidarity; and seeing as this is not something considered to definitively be a civil crime according to Catholic Teaching, there is therefore absolutely no justification in Catholic Teaching for spreading the criminalization of it through centralized big government.[/quote]

I am not questioning your reasoning Aloysius, its obvious you have a grip on Aquinas beyond me.

Anyhow here is the latest poles, Hilary is indeed still ahead according to these:

[url="http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/candidates/"]http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/candidates/[/url]

Posted

I was thinking of the very recent polling in Iowa, which shows Huckabee in the lead in the Republican Party (a major shift has taken place since the polls you cited) and Obama in the lead in the Democratic party (though within the margin of error)... Hillary has even started lashing out against Obama in what appears to be desperation, as she no longer seems as untouchable as she once did. The polls you cite are still behind the latest changes, I believe, and I think the rest of the nation will shortly follow this trend:
[url="http://www.katc.com/global/story.asp?s=7438680"]http://www.katc.com/global/story.asp?s=7438680[/url]

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 09:17 PM']Sin is a consequence of true freedom, of course it is not a freedom in itself; my statements have been clear and philosophically nuanced, yet you refuse to listen.[/quote]

Sin is a consequence of rebellion against and a rejection of God, not freedom. True Freedom is Christ, sin is by no means freedom it is slavery to Satan. Your statements have also been emotionally charged. Accusing me of things I did not state.


[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 09:17 PM']Ron Paul is not talking moral philosophy here, but political philosophy, and on it he is absolutely in sync with Aquinas who suggested that just as God tolerates evil for the sake of free will, a government ought to tolerate evil for the sake of freedom (this is the "freedom" which he talks about).[/quote]


Ron Paul being in line with Aquinas should not be our only concern but, the full teaching of Holy Mother Church which includes the current Magisterium. Which would not tolerate and in fact would oppose any decriminalization of prostitution, on the federal or state level. It is also not wise to separate moral philosophy, from political philosophy to many do that now. Great evils such as prostitution are cancers to freedom, and poison to society. Evil should not be tolerated by the government which duty is to protect society.


"Furthermore, whatever is opposed to life itself, such as any type of murder, genocide... whatever violates the integrity of the human person, such as mutilation, torments inflicted on body or mind, attempts to coerce the will itself; whatever insults human dignity, such as subhuman living conditions, arbitrary imprisonment, deportation, slavery, [b]prostitution[/b], the selling of women and children; as well as disgraceful working conditions...; all these things and others of their like are infamies indeed. [b]They poison human society[/b], but they do more harm to those who practice them than those who suffer from the injury. Moreover, they are a supreme dishonor to the Creator."

- Pastoral Constitution on the Modern World, Second Vatican Council.

The only thing more degrading to women than prostitution is abortion. The decriminalization of prostitution will do nothing but harm women and children.

[quote]Janice Raymond of the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women International wrote an article some years ago giving 10 Reasons for Not Legalizing Prostitution. [url="http://www.rapereliefshelter.bc.ca/issues/prostitution_legalizing.html"]The article[/url] gives arguments under the following headings:[list=1]
[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution is a gift to pimps, traffickers and the sex industry.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution and the sex industry promotes sex trafficking.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution does not control the sex industry. It expands it.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution increases clandestine, hidden, illegal and street prostitution.

[*]Legalization of prostitution and decriminalization of the sex Industry increases child prostitution.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution does not protect the women in prostitution.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution increases the demand for prostitution. It boosts the motivation of men to buy women for sex in a much wider and more permissible range of socially acceptable settings.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution does not promote women's health.

[*]Legalization/decriminalization of prostitution does not enhance women's choice.

[*]Women in systems of Prostitution do not want the sex industry legalized or decriminalized.
[/list][url="http://the-hermeneutic-of-continuity.blogspot.com/2007/11/should-brothels-be-legalised.html"]Source[/url][/quote]






[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 09:17 PM']The question of where to draw the line becomes a question of which evils ought to be considered civil crimes and which evils ought to not be considered civil crimes... the Church leaves open the possibility that prostitution not be considered a civil crime; though pedophilia certainly ought to be a civil crime.[/quote]

Perhaps the Church in the past left open the possibility that prostitution not be considered a civil crime. But it is clear She does not to so now. She teaches that governments have the duty to protect society from harm, and that prostitution is poison against society, namely women.




[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 09:17 PM']But Ron Paul's position doesn't even go this far into it, it simply says that the federal government should not say one thing or the other on the issue, as it is a matter for states to decide; which, of course, any Catholic ought to support because we're supposed to support things being done on lower levels based on the principal of subsidarity; and seeing as this is not something considered to definitively be a civil crime according to Catholic Teaching, there is therefore absolutely no justification in Catholic Teaching for spreading the criminalization of it through centralized big government.[/quote]

Ron Pauls position prostitution goes further than the federal goverment. He [url="http://blog.washingtonpost.com/sleuth/2007/05/do_tell_ron_paul_on_babies_pro.html"]"would essentially have no restrictions, certainly on the federal level..." [/url]

Which means that he would not oppose states that chose to decriminalize prostitution, which would not be in line with the current teaching of Mother Church, which is again to protect society from poisons such as prostitution.






[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 09:17 PM']pedophilia is considered a civil crime because it is an assault of one party against another. prostitution is not considered a civil crime because it is the choice of two people with free will to engage in a sexual sin; the government has no place attempting to stop consensual sexual sins through legislation, and there is absolutely no justification in Catholic teaching for the government to play such a role. it may only play the role of stopping assaults; and it may define that a minor is by definition considered assaulted because they are not of the legal age where they are considered on an equal playing field to give consent.[/quote]

Again the Catholic Church teaches that prostitution is poison to society, and it is the duty of government to protect society, that is justification. The Pope and vast marjory of bishops would oppose any decriminalization of prostitution on these grounds.

As for "legal age" if this also where left up to the states, and why not if prostitution is it would differ in each. In some it could even be possible in time that a 15yr could legally be a prostitute. Such a thing can not be aloud to happen.

Big government is a problem but we do not have to sacrifice the goodwill of American society and decriminalize prostitution in the fight against it.


[quote name='Aloysius' post='1428842' date='Dec 3 2007, 09:17 PM']Again, I'd ask for you to show, based on an actual quote of Ron Paul, where he differs from Aquinas's position. I have not seen that, all I have seen is an attempt to smear him by associating him with prostitutes.[/quote]

Again it is not the meer association that is the problem. As you have shown Christ associated with prostitutes. However Christ did not and does not call their sin a "freedom" as does Ron Paul, Christ calls such sin slavery to Satan.

Another difference, Christ called His associates to repeat and be free. Ron Paul however does not, and calls their sin freedom and [url="http://blog.washingtonpost.com/sleuth/2007/05/do_tell_ron_paul_on_babies_pro.html"]"would essentially have no restrictions" [/url] . And Aquinas chased out prostitutes with a torch, but Ron Paul seemly, gladly takes their money. Ron Paul should the right thing and at least return the money that has been given to him by brothels, and prostitutes.

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

moral theology 101: a consequence of free will is the potentiality for sin. rebellion against God? possible as a consequence of free will. that is how you take your free will and lead yourself into true slavery to sin, yes, but the reason you can do that is because you have free will to begin with.

your quote from Vatican II calls them a poison to society, as Aquinas did. that does not follow that they should be illegalized, however. Ron Paul, myself, and St. Thomas Aquinas all oppose the sin of prostitution; where your logic fails is when you begin to see me, or Ron Paul, as supporting the act just because they do not want the government to go around fighting it. So Ron Paul should want them to repent? I'm sure he does, he's a Christian man himself. But wanting them to repent and wanting to throw them in jail are two different things, he'd want the former (not coerced by the government he would represent as president, though) but not the latter.

if the Church is so up in arms supporting the illegalization of prostitution, someone needs to reign this bishop in: [url="http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/246070/Bishop_backs_brothel_regulation_in_Portsouth_England"]http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/2460...tsmouth_England[/url]

as it stands: that is a legitimate position possible for a Catholic to hold according to the Magisterium of the Church. Show me where the Magisterium indicates that it absolutely must be made illegal, and I'll throw my support to their current temporal initiative the way I have a tenuous support of their current temporal initiative to end the death penalty though I have a more nuanced and potentially pro-death penalty view than some. I don't see the Church saying that though. She repeats that it is a sin, but does not advise on whether it should be criminalized or not; and much of her teaching about government throughout history indicates that it is good to not criminalize it.

he calls them having the option open a freedom, and it is: it is a political/civil freedom (not a moral freedom). it is the temporal government mimicking the Divine government by allowing freedom the way God allows free will.

you're engaging in a ridiculous smear campaign, and I stand by my charge that this is calumny of the clearest order.

Posted

Mini-hijack: I wish everyone reading this thread would take a moment to say a prayer for every soul entrapped in Nevada's legal houses of prostitution. I once read the blog of a young lady who at one time belonged to one of them. They are dens of unspeakable human suffering, "regulated" though they are.

Amsterdam has legalized prostitution. Many people know that, but they say it doesn't really hit home until you stroll down the streets, which are lined on both sides with store windows in which girls in lingerie pose or dance, waiting for a buyer. Then you get to watch the men haggling for a price, going in, and the curtain dropping over the window.

You can bet if they tried to install something similar, in, say, Chicago, Cardinal George would "clarify" the modern Catholic position on the flesh trade in a hurry.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...