Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I know, I know, there have been and will be many election threads as we get closer to primaries and to the final election. I just need some advice.

I will be turning 18 this March, and therefore will be able to vote. I havent really cared much about the issues, but I've realized how important it is for me, as well as my generation, to vote. As a young Catholic, what issues do I need to be looking for? Obviously, abortion is one. I am somewhat liberal on some issues, but very conservative on others. However, I want to make sure that everything I support is in line with the Church.

What do I need to know? Is there a good (catholic) website that will tell me all this?

sorry for seeming naive.

Thanks pham!
Chelsea

Posted

Well, there are considered to be five non-negotiables, which are abortion, euthanasia, marriage, cloning, and stem cells.

This should also be referenced:

[url="http://www.usccb.org/bishops/FCStatement.pdf"]http://www.usccb.org/bishops/FCStatement.pdf[/url]

elizabeth_jane
Posted

I second Norseman's suggestions. The five non-negotiables are what they are--non-negotiable! :)

I work in politics and even I'm having a hard time deciding who to support in this election...sigh.

Posted

I know about those 5 issues, but what i really need to know about are the other big ones. Welfare, health care, etc...

Posted

[quote name='chelsea' post='1430512' date='Dec 6 2007, 10:56 PM']I know about those 5 issues, but what i really need to know about are the other big ones. Welfare, health care, etc...[/quote]
As far as I know the Church permits your personal conscience on those, however you may not vote on them over the five non-negotiables, obviously.

I have yet to determine whom I'll be voting for this election cycle. I won't be voting at all if its Gulliani vs. Hillary.

Posted

what candidates are acceptable to vote for in the eyes of the church? aka who follows the 5 non-negotiables?

Posted

[quote name='chelsea' post='1430516' date='Dec 6 2007, 11:17 PM']what candidates are acceptable to vote for in the eyes of the church? aka who follows the 5 non-negotiables?[/quote]
Out of the front runners there's Romney(barely), Huckabee, and Thompson. To my knowledge none of the Democratic candidates follow the non-negotiables.

Posted

Gullaini doesn't follow the non-negotiables, btw.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1430515' date='Dec 6 2007, 09:13 AM']As far as I know the Church permits your personal conscience on those, however you may not vote on them over the five non-negotiables, obviously.

I have yet to determine whom I'll be voting for this election cycle. I won't be voting at all if its Gulliani vs. Hillary.[/quote]

Yes, the other "social justice" issues are up to you - following the 5 non-negotiables.

As for Rudy v Hill... Rudy has consistently said that he is personally pro-choice. He has also consistently said that legislation belongs in the legislature and not the judiciary and, therefor, Roe v Wade is inherently flawed. He would continue to appoint justices that rule by the US Constitution, the Supreme Court overturing Roe v Wade and support our elected representatives taking up the issue (as it should have happened). Rudy has further said that he would sign whatever Congress decided to go with as far as abortion legislation, and enforce it.

Rudy is kinda the opposite of John Kerry (who always supported Roe v Wade but tried to tell us how personally pro-life he was).

Because Rudy supports the course that I as a pro-life advocate support, I would have no problem voting for him.

  • 5 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1430515' date='Dec 6 2007, 08:13 AM']As far as I know the Church permits your personal conscience on those, however you may not vote on them over the five non-negotiables, obviously.

I have yet to determine whom I'll be voting for this election cycle. I won't be voting at all if its Gulliani vs. Hillary.[/quote]
but you have to vote, right? :unsure:

my parents have said that they'll vote for anyone to make sure Hillary isn't president. they probably won't WANT to vote for them, but the lesser of two evils, I guess.

Posted

i agree with your parents.

if it ends up giuliani vs hilary i will still be voting GOP, because it could mean the difference between a strict and a loose interpretation in the Supreme Court when the chance arises to overturn Roe v. Wade.

Posted

Well I'm a politician and I don't know who i'm going to vote for yet.... I have no affinity for any Republican. I must say that I was impressed with John Edwards speech last night although I wouldn't vote for him.

I have always supported Thompson, but I doubt he'll get the nomination. In my humble opinion the most electable republican is John McCain.

Posted

Here's my beef.

I don't understand why the "5 non-negotiables" take precident over other issues. Who is to say that a candidate's stance on euthanasia is more important than his/her stance on healthcare or taxes or foreign policy? I understand that it shows that the candidate's moral conscience is out of whack to some degree, but it seems like saying "Look, if a candidate has all 5 of these things in line, you've got to vote for him/her, regardless of whether or not you agree with the rest of their stances." For instance, I deplore Hillary, and find John Edwards to be condecending; however, I find their some of their populist stances (i.e.- healthcare, relieving tax burdens from the middle class, etc.) as well as their more progressive foreign policy positions (i.e.- returning America's prestige through diplomacy, agressively-subsidizing research to get us off of oil and, thus, chipping away at the controlling-mechanism that the Middle East has over us, etc) agreeable. Further, if it comes down to a pro-choice GOP candidate (Giuliani) and a pro-choice Democratic candidate (Obama?), I can see myself being wooed by our brothers and sisters in blue. I have said that I am socially conservative, but open to discussion in terms of domestic and foreign policy.

Any thoughts?

Posted

Question, as a first time voter and young Catholic:

What happens to us if we do vote for a candidate with a stance contrary to a non-negotiable? To what extent do we have primacy of conscience over this? If it does come down to both pro-choice candidates, will I be in mortal sin if I vote? Can I receive absolution in such a scenario?

Spell it out in small words for me, please. ;)

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1442269' date='Jan 5 2008, 01:06 AM']What happens to us if we do vote for a candidate with a stance contrary to a non-negotiable? To what extent do we have primacy of conscience over this? If it does come down to both pro-choice candidates, will I be in mortal sin if I vote? Can I receive absolution in such a scenario?[/quote]

Word. What's the Church's stance on this?

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1442269' date='Jan 5 2008, 01:06 AM']What happens to us if we do vote for a candidate with a stance contrary to a non-negotiable? To what extent do we have primacy of conscience over this? If it does come down to both pro-choice candidates, will I be in mortal sin if I vote? Can I receive absolution in such a scenario?[/quote]

Word. What's the Church's stance on this?

Posted (edited)

My understanding is as follows:

Short answer, you can't ideally vote for someone contrary to the five-non-negotiables.

However, you may vote for the lesser of two evils.

There are five non-negotiables, but abortion is the biggest one. It's either abortion or just general defense of the unborn (which would include ESCR and abortifacient birth control as part of the #1 issue). Anyways, if you choose to vote for the lesser of two evils, it may be because the lesser of two evils will at least defend the unborn more than the other guy.

Also, the 5 non-negotiables are intrinsic evils, wrong in all cases. You may, for example, think that taxes are way too high and I would agree with you, but Catholics are allowed to favor tax hikes. Same thing with foreign policy, health care, etc. The Catholic Church does not require us to have a specific opinion on these issues.

Edited by XIX
goldenchild17
Posted

I understand the concern there is in deciding between two top candidates and the morality of choosing one over the other, even if they are both less than desirable. That is something to seriously think about. What I don't get is why we are even really discussing this now. Right now this is not an either or scenario. Granted, some have more momentum right now than others, but no one has won the candidacy from either side as of yet. Why not concentrate on voting for who you want to win the election, who you think is the most in line with Catholic teaching and leave the decision between less desirable candidates for another time, should it even arise as a problem. To me, it's thinking like this that generates the lesser of two evils type of elections in the first place, because people won't just vote for who they believe should win, instead voting for the one who is the "best" out of only those who are deemed "electable." Vote for the best and let the rest play out as the days and weeks and months pass.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1430519' date='Dec 6 2007, 08:32 AM']Out of the front runners there's Romney(barely), Huckabee, and Thompson. To my knowledge none of the Democratic candidates follow the non-negotiables.[/quote]

What about Paul and McCain?

Posted

Everyone who want an anti-abortion person in office should be throwing their support behind Huckabee or Ron Paul. This is because these two guys (especially Huckabee) are the only two who have any shot at all of a unified Evangelical backing against the Dems. If any other Republican wins the front-running position, there will be a divided Evangelical vote against a unified Dem vote.

JMO

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...