KnightofChrist Posted December 6, 2007 Posted December 6, 2007 It is...Our will that Catholics should abstain from certain appellations which have recently been brought into use to distinguish one group of Catholics from another. They are to be avoided not only as "profane novelties of words," out of harmony with both truth and justice, but also because they give rise to great trouble and confusion among Catholics. Such is the nature of Catholicism that it does not admit of more or less, but must be held as a whole or as a whole rejected: "This is the Catholic faith, which unless a man believe faithfully and firmly; he cannot be saved" (Athanas. Creed). There is no need of adding any qualifying terms to the profession of Catholicism: it is quite enough for each one to proclaim "Christian is my name and Catholic my surname," only let him endeavour to be in reality what he calls himself. [Pope Benedict XV: Encyclical Letter Ad Beatissimi Apostolorum 24 (c. 1914)]
Brigid Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 what other labels is he talking about? I just need a few examples...
Didymus Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 (edited) liberal, conservative, cafeteria, etc. is that what hes referring to? Edited January 5, 2008 by Didymus
HotRod Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 Traditional Catholic, Novus Ordo Catholic, those are the two jumping into my mind. Although i've never met anyone who refered to themselves a a novus ordo Catholic.
Brigid Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 [quote name='Didymus' post='1442234' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:06 PM']liberal, conservative, cafeteria, etc. is that what hes referring to?[/quote] that makes sense. [quote name='HotRod' post='1442241' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:14 PM']Traditional Catholic, Novus Ordo Catholic, those are the two jumping into my mind. Although i've never met anyone who refered to themselves a a novus ordo Catholic.[/quote] that makes sense, too. thank you.
Veritas Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 [quote name='HotRod' post='1442241' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:14 PM']Traditional Catholic, Novus Ordo Catholic, those are the two jumping into my mind. Although i've never met anyone who refered to themselves a a novus ordo Catholic.[/quote] + NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.
Adrestia Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 [quote name='Veritas' post='1442252' date='Jan 4 2008, 10:35 PM']+ NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.[/quote] "Novus Ordo" is a rite?
Vincent Vega Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 [quote name='Veritas' post='1442252' date='Jan 5 2008, 12:35 AM']+ NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.[/quote] Thanks for the historical context and the Pontifical clarification. My brain tacked on the extra I unwillingly Pax Christi, Mitch
Brigid Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 [quote name='Veritas' post='1442252' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:35 PM']+ NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.[/quote] Oh. that makes much more sense. I definitely didn't look closely at that.
Didymus Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 i saw that it was #15, but i figured it could still apply to terms such as "cafeteria catholic"
XIX Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Veritas' post='1442252' date='Jan 5 2008, 12:35 AM']+ NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.[/quote] Thanks for the context. It definitely helps. I do think that the B15 quote applies today. While he was no doubt referring to an early-nineteenth century phenomenon, he did not specifically say what he was referring too. He made a blanket statement--"Catholic is Catholic--period." Look at the quote carefully, and I think you will see that his explanation could just as easily be used to refute today's use of the terms "liberal/conservative Catholic." I think he was throwing those terms under the bus as well, including a few others that we use. I mean, why create divisions within the Catholic Church? Isn't division part of what caused schisms and Protestant denominations to begin with? Edited January 5, 2008 by XIX
qfnol31 Posted January 6, 2008 Posted January 6, 2008 The time in which Pope Benedict XV wrote this would have been an interesting (and kind of weird) time in theology. I think we should try to find out exactly what the quote refers to before we try to say that it is relevant to today. E.g., Latin Catholic is very appropriate, as is Byzantine, etc.
Dismas Posted January 6, 2008 Posted January 6, 2008 [quote name='HotRod' post='1442241' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:14 PM']Traditional Catholic, Novus Ordo Catholic, those are the two jumping into my mind. Although i've never met anyone who refered to themselves a a novus ordo Catholic.[/quote] Generally the term "Novus Ordo" is used almost exclusively by Traditional Catholics in reference to the Mass of Paul VI, and sometimes as a derogative. Many Catholics who practice according to the Novus Ordo would not have a clue of what you are talking about when you use that term.
Dismas Posted January 6, 2008 Posted January 6, 2008 [quote name='Veritas' post='1442252' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:35 PM']+ NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.[/quote] Liberal and Conservative did not have the same meanings as they do now. Today's liberal would have been labeled as a Bolshevik, and maybe just maybe a Progressive. Today's Conservative would be considered anything from a Liberal (now called Classical Liberal) to a Protestant to an Average Joe Catholic.
Catholictothecore Posted January 6, 2008 Posted January 6, 2008 (edited) [quote name='HotRod' post='1442241' date='Jan 4 2008, 11:14 PM']Traditional Catholic, Novus Ordo Catholic, those are the two jumping into my mind. Although i've never met anyone who refered to themselves a a novus ordo Catholic.[/quote] Here's the thing, though. To be truly Catholic is to be traditional. To be truly traditional is not to be puritanical. ok, to little words for to strong a message. What I mean is that if you are Catholic, you are part of the Church, WHICH IS THE BODY OF JESUS CHRIST. It is unchanging because He is unchanging. That's why we call it the Communion of Saints. We are all one. It makes me sad to realize how much wanting to have "modern" things, such as women priests, gay marriage, and other impossible stakes claimed in the name of false equality, really do strike and the Heart of Christ. And, so, really, not just these things. They are the symptom. Personally, it makes me humbled. I have done my share in sinning in this world. BUT THANK GOD THAT HE IS THE WAY, THE TRUTH, AND THE LIFE! And He comes to make all things new! Edited January 6, 2008 by Catholictothecore
Veritas Posted January 6, 2008 Posted January 6, 2008 [quote name='Dismas' post='1442593' date='Jan 6 2008, 12:22 AM']Liberal and Conservative did not have the same meanings as they do now. Today's liberal would have been labeled as a Bolshevik, and maybe just maybe a Progressive. Today's Conservative would be considered anything from a Liberal (now called Classical Liberal) to a Protestant to an Average Joe Catholic.[/quote] + True, and in Europe, these terms still have very different meanings! The word "liberal" for example is much different in the states.
Socrates Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 [quote name='Veritas' post='1442252' date='Jan 5 2008, 12:35 AM']+ NB, this is from Pope Benedict XV, NOT (caps for clarity) Pope Benedict XVI previously Cardinal Ratzinger. This came out in 1914. The label "Cafeteria Catholic" did not exist then, neither did the "Novus Ordo" because, quite simply, there was no Novus Ordo rite. Of course the political terms "liberal and conservative" existed then, but I cannot vouch for whether or not they were misapplied to religious infidelity or fidelity as they are now. I find it more likely that he was referring to national alliances granted the proximity of this letter to WWI. Just a few thoughts.[/quote] True. Probably referring to the extreme nationalism characteristic of that time - "American Catholic" or "Irish Catholic," "German Catholic," etc. It can't be used as a blanket statement, because such terms as "Latin Rite Catholic" and "Byzantine Catholic" are perfectly legitimate (so long as one does not imply the other rites are not valid).
EJames2 Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 a semi-relevant reflection "The reality is that liberal Catholics always seemed to want the Catholic Church to be something other than she is. Thus the incessant use of two-church language—the pre-Vatican II Church and the post-Vatican II Church. Those in the ascendancy since the election of John Paul want the Church to be what she is, except more so. Some call themselves “John Paul II Catholics,” and now “Benedict XVI Catholics.” But that can sometimes smack of party spirit. Better is the response of the abovementioned Cardinal George when he became archbishop of Chicago ten years ago. Reporters pressed and pressed to get him to say whether he was a liberal or a conservative. In response, George pointed out that Catholicism is necessarily conservative in preserving the fullness of tradition and necessarily liberal in its generous understanding of human frailty and eagerness to share the faith with others. “If you need a word to describe me,” he said, “just call me Catholic.” That will do nicely."- from First Things Magazine,PUBLIC SQUARE.-Fr.Richard John Neuhaus
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now