Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Attack! Attack!


Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If it is your house, tell him kindly you will NOT discuss religiou with him. Do not go off and pray about it. It simply makes him think the truth is a matter of him convincing you of his version of whatever denomination he attends and the attecks will continue and gives him time to prepare the onslaught Hie feelings are telling him he is right. Instead you need to explain [ once] that the Church has been teaching the same truth for 2000 years, its older than the bible and you can lend him some books [ or direct him HERE :)]. Then shut up. He cannot unless he is totally rude have an argument by himself.

If it is his house, simply make a point by your absence in the future. When inquiring minds want a reason tell he you prayed about it and God told you it was wrong to be in the presence of unbelievers and have your sister tell her brother to back off for the sake of family peace and simple GOOD MANNERS!
He is beling incredibily rude.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If it is your house, tell him kindly you will NOT discuss religiou with him. Do not go off and pray about it. It simply makes him think the truth is a matter of him convincing you of his version of whatever denomination he attends and the attecks will continue and gives him time to prepare the onslaught Hie feelings are telling him he is right. Instead you need to explain [ once] that the Church has been teaching the same truth for 2000 years, its older than the bible and you can lend him some books [ or direct him HERE :)]. Then shut up. He cannot unless he is totally rude have an argument by himself.

If it is his house, simply make a point by your absence in the future. When inquiring minds want a reason tell he you prayed about it and God told you it was wrong to be in the presence of unbelievers and have your sister tell her brother to back off for the sake of family peace and simple GOOD MANNERS!
He is beling incredibily rude.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1431110' date='Dec 8 2007, 03:30 AM']i know this is long - sorry...

my brother-in-law, has a game he often likes to play called "let's attack the faith of the only Catholic I happen to know." The game takes on various forms, but usually involves running down a hit-list card i am convinced he must carry in his pocket of generalizations/attacks to use when talking at Catholics.

i try my best never to get into discussions with him about the Church - arguing goes nowhere, and that's not apologetics in my book.

He, though, is always trying to push buttons.[/quote]

Sounds like he needs more hobbies. :huh:


[quote]After he presented his, "Ha! There! i just read it on the internet" position, i was like, "well, if that's the source you want to believe, okay - i am not a Greek scholar, and i have never read the original Greek." He was like, "Me neither, but i have read the Bible!" Seeing i wasn't going to argue with him, he got upset and said, "You can't just say things like you did at the table as if it's something that's true! [b] You're never going to get anyone to become Christian if you're so hard on things like that!"[/b]i said, "Thank you for the criticism," and went down to my room.[/quote]

He won't win many people over with his brash attitude either.

[quote]Well, after a minute or two, he followed me down, and continued the attack. He took my laptop, googled "Jesus' brothers,"[b] skipped the EWTN article that was at the top of the list[/b], and opened the website that backed his point. Before he even started the second attack, i had told him i'm not a good apologist; he shouldn't come to me about them because it's never worked in the past. He just wouldn't stop, though: i put the Church ahead of God; [b]God speaks directly to him; [/b]the Church has been wrong in the past; it makes more sense to him for Jesus to have brothers... i did the best i could, but kept asking him to stop, and if he had honest questions, to go to someone else who actually has training in theology.[/quote]

Woah, woah, woah! Holllllld on. He skipped EWTNs because it didn't agree with his point. Nice, real nice. Way to actually debate. :wacko:

Oh God talks directly to him huh? Okay then, God talked to me, told me hes wrong. That seems to be his logic, if there is any.

I would have way more respect for this dude if he wasn't picking on a teenager who is still learning about their faith. :boxer:

Edited by Luthien
Posted

just had another idea...

Suggest a quick little vacation at the beach!!! I put a queen size bed in the guest room so the entire family can sleep comfortably while I explain things to your favorite bro-in-law.

It's 70 degrees today! You could go surfing! You know you want to...

Besides, why would Jesus on the cross give his mother to some other guy if He had a bunch of siblings ready to take care of their momma?

SaintOfVirtue
Posted

I say if uses google you use google, fight fire with fire.

not being able "think on your feet"? That problem is easily solved. I somtimes have the same problem but what I do is this: When I finally think of what to say I tell them "You know that debate we were having the other day, well I've been thinking...." and put in whatever you researched or thought of. keep calling him when he skips the Catholic websites; make him go to those sites.

also check out the apologetic flash cards at [url="http://www.friendlydefenders.com/info_uses.htm"]http://www.friendlydefenders.com/info_uses.htm[/url] they may seem childish but they asnwer a lot of questions and back it up with scriptoral evidence as well as with Catechism of the Catholic Church.

[center]hope this helps[/center]

Posted

My favorite tactic is to turn the tables and ask the harasser to show where "sola scriptura" is in the Bible.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1431182' date='Dec 8 2007, 02:22 AM']i know what you are going through! but you are not letting Mother Church down by being a good example of meekness and humility, instead of erupting in anger and passion. God be with you.[/quote]

To expound on what Lil Red says here, may I offer an example? My father is quite of a similar vein to your brother, though in reaction to Christianity in general. I could compile a great Apologetics work (Given a skill at apologetics and fifty years to spare), and it would matter not to him, for anything I would say would seem biased in his point of view.

He constantly assails my beliefs, and I think, would only intensify them were I to defend a Catholic point of view. I know you are undoubtedly doing this, as you said in your post, but pray for your brother. Sometimes, if the heart of a man is hardened, it can be a Christian's greatest weapon.

Your humility in dealing with him is admirable; your ability to contain any passions is also a wonderful thing.

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1431847' date='Dec 9 2007, 10:32 AM']Besides, why would Jesus on the cross give his mother to some other guy if He had a bunch of siblings ready to take care of their momma?[/quote]

I'd never actually thought of that point. Thanks.

Posted

" Among human beings, who knows what pertains to a person except the spirit of the person that is within? Similarly, no one knows what pertains to God except the Spirit of God.
We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit that is from God, so that we may understand the things freely given us by God.
And we speak about them not with words taught by human wisdom, but with words taught by the Spirit, describing spiritual realities in spiritual terms.
Now the natural person 8 does not accept what pertains to the Spirit of God, for to him it is foolishness, and he cannot understand it, because it is judged spiritually." 1 Corinthians 2:11-13

Pray for they can not understand.

Posted

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1431847' date='Dec 9 2007, 08:32 AM']Besides, why would Jesus on the cross give his mother to some other guy if He had a bunch of siblings ready to take care of their momma?[/quote]

But, I have heard prots say that this was one of Jesus' brothers.

But good point if they believe it wasn't.

Sister Rose Therese
Posted

It doesn't sound like he will really listen even if you had perfect answers for everything. But he seems to feel like he has won the debate when he gets you flustered. Perhaps you could try to calmly listen to his rant. When he is done, summarize his points and write them down. Tell him that you will look into them and you can deal with the issues one by one. If you think he'll listen to you later you could try to talk to him alone. Set an apointment with a time limit and keep it to only one topic. (See if he is serious enough about this to handle that.) If not, talk to someone with some expertise in the subject and see if they'll be willing to do that. Then tell him you have spoken to someone who is eager to speak to him about his issues and was wondering if he were available at such a date to discuss it.
It would be a lot of work, but it might take the wind out his sails.

Posted

Ask him why he was surfing the net instead of praying with you two. Would cure what ails him :D

Posted

It really sounds like your brother in law is seriously angry about something. He may just have a very hardened heart right now. I think your desire to avoid conflict with him at the moment may very well be the Holy Spirit directing you. Jesus wants us to turn the other cheek and sounds like you are doing it. Continue to pray for him, stay calm. This doesn't mean that you need to be a doormat. Just tell him that you don't care for his overly agressive approaches, tell him that out of love for him and your sister this has to stop. When and if he can be calmer and more charitable then you can speak with him. Don't worry about being perfect at apologetics, he should respect your love of Christ, that you definetly [i]can[/i] show him

Praying for you.

Posted

if the problem persists...send him to meet this guy [img]http://i217.photobucket.com/albums/cc183/corban3music/rexkwondo.jpg[/img]

and see how he likes a round house kick to the face

Posted

[quote name='corban711' post='1433155' date='Dec 12 2007, 12:57 AM']if the problem persists...send him to meet this guy [img]http://i217.photobucket.com/albums/cc183/corban3music/rexkwondo.jpg[/img]

and see how he likes a round house kick to the face[/quote]
just break the wrist, walk away. Just break the wrist, walk away.

Posted

[quote name='corban711' post='1433155' date='Dec 12 2007, 12:57 AM']if the problem persists...send him to meet this guy [img]http://i217.photobucket.com/albums/cc183/corban3music/rexkwondo.jpg[/img]

and see how he likes a round house kick to the face[/quote]I dunno. Oswald of the Drew Carey show is pretty darn thick. I don't think he'd know how to respond, even with those awesome puff pants and that radical bandanna.

Posted

I'm not sure I'd go so far as to say he's letting down the Church. "Be ye angry, and sin not: let not the sun go down upon your wrath." (Eph. 4:26) People are bound to ruffle one another's feathers sometimes. It also must be said that it has something to do with how the other person approached him, as well. It's one thing to debate in a friendly way. It's another to sort of appoint oneself the religion police and badger someone with, "Why don't you do this? Why don't you do that?" Reasonable and well-defined general statements may sometimes be useful in debates. Unreasonable, sweeping ones are not. If the person is putting him on the spot and is asking him to answer for "the church," that's a little much right there. I'd just agree to disagree.

Posted

Your brother in law would be known, in academic circles, as a butthole. There are, of course, other terms.

Since he's not interested in discussion, you may defuse him by agreeing with him or coming up with even more outrageous claims. Admit to a conspiracy to subvert the kingdom of God through good deeds, incense and fancy clothes. Don't show him the slightest bit of irritation or respect. Treat him and the conversation like the lark that it is. He will eventually tire of this game, if you are more clever than he, and perhaps become an astronaut, busboy or something useful.

Alternatively, you could require him to get a job and pay you rent for sleeping on your couch.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

i wish i'd had time before now to check back on this - thank you all so much for your comments - at the very least, i haven't laughed this hard in quite a while! you guys rock.

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1431310' date='Dec 8 2007, 08:29 AM']He knows [i]two[/i] Catholics... and this one doesn't know how to keep her mouth shut.

How far a drive is it? Maybe it's time for another visit. :teach:[/quote]

Less than two days!

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1431847' date='Dec 9 2007, 08:32 AM']just had another idea...

Suggest a quick little vacation at the beach!!! I put a queen size bed in the guest room so the entire family can sleep comfortably while I explain things to your favorite bro-in-law.

It's 70 degrees today! You could go surfing! You know you want to...[/quote]

you know i do want to; or you could come here and go skiing - it's 20 degrees today!

[quote name='Sister Rose Therese' post='1433084' date='Dec 11 2007, 09:40 PM']It doesn't sound like he will really listen even if you had perfect answers for everything. But he seems to feel like he has won the debate when he gets you flustered. Perhaps you could try to calmly listen to his rant. When he is done, summarize his points and write them down. Tell him that you will look into them and you can deal with the issues one by one. If you think he'll listen to you later you could try to talk to him alone. Set an apointment with a time limit and keep it to only one topic. (See if he is serious enough about this to handle that.) If not, talk to someone with some expertise in the subject and see if they'll be willing to do that. Then tell him you have spoken to someone who is eager to speak to him about his issues and was wondering if he were available at such a date to discuss it.
It would be a lot of work, but it might take the wind out his sails.[/quote]

thank you so much for this approach - i will try it next time he's on the attack. maybe it will work, although he kept saying he doesn't have any questions about the Church - he's just trying to help me see the errors of the Church i belong to.

[quote name='Winchester' post='1433425' date='Dec 12 2007, 04:17 PM']Your brother in law would be known, in academic circles, as a butthole. There are, of course, other terms.

Since he's not interested in discussion, you may defuse him by agreeing with him or coming up with even more outrageous claims. Admit to a conspiracy to subvert the kingdom of God through good deeds, incense and fancy clothes. Don't show him the slightest bit of irritation or respect. Treat him and the conversation like the lark that it is. He will eventually tire of this game, if you are more clever than he, and perhaps become an astronaut, busboy or something useful.[/quote]

i really like this one too, although i am not sure if it is the most charitable; i was taught that sarcasm is a sign of insecurity... it would be the more entertaining option, though!

Anyway, thank you guys so much for all of your comments. we'll see how it goes next time.

Posted

I would not take that kind of behavior! If someone's going to be that rude I would just say, "sorry, but I don't think you really want answers from me, you just want to argue." Then I'd be done with it. :P

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...