Autumn Dusk Posted December 8, 2007 Posted December 8, 2007 My roommate is protestant. She says that the Bible is everything, that it holds all knowledge, is the voice of God to every person of every time. Anything derived from the Bible is "nice" but not necessary for faith. I say that the Bible is the cornerstone of faith. Its the cornerstone of faith. It has been given to us humanly written down for a certain people of a certain time, divinely inspired and meant to be interpreted with much guidance.
Justin86 Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1431255' date='Dec 8 2007, 06:15 PM']I say that the Bible is the cornerstone of faith. Its the cornerstone of faith. It has been given to us humanly written down for a certain people of a certain time, divinely inspired and meant to be interpreted with much guidance.[/quote] *applause* Try telling her when you can get the majority of Bible Alone believers to come up with the exact same doctrines maybe then you'll start to consider she might be right.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 Your roomie lacks an understanding of history.The bible was not put into final form until the Church was over 400 years old. And all that time the church was preaching and teaching and baptising and burying, handing on the Mass thru the sucessors of St Peter. The Scriptures themselves say the church is the pillar and foundation , it says nothing of a book.
Nathan Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1431587' date='Dec 8 2007, 10:12 PM'][b]Your roomie lacks an understanding of history.[/b] The bible was not put into final form until the Church was over 400 years old. And all that time the church was preaching and teaching and baptising and burying, handing on the Mass thru the sucessors of St Peter. The Scriptures themselves say the church is the pillar and foundation , it says nothing of a book.[/quote] This seems to be the case with the majority of serious Protestants (I would add, the number one [i]reason[/i] for their being Protestant and not Catholic). Their love of Scripture is to be commended, but their knowledge of Christianity as an historical, living-and-breathing faith, is quite lacking.
Autumn Dusk Posted December 9, 2007 Author Posted December 9, 2007 My roommate is all about KJV she says that its the word of God...period and things lost in translation are just that. She also sais the bible has NO contradicitions.
Nathan Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1431616' date='Dec 8 2007, 11:44 PM']My roommate is all about KJV she says that its the word of God...period and things lost in translation are just that. She also sais the bible has NO contradicitions.[/quote] Well, technically the KJV [i]is[/i] the Word of God, and the Bible certainly has no contradictions.
Maggyie Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 I know of quite a number of folks who are KJV-only... which is too bad, since that version has a lot of translation errors.
Nathan Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 Yeah, KJV-Onlyism is pretty sad. Not so much because the translation has a lot of errors -- despite this, I think it's a beautiful piece of work, and the fact that fundamentalist Protestants have "hijacked" from the Anglicans turns a lot of Catholics off of it for the wrong reasons -- but because it's an unfounded and illogical theological position to hold! When you get to the bottom of it, it's actually insane.
Mateo el Feo Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Nathan' post='1431618' date='Dec 8 2007, 11:48 PM']Well, technically the KJV [i]is[/i] the Word of God, and the Bible certainly has no contradictions.[/quote]I'd disagree. The KJV is a [i]translation[/i] of the Word of God, and one that has never been fully approved by that Catholic Church.
Nathan Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1431663' date='Dec 9 2007, 12:14 AM']The KJV is a [i]translation[/i] of the Word of God, and one that has never been fully approved by that Catholic Church.[/quote] True statements. But if the NAB or Douay-Rheims (or any Catholic translation of the Bible) can be said to be "the Word of God" without controversy -- which they can -- then it can also be said of the KJV. The approval of the Catholic Church, while extremely important, has little bearing on this one point. To put it another way, if our priests can read from the NAB -- a translation -- and say "this is the Word of God," then the same can be said of the KJV.
Farsight one Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1431616' date='Dec 8 2007, 10:44 PM']My roommate is all about KJV she says that its the word of God...period and things lost in translation are just that. She also sais the bible has NO contradicitions.[/quote]You might point out that the deuterocanon/apocrypha used to be IN the KJV, and was after some time(not sure how long) removed. That usually throws KJV-only people for a loop as it forces them to realize that even their precious version of the bible has changed as well. Logic is a gift from God, and it always frustrated me when people don't use it. The bible is the word of God, but you certainly need other things to help you understand that word. edit in - always could ask your roommate what their biblical basis for believing KJV only is. They usually quote you a verse from the bible about His holy word being free from error(or something of the like.), but its easy to point out that the verse is in every version, and not just the KJV. Edited December 9, 2007 by Farsight one
rkwright Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Farsight one' post='1431706' date='Dec 8 2007, 11:47 PM']edit in - always could ask your roommate what their biblical basis for believing KJV only is. They usually quote you a verse from the bible about His holy word being free from error(or something of the like.), but its easy to point out that the verse is in every version, and not just the KJV.[/quote] wow... this is just brilliant! I have to say when I read this I was floored! Why had I never thought of this\heard of this argument. When debating the Apocrypha just say the Holy Word is free from error (which it is!)
KnightofChrist Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 The Bible is the written word of God, infallibly written down by divinely inspired men, it contains no errors or contradictions. The words therein are universal and catholic for every generation of every nation, of all time, or at least from when a particular book was written till the end of time. The Bible is just as necessary for the faith as is Sacred Tradition, both complimented the other.
Mateo el Feo Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Nathan' post='1431677' date='Dec 9 2007, 12:29 AM']True statements. But if the NAB or Douay-Rheims (or any Catholic translation of the Bible) can be said to be "the Word of God" without controversy -- which they can -- then it can also be said of the KJV. The approval of the Catholic Church, while extremely important, has little bearing on this one point. To put it another way, if our priests can read from the NAB -- a translation -- and say "this is the Word of God," then the same can be said of the KJV.[/quote]I would disagree with your statement here...or maybe we do agree and I just don't realize it. The approval of the Catholic Church is important for particular translations, just as the approval of a particular New Testament Canon was important way back when. To illustrate my point, things get a bit clearer when we move to translations produced by Jehovah's Witnesses (i.e. New World Translation), the Mormon version of the KJV, or the translation produced by Martin Luther (with the famous addition of "Faith alone" phrase). It is precisely because the Catholic Church rejects these translations that they cannot properly be called the Word of God. Edited December 9, 2007 by Mateo el Feo
Farsight one Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='rkwright' post='1431743' date='Dec 9 2007, 12:06 AM']wow... this is just brilliant! I have to say when I read this I was floored! Why had I never thought of this\heard of this argument.[/quote]Well...thank you, I guess. I find that the simple question "Where is that in the bible?" is FAR underused by Catholics when debating. Half the time they have no answer, and pretty much the rest of the time, they'll provide a bible quote that is really easy to debate. If you don't ask, you don't get a bible quote. And without a bible quote, people are often at a loss as to how to respond to a claim.
st-annes Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1431616' date='Dec 8 2007, 11:44 PM']My roommate is all about KJV she says that its the word of God...period and things lost in translation are just that.[/quote] That's pretty funny. Ask her what was the Word and the absolute truth [i]before[/i] it was printed.
Nathan Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1431780' date='Dec 9 2007, 02:56 AM']I would disagree with your statement here...or maybe we do agree and I just don't realize it. The approval of the Catholic Church is important for particular translations, just as the approval of a particular New Testament Canon was important way back when. To illustrate my point, things get a bit clearer when we move to translations produced by Jehovah's Witnesses (i.e. New World Translation), the Mormon version of the KJV, or the translation produced by Martin Luther (with the famous addition of "Faith alone" phrase). It is precisely because the Catholic Church rejects these translations that they cannot properly be called the Word of God.[/quote] Good point. However, consider the fact that there have been Bible translations that were initially not approved by the Catholic Church and then years later suddenly approved. The Old Testament of the Revised Standard Version, for instance, is a Protestant translation and was used by Protestants for a long time in the "limbo" period before it was approved by the Catholic Church. Now, when the Catholic Church approved the RSV as a whole with its Catholic Edition, the revisions were limited to a few minor problem areas in the New Testament -- the Old Testament text was left untouched. So the RSV Old Testament that Protestants used for years previously and the RSV Old Testament that Catholics used after its approval is 100% the same text. But if the approved RSV Old Testament is the Word of God -- and I think we both agree on this -- then how could the RSV Old Testament not be the Word of God? For they are the exact same text.
Autumn Dusk Posted December 9, 2007 Author Posted December 9, 2007 [quote]The Bible is the written word of God, infallibly written down by divinely inspired men, it contains no errors or contradictions. The words therein are universal and catholic for every generation of every nation, of all time, or at least from when a particular book was written till the end of time. The Bible is just as necessary for the faith as is Sacred Tradition, both complimented the other.[/quote] See that boarders along the lines of what she was saying. What I have learned is the bible is the written word of God, divinely inspired (though not infallible). They were written for a certain generation of a certain time but apply to us now. That it is necessary for faith, it is the cornerstone, but it is part of a much bigger picture that MUST be taken into account. It is not the end-all-be-all. I still maintain that the Bible has small errors becuase it has been handed down by the hands of men. The reason I talked about KJV is becusae my roommate believes there are infalliable, word for word what God told someone to write....versions of the bible, KJV being the one but acknowlging other bibles may be "useful" My point about that was the only words that God ever inscribed that a human copied were the Ten Commandments. All other was divinely inspired things written by flawed men, copied by flawed men and translated by flawed men.
Nathan Posted December 9, 2007 Posted December 9, 2007 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1431928' date='Dec 9 2007, 04:27 PM']What I have learned is the bible is the written word of God, divinely inspired ([b]though not infallible[/b]). ... I still maintain that [b]the Bible has small errors[/b] becuase it has been handed down by the hands of men.[/quote] Just know that this is not what the Catholic Church teaches or has ever taught. Perhaps you need to study [i]why[/i] the Catholic Church teaches what she does on these matters. Moreover, you should have a simple faith that the Catholic Church, as Christ's Holy Church, has not been led into error on these matters or any matter of faith. Have some trust that God would not have let that happen! This is part of what being a Catholic, as opposed to being a Protestant, is about. The Magisterium knows better than you do.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now