TheoGrad07 Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1436461' date='Dec 20 2007, 11:28 AM']The Averroists were "Catholics" (sort of) and they were Aristotelians. Thomas might have been an Aristotelian in some sense, but not completely. He was very heavily influenced by Augustine (neo/middle Platonist)-so much by him you could do a whole class on "Thomas the Augustinian"-, also he took some from the East (John Damascene, etc.). Being a Catholic Aristotelian can be very far from Thomism. It can also be very close. I just think that to define Thomism as Catholic Aristotelianism is inaccurate and gives too little credit to either philosopher. I was a philosophy major at this school and sadly the guy who said it was a philosophy professor. [/quote] I agree; I think it is too simplistic to classify Thomas simply as an Aristotelian. He certainly didn't adopt everything Aristotle proposed, nor was Aristotle Thomas' sole source. As far as being a Thomist ... I think often what passes as Thomism is actually neo-Thomism, perhaps because of the influence of neo-scholasticism in the first half of the 20th century. I would say a true Thomist reads Thomas as Thomas, trying to understand his work within the context of the 13th century, avoiding as much as possible the contamination of modern philosophy. Not that there isn't a place for trying to work with Thomas in light of modern philosophy, but I think it should come only after firmly grasping what Thomas was saying when he said it.
TheoGrad07 Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 I should probably clarify: Originally, neo-Thomism was essentially neo-scholasticism: textbook theology specifically rejecting modern philosophy. It was simply "believe this, what Thomas says" because all modern philosophy is evil. However, certain theologians (a professor I had called them "the class of 1904" because many of them were born that year) didn't like the neo-scholastic textbook approach, in part because it was simply listing propositions that must be assented to but was not communicating the tradition in a form accessible to the society. Generally speaking, these theologians proposed reading Thomas in light of modern philosophy and seeking an answer to modern philosophy in his thought. I'm thinking of Rahner, Lonergan, and perhaps de Lubac.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1436073' date='Dec 19 2007, 11:03 AM']LD I had a professor claim he was a Thomist once, but defined it as a "Christian Aristotelian." You can only be a honorary Thomist if that's [b]not[/b] how you define it. [/quote] I don't generally have any problem with people describing a philosophy as "Aristotelian" when it clearly has Aristotle's philosophy as a significant source. If a philosopher's exploration of reality is generally based on Aristotle's logical and ontological axioms, and is marked by such things as hylomorphism, teleology, et cetera, I see nothing wrong with calling it "Aristotelian" in a general sense. In any strict sense there are very few philosophers that I would call Aristotelians; I'm hesitant to call Aristotle an Aristotelian in some respects considering what many people seem to think this term implies. As for Thomas, I consider him to be a theologian and my first choice would not be to label his thought in generic philosophical terms. Yes, Thomas’ metaphysics, ethical theory, epistemology and so forth are obviously Aristotelian in inspiration but anyone who has really studied Aristotle and Thomas will perhaps be struck more by the differences than the similarities; at least this is how I see things. To my mind Thomas is a theologian and Aristotle is primarily a natural philosopher. Sure Aristotle can be said to have a theology, but it is pretty lame and hardly developed. In my opinion this lack of full development is the main cause of difficulties in interpretation that persist to this day (although I say "developed" in reference to the extant corpus; who knows what all the historical Aristotle taught and believed). One might say, yes, but Thomas’ theology is based on Aristotelian foundations. Again, this is true in a qualified and superficial sense, but my point is that Aristotle and Thomas had radically different projects and I think this is an extremely important fact. I also have a problem with this because it suggests that Thomas was a devout little Aristotelian sitting at his master's feet. Not only does this obscure the fact that Thomas was a radically original thinker, but it fails to emphasize the fact that Thomas was really responding to Aristotle more than hanging on his every word. In many respects Thomistic philosophy is a challenge to "pure" Aristotelianism (if one believes in such things) and while Thomas accepted many fundamental insights of Aristotelian thought (the tradition of the time and not necessarily Aristotle himself) he transformed or jettisoned quite a bit. Aristotelian insights are given a radically new context and in this bigger context a lot of things are redefined and some things fall away; how then can he be described as essentially Aristotelian? – In a very qualified way at least. Thomas' Aristotle was really the figment of a tradition stretching back through such men as Porphyry, Proclus, Simplicius, Boethius, Al Farabi, Averroes, the ill attributed [i]Theology of Aristotle[/i], et cetera. I don't think Thomas could have been a "pure" Aristotelian even if he had wanted to. So yeah, I don't really care when people throw around the old Aristotelian label but I prefer not to do so myself unless it is in a thoroughly qualified manner. Although I have found that professors who speak of such things as "Christian Aristotelianism" or "Christian Platonism" mean to refer the broad and often forced traditions of thought that can be categorized based on logical and ontological characteristics as well as some degree of historical continuity. If one were to think of it this way I suppose there is a sense in which Thomas could be situated neatly into this little category of Christian Aristotelianism. I know what people mean by this, but it is not my style, and I would certainly not define Thomism (in the broad sense) as "Christian Aristotelianism" mainly because to my mind Thomism is a school of theology and such a definition is suggestive to me of the limited perspective of a philosopher.
qfnol31 Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 LoL, I don't think his response involved all that when he stated it. I think he just meant to say that all Christian Aristotelians are Thomist. I thought that was silly.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1436618' date='Dec 20 2007, 04:12 PM']LoL, I don't think his response involved all that when he stated it. I think he just meant to say that all Christian Aristotelians are Thomist. I thought that was silly.[/quote] Yeah, I'm sure many a Scotist would resent that statement. haha
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 I don't know much philosophy, but related to your discussion, I remember this by Ralph McInerny in a book I have: [quote]There is an old maxim, passed on by Pico della Mirandola: [i]Sine Thoma, Aristoteles mutus esset[/i]: without Thomas, Aristotle would be silent. The phrase is a signal tribute to the commentaries. But the reverse of the claim is also true, and true throughout Thomas's career: [i]Sine Aristotele, Thomas non esset[/i].[/quote]
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 Ralph McInerny is cool. His books on Thomas are pretty sweet. Gilson is still the king though (IMHO). hehe
Nathan Posted January 4, 2008 Author Posted January 4, 2008 [img]http://godzdogz.op.org/uploaded_images/summagod8ue-755920.jpg[/img] ^ Absolutely amazing. This one volume is Aquinas' natural theology -- [i]philosophy[/i] of God -- [i]par excellence[/i]. For any Catholic who spends any time at all in philosophical discussion with atheists, this is your armor.
Thomist-in-Training Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 I cannot express in words my affection and admiration for St. Thomas. I'm not well-read in him right now, but I did buy a copy of the Prima Pars at Half Price books a few weeks ago--I was thinking of just beginning at the beginning, and so on. I have read a few questions here and there, and done a paper or two for introductory-level theology classes. Next semester is Medieval Phil, though. It should be like a Thomas party!
mortify Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 [url="http://iteadthomam.blogspot.com/"]http://iteadthomam.blogspot.com/[/url]
Innocent Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 Hey, I came across [url="http://www.thesumma.info/reality/index.php"][b]this book[/b][/url] about Thomism today online. I could read it for free online. Do you think it's a good introduction to Thomism for someone who knows next to nothing about Thomism?
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 Most certainly! That book is a classic of 20th century Thomistic studies by one of the big dawgs.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now