goldenchild17 Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 This might be a pretty boring idea for some, but I have a list of books that I plan to get through and I thought I might post the list of books to see if anyone else either had them and/or was interested in reading along and then posting our thoughts on them or something like that. Anyways: Prummer Moral Theology Wilhelm & Scannell, "Manual of Catholic Theology" Hunter, S.J. "Outlines of Dogmatic Theology" Van Noort, "Dogmatic Theology" Pohl-Preuss, "Dogmatic Theology" Berry, "The Church" Mura, "The Nature of the Mystical Body" Glenn, "Apologetics" The papal encyclicals St. Thomas, "Summa Theologica" - transl. by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province I know where I can read Wilhelm and Scannell's work online, but I'm double checking to see if it is the full text or if some of it is missing. I have links to where I can buy most of the other books and depending on cashflow I might be able to get one or two to start. Also, I think New Advent's version of the Summa is the one by the English Dominican Province Fathers (correct me if I'm wrong). I know papalencyclicals.net has a lot of the encyclicals but is it the most exhaustive list online? So I think there's a couple options. I'm think of starting with Wilhelm and Scannell, but if anyone really wants to go through the Summa that would be cool too probably. peace
Lena Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 Wilhelm & Scannell, "Manual of Catholic Theology" where is that one online?
goldenchild17 Posted December 13, 2007 Author Posted December 13, 2007 (edited) Well it's at a site that isn't exactly in-line with Phatmass guidelines, so I'd better not post the link, but it was typed up from a hard-copy by the guy who runs the site who I have a lot of respect for. If anyone wants to read this manual and discuss it here then I can just copy and paste the sections from the manual that we are reading here. That way no one would have to visit the site if they don't like. That's the only site I know of it being at. If it's anywhere else online then people could read from there too. Edited December 13, 2007 by goldenchild17
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 Have a group on here reading the Summa together would be phat! Going through a manual of theology, or maybe something like Denzinger's text would be pretty phat too. Good idea...
goldenchild17 Posted December 13, 2007 Author Posted December 13, 2007 well I'll let this sit for a day or two and see how much interest there is and then whoever wants in can go about getting it organized. Like I said, right now Wilhelm & Scannell and the Summa at New Advent are the only ones I have access too at the moment. I preferred Wilhelm & Scannell to start because I'm not so sure I care to jump into something as intense as the Summa right when I'm starting my break from school. But either would be fine, whichever people want to do. I'll be reading everything on the list eventually so the order isn't particularly crucial.
rkwright Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 (edited) I'd be interested in the Wilhelm & Scannell book... trying to go through the entire summa, online, would be a daunting undertaking. Sounds like a grad course... I do have a request... we need somewhat of a 'teacher' or as my law professors call it, a 'facilitator'. Someone who can guide the discussion. But this person needs a good grounding in the subject we discuss; I would prefer some course work in it? My point: I don't want the blind to lead the blind. Edited December 13, 2007 by rkwright
goldenchild17 Posted December 13, 2007 Author Posted December 13, 2007 I just heard from Mr. Lane (the one who put that text up) that it isn't the full text anyways, so it might take awhile before I can get a full text of one of the manuals on my list. I might have to start with the Summa for now. As for the idea of a facilitator, if that's what you guys want I'm sure you could appoint someone. I don't know how it would work with me though with my differing theological/philosophical viewpoints though. I agree with the need for such a leader, and it might be good for whoever else is following along to have such a person. But I don't know how that would work for me. More ideas to come if I think of any.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1433592' date='Dec 13 2007, 12:20 AM']As for the idea of a facilitator, if that's what you guys want I'm sure you could appoint someone. I don't know how it would work with me though with my differing theological/philosophical viewpoints though. I agree with the need for such a leader, and it might be good for whoever else is following along to have such a person. But I don't know how that would work for me. More ideas to come if I think of any.[/quote] I know you're a sedevacantist and as such a minority on these boards (perhaps you are the only one right now?) but I don't think this should be exaggerated as though we have different religions. We could discuss a classic theology text as Catholics and hopefully leave aside contemporary controversies. I don't see the problem anyway, but I suppose it could be difficult to find a facilitator that everyone would be comfortable with. I guess the important thing would be to keep things on track in a way that is neutral to the Vatican II-Sedevacantist type of issues. I've studied the Summa both on my own and formally in college and I believe I could handle keeping things uncontroversial. I'm tempted to suggest myself as facilitator but then I'm not sure if I'd be an acceptable choice for some and I'm not exactly a Thomist.. Maybe Pio Nono or TheologianInTraining would be interested? Myles comes to mind as well.
rkwright Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1433605' date='Dec 12 2007, 11:37 PM']I know you're a sedevacantist and as such a minority on these boards (perhaps you are the only one right now?) but I don't think this should be exaggerated as though we have different religions. We could discuss a classic theology text as Catholics and hopefully leave aside contemporary controversies. I don't see the problem anyway, but I suppose it could be difficult to find a facilitator that everyone would be comfortable with. I guess the important thing would be to keep things on track in a way that is neutral to the Vatican II-Sedevacantist type of issues. I've studied the Summa both on my own and formally in college and I believe I could handle keeping things uncontroversial. I'm tempted to suggest myself as facilitator but then I'm not sure if I'd be an acceptable choice for some and I'm not exactly a Thomist.. Maybe Pio Nono or TheologianInTraining would be interested? Myles comes to mind as well.[/quote] You were one I had in mind Myles would be a first choice of mine also, but sadly I don't see him quiet as active as he has been in the past. Really talking the Summa though? I'm willing but wow! That seems like a big undertaking. But I'm up for it... I have Kreft's Summa of the Summa, and its helped me along, but honestly I haven't read all of it... goldenchild - it would be no different than taking a class at school, there are many viewpoints to be heard and discussed. Though like L_D I don't see how your present views on the Church would have an impact on the study of the Summa or other books... Just leave it at the door when we discuss
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 [quote name='rkwright' post='1433623' date='Dec 13 2007, 12:55 AM']You were one I had in mind Myles would be a first choice of mine also, but sadly I don't see him quiet as active as he has been in the past. Really talking the Summa though? I'm willing but wow! That seems like a big undertaking. But I'm up for it... I have Kreft's Summa of the Summa, and its helped me along, but honestly I haven't read all of it... goldenchild - it would be no different than taking a class at school, there are many viewpoints to be heard and discussed. Though like L_D I don't see how your present views on the Church would have an impact on the study of the Summa or other books... Just leave it at the door when we discuss[/quote] I have a copy of Kreeft's [i]Summa of the Summa[/i] laying around some place too. Maybe it would be more realistic to go through selections of the Summa rather than trying to tackle the whole thing. We could follow the selections in Kreeft's book and people who don't have this book could read the questions on newadvent (I believe Kreeft uses the same translation). As I recall Kreeft includes lots of footnotes and perhaps one of us who own that book could type out his footnotes as a normal part of the discussion? Just an idea anyway; what do you guys think? I wonder if any of the classic commentaries on the Summa are available online? This would be extremely phat and it would reduce the importance of the facilitator somewhat (if I were the facilitator I would greatly appreciate this believe me) since we could get multiple expert comments on the texts we read.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 This is probably extremely tacky but I must admit that several years ago I bought a collection of Peter Kreeft's books and I read them in the bathroom. Yes, for at least a year I would keep one of Kreeft's books on top of the toilet. The [i]Radio Replies[/i] set is also very good for this sort of thing. I realize this sounds pretty distasteful, but it is actually a pretty good way to read certain types of books. Texts that can be read in small chunks are of course best suited to this. I think I got through the [i]Handbook of Christian Apologetics[/i] in about a month and a half so it is kind of slow going.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now