Guest kkerwin Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 Hi all, I'm in an ongoing discussion with someone over life issues (in this particular case, the death penalty). I've already more than outlined the Catholic teaching specific to the death penalty, but now we're on to a related topic: what is the value of a person based on? Is it extrinsic, that is, based on their contributions to society? Or is it intrinsic, that is, is the person of value simply because they are a living human person? I know what the Catholic Church teaches (that the value of life is intrinsic), but I can't seem to figure out a way of demonstrating that in a way that is logically rigorous for my friend, who is looking for that rigor. Thanks!
Mateo el Feo Posted December 21, 2007 Posted December 21, 2007 [quote name='kkerwin' post='1436429' date='Dec 20 2007, 06:36 AM']Hi all, I'm in an ongoing discussion with someone over life issues (in this particular case, the death penalty). I've already more than outlined the Catholic teaching specific to the death penalty, but now we're on to a related topic: what is the value of a person based on? Is it extrinsic, that is, based on their contributions to society? Or is it intrinsic, that is, is the person of value simply because they are a living human person? I know what the Catholic Church teaches (that the value of life is intrinsic), but I can't seem to figure out a way of demonstrating that in a way that is logically rigorous for my friend, who is looking for that rigor. Thanks![/quote]This may touch on what you're looking for: [url="http://www.amazon.com/Healing-Culture-Commonsense-Philosophy-Happiness/dp/0898707862/"]Healing the Culture[/url] by Rober Spitzer, SJ.
withouthavingseen Posted December 26, 2007 Posted December 26, 2007 That a human's worth is intrinsic to his personhood is logically demonstrable, but only if the debate takes for granted a transcendent dimension to reality - something beyond the merely material. But if a person will only discuss the material aspect of reality, merely physical stuff, then what is the sense of speaking of "worth" or "value"? If such a person were to speak about such things, they should be aggressively challenged to justify speaking of the (very clearly immaterial) concepts of worth and value while insisting that only the material exists.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now