Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Tour Of The Summa Theologiae


Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

The impetus of this thread is here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=75510"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=75510[/url]

I will be the facilitator which means I will post a new article or question from the Summa periodically which will initiate a topic change. The format of this facilitator posts will be...

Post #1
[Heading]
[Complete text of selection]
[Link to online version]

Post #2
[Introductory Blurb]
[Quotes from commentary or other sources]
[Links to online supplementary materials]

The plan was for me to reproduce commentary from Kreeft's book when possible but as I have misplaced my copy of this book this won't be possible straight away. This is not a problem right now anyway since I plan to start with some selections that are not included in Kreeft's book. The difference here is that Kreeft's book is focused on the philosophical aspects of the Summa whereas this thread seeks to tour the Summa from more of a theological point of view.

Cheers!

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[b]Pericope #1[/b]
[i]Summa Theologiae, Prima Pars, Question I, Article 1[/i]

Article 1. Whether, besides philosophy, any further doctrine is required?
Objection 1. It seems that, besides philosophical science, we have no need of any further knowledge. For man should not seek to know what is above reason: "Seek not the things that are too high for thee" (Sirach 3:22). But whatever is not above reason is fully treated of in philosophical science. Therefore any other knowledge besides philosophical science is superfluous.

Objection 2. Further, knowledge can be concerned only with being, for nothing can be known, save what is true; and all that is, is true. But everything that is, is treated of in philosophical science--even God Himself; so that there is a part of philosophy called theology, or the divine science, as Aristotle has proved (Metaph. vi). Therefore, besides philosophical science, there is no need of any further knowledge.

On the contrary, It is written (2 Timothy 3:16): "All Scripture, inspired of God is profitable to teach, to reprove, to correct, to instruct in justice." Now Scripture, inspired of God, is no part of philosophical science, which has been built up by human reason. Therefore it is useful that besides philosophical science, there should be other knowledge, i.e. inspired of God.

I answer that, It was necessary for man's salvation that there should be a knowledge revealed by God besides philosophical science built up by human reason. Firstly, indeed, because man is directed to God, as to an end that surpasses the grasp of his reason: "The eye hath not seen, O God, besides Thee, what things Thou hast prepared for them that wait for Thee" (Isaiah 66:4). But the end must first be known by men who are to direct their thoughts and actions to the end. Hence it was necessary for the salvation of man that certain truths which exceed human reason should be made known to him by divine revelation. Even as regards those truths about God which human reason could have discovered, it was necessary that man should be taught by a divine revelation; because the truth about God such as reason could discover, would only be known by a few, and that after a long time, and with the admixture of many errors. Whereas man's whole salvation, which is in God, depends upon the knowledge of this truth. Therefore, in order that the salvation of men might be brought about more fitly and more surely, it was necessary that they should be taught divine truths by divine revelation. It was therefore necessary that besides philosophical science built up by reason, there should be a sacred science learned through revelation.

Reply to Objection 1. Although those things which are beyond man's knowledge may not be sought for by man through his reason, nevertheless, once they are revealed by God, they must be accepted by faith. Hence the sacred text continues, "For many things are shown to thee above the understanding of man" (Sirach 3:25). And in this, the sacred science consists.

Reply to Objection 2. Sciences are differentiated according to the various means through which knowledge is obtained. For the astronomer and the physicist both may prove the same conclusion: that the earth, for instance, is round: the astronomer by means of mathematics (i.e. abstracting from matter), but the physicist by means of matter itself. Hence there is no reason why those things which may be learned from philosophical science, so far as they can be known by natural reason, may not also be taught us by another science so far as they fall within revelation. Hence theology included in sacred doctrine differs in kind from that theology which is part of philosophy.

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/1001.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/summa/1001.htm[/url]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[b]Pericope #1 Facilitator Comment[/b]

Is Divine Revelation necessary? Is there anything to be known or anything that can be known apart from natural reason and philosophical investigation (including natural science)? Even if reality ultimately transcends the range of human reason and natural experience ought we to pursue knowledge of this sort?
Thomas proposes that divine revelation is necessary for the salvation of man. Our ultimate end and good is directed toward the life of God which is a mystery surpassing human reason. God’s own revelation to man makes it possible for us to order our thoughts and actions to that end in a way that is not possible though natural reason alone.
There is indeed a kind of theology based on reason alone (natural theology) but this will always lack the definitive character of a supernatural revelation which is required for the good of man. Reason illuminated by divine revelation allows man to interpret the world in the light of the mystery of God’s inner life which would otherwise remain obscure and inaccessible to unaided speculation. Pure philosophy can only understand God according to the structures of created being whereas the light of revelation and grace elevates the heart and mind to the higher sphere of God’s love and action; it truly puts man in a relationship with God when this knowledge is active through the gift of faith. Thus for Thomas truths such as God as Trinity and the Incarnation are outside the scope of natural reason alone and are essential truths necessary for the proper spiritual elevation, sanctification and salvation of man (his ultimate fulfillment and end). There can be knowledge of this sort because God has revealed it in the Mystery of Christ and has drawn us to participate in His Divine Life through grace; the right worship of God, and being in right relationship with God requires the truth of God which natural theology, by the very limits of its mode of cognition and object, cannot provide. It is the theological virtues and the action of God that make possible this knowledge of realities that transcend the created order and the sphere of unaided human reason. Thus Thomas begins his great introductory treatise on theology by establishing the link between the content and nature of theology and the very sanctification and salvation of man.

[b]Related Sources[/b]
[i]That faith thus understood is necessary to salvation no man can reasonably doubt, particularly since it is written: Without faith it is impossible to please God. For as the end proposed to man as his ultimate happiness is far above the reach of human understanding, it was therefore necessary that it should be made known to him by God. This knowledge, however, is nothing else than faith, by which we yield our unhesitating assent to whatever the authority of our Holy Mother the Church teaches us to have been revealed by God; for the faithful cannot doubt those things of which God, who is truth itself, is the author. Hence we see the great difference that exists between this faith which we give to God and that which we yield to the writers of human history.
- The Roman Catechism, Part I, Introduction[/i]

[b]Links of Interest[/b]
Online Commentary: [url="http://www.nd.edu/~afreddos/courses/439/summa1,1.htm"]http://www.nd.edu/~afreddos/courses/439/summa1,1.htm[/url]
Roman Catechism: [url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/ebooks/master/trent/tcreed00.htm"]http://www.cin.org/users/james/ebooks/mast...nt/tcreed00.htm[/url]

Posted

Just wondering... was this question meant to answer St. Anselm's rationalistic perspective?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I would say that Saint Thomas asserts the distinction between philosophy and theology (or their autonomy) more than Saint Anselm, but for Anselm faith does in fact have priority. I think this question would speak more to the Averroists or in general the intellectual heretics of the time who would assert that only philosophy is necessary and fully true or perhaps a two truths theory such as Siger of Brabant. An extreme position of those days might even assert that religious faith is the "truth" for the rabble whereas philosophy is the higher truth for the elite.
Considering the context of the time - particularly the scene at the University of Paris - starting out the Summa in this way would seem to be a clear statement of Saint Thomas' leanings. He is about to present a summary of theology from the perspective of his development of Aristotelian thought and yet he is immediately distancing himself from the “liberals” and heretics of the time who claimed Aristotle as their guy. I’m reading a lot into it but this is more how I would see it rather than singling out Anselm.

Posted

See this is why I like you as our 'leader'... I didn't know any of that... :)

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Thanks for getting this started. My comments are surely going to be less sophisticated and far less educated that all of yours. So just be patient with my idiocy.

In regards to objection 2: "Further, knowledge can be concerned only with being, for [b]nothing can be known, save what is true; and all that is, is true[/b]. But everything that is, is treated of in philosophical science--even God Himself; so that there is a part of philosophy called theology, or the divine science, as Aristotle has proved (Metaph. vi). Therefore, besides philosophical science, there is no need of any further knowledge."

Consider the bolded. Now, at least at the lower community college level that I have attended, a common question debated in philosophy courses asks whether or not the fact that we question and even consider the possibility of the existence of God, can serve as a proof for His existence. Why is God (in any of His conceived forms) and heaven such a common belief by such a diverse number of peoples over the centuries? Can God be true because such a belief would not be such a universally held one, if it were not true? Now, granted it says "nothing can be KNOWN" rather than "nothing can be conceived of", but what would Aquinas think of the idea?

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1436973' date='Dec 21 2007, 04:00 AM']Thanks for getting this started. My comments are surely going to be less sophisticated and far less educated that all of yours. So just be patient with my idiocy.

In regards to objection 2: "Further, knowledge can be concerned only with being, for [b]nothing can be known, save what is true; and all that is, is true[/b]. But everything that is, is treated of in philosophical science--even God Himself; so that there is a part of philosophy called theology, or the divine science, as Aristotle has proved (Metaph. vi). Therefore, besides philosophical science, there is no need of any further knowledge."

Consider the bolded. Now, at least at the lower community college level that I have attended, a common question debated in philosophy courses asks whether or not the fact that we question and even consider the possibility of the existence of God, can serve as a proof for His existence. Why is God (in any of His conceived forms) and heaven such a common belief by such a diverse number of peoples over the centuries? Can God be true because such a belief would not be such a universally held one, if it were not true? Now, granted it says "nothing can be KNOWN" rather than "nothing can be conceived of", but what would Aquinas think of the idea?[/quote]

Well... I don't know what Aquinas would say about this... But I'll give you what I think...

1) Don't make the question do more than its intended to do. The question is basically only asking are their sources of knowledge outside of philosophy. Objection 2 is saying that everything falls under philosophy so there is no need to examine revealed knowledge. I wouldn't jump to apriori arguments on the existence of God so quickly. I'm pretty sure Aquinas covers those questions later.

From my understanding, Aquinas is merely saying that there are all types of sources of knowledge; oberservation of the world around us (see his reply to Objection 2), and knowledge of God from scripture.

2) Now, not too jump too far ahead; but I'm pretty sure Aquinas covers your question a bit later; that is are ideas or notions of God proof of God. I'm pretty sure (but could be wrong) that he answers in a negative fashion, that these ideas are not proofs. (Look at Q2A1).

Edited by rkwright
goldenchild17
Posted

Thanks. I understand not to make more of the question than what it is. Maybe it's my lack of formal training in philosophy but I tend to bring things up that come to mind, whether or not they are specifically in the context of what I am reading at the moment. Probably a result of my weak memory so I bring things up so that I don't forget them later. I'll try to keep them at a minimum.

That said, L D if you have a chance as you are preparing each new section that is being addressed, do you think that you could post which section numbers we will be reading here ahead of time, so that I can try and keep up with reading the sections not covered here on my own? If that's too much don't worry about it.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

For the Memorial of St. Thomas Aquinas, priest and doctor (1/28/08), I offer the following blog post, which contains links to articles about Thomas and his works, and links to those of his works that are available online:
[url="http://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2008/01/for-memorial-of-st-thomas-aquinas.html"]http://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2008/01/f...as-aquinas.html[/url]

I thought the participants in this thread might enjoy that :)

Pax Christi,
phatcatholic

goldenchild17
Posted

thanks, good stuff though I think participation kind of died here already :)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1452671' date='Jan 29 2008, 09:19 PM']thanks, good stuff though I think participation kind of died here already :)[/quote]
Yeah, Christmas came and I was away from phatmass for a week and nobody really posted. It seems like there were only a couple of us who were really into it. I thought the thread would be lots of discussion and I'm afraid that it would be mostly me copying and pasting and blabbing about the Summa (something I'm not even an expert on). :(

Cool avatar btw! I always wondered what you look like in real life. :cool:

goldenchild17
Posted

yeah I figured I probably wouldn't do a whole lotta insightful posting since I'm really just trying to learn it. It's all good though, I'm still trying to read it. Not making as much progress without a knowledgeable guide, but it's coming.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1452953' date='Jan 30 2008, 01:57 PM']Cool avatar btw! I always wondered what you look like in real life. :cool:[/quote]

I was going to put up a pic of Brad Pitt or Tom Cruise like Notardillacid did, but I thought it'd be more fun to scare the women and children :mellow:

:smokey:

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Attempting to read this with others (new converts) and REALLY struggling. :sweat: I have Kreeft's shorter Summa of the Summa.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='misereremi' post='1471121' date='Feb 29 2008, 05:44 AM']Attempting to read this with others (new converts) and REALLY struggling. :sweat: I have Kreeft's shorter Summa of the Summa.[/quote]
Feel free to post any questions that you have along the way! I'm sure between all of us phatmassers someone is bound to have some good insight. I've worked my way through the better part of the Summa in the past but I must confess that I'm not a Thomist and my knowledge of the subject is scattered at best.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1471123' date='Feb 29 2008, 11:00 AM']Feel free to post any questions that you have along the way! I'm sure between all of us phatmassers someone is bound to have some good insight. I've worked my way through the better part of the Summa in the past but I must confess that I'm not a Thomist and my knowledge of the subject is scattered at best.[/quote]
Thank you LD. :)

  • 1 month later...
goldenchild17
Posted

I know this kind of fell off, but just to let people know there are at least three of the manuals I listed on-line for free. 2 at google books and 1 at another website.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1500504' date='Apr 16 2008, 04:30 AM']I know this kind of fell off, but just to let people know there are at least three of the manuals I listed on-line for free. 2 at google books and 1 at another website.[/quote]
Many thanks

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...