Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://newsbusters.org/blogs/warner-todd-huston/2007/12/21/msm-exaggerates-american-indians-claims-seceding-usa"]http://newsbusters.org/blogs/warner-todd-h...ms-seceding-usa[/url].
[quote]MSM Exaggerates American Indians Claims of Seceding From USA
By Warner Todd Huston | December 21, 2007 - 15:29 ET
Sioux Indians "Withdraw From the USA"? Or not!

Here is the kind of story that really proves how little the MSM bothers to research things, how they often simply print glorified press releases without doing any real "journalism," and how the defective end product gets picked up and regurgitated like it is suddenly a "fact." In this one we have the story of "the Lakota Sioux Indians" announcing that "they" have withdrawn from agreed upon treaties with the US government and that they are now a sovereign nation, no longer to be called citizens of the USA. Problem is "the Lakota Sioux Indians" that have made this announcement are just an unaffiliated group of Indian activists the leader of whom does not represent the official Lakota tribe leadership! Yet here is the news media reporting this story as if all "the Lakota Sioux Indians" have banded together and quit the union.

Take this report from USA Today: Lakota withdraw from treaties, declare independence from U.S

The Lakota Sioux Indians, whose ancestors include Sitting Bull, Red Cloud and Crazy Horse, have withdrawn from all treaties their forefathers signed with the U.S. government and have declared their independence. A delegation delivered the news to the State Department earlier this week.


Wow, it sounds momentous, alright. But, who says that "the Lakota Sioux Indians" have abandoned their treaties?

"We are no longer citizens of the United States of America and all those who live in the five-state area that encompasses our country are free to join us," said Russell Means, a longtime Indian rights activist. "This is according to the laws of the United States, specifically Article 6 of the Constitution," which states that treaties are the supreme law of the land.


And who is the Russell Means? He is a long time Indian activist who does not officially represent any tribe, that's who. It takes the local press to make this clear. The Rapid City Journal of Rapid City, South Dakota informs us that, "Means' group is based in Porcupine on Pine Ridge Indian Reservation," and that "it is not an agency or branch of the Oglala Sioux Tribe. Means ran unsuccessfully for president of the tribe in 2006."

Yet in report after report, this Means character is presented as if he is "the Lakota Sioux" when, in truth, all he really is is A Lakota Sioux -- not a representative of all of them. He does not represent American Indians except as a tangential, activist. He has no authority to make this "declaration of Independence" for the Lakota or any other American Indian tribe.

It turns out that these reports are nearly all just a rehash of Russell Means’ press releases and not based on any real reporting at all.

And here is the worst part. The bulk of the news outlets that have picked up this story are foreign press agencies like the Agence Presse France, The Telegraph, and Radio Netherlands, all of whom presented this as if it was somehow legal and binding instead of an activist's scheming.

So, since this story wasn't reported correctly, foreigners are imagining that all American Indians are trying to leave the USA and become a new nation. The truth is less shocking, that Russell Means does not represent "the Lakota Sioux Indians" at all.[/quote]



A comment from a reader confirms:

[quote]The Lame Stream Media has gotten truly pathetic. I reside in the Peoples Republic of Minnesota, right in the middle of Sioux Land. I couldn't imagine such an idiot move by the tribes and sure enough - NOT.

Russell Means is the Al Sharpton of the midwest indian movement. He's just a cheap self agrandising hustler. The tribes dumped his butt years ago for good reason.

He was one of the idiots pushing "Native Americans" as a label that is completely false and therefore demeaning to our non-white brothers. Some of us unsuccessfully pushed for "The First Ones" which would have been true and honorable, considering no human is 'native' to the Americas and the American Indian tribes all got here first.[/quote]

Well then....

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well there you have it then, all the fuss for nothing...

Posted

I figured the "delegation of Lakota leaders" was bull honky since they had no stories actually naming these "leaders" besides Mr. Means.

I think this kills Al's topic.

Posted

Funny how we never heard about it on the news, or saw any reaction from the Justice Department, the FBI or the President. You know, the people who would react if any large group of people actually did this.

Posted

the story is real in the sense that there is a group who live on these reservations who now consider themselves to be members of a new sovereign nation... and that nation has been recognized by foreign governments.

Posted

How many people? And what allows them to break from the treaties for the whole group? Do the treaties only apply for some of the Lakota now?
What other nations recognize this 'new' nation? If it's a small group, what land is theres?

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1438187' date='Dec 25 2007, 06:46 AM']the story is real in the sense that there is a group who live on these reservations who now consider themselves to be members of a new sovereign nation... and that nation has been recognized by foreign governments.[/quote]
What? :blink: Come now Al, surely even you wouldn't recognize that as valid. Its not even the legitimate Sioux government for crying out loud, how could you possibly say they have the right to secede?

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

Here is what the website [url="http://www.lakotafreedom.com/index.html"]Lakota Freedom[/url] has to say on the issue:

[quote]The Lakota Freedom Delegation is the powerful realization of an ongoing process lasting no less than 33 years. Despite criticism the Delegation does not speak for the Lakota people, Delegation representatives have been in ongoing communication with the traditional chiefs and treaty councils all across Lakota for the last three and a half years.

Canupa Gluha Mani (Duane Martin Sr.) , leader of the Cante Tenza (Strongheart Warrior Society) of the Ogalala Lakota and Oyate Wacinyapin (Russell Means) have been in discussion with the traditional treaty councils across Lakota. The traditional treaty councils in the following communities were consulted:

Pine Ridge
Porcupine
Kyle
Rosebud
Lower Brule
Cheyenne River
Standing Rock
Flandreau

Additional consultation with the treaty council occurred during Defenders of Black Hills meeting in Rapid City. Mni yuha Najin Win (Phyllis Young) also consulted with the people in Standing Rock regarding this action.[/quote]

While all this might not be as dramatic as a unanimous split, the level of participation and discussion from different treaty councils means that this is not about one man getting up and announcing that the Lakota have seceded either. The truth lies somewhere in between.

Posted

That they are "in communication" with them means nothing. That could mean he gave them a phone call and they hung up on him as soon they heard the name "Russell Means". Given what I hear from Native Americans concerning him that may very well have been what happened.

Posted (edited)

Here's one Indian's view on Russell Means, and the fake Lakota sucession.

[url="http://www.badeagle.com/journal/"]http://www.badeagle.com/journal/[/url]

[i]Whites Create Lakota Withdrawal

So the Lakota are withdrawing from the United States? The Lakota Sioux are 'walking away' from the 150 year-old treaties with the United States government?

Sounds like another grand publicity stunt. Russell Means is speaking for the movement, but, there are apparently no tribal leaders involved, of any Sioux. This is another one of those "white" Indian schemes, behind which white Communist-oriented liberals seek to create racial agitation. They love to use Indians for this kind of stunt. They make their careers off this--off using Indians. They've trained certain Indians to front for them. Well-trained them. AIMsters still live high, (though Floyd Westerman and Vernon Bellecourt have passed on recently).


Russell Means

The "Lakota delegation" sported their theoretical wares in Washington, it looks like, visiting the embassies of certain South American nations--which of course love to hate the United States, and of course are filled with "Indian" populations. That must have been a curious race fest there in the national offices. But, this is what happens when you base a whole movement on an anti-white position. You become a reverse Nazi. That's what all these "skins" do nowadays. Anyone who is not white is automatically "Indian," whether Negro, Oriental, Pacific Islander, or homosexual. And so an Indian like Russell Means fronts for anti-white people and anti-American people, gets well-paid for it, but at the same time he actually wants to do something for Indian people. This is the predicament. Means becomes associated with the reverse Nazi racist movement which seeks to unite all non-white people against the United States. This is pure racism. Racism in its most obvious form. This is Hitler, as an Indian.

Of course, BadEagle.com has long presented various radical theories for improving Indian country. I myself have suggested the Indian nations act like nations--particularly when it comes to casino businesses. I suggested to Governor Schwarzenegger that all Indian casinos in the United States should have one currency--separate from the US government. I have public suggested passports, and even national levies, tariffs, and taxes on the money changing itself. You should have to use Indian money to gamble in an Indian casino. And when Indians want to spend the money in any American markets, for anything, they have to change it into American money, etc. I have offered many radical ideas about Indian nationhood.

However, Indians nations are United States nations. More like states. And I despise association with other third world nations. They have nothing to do with American Indians, and they could never have fought and defeated any American Indian tribe. At least not any Plains Indian tribe, nor any of the major Eastern tribes, either. We owe them nothing, not even the time of day. To reach out to them for affirmation is hideous, ahistorical, and is terribly degrading to American Indians. It is the epitome of weakness.

But that's the racism involved in these publicity stunts. Indians are being used by white Leftists, and made into absolute geniuses. The Indians involved simply take in the money, and really don't care what happens. This is leading in the wrong direction. Furthermore, I repeat, there are no tribal leaders involved in this Lakota thing. This is strictly a publicity stunt for the old AIMsters, and their activist heirs. This is a disgrace to all American Indian people--especially those trying to accomplish something in the way of self-reliance, a job, economic independence, etc. This holds everyone back--especially in the primitive white areas of the country, like the Dakotas, and the plains states. This kind of thing makes it harder for any real Indians to have any real professional success in the world. This is a bad thing. A very, very bad thing.

Just let everyone remember that it is white people that create these anti-white racist movements. This is the work of white Leftists. Lets not blame Indians for this, in spite of the few that get paid (by white people) to protest.

For Indians, it is only a dance. It is the Ghost Dance. It is a particularly cruel version of it. All this Lakota movement does is suggest a stepped up version of the reservations. To seek to be recognized by Third World countries doesn't mean anything. Their recognition is worthless. Their recognition doesn't suddenly make the Indians into bonified nations in the world, on a par with all the others. They cannot treat American Indian people as real nations. American Indian nations exist withint the physical boundaries of the United States. It is the United States they must relate to. There are laws about international commerce. You can't just pretend there are no borders. (Or, can you?! Mexicans and Democrats do. Even some Republicans do.)

Therefore, this is perhaps the most ridiculous publicity stunt the old AIMsters and their white Leftist racist backers have ever come up with. This is the most denigrating, foolhardy gimmick they've ever invented.

Real Indians love America. Most real Indians are all Christian, too. Look to the elders of any tribe in the United States. Not the new casino pop-up groups (many of whom aren't even Indian), but to the real, historically great tribes. The elders are all Christian. And American Indians serve in the US military in the highest percentage rate of any ethnicity, with nearly 100,000 living veterans. There are veterans in almost every family.

The Bad Eagle Foundation hopes one day to create a national organization for the real Indians, the American patriot Indians, the Christian Indians, the conservative Indians--who are the vast majority of Indians, but who have no focus, no organization, and no leadership. It is late in the game, but, hey, Comanches were late in the game before, and burst out on the southern plains and took over! It can happen again.

Of course, I do not speak for Comanche people. I am not an elected leader. But I know of no offical, elected Comanche leader who has ever been involved in any of this kind of racist, anti-American publicity stunt. Comanches don't do that. An individual here and there might, but, most would never think of it. This is true for most American Indian tribes, too.

Finally, I do know for a fact that the great Sioux people do have special challenges. The level of white civililzation up in the Dakota territories is among the less developed in the country. The relations between whites and Indians is probably the worst of all. It would seem radical measures are called for, indeed,--but rational measures. Not racist measures. This last stunt does not light a fire under Indians to make them want to live differently than they do. This kind of nonsense makes Indians even more dependent, psychologically. This means they can't participate in America, ever. This destroys all hope. This kills all the natural ambition, the innate aspirations of Indian youth. This is a horrible curse, really. This level of profound discontent is the worst thing that any Indian could promote.

As I said, let's remember that white Leftists, white Commies are behind this, and always have been. I can only hope that reasonable white people understand this. This is not an Indian movement. This is a white political movement, using a few well-paid Indians to front.[/i]

Edited by Justin86
cathoholic_anonymous
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Justin86' post='1438243' date='Dec 25 2007, 01:41 AM']This is another one of those "white" Indian schemes, behind which white Communist-oriented liberals seek to create racial agitation.[/quote]

Oh, it's those [i]liberals[/i] again. How did I guess? :rolleyes:

The article says that the treaty councils were consulted. Consultation does require two-way communication. And while stories of a total, unanimous breakaway are grossly overexaggerated, implying that any Lakota native who wants independence must be the puppet of faceless, lurking liberal hordes is equally far-fetched.

You've done what you accuse Means of doing - you've produced one Native American commentator and puts his views forward as if they are mainstream among Native Americans. I expect there is a whole spectrum of opinion in the issue, not just two starkly defined camps whose membership numbers fluctuate depending on the personal stance of whoever is speaking at the time.

Edited by Cathoholic Anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1438247' date='Dec 25 2007, 11:07 AM']You've done what you accuse Means of doing - you've produced one Native American commentator and puts his views forward as if they are mainstream among Native Americans.[/quote]
I did no such thing. I specficly said "here is what [i]one[/i] native American thinks". This is not the first time you've put words into my mouth. Please stop, or I am putting you on my ignore list.

Posted

I would've recognized the Irish as their own nation before the negotiations between Michael Collins and the British Government... when the "legitimate" government of the island was not seeking independence. so it's not that far-fetched for me to recognize this group's claims of independence.

it's not JUST Russel Means, it's a decently sized group (they may or may not be a majority, there is no data) with the support of many tribal councils.

anyway, yes, I am sure there is a whole spectrum of opinion on the issue.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1438267' date='Dec 25 2007, 01:43 PM']I would've recognized the Irish as their own nation before the negotiations between Michael Collins and the British Government... when the "legitimate" government of the island was not seeking independence. so it's not that far-fetched for me to recognize this group's claims of independence.[/quote]
Recognizing them gets you no where in achieving your goal, however. You would not only have to deal with Britain, but also the real Irish government.

Look, setting up "rival governments" are useless unless your planning some militant overthrow of the current government. Its a complete waste of time.

[quote]it's not JUST Russel Means, it's a decently sized group (they may or may not be a majority, there is no data) with the support of many tribal councils.[/quote]
If there's no data how do you know its a decently sized group, or even a group at all?

[quote]anyway, yes, I am sure there is a whole spectrum of opinion on the issue.[/quote]
Agreed. Only one member here ever thought anyone disputed that.

Posted

One more thing: Yesterday when I was on watch and posting here using a government computer I tried accessing the Lakota Freedom site, and it wouldn't let me look at it declaring it a "malicious site". Read into that what you will.

Posted

I know it's a group, that much is obvious. There is no data that I know of regarding how many people wish to support the idea of withdrawing from the treaties, but there might be some sort of membership list for this group... I don't know. But that's really not a disputed fact, it's a group of decent size. How much percentage of the vote did Means get in the last election? maybe that would shed some light on who supports him.

I have no problem with the idea of setting up a rival government and attempting to have it recognized through diplomatic non-violent means, myself. Much less effective, of course, but absolutely admirable nonetheless. the fact that tribal councils were consulted means, however, that this involves a portion of the legitimate government of the tribe. Like if a bunch of city councils supported the institution of a new state government which would secede from the union... you could support them, you could recognize them, and there would be an issue in play. that's what this is... the issue is really in play.

HA, that's funny that the government censors that site on its computers. Makes sense, the sites purpose is to remove a portion of land and a group of people from the jurisdiction of the Federal Government.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1438322' date='Dec 25 2007, 04:23 PM']I know it's a group, that much is obvious. There is no data that I know of regarding how many people wish to support the idea of withdrawing from the treaties, but there might be some sort of membership list for this group... I don't know. But that's really not a disputed fact, it's a group of decent size. How much percentage of the vote did Means get in the last election? maybe that would shed some light on who supports him.[/quote]
Probably not very much, being from what I hear they chased him away after that election.

[quote]I have no problem with the idea of setting up a rival government and attempting to have it recognized through diplomatic non-violent means, myself. Much less effective, of course, but absolutely admirable nonetheless. the fact that tribal councils were consulted means, however, that this involves a portion of the legitimate government of the tribe. Like if a bunch of city councils supported the institution of a new state government which would secede from the union... you could support them, you could recognize them, and there would be an issue in play. that's what this is... the issue is really in play.[/quote]
Since when does talking to someone mean they officially recognize you? Like I said, the two-way communication could just have easily been them hanging up the phone.

[quote]HA, that's funny that the government censors that site on its computers. Makes sense, the sites purpose is to remove a portion of land and a group of people from the jurisdiction of the Federal Government.[/quote]
Maybe, but being that this is the same government whose Army I am hearing is now confiscating "Right-Wing Christian Conservative materials" from barracks rooms after there was a compliant at Fort Riley when Ann Coulter's famous quote "We should invade their countries, kill their leaders, and convert them to Christianity" appeared outside of the police battalion headquarters I'm thinking probably not.

More than likely they might not want me viewing websites put up by someone who took Indians hostage on a reservation in the 1970s and was driven out when the Indians revolted against him with their 30-30 rifles and into the arms of the FBI waiting patiently outside the reservation.

Not to mention this picture of him on the site [i]does[/i] look pretty "malicious".

[img]http://i213.photobucket.com/albums/cc131/justin86_bucket/Humor/duanedl.jpg[/img]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...