Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

A Question About Transubstantiation


Recommended Posts

Posted

Good evening and Merry Christmas, Phatmassers.
As someone who has just recently started on the road to Catholicism (a year and a half or so), naturally, I still have some questions and misunderstandings.
As I was reading this evening, I came across the wikipedia article on Transubstantiation. While I already knew what it was and had a pretty good grasp on it, I didn't understand it fully until I read the first part of the article. However, since the articles are editable by anyone, I wanted to verify with y'all that it is accurate. This is the part in question:
[quote]"Substance" here means what something is in itself. (For more on the philosophical concept, see Substance theory.) A hat's shape is not the hat itself, nor is its colour the hat, nor is its size, nor its softness to the touch, nor anything else about it perceptible to the senses. The hat itself (the "substance") has the shape, the colour, the size, the softness and the other appearances, but is distinct from them. While the appearances, which are referred to by the philosophical term accidents, are perceptible to the senses, the substance is not.

When at his Last Supper, Jesus said: "This is my body", what he held in his hands still had all the appearances of bread: these "accidents" remained unchanged. However, the Roman Catholic Church believes that, when Jesus made that declaration, the underlying reality (the "substance") of the bread was converted to that of his body. In other words, it actually was his body, while all the appearances open to the senses or to scientific investigation were still those of bread, exactly as before. The Church holds that the same change of the substance of the bread and of the wine occurs at the consecration of the Eucharist.[/quote]
from [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transsubstantiation#Theology_of_transubsantiation"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transsubstant...nsubstantiation[/url]
Is this a reasonable and accurate explanation?
Thank you and Pax Christi,
Mitch

Posted

I'm pretty sure that that is accurate. We'll wait for the really smart people to get here, though. :)

Posted

I believe that wikipedia excerpt is a reasonable and accurate explanation. however I would advise you to stick to more legit sources that wikipedia such as the Catholic Encyclopedia.

But I think that excerpt is correct, however, just wait until someone with a littlemore theological background has a chance to comment on it, because I could be wrong.

Posted

[quote name='curtins' post='1438471' date='Dec 25 2007, 11:42 PM']I believe that wikipedia excerpt is a reasonable and accurate explanation. however I would advise you to stick to more legit sources that wikipedia such as the Catholic Encyclopedia.

But I think that excerpt is correct, however, just wait until someone with a littlemore theological background has a chance to comment on it, because I could be wrong.[/quote]

I agree. That's basically the classic philosophical explanation of the doctrine.

Posted (edited)

"While I already knew what it was and had a pretty good grasp on it, I didn't [b]understand it fully until[/b] I read the first part of the article. "

Careful. We never fully understand but that is the beauty. We spend eternity growing in understanding. God is infinite and so is the Eucharist. The article looks fine but it's not the end of this great mystery. All praise and glory be to our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.

PS. One thing to be a little careful of is that the Church does not say that Jesus is physically present in the eucharist in that we would take a bite out of his arm, but that he is sacramentally present, body, blood, soul, and divinity. This is a real and substantial presence but not the same as he in human form. This negates the canabal arguement.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

Thank you all for your replies. :)
[quote name='thessalonian' post='1438864' date='Dec 27 2007, 02:18 PM']Careful. We never fully understand but that is the beauty. We spend eternity growing in understanding. God is infinite and so is the Eucharist. The article looks fine but it's not the end of this great mystery. All praise and glory be to our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.[/quote]
I shouldn't have phrased it like that, you're right. I guess I meant that I didn't understand it [i]as[/i] fully.
[quote]PS. One thing to be a little careful of is that the Church does not say that Jesus is physically present in the eucharist in that we would take a bite out of his arm, but that he is sacramentally present, body, blood, soul, and divinity. This is a real and substantial presence but not the same as he in human form. This negates the canabal arguement.[/quote]
Reading further on the matter (from online sources and the Catechism) yesterday, I learned more about this. Some of it is difficult for me to understand as I have no philosophical background.
Thanks again and Pax Christi,
Mitch

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1438864' date='Dec 27 2007, 02:18 PM']PS. One thing to be a little careful of is that the Church does not say that Jesus is physically present in the eucharist in that we would take a bite out of his arm, but that he is sacramentally present, body, blood, soul, and divinity. This is a real and substantial presence but not the same as he in human form. This negates the canabal arguement.[/quote]


Christ is PHYSICALLY present, while under the forms of bread and wine, but he is physically present. Not humanly present, but physically sacramentally present.

Posted

[quote name='curtins' post='1438882' date='Dec 28 2007, 05:53 AM']Christ is PHYSICALLY present, while under the forms of bread and wine, but he is physically present. Not humanly present, but physically sacramentally present.[/quote]
Thank you, I was about to say that. While its true that maybe Catholics aren't cannibals in the sense that we take bites out of Jesus' body parts, we do eat His Body. Christ is present in the Eucharist [b]Body[/b], Blood, Soul, and Divinity, remember?

By the way, I find God very tasty myself.

Posted (edited)

Perhaps you can find a church document that says Christ is PHYSICALLY present in the eucharist. Here is what the CCC says:

The mode of Christ’s presence under the Eucharistic species is[b] unique[/b]. It raises the Eucharist above all the sacraments as “the perfection of the spiritual life and the end to which all the sacraments tend.” In the most blessed sacrament of the Eucharist “the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ and, therefore, the whole Christ is truly, really, and substantially contained.” This presence is called ’real’ -- by which is not intended to exclude the other types of presence as if they could not be ’real’ too, but because it is presence in the fullest sense: that is to say, it is a substantial presence by which Christ, God and man, makes Himself wholly and entirely present.”

Nowhere in any church document is Christ's prescence called physical. Nowhere can you find language such as you use "physically, sacramentally present".

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

Mitch,

I heard a story I think it was from bishop Fulton Sheen one time. He had a man come to him who wanted to be Catholic and was attending classes to be baptized. Toward the end he told the Bishop Sheen, I want to be Catholic but I do not understand the Trinity. Bishop Sheen told him, then I cannot baptize you. He went away sad. Some time later he came back and said "Bishop Sheen I now fully understand the trinity and want to be Catholic". Bishop Sheen told him I cannot baptize you. We must remember that these are great mysteries that we are entrusted with and know that they are above our ability to fully comprehend them. You know this I am sure, but the story helps put me in awe of what God has given us as Catholics.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1439074' date='Dec 28 2007, 10:28 AM']Perhaps you can find a church document that says Christ is PHYSICALLY present in the eucharist. Here is what the CCC says:

The mode of Christ’s presence under the Eucharistic species is[b] unique[/b]. It raises the Eucharist above all the sacraments as “the perfection of the spiritual life and the end to which all the sacraments tend.” In the most blessed sacrament of the Eucharist “the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ and, therefore, the whole Christ is truly, really, and substantially contained.” This presence is called ’real’ -- by which is not intended to exclude the other types of presence as if they could not be ’real’ too, but because it is presence in the fullest sense: that is to say, it is a substantial presence by which Christ, God and man, makes Himself wholly and entirely present.”

Nowhere in any church document is Christ's prescence called physical. Nowhere can you find language such as you use "physically, sacramentally present".[/quote]


Is that to say then that you've read every single church document ever produced (or at least those that mention the Eucharist) ?

So if his presence is not Physical, then what is it? Surely not symbolic, and surely not merely spiritual. The Eucharist is a PHYSICAL reality- one can touch it, see it, etc etc.... If Christ is truly present in the Eucharist, and the Eucharist is a physical reality, then Christ is physically present in the Eucharist


semantics much?

Posted

Let's just call it a challenge. If you come accross it I am all ears. I'm not trying to be antagonistic about this. You are correct that there is some sort of physical prescence in the Eucharist, that is obvious. But I think the Churches avoidance of the term is in that, again it is not human flesh, such that it is not canabalism to consume it. Augustine has some quotes that lots of noncatholics like to use to deny transubstantition. But I think the quotes are better explained when the sacramental presence is mroe fully understood.

As far as your question of what is it, i.e. what does sacramental exactly mean, I may start a thread on that somewhere here because I am not quite sure what the difference is between sacramental, physical, and spiritual.

Do a web search if you like for physical, sacramental, and Eucharist and you will find a number of articles on the matter. .

Posted

By the way if the Church wanted to speak of Christ's presense in the Eucharist as a physical one, it would seem rather odd to leave the word out of so many documents that speak on the Eucharist. Yes, I have read many of them and have searched for the word physical with regard to the Eucharist and it is clearly avoided by the Church. Sacramental is the proper word for the prescence of Christ. I believe there are even problems with the terminology "spiritual prescence". Again this is a matter that I need to look in to further.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...