Dave Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 (edited) Of course, canonizations are considered infallible by the Church. So what if a Catholic refuses to accept a given canonized person as a saint? Wouldn't that be sinful? And would it be heresy or just grave disobedience? I ask this question because I've heard of extreme traditionalist (non-sedevacantist) Catholics who reject certain canonizations for whatever reason. St. Josemaria Escriva is one saint whose canonization some don't accept. I also know a guy who refuses to consider St. Faustina a saint. I have no idea why. Edited January 2, 2008 by Dave
catholicinsd Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 Well even if the Church declares an apparition to be of the Dvine, it is still up each Catholic to form their own opinion of it. I suspect it the same case with canonizations.
Dave Posted January 2, 2008 Author Posted January 2, 2008 There's a huge difference between the two. While the Church can judge apparitions to be "worthy of belief," it doesn't claim infallibility in the matter. It's different with canonizations. The Church teaches that canonizations are infallible.
Didymus Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 but with apparitions, the Church approves them to be honored, whereas with canonizations, the Church declares the deceased to be in heaven...
Mercy me Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 With apparitions, the Church declares them not contradictory to Church teaching. That is different from honoring them. That is partly why Divine Mercy was so unusual. Please correct me if I am wrong.
mortify Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 Interesting question, not sure but you almost wonder why the late Pope JP2 canonized so many people.
goldenchild17 Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 [quote name='Dave' post='1441116' date='Jan 1 2008, 10:35 PM']Of course, canonizations are considered infallible by the Church. So what if a Catholic refuses to accept a given canonized person as a saint? Wouldn't that be sinful? And would it be heresy or just grave disobedience? I ask this question because I've heard of extreme traditionalist (non-sedevacantist) Catholics who reject certain canonizations for whatever reason. St. Josemaria Escriva is one saint whose canonization some don't accept. I also know a guy who refuses to consider St. Faustina a saint. I have no idea why.[/quote] St. Alphonsus Liguori, The Great Means of Salvation and Perfection, 1759, p. 23: “To suppose that the Church can err in canonizing, is a sin, or is heresy, according to St. Bonaventure, Bellarmine, and others; or at least next door to heresy, according to Suarez, Azorius, Gotti, etc.; because the Sovereign Pontiff, according to St. Thomas, is guided by the infallible influence of the Holy Ghost in an especial way when canonizing saints.” St. Thomas says: "Since the honour we pay the saints is in a certain sense a profession of faith, i.e., a belief in the glory of the Saints [quâ sanctorum gloriam credimus] we must piously believe that in this matter also the judgment of the Church is not liable to error." [u] The Catechism Explained - An Exhaustive Explanation of the Catholic Religion[/u] Spirago-Clark, Copyright 1899. - "Any mistake in either beatifying or canonizing seems well-nigh impossible even on natural grounds, on account of the strict examination insisted on. By the act of canonization, the veneration of a saint, and so to a certain extent the acknowledgment of the Church's belief in him, is imposed on the faithful, and he is then officially recognized in the Church's offices, as in the Mass and Breviary; hence if any one not a saint were declared holy, the whole Church would approve an error. Such a supposition is impossible. Pope Benedict XIV. declares his own experience in these cases of the assistance of the Holy Spirit in removing insuperable difficulties which beset a process, or, on the other hand, in breaking it off entirely. Finally the Church in its decisions whether of beatification or canonization is dealing with things which have the closest connection with doctrine of faith or morals." 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia at New Advent: "[b]PAPAL INFALLIBILITY AND CANONIZATION[/b] Is the pope infallible in issuing a decree of canonization? Most theologians answer in the affirmative. It is the opinion of St. Antoninus, Melchior Cano, Suarez, Bellarmine, Bañez, Vasquez, and, among the canonists, of Gonzales Tellez, Fagnanus, Schmalzgrüber, Barbosa, Reiffenstül, Covarruvias (Variar. resol., I, x, no 13), Albitius (De Inconstantiâ in fide, xi, no 205), Petra (Comm. in Const. Apost., I, in notes to Const. I, Alex., III, no 17 sqq.), Joannes a S. Thomâ (on II-II, Q. I, disp. 9, a. 2), Silvester (Summa, s. v. Canonizatio), Del Bene (De Officio Inquisit. II, dub. 253), and many others. In Quodlib. IX, a. 16, St. Thomas says: "Since the honour we pay the saints is in a certain sense a profession of faith, i.e., a belief in the glory of the Saints [quâ sanctorum gloriam credimus] we must piously believe that in this matter also the judgment of the Church is not liable to error." These words of St. Thomas, as is evident from the authorities just cited, all favouring a positive infallibility, have been interpreted by his school in favour of papal infallibility in the matter of canonization, and this interpretation is supported by several other passages in the same Quodlibet. This infallibility, however according to the holy doctor, is only a point of pious belief. Theologians generally agree as to the fact of papal infallibility in this matter of canonization, but disagree as to the quality of certitude due to a papal decree in such matter. In the opinion of some it is of faith (Arriaga, De fide, disp. 9, p. 5, no 27); others hold that to refuse assent to such a judgment of the Holy See would be both impious and rash, as Francisco Suárez (De fide, disp. 5 p. 8, no 8); many more (and this is the general view) hold such a pronouncement to be theologicallycertain, not being of Divine Faith as its purport has not been immediately revealed, nor of ecclesiastical Faith as having thus far not been defined by the Church. What is the object of this infallible judgment of the pope? Does he define that the person canonized is in heaven or only that he has practiced Christian virtues in an heroic degree? I have never seen this question discussed; my own opinion is that nothing else is defined than that the person canonized is in heaven. The formula used in the act of canonization has nothing more than this: "In honour of . . . we decree and define that Blessed N. is a Saint, and we inscribe his name in the catalogue of saints, and order that his memory by devoutly and piously celebrated yearly on the . . . day of . . . his feast." (Ad honorem . . . beatum N. Sanctum esse decernimus et definimus ac sanctorum catalogo adscribimus statuentes ab ecclesiâ universali illius memoriam quolibet anno, die ejus natali . . . piâ devotione recoli debere.) There is no question of heroic virtue in this formula; on the other hand, sanctity does not necessarily imply the exercise of heroic virtue, since one who had not hitherto practised heroic virtue would, by the one transient heroic act in which he yielded up his life for Christ, have justly deserved to be considered a saint. This view seems all the more certain if we reflect that all the arguments of theologians for papal infallibility in the canonization of saints are based on the fact that on such occasions the popes believe and assert that the decision which they publish is infallible (Pesch, Prael. Dogm., I, 552). This general agreement of theologians as to papal infallibility in canonization must not be extended to beatification, not withstanding the contrary teaching of the canonical commentary known as "Glossa" [in cap. un. de reliquiis et venerat. SS. (III, 22) in 6; Innocent., Comm. in quinque Decretalium libros, tit. de reliquiis, etc., no 4; Ostiensis in eumd. tit. no 10; Felini, cap. lii, De testibus, etc., X (II, 20); Caietani, tract. De indulgentiis adversus Lutherum ad Julium Mediceum; Augustini de Ancona, seu Triumphi, De potestate eccl., Q. xiv, a. 4). Canonists and theologians generally deny the infallible character of decrees of beatification, whether formal or equivalent, since it is always a permission, not a command; while it leads to canonization, it is not the last step. Moreover, in most cases, the cultus permitted by beatification, is restricted to a determined province, city, or religious body (Benedict XIV, op. cit., I, xlii). Some, however, have thought otherwise (Arriaga, Theol., V, disp. 7, p. 6; Amicus, Theol., IV, disp. 7, p.4, no 98; Turrianus on II-II, V, disp. 17, no 6; Del Bene, De S. Inquisit. II, dub. 254). "
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 [quote name='Dave' post='1441116' date='Jan 2 2008, 05:35 AM']Of course, canonizations are considered infallible by the Church. So what if a Catholic refuses to accept a given canonized person as a saint? Wouldn't that be sinful? And would it be heresy or just grave disobedience? I ask this question because I've heard of extreme traditionalist (non-sedevacantist) Catholics who reject certain canonizations for whatever reason. St. Josemaria Escriva is one saint whose canonization some don't accept. I also know a guy who refuses to consider St. Faustina a saint. I have no idea why.[/quote] I have heard people who call themselves traditionalists or arch-traditionalists saying similar things about more modern saints and blesseds, particularly Mother Teresa. They are concerned that her life was not orthodox enough for her to be truly holy. All a canonization means is that we know for sure that that person is in Heaven. It tells us more about God's mercy than it does about the particular saint. When you look at a saint's life and death, you should be able to see that mercy at work, transforming them, animating them. In spite of their personal faults and sins, saints remain open to grace, always turning back to God, always saying 'yes' to Him. To suggest that a saint can't be 'real' because they weren't holy enough when alive is to cast doubt on the power and glory of God, as it involves focusing on people's sins and errors over and above the transforming love of God. But I don't think this doubt is unique to traditionalists. It has being going on ever since Christianity began. Lots of people doubted Jesus because His holiness didn't manifest in the way that they expected. We're all capable of such presumptuous thought, and we all reject Jesus in certain things - yes, this is Him, this is Him, that is Him, that and that and that...but not [i]this[/i]. It amounts to the same thing as deciding that such a person could not possibly be in Heaven.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 Disagreeing with a canonization is saying we know better and have more facts than the Church who spent years studying that particular persons life. As in most cases with trads, it is simply refusing to trust the Church and the Grace of God more than our own opinions. It is in fact being protestant ,not catholic, in your thinking.
HotRod Posted January 2, 2008 Posted January 2, 2008 Basically, any non-sedevacantist Catholic who doesn't believe the Infallibility of the Pope they claim to follow, seems to be, in my lay opinion, in heresy. Refusing to honor I can see, but refusing to believe that person is a saint? who would actually refute that St. Faustina is in Heaven? Or that Mother Theresa is? Maybe they are sedevacantist after all?
st-annes Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 (edited) If someone does not have to accept the validity of a canonization, what else can adding someone to the canon possibly mean? If a person decides he or she knows better than the rest of the church, there is a serious problem. What would be the point of continuing to call yourself part of that church? I don't understand who could have an issue with the life of a saint. Edited January 3, 2008 by st-annes
Dismas Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1441182' date='Jan 2 2008, 06:15 AM']I have heard people who call themselves traditionalists or arch-traditionalists saying similar things about more modern saints and blesseds, particularly Mother Teresa. They are concerned that her life was not orthodox enough for her to be truly holy.[/quote] Hmmm.... [quote name='Gospel According to Luke:18:9-14 (RSV)']9 He also told this parable to some who trusted in themselves that they were righteous and despised others: 10 "Two men went up into the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. 11 The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, `God, I thank thee that I am not like other men, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. 12 I fast twice a week, I give tithes of all that I get.' 13 But the tax collector, standing far off, would not even lift up his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, `God, be merciful to me a sinner!' 14 I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for every one who exalts himself will be humbled, but he who humbles himself will be exalted."[/quote]
Socrates Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1441213' date='Jan 2 2008, 11:16 AM']Disagreeing with a canonization is saying we know better and have more facts than the Church who spent years studying that particular persons life. As in most cases with trads, it is simply refusing to trust the Church and the Grace of God more than our own opinions. It is in fact being protestant ,not catholic, in your thinking.[/quote] [quote name='HotRod' post='1441337' date='Jan 2 2008, 07:54 PM']Basically, any non-sedevacantist Catholic who doesn't believe the Infallibility of the Pope they claim to follow, seems to be, in my lay opinion, in heresy. Refusing to honor I can see, but refusing to believe that person is a saint? who would actually refute that St. Faustina is in Heaven? Or that Mother Theresa is? Maybe they are sedevacantist after all?[/quote] [quote name='st-annes' post='1441346' date='Jan 2 2008, 08:41 PM']If someone does not have to accept the validity of a canonization, what else can adding someone to the canon possibly mean? If a person decides he or she knows better than the rest of the church, there is a serious problem. What would be the point of continuing to call yourself part of that church? I don't understand who could have an issue with the life of a saint. [/quote] Exactly. This self-righteous, hyper-critical, and excessively negative accusatory attitude is one of the most sickening attributes of certain extreme groups of self-styled "Trads." They are forever accusing and tearing down others - the Pope, Mother Theresa, Mother Angelica, canonized saints - few can live up to their standards of of "holiness." They seem to thrive on every manner of scandal and calumny. Is Satan not known as "The Great Accuser"? Judge not, lest ye be judged yourself.
goldenchild17 Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 (edited) Edited January 3, 2008 by goldenchild17
corban711 Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1441166' date='Jan 2 2008, 03:38 AM']Interesting question, not sure but you almost wonder why the late Pope JP2 canonized so many people.[/quote] my thought has always been that JPII really wanted the world to see that 1.) saints still exist (especially in modern times) and 2.) by seeing the possibility of becoming saints in our own times, we will have the hope and courage to strive to become saints ourselves. i always thought it was quite beautiful that he canonized so many.
corban711 Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Dave' post='1441116' date='Jan 2 2008, 12:35 AM']I ask this question because I've heard of extreme traditionalist (non-sedevacantist) Catholics who reject certain canonizations for whatever reason. St. Josemaria Escriva is one saint whose canonization some don't accept. I also know a guy who refuses to consider St. Faustina a saint. I have no idea why.[/quote] my guess would be that these "traditionalists" have a great dislike for JPII, or in some cases even believe him to be guilty of heresy, so they will pretty much distrust all of his decisions and so reject the saints they personally don't like. Edited January 3, 2008 by corban711
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now