Falcon Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 I do not want to get into the topic of abortion or Pro-life here....Please understand.... My issue is this, I do not believe in abortion. As a Catholic I know it is wrong (MY OPINION). My wife is currently pregnant with twins and we were advised to go for "genetic testing". Basically they can test both babies and if they should find that 1 is not going to make it, they can end that baby to improve the second one. First, this is not the case for us but it is on my mind since talked to by the doctors. Second, would it be wrong if that were the case and we decided to end the 1 for the life of the second? PLEASE PLEASE keep this adult and not get into any kind of political conversation. Thanks
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 "Ending it" for that baby would be abortion, which is murder, so yeah, it's absolutely wrong. Other than that I'm really nut sure what sort of answer you're looking for....
Deb Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 Just think that there are two souls already in the womb. I would recommend not even having the test and letting God do as he wills unless you are are willing to make a decision like you are thinking of. I will pray for you.
MIKolbe Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 Yes, it would be wrong. If you need someone to talk to, PM me. You, your wife, and your two children will be in my prayers. - MIKolbe
Totus Tuus Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 Always remember that while it may look like one baby "won't make it", only God should decide whether the baby will or not. It's not up to us to end a life - God's Providence takes care of that for us! If the baby lives, it was his holy will; if not, it was his will. To add a bit of encouragement, I have heard many, many stories of mothers whose babies were not supposed to "make it" based on prenatal testing, and their babies not only survived, but were normal and healthy. Prayers are headed your way! Lauren
cmotherofpirl Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 [quote name='Falcon' post='1441537' date='Jan 3 2008, 09:24 AM']I do not want to get into the topic of abortion or Pro-life here....Please understand.... My issue is this, I do not believe in abortion. As a Catholic I know it is wrong (MY OPINION). My wife is currently pregnant with twins and we were advised to go for "genetic testing". Basically they can test both babies and if they should find that 1 is not going to make it, they can end that baby to improve the second one. First, this is not the case for us but it is on my mind since talked to by the doctors. Second, would it be wrong if that were the case and we decided to end the 1 for the life of the second? PLEASE PLEASE keep this adult and not get into any kind of political conversation. Thanks[/quote] Unless you are gonna agree to murder one or both of the children if they are defective, why have the test in the first place? You cannnot murder one child to save another. You cannot murder children to save the life of the mother. The end does not justify the means. Children born with something wrong with their bodies still have perfect little souls from God, and that is what you are responsible for. My first pregnancy resulted in one twin alive and one miscarried along the way. My next 2 pregnancies were perfect. Forget the test, have a happy pregnancy, and accept the children God has chosen for you.
Mary-Kathryn Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 Dear Falcon, What you need more than anything right now is the ear of a compassionate priest. Please, please go talk to one you and your wife are comfortable with. He will guide you and help you through. many prayers for you and the babies!
prose Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 No, it would not be legitimate to kill one for the other. However, I do believe that if one is dying or will cause the other to die it may be okay to give birth like as in the moral type of completing a tubal pregnancy. It is not to cause death, but to ensure survival. I, personally, have always gotten the genetic testing with both pregnancies and I would do it again. I liked the option of being able to prepare myself if I am to be raising a child with disabilities, and if I was carrying twins, I would like to be able to prepare myself should it be the case that one is likely to pass away in utero. That is my own opinion though. Others (obviously) feel otherwise.
Adrestia Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 Do they have reason to believe that your wife is at a higher risk for adverse genetic mutations? Or do they just screen all multiples? Is there a vascular issue? If the doctor has no specific reason to suspect a genetic condition I would consider skipping the test altogether. Medical explanation below, if you want it. As for the question of selective abortion... I can't imagine doing it... but I've never had to face that decision. - warning - medical speak below, skip if you don't like big words - There is a significant amount of data that indicates the [i]in utero[/i] death of one [u]monochorionic[/u] twin can adversely affect the surviving twin to a great degree. That's not necessarily the case with [u]dichorionic[/u] twins. Monochorionic twins are also monozygotic - so they should have the same genes - so I don't see why genetic testing would be indicated. If the twins are dichorionic the risk to the surviving child is low - so I don't see why genetic testing would be indicated. I'm not a perinatologist so please don't consider my opinion to carry any more weight that any other phatmasser.
HotRod Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 I am really undecided about the testing process I have 4 children, and each time they ask us if we want to do all these tests, part of me says, ok, I want to know if there is a problem, as I would need to make different preparations, but on the other hand, the underlying motivation for the test's in the first place seems to be, for them to let you know if you should consider an abortion. And when that fact is pondered, it sickens me to think that the doctor would think I would EVER consider that.
Totus Tuus Posted January 3, 2008 Posted January 3, 2008 I don't know how the testing is done these days with all the new technology, but are we talking amniocentesis? Isn't that procedure a really high risk in the first place? I have heard about the procedure itself causing a lot of problems to unborn children. I wonder if any Church authorities have made statements on genetic testing? Our current Holy Father is very scientifically-minded so it would be a real blessing to get his thoughts some time.
beata_virgo_maria Posted January 4, 2008 Posted January 4, 2008 Doctors often don't tell you that these tests can [u]cause[/u] miscarriages and other complications. With Amniocentesis there is a 1- 3% chance you will have a miscarriage, and with Chorionic Villus Sampling (CVS) there is a 1- 5% chance of a miscarriage, and there are also side effects like higher rates of preterm birth, limb and facial deformities, cervical lacerations, and maternal infection. (However, keep in mind I'm not doctor, this is just information I learned in my medical classes.) 1. NIH, "Diagnostic Ultrasound Imaging in Pregnancy," Consensus Development Conference Statement 5, no. 1 (1984, Washington, DC). 2. World Health Organization, "Diagnostic Ultrasound in Pregnancy, WHO View on Routine Screening," Lancet 2 (1984): 361.
Adrestia Posted January 4, 2008 Posted January 4, 2008 Amniocentesis is not [i]that[/i] dangerous. The sources below are updated routinely. from [url="http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/6937"]http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/6937[/url] "The best estimate of the risk of miscarriage related to amniocentesis performed under ultrasound guidance is 0.8%" For CVS, see [url="http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/7849"]http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/7849[/url] "For every 100 women who undergo CVS, approximately one woman will have a miscarriage as a result of the procedure."
beata_virgo_maria Posted January 4, 2008 Posted January 4, 2008 (edited) It depends on the study you look at. Also on the doctor, etc. They very at about 1% to 3-4% miscarriage rates, which would coincide with the studies you posted. Edited January 4, 2008 by beata_virgo_maria
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 4, 2008 Posted January 4, 2008 [quote name='HotRod' post='1441672' date='Jan 3 2008, 04:32 PM']I am really undecided about the testing process I have 4 children, and each time they ask us if we want to do all these tests, part of me says, ok, I want to know if there is a problem, as I would need to make different preparations, but on the other hand, the underlying motivation for the test's in the first place seems to be, for them to let you know if you should consider an abortion. And when that fact is pondered, it sickens me to think that the doctor would think I would EVER consider that.[/quote] Yeah, thats part of the reason why I have always refused the tests. I know no matter what I am keeping that baby so knowing in advance doesn't really change much for me. I can understand why Prose and others would opt to have it done to prepare in the event that their child did have an illness that they would need to deal with.... but for me I find them pointless. From what I've heard from other mothers more often than not IF you end up with a positive on the first test its a false positive and you have to go through further, more invasive testing only to show that there was nothing wrong in the first place. No thanks. As long as its optional I refuse.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 4, 2008 Posted January 4, 2008 MDs told my SIL that her baby was defective and tried to schedule an abortion. My niece enters Wheeling college this year.
let_go_let_God Posted January 4, 2008 Posted January 4, 2008 I could never get the testings done period. Not only because for the risk of a miscarriage, but also my massive fear of needles. [quote name='tgoldson' post='1441875' date='Jan 3 2008, 10:26 PM']Amniocentesis is not [i]that[/i] dangerous. The sources below are updated routinely. from [url="http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/6937"]http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/6937[/url] "The best estimate of the risk of miscarriage related to amniocentesis performed under ultrasound guidance is 0.8%" For CVS, see [url="http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/7849"]http://patients.uptodate.com/topic.asp?file=pregnan/7849[/url] "For every 100 women who undergo CVS, approximately one woman will have a miscarriage as a result of the procedure."[/quote] As for the numbers above, I shutter at the thought. The math is easy. For the first test that eight out of 1000 mothers will miscarry due to amniocentesis with an ultrasound. In my opinion that is eight children too many and for CVS to expand it to 1000 is still 10 children out of 1000. Between the two testings that's 18 children who died at the hands of these tests. The numbers I would want to see though are those in regards to how many "positive" results are given and how many abortions are preformed based on them. God bless- LGLG
Falcon Posted January 7, 2008 Author Posted January 7, 2008 Update..... We did not and have not even planned to have the genetic test done. We placed our babies lives in the hands of God. My post was to better understand how it would be viewed "IF" this were to happen. Thanks God we do not have to face anything like this and pray no one ever does. Thank you everyone. Vivat Jesus.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1442013' date='Jan 4 2008, 07:15 PM']MDs told my SIL that her baby was defective and tried to schedule an abortion. My niece enters Wheeling college this year.[/quote] My parents were offered an abortion for me on the same grounds. The doctors were right on one count - I am disabled. But disabled does not equal defective. No one is 'defective'. And while there are many basic things that I am unable to do, I don't see why that would justify a killing. I really don't understand how a society that talks about equal opportunities for everybody discriminates against children in the womb on grounds of disability and illness. In April I am going to Downing Street with some other young disabled authors to attend a function for children who share our disabilities. I really wish that the doctors who urged my mother to abort me could also go. Despite being medical professionals, there is a lot that they obviously don't realise about disability. [quote name='Falcon' post='1442955' date='Jan 7 2008, 03:47 PM']Update..... We did not and have not even planned to have the genetic test done. We placed our babies lives in the hands of God. My post was to better understand how it would be viewed "IF" this were to happen. Thanks God we do not have to face anything like this and pray no one ever does. Thank you everyone. Vivat Jesus.[/quote] Edited January 7, 2008 by Cathoholic Anonymous
Archaeology cat Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1442979' date='Jan 7 2008, 04:34 PM']But disabled does not equal defective. No one is 'defective'. And while there are many basic things that I am unable to do, I don't see why that would justify a killing. I really don't understand how a society that talks about equal opportunities for everybody discriminates against children in the womb on grounds of disability and illness.[/quote] Excellent point!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now