Ziggamafu Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 Has anyone read this little book by (then) Ratzinger, [i]Daughter Zion[/i]? I just finished it and it was quite good. However, I wondered how many B16 fans found his treatment of the Assumption of Mary to be theologically questionable. After reading his thoughts, I was more or less fine with what he said (but I'm one of his fan-boys). Basically, he seems to remove the dogma of the Assumption from a literal / historical context and instead places it into a strictly theological context, arguing that the Assumption is actually an extraordinarily grand canonization. He doesn't outright say that the Assumption was [b]not [/b]a literal event in history, but that is the very clear implication. If nobody has read this and needs more clarification, I'll bust out the book and transcribe relevant sections when I have time. Just curious if anybody has thought about this.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 I have not read the book lately but I did find it to be a very good essay back in the day. I do recall that the book ended with some ambiguity and a questionable bracketing of historicity in the discussion of the Assumption. I have read some of the scholarship that forms the context of this essay and I must say that even with the shortcomings it is a breath of fresh air for that time. I should probably find my copy of the text before I spout off about it but I would suggest that the little book was not meant to be a comprehensive treatment of the subjects and that the scholarly context of the time could explain some of the strange methodology. As an example I seem to recall that in the 1993 supplement of Brown's [i]Birth of the Messiah[/i] (originally published in the late seventies) Brown mentions Ratzinger's book as one of the sources since the original publication of his tome that have caused him to revise some of his views (in particular he is much more favorable to the Daughter Zion typology in the supplement). If I consider Ratzinger's methodology in light of Brown's views of the late seventies I might infer that the intention is to change the trajectory of the discussion a bit in order to look at some of the issues in a new way. I could see how there might be some wisdom in bracketing the historical discussion if the intended audience is scholars such as Brown, especially when I call to mind the way in which these topics were dealt with in the literature of the late seventies and early eighties (yuck!). As long as it is understood that the essay is not the whole story on the Assumption or the final word I don't think this is necessarily a problem. [i]Daughter Zion [/i]was a contribution to a set of bigger discussions being carried out through the works of various scholars. Of course it is a short and accessible text that can be read by laymen with profit, but as with most of Ratzinger’s books the concerns of contemporary theology in general are present in some fashion. Again, I'll have to review the text before speaking on it in any depth but I was quite interested in these subjects several years ago and I still have some impressions floating around in my mind.
qfnol31 Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 I would personally ask what we mean by the Assumption before asking about the historicity. I don't think the Holy Father ever denies the fact that Mary is in Heaven both body and soul, which is in fact the dogma of the Assumption: [quote]We pronounce, declare, and define it to be a divinely revealed dogma: [b]that the Immaculate Mother of God, the ever Virgin Mary, having completed the course of her earthly life, was assumed body and soul into heavenly glory.[/b][/quote] I must confess I never finished the book and it's been a couple of years since I read it, but I think I remember him upholding this truth.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 I just found my copy of the book and reread the final section on the Assumption. I completely disagree with your summary of his treatment here. "[i]He seems to remove the dogma of the Assumption from a literal / historical context and instead places it into a strictly theological context[/i]." This is very inaccurate in my opinion because you seem to be confusing historicity, as Ratzinger is using it in his discussion, with the idea of a literal or actual event, and similarly I believe you may be confusing 'theological' with the made up or mythical. These dichotomies, and these ways of thinking in general, are not a part of Ratzinger's train of thought as I understand it. A better way of describing what he is doing (again, in my opinion) would be to say that unlike a doctrine such as the Resurrection of Christ, the doctrine of the Assumption, in its theological datum, is not inextricably historical. I think that the book as a whole is suggestive of this point. It is to suggest that seeking to ground this doctrine (or dogma) in specific witness to a concrete historical event would be a mistake since the content of the doctrine is rather founded upon its being written into the structure of revelation and elucidated by the life and devotion of the Church in history. It is an admittedly ecclesiological approach but it is perfectly consistent with the whole tone of the book. The early testimony to an historical event is considered apocryphal and the Scriptures are not seen as containing proof texts for the doctrine, and yet the whole complex of interwoven Marian themes and implications throughout the Bible (and revelation in the broadest sense) indicate this doctrine. There is nothing in any of this which ought to suggest that the doctrine is merely a fable or a pious legend, just that it has been revealed and passed down in a strictly theological way rather than as concrete historical witness. I still believe that the treatment is lacking - it never claims to be complete - but clearly (to my mind at least) there is no question of the truth of the dogma in this essay. Before the dogma was proclaimed its truth was implied and manifested by the veneration. I think this was a big part of Ratzinger’s distinction. He described the proclamation as itself an act of veneration – perhaps a crowning act of veneration – and I think this is entirely true. What is important theologically is the full content of what this doctrine expresses and implies about Our Lady, the work of God in the economy of salvation, and the Church - particularly in the eschatological mystery of Her life, et cetera. None of this means that there was not a real event two thousand years ago in which Our Lady was assumed body and soul (although we do not know how or when this happened); in fact this must have actually happened or else the doctrine is a lie. To simplify things one might say that the Church’s unique veneration of Our Lady has always expressed and passed down this doctrine, but unlike a doctrine that is explicitly proclaimed and rooted in a historical event it has been a mystery ever present within the heart of the Church, pondered silently and at times gazed upon directly. Does this not give at least some kind of closure to the essay as a whole? The Church’s veneration of Our Lady reflects the unity of the Old and New Testaments. The doctrine of the assumption is integral to the Marian dimension of Christian revelation that Ratzinger’s book has sought to explore. No doubt a big point made by the distinction in question is that it is not necessary to locate the doctrine in some ancient historical source like one might hope to prove the date of Plutarch’s death or Lucian’s place of birth. I admit that for me this somewhat agnostic approach to the historical data is unfortunate, but it is perhaps useful in this case since it is a very short treatment hoping to make a few salient points. What do you think?
qfnol31 Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 I'm just wondering, would it be fair to say that the book is a defense of the Assumption in the absense of a good historical accout of what happened at Mary's dormition? Also, what is the significance of the book being (originally) addressed to Bishops primarily? Does that change the way we read the book?
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1442969' date='Jan 7 2008, 12:06 PM']I'm just wondering, would it be fair to say that the book is a defense of the Assumption in the absense of a good historical accout of what happened at Mary's dormition? Also, what is the significance of the book being (originally) addressed to Bishops primarily? Does that change the way we read the book?[/quote] One thing I am sure of is that the book (originally a lecture I believe) was produced during a major low point for Marian Theology, namely the late 1970's. The mainstream fads of the time were extremely minimalistic and revisionary - even iconoclastic. There was some relatively good stuff of course (Laurentin produced some good works and I consider Ratzinger's little text to be good; there are really a host of good texts to be found but I am being most general here) but there was a lot of "ecumenical" Mariology and a particular brand of Biblical Mariology was in vogue (see John McHugh's popular book, R. Brown, Laurentin, Shurmann, et al. for examples). I must highlight the Biblical Mariology of the time because if one compares the mainstream trends of the 1950's to that of the 1970's the difference is staggering. 1950's Mariology tends to be tightly coupled to defined dogma and is generally systematic theology; 1970's Mariology is much more about redefining the foundations of Marian Theology in light of modern critical scholarship often with ecumenical aims. I'm being very general here but I believe that if one were simply to read through back issues of [i]Marian Studies[/i] from these decades they would see my point (although I must point out that some of my favorite works of Biblical Mariology are actually from the 1950's). Based on the above I would agree with your intuition that part of the aim of this book is most likely a vindication of the Church's Marian belief in the midst of an onslaught of heterodoxy or simply bad theological method. I don't know that the fact of the original audience being Bishops would change how I would read the text. The occasion to address Bishops may have inspired Ratzinger since Marian devotion had sustained a lot of attacks back then and there was often a good bit of confusion even among Bishops as to the limits of post-Vatican II theology and practice.
qfnol31 Posted January 7, 2008 Posted January 7, 2008 The biggest difference between addressing the lectures to Bishops and writing a book for a general audience is that you can assume a lot more with Bishops. For one, you can hopefully assume they're Catholic and not Protestant, etc.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1443003' date='Jan 7 2008, 02:24 PM']The biggest difference between addressing the lectures to Bishops and writing a book for a general audience is that you can assume a lot more with Bishops. For one, you can hopefully assume they're Catholic and not Protestant, etc.[/quote] Maybe I didn't understand your question. Those facts can certainly shed light on how the book is written et cetera but it still doesn't change much in terms of how I read and interpret the book. The background to a book such as [i]Mary in the New Testament[/i] (by Raymond Brown, Joseph Fitzmeyer, Karl Donfried, and John Reumann) would make me crank up the skepticism a few notches, but a book written by a solid Cardinal directed towards Bishops doesn't really cause me to adjust my default reading glasses.
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I agree. I don't think we have to change how we read it, but we're also Catholic. We can take a ton for granted. That means that he doesn't have to say the obvious when writing the book, which is different than his normal approach, which is more systematic and comprehensive. I'm not sure if this makes a difference, but I was wondering if the omission of certain teachings can be explained by this fact?
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1443892' date='Jan 10 2008, 12:22 AM']I agree. I don't think we have to change how we read it, but we're also Catholic. We can take a ton for granted. That means that he doesn't have to say the obvious when writing the book, which is different than his normal approach, which is more systematic and comprehensive. I'm not sure if this makes a difference, but I was wondering if the omission of certain teachings can be explained by this fact? [/quote] I see what you mean. While the book is published through Ignatius and is thus a book for the masses it is not exactly a catechetical text that will hold the reader's hand through all the nuances of the discussion. This is quite true. Having read some of the scholarship of the time that the book cites or alludes to I am in a position to understand that the book is essentially a defense of orthodox teaching, whereas a reader without any background might be shocked by some of the questions or simply misunderstand some of the points. Although the book covers a lot of ground in a very short amount of space I would say that the book is little more than a survey of the state of Marian theology in the late seventies with some hints at the proper direction with which to take on some of these issues. It would probably be cool to read this book along with [i]Mary: The Church at the Source[/i] to understand Ratzinger's POV a little better.
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I have that book, and when I'm done I'll let you know what I think.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1443930' date='Jan 10 2008, 01:54 AM']I have that book, and when I'm done I'll let you know what I think. [/quote] Sweet!
Ziggamafu Posted January 10, 2008 Author Posted January 10, 2008 I actually purchased [i]Daughter Zion[/i] because I enjoyed [i]Mary: the Church at the Source[/i] so much. Also relevant / associated texts: [i]Mary: God's Yes to Man[/i] (Redemptoris Mater with commentary by Balthasar and the introduction by Ratzinger included in [i]Mary: the Church at the Source[/i]) [i]Mary Today[/i] by Balthasar (published in the 80's)
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 12, 2008 Posted January 12, 2008 There have been a few sweet Marian essays in [i]Communio[/i] over the years too. I have a small collection of the older issues but many Catholic libraries have them all (such as FUS). I can dip into my collection and give specific issues if you're interested (unless someone else has the information handy).
Ziggamafu Posted January 12, 2008 Author Posted January 12, 2008 yeah, i just found it curious how the Assumption was presented in [i]Daughter Zion[/i]... I really think I'm going to transcribe a few bits when I get a long enough "moment"
phatcatholic Posted January 12, 2008 Posted January 12, 2008 I don't have the book, so I look forward to reading your transcriptions.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 13, 2008 Posted January 13, 2008 You can borrow my copy dude. It is only about 80 pages long btw so it shouldn't really cut into school. I heard you got a new sword! You should bring it with next time you come over for archery.
st-annes Posted January 13, 2008 Posted January 13, 2008 I haven't read it yet. I am planning to get to several of the Holy Father's books this year.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now