Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi, pham. As some of you might know, I came back to the Church this past April after spending some time in Protestantism and general apathy. I'm glad to be back (understatement), but there are still some things about Our Lady that trouble me.

So, let's talk about the Assumption.

Clearly, this is something not noted in Scripture, though others were taken to Heaven body and soul, like Elijah(?) and Noah's grandfather.

The doctrine that Mary was taken bodily into Heaven at the end of her life is something that Sacred Tradition says has been revealed to us through what we know about her already.

I know that we as Catholics believe Tradition to be just as viable as Sacred Scripture, but on what grounds do we make the claim of the Assumption? From where do we get our facts?

This is something I've struggled with, as nearly everything about the Faith is in the Bible. The things that aren't, like this, leave me feeling a little less than certain. I hope you can understand that. :) I know the Church wouldn't be making statements like this without a fair bit of reasoning--they wouldn't make things up just because--but I'd feel better if I knew where this is coming from.

Would anyone like to help me out? The thoughts of our clergy/religious/scholars on the board are especially welcome, but I've put the thread here so I can reply, and work things out as needed.

Thanks in advance!
Pax Christi,
Missy

goldenchild17
Posted

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0832.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0832.htm[/url]

Posted

This says the collection as a whole is an apocryphal work. That would mean it wasn't included in the Biblical canon, correct? Why, then, would it have any merit? We don't take any of our doctrines from the Gnostic Gospels...

Just curious.

Pax.

goldenchild17
Posted

This talks about it a little bit. See if it helps. If not I'll pull up something else for you. I'm going to also try and find some of the texts referenced on this page but no promises :).

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02006b.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02006b.htm[/url]

Posted

Since the times of the Early Church Fathers Mary has been called the ark of the covenant. There are many similarities between the ark of the covenant in the Old Testament and Mary in the new. For instance, the ark was holy because it contained the tablets on which the commandments were written (the word of God), some manna which kept God's people alive (the bread of life) and the rod of Aaron (the priesthood) all of which were made perfect in Christ. And when they had the ark they believed that God was with them. In the New Testament we see The Word of God, the Bread of life and the High Priest all dwelling in the womb of Mary...the carrier of Emmanuel (God with us). But in the book of Revelation, at the end of Chapters 11 through Chapter 12, John says that he saw the ark..."Then God's temple in heaven was opened, and the ark of His covenant was seen...A great portent appeared in heaven, a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars; she was with child" John tells us that this child "is to rule all the nations with a rod of iron" which is a reference to Psalm 2:9, a psalm prophecying the messianic king to come. The child the woman is giving birth to is Christ and the woman is clearly Mary. Right after John says he saw the ark of the covenant (which had been missing for centuries) he describes the woman clearly pointing to her as the ark.

if you want to read more about Mary in Scripture a good starting point could be reading "Hail, Holy Queen: The Mother of God in the Word of God" by Scott Hahn. Also "Catholic for a Reason II: Scripture and the Mystery of the Mother of God" edited by Leon Suprenant Jr.

withouthavingseen
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1443007' date='Jan 7 2008, 02:47 PM']Hi, pham. As some of you might know, I came back to the Church this past April after spending some time in Protestantism and general apathy. I'm glad to be back (understatement), but there are still some things about Our Lady that trouble me.[/quote]

Welcome home, Missy!

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1443007' date='Jan 7 2008, 02:47 PM']I know that we as Catholics believe Tradition to be just as viable as Sacred Scripture, but on what grounds do we make the claim of the Assumption? From where do we get our facts?

This is something I've struggled with, as nearly everything about the Faith is in the Bible. The things that aren't, like this, leave me feeling a little less than certain. I hope you can understand that. :) I know the Church wouldn't be making statements like this without a fair bit of reasoning--they wouldn't make things up just because--but I'd feel better if I knew where this is coming from.[/quote]

Ah, Missy. A better question would really be "Where do we get [i]the Bible[/i] from?" Huh? It's one of those questions we never ask because we just take the answer for granted. God.

Right. But how did it get to us? How was it written, edited, compiled into a single book, translated, and handed down from generation to generation to us? Well, I've tipped my hand. "Handed down" in Latin is [i]traditus[/i], and a handing-down of something is a [i]traditio[/i]. The Sacred Scripture isn't [i]just as viable[/i] as the Tradition; it is [i]part of[/i] the Tradition. That's a lot to digest, especially for Protestants who are used to positing Scripture over and against Tradition. But the dichotomy is false. Scripture never contradicts tradition because it is part of it. Catholic bishops in the 2nd - 4th century, and finally only in the 16th century (!) solidified the canon of what goes in the Bible and what doesn't. Anything that didn't fit in with the whole, they would have filtered out - like the filtered out the gnostic "gospels" as you mentioned.

That Tradition includes a lot more beyond the Sacred Scriptures that are very important but not part of the Sacred Scriptures: how to celebrate Mass, how to deal with persecuting kings, what color we like to dress Mary in, and so on. Some of the things are trivial, others not; some changeable, others not. But it is all handed down to us, generation after generation, by the Apostles and their successors under the action of the Holy Spirit, whom Jesus promised would lead us into all truth (Jn 16:13) as we have become able to take it (Jn 16:12). The Scriptures themselves are a sort of crystallization of our collective memory, a sort of Judeo-Christian family scrapbook. It has a special inspiration that makes it inerrant (correct in all the ways it was intended to be).

In St. Augustine's words, Christ is present in all the Scriptures, the whole of Scriptures speak of Christ, "In the Old, He is hidden; in the New, He is manifest." The Scriptures are primarily about Jesus. Which is why you don't find in them a compiled and orderly set of instructions for how to be a good Christian technical writer. It's not about that. And the Scriptures aren't primarily about Mary, either. They discuss her only inasmuch as her and Jesus' lives intersect (which is a lot), but after His Ascension, she is not having a fleshly-earthly-normal-humanly interaction with Him any more than we are. Her Assumption comes after that point, thematically, and so isn't included or discussed. In some sense, its not relevant. In another sense, her Assumption is everything.

Whoopee for Jesus: He can go bodily to heaven. Yay. He's GOD! Of course He can. But can a human-merely-being do the same? Is that what He meant by all of His promises? Will He keep His promises?

The Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary is the emphatic answer to those questions: Yes. And so her Assumption becomes for us a sign of hope that God's promises, whose fulfillment has begun in Christ, will continue in us.

That's why the Church emphasizes the Assumption, aside from the fact that it actually happened.

But how do we KNOW it happened? The same way we know all the rest of it happened. Generation after generation, moms, dads, grandmas, uncles, godfathers, teachers, priests, neighbors have taught their children, grandchildren, nieces, godchildren, students, flocks, and friends these things that they heard from their own forebears. And from time to time, as the memory seems to be growing fainter, God renews our faith, hope, and love by miracles, apparitions, and other graces. From time to time, martyrs shed their blood rather than renouncing one little iota of God's revelation, not even an Assumption will be forgotten, strengthening our faith, aiding our hope, and building our love of brethren and God. These things reassure us that, from His first coming until His second, God has not forgotten us, and the strengthen us to wait in joyful hope.

Try reading the Apostolic Constitution, [i]Ineffabilis Deus[/i], that confirmed the Immaculate Conception as a dogma whose belief is to be held by all Christians:
[url="http://www.papalencyclicals.net/Pius09/p9ineff.htm"]http://www.papalencyclicals.net/Pius09/p9ineff.htm[/url].

God bless, Missy.

Posted

Corban, thanks a lot for your insight. I know that the Assumption is an infallible teaching, and I'm trying to understand and accept it. Trust me, I'm not trying to be a stubborn mule. ;)

The parallels that exist between the Old and New Testaments are huge, and enlightening. The bit about the woman in Revelations is what I put my faith in.

Still, I find myself unfulfilled and uncertain. Why do we take an apocryphal statement and base a doctrine on it?

Can anyone find for me when this statement was made? Don't they, I don't know, explain why they're saying it?

Forgive me if I said put off and desperate--but this is an infallible issue. Struggling with it is obviously something I cannot risk.

Pax.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1444780' date='Jan 11 2008, 10:09 PM']Why do we take an apocryphal statement and base a doctrine on it?[/quote]
If you check out the thread on Ratzinger's book [i]Daughter Zion[/i] you will see that in this text Ratzinger makes it clear that the doctrine is not based on apocryphal sources. This book provides one approach to this doctrine but if you are highly interested in the subject I can recommend a great many phly texts on the subject.

Posted

I was in a debate a while back on the Assumption of Mary. Here's Part 3 in the debate, where I outline the evidence from Scripture and Tradition:

[url="http://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2006/09/debate-with-little-les-on-assumption_13.html"]http://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2006/09/d...umption_13.html[/url]

I hope that helps.

Pax Christi,
phatcatholic

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1445006' date='Jan 12 2008, 04:59 PM']I was in a debate a while back on the Assumption of Mary. Here's Part 3 in the debate, where I outline the evidence from Scripture and Tradition:

[url="http://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2006/09/debate-with-little-les-on-assumption_13.html"]http://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2006/09/d...umption_13.html[/url]

I hope that helps.

Pax Christi,
phatcatholic[/quote]
Haha, those were the days. :)

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1443007' date='Jan 7 2008, 01:47 PM']So, let's talk about the Assumption.

Clearly, this is something not noted in Scripture, though others were taken to Heaven body and soul, like Elijah(?) and Noah's grandfather.

The doctrine that Mary was taken bodily into Heaven at the end of her life is something that Sacred Tradition says has been revealed to us through what we know about her already.

I know that we as Catholics believe Tradition to be just as viable as Sacred Scripture, but on what grounds do we make the claim of the Assumption? From where do we get our facts?

This is something I've struggled with, as nearly everything about the Faith is in the Bible. The things that aren't, like this, leave me feeling a little less than certain. I hope you can understand that. :) I know the Church wouldn't be making statements like this without a fair bit of reasoning--they wouldn't make things up just because--but I'd feel better if I knew where this is coming from.

Would anyone like to help me out? The thoughts of our clergy/religious/scholars on the board are especially welcome, but I've put the thread here so I can reply, and work things out as needed.

Thanks in advance!
Pax Christi,
Missy[/quote]

I am willing to help, I am not fancy with quotes so I will quote your words:

“Is the Assumption in Sacred Scripture?” Explicitly no, but implicitly I say yes. Take a look at these:

Psalm
{3:6} I have slept, and I have been stupefied. But I awakened because the Lord has taken me up.
~I think this refers to the BVM's Dormition and Assumption

{131:7} We will enter into his tabernacle. We will adore in the place where his feet stood.
{131:8} Rise up, O Lord, into your resting place. You and the ark of your sanctification.
~here the 'resting place' is Heaven and the 'ark of your sanctification' is Mary

Were Enoch and Elias assumed into Heaven? I dont think so.

Genesis
{5:23} And all the days of Enoch that passed were three hundred and sixty-five years.
{5:24} And he walked with God, and then he was seen no more, because God took him.
2 Kings 2:11
{2:11} And as they went on, walking and talking together, behold, a fiery chariot and fiery horses parted them both asunder: and Elias went up by a whirlwind into heaven.

During Enoch's & Elias' times Christ had not yet ascended into Heaven and Mary had not been assumed into Heaven, therefore Enoch or Elias could not have ascended or been assumed into Heaven. in the verse about Elias Scripture refers to him as being taken to heaven, but I think this refers to the heavens in the sense of 'the sky'. Where did they go? I think they are the two prophets of Revelation (Rev 11:3) so I believe they were taken to a place (perhaps the Garden of Eden) to prepare them or perhaps they were taken by God into the future time during the events of Revelation.

"I know that we as Catholics believe Tradition to be just as viable as Sacred Scripture, but on what grounds do we make the claim of the Assumption? From where do we get our facts?"

From where do we get our facts?

Through Divine Revelation or Deposit of Faith found in three sources namely, Tradition, Scripture, and Magisterium.



Sacred Tradition is unwritten truths about faith and morals. Sacred Tradition is “the deeds wrought by God in the history of salvation.” Since these deeds were wrought by God, the deeds and their meaning are infallible.

“This plan of revelation is realized by deeds and words having an inner unity; the deeds wrought by God in the history of salvation manifest and confirm the teaching and realities signified by the words, while the words proclaim the deeds and clarify the mystery contained in them. By this revelation, then, the deepest truth about God and the salvation of man shines out for our sake in Christ, who is both mediator and the fullness of all revelation.” (Dei Verbum, 2)

~in the above "revelation" refers to the Sacred Deposit of Faith, "words" refers to Sacred Scripture, and "deeds" refers to Sacred Tradition.

The Assumption is a deed wrought by God in salvation history whereby the Blessed Virgin was taken up body and soul into Heaven. So the truth of the Assumption is contained in Sacred Tradition, the unwritten truths of the Divine Revelation and transmitted by the faithful through their words and deeds (not infallible in themselves) and also by the spiritual and liturgical life of the Church, and the prayers of the Church. The Assumption also may be contained implicitly in Sacred Scripture, which are the words written by God, in Salvation history. Both Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture is infallible since these are the deeds and word wrought and written by God,

Fortunately with the Assumption it was infallibly defined by the Magisterium, therefore we have to believe it. The Magisterium is an ability and authority, given as a gift to the whole Church, but exercised only by the Pope and the Bishops, to teach the truths of Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture. The Magisterium can only teach truths which are either explicit or implicit in Tradition or Scripture. And may under certain criteria teach infallibly the truths of Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture.

Hope this helps. Let me know if you have any questions on this post.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...