Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

My mom is the choir director for my parish. So when the old life-teen musicians quit for the same reason why I did not want to sing for it (forced to sing protestant praise and worship songs during Mass), my mom asked me if I wanted to do it. Out of obedience to my mom because she was getting kind of desperate, I decided to do the music for the teen Mass. I asked my fellow young choir people to do it with me and they said yes because they just follow me anyway. When we first started doing the music for the teen Mass, we did traditional songs such as "Holy God We Praise Thy Name", "Beautiful Savior", and "Ave Verum Corpus" by Mozart. The church was so loud because the songs we chose were simple enough that everyone else could sing along to it and our fake organ sounded beautiful even though it's, well, fake. Anyway, the life-teen minister and his "crew" complained about the music. Surprising isn't it? At first I was very upset and was going to quit but upon further consideration, I decided to stay because 1) I sing for God and no one else and I think God would knows it's not our fault we're singing protestant songs during a Catholic Mass, we're forced, 2) I was afraid that they would hire someone who is going to do an all-out rock concert during Mass (by the way, I am not paid as a cantor for my church and so is everyone else except for the people who play instruments), and 3) I just wanted to help my mom out. BUT the life-teen minister is going to force us to play electric guitar. They already forced us to sing protestant songs, and to add annoying drums, and now He wants us to have electric guitar as well?! We only have around 5 singers and we have 4 instrumentalists (whatever you want to call it), pianist, drummer, acoustic guitar player, and a bass player. I mean, if we add an electric guitar, the accompaniment will definitely over power the voices and it's just going to get louder, more distracting, and more annoying during the Mass.
So here's what I was thinking of doing. I asked Heather (one of our group member who's brother was asked to play the electric guitar... oh, and the life-teen ministers asks people to join our choir without telling the choir which , for me, is rude and disrespectful) to tell her brother to tell the life-teen minister (we'll call him Bob because I'm I don't want to type out "life-teen minister" anymore) that the choir will not have an electric guitar but if Bob has a problem with that, that he should come straight to us and not hide behind our "sister pastor" (this is a different story.. I'll explain it later) or run around us and avoid us. I'm sure he is going to say that the life-teen Mass is aimed for teens. Well, no duh but teens in my area don't really want rock music, they prefer rap. So should we have rap during Mass? I don't think so. Anyway, if Bob and his buddies really want electric guitar and if they keep whining about it, I would allow electric guitar for the entrance, offertory, and final hymn BUT we will chant the Gloria, Sanctus, Mortem Tuam, Amen, and the communion song.

I don't know if what I am planning on doing is the right thing to do or uncharitable. I guess I'm just very frustrated and I needed to let it out. I don't even know if I'm making any sense right now, oh well.
So, I need some advice on what my group should do.. Thanks guys.

About the "sister-pastor" comment earlier. I am in the San Bernardino Diocese here in CA and if you've read [i]Goodbye, Good Men[/i], you would know we have a nun as our vocations director and we have some parishes here that are run by nuns as well. I think they are called "Pastoral Coordinators". So they pretty much are the pastors of the parish (makes me cringe every time). My friends and I came up with the name "sister-pastors" for them.

Thanks for taking your time to read this.

Edited by doe-jo
Posted

aw. :( that's really tough.

what you talked about doing doesn't sound uncharitable to me. I would give advice, but I really don't know what would be right in that situation. but I'm sure there are plenty of people on here who will help you out. :)

I'll keep you in my prayers!

Posted

No advice from me. Just sympathy...and respect for you, that you are fighting the good fight for faithful Catholics who deserve a liturgy that isn't subject change from each passing fad.

Posted

A Lifeteen minister doesn't exactly have that much power, does he? I think he's overstepping his bounds, especially if he's *forcing* you to do it...plus, there's no reason for NEEDING to have *electric* guitar, you could technically do acoustic and it'd be less...disruptive...

Posted

It's possible to keep the volume of the electric guitar very low.

Maybe in the "spirit of Life Teen" you could "free style" or "remix" the generic praise and worship songs into Catholic songs...

That Chris Tomlin song - "How great is our God... sing with me... how great is our God..."
becomes "How great is our God... and mother Mary... how great is our God..."

Maybe you could suggest modern sounding Catholic songs... like the Crispin version of "When the Saints go marching in" where they have verses about the lives of different saints asking them to pray for us.
[url="http://www.crispinmusic.org/index.php?page=soundbooth"]http://www.crispinmusic.org/index.php?page=soundbooth[/url] - track 1 on Psalmba.

Keep praying for Bob... our Lord will help you deal with him.

Posted

[quote name='jiyoung' post='1444487' date='Jan 11 2008, 02:29 AM']A Lifeteen minister doesn't exactly have that much power, does he? I think he's overstepping his bounds, especially if he's *forcing* you to do it...plus, there's no reason for NEEDING to have *electric* guitar, you could technically do acoustic and it'd be less...disruptive...[/quote]
ditto

Posted

Sigh... That really smells of elderberries. I will keep you in my prayers this weekend. I hope it all works out.

As a youth minister, I would never DREAM of telling the music coordinator what to do.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1444553' date='Jan 11 2008, 09:24 AM']As a youth minister, I would never DREAM of telling the music coordinator what to do.[/quote]
no kidding.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1444553' date='Jan 11 2008, 11:24 AM']Sigh... That really smells of elderberries. I will keep you in my prayers this weekend. I hope it all works out.

As a youth minister, I would never DREAM of telling the music coordinator what to do.[/quote]

LoL! I've never been in such a situation, but I know VERY well that you should never tell the music coordinators/directors, etc. (the ones I know that is) what music to have.

Unfortunately, the Priests I know also know this. :(

Posted

Thanks for all the prayers and support guys.

Our youth minister doesn't have that kind of power but he always hides behind our "pastoral coordinator"and she backs him up. He pulls the whole but-life-teen-is-for-the-youth excuse which is true but our life-teen ministry is failing miserably. Less and less teens show up every week but this would a whole different topic.

And about lowering the volume of the electric guitar or not distorting the sound to make it sound more acoustic is a pretty good idea but we already have an acoustic guitar player. It would be useless and a waste of money to have another one.

Anyway, thanks for all the help guys. I am going to look into the modern catholic songs.

Posted

I sympathise as well. I am reluctant to give advice because I'm in a bit of a bad mood about my musical situation myself (though there isn't any cause for alarm, I'm just sorta bein' a chump). For the record, I'd just tell your mom that you're sick of hippy-pentecostal music and go from there. Tell those involved that Jesus is the one who reaches out to people, not the music. The efforts of trying to draw people to the mass (which is actually a problem, because it takes away from the liturgy and makes it a concert) is in vain because Jesus--the sacrifice on the altar--is the focal point.
Bring back the sacred music, I say! Because it does not seek to be the ornament but the wallpaper to a spacious room.

Btw, I'm sorta mad that I let my youth ministry call sacred music "classical music". I didn't wanna open up the music debate because we were sorting other things out that night, but I'm sorta upset I didn't correct them there... actually, it was the priest who first broadbrushed sacred music as "classical" music... sorry... it just bugs me as a musician... :pinch:

:sign: hope things turn out, Doe-jo.

Posted

don't let it bother you too much. If they throw an electric guitar in there, just try to stay joyful about everything even when you're dealin with some pigheaded folks. i know what you're goin through, and it's frustrating when people act like they know what the youth want. It just ticks me off...

Posted

Don't roll over. Some people are just asking to be put in their place. Ditch the drums too.

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

there are some good catholic contemporary musicians that might appeal to life teen folks like spirit and song dot com you dont need to go all out with electric guitars if it makes you uncomfortable.
I think the issue is that the songs seem out of touch with the youth around them. But i am not here taking sides.
Rock on homey g
shalom
bro mark menegatti osa

Posted

Could you sit down and have a (non-confrontational) talk with the youth minister, along the lines of trying to do what will be best for the youth? Let him share his vision, see where you can help, see what parts of it don't make sense and could be modified, explain some of your objections to various things (ex: too many instruments drown out the vocals, people join in singing the ones that everyone knows, etc) and see what kind of plan of action you can agree on and work together on. I wouldn't suggest saying that x,y, and z don't belong in the liturgy, especially not at the first meeting, because you want to establish a co-operative relationship. Focus more on what actually works for youth.

Posted

Some observations:
[quote]I asked my fellow young choir people to do it with me and they said yes because they just follow me anyway.[/quote]
You sound as though you might be a natural leader. Don't take this gift from God lightly. A leader should act with wisdom and compassion with all whom he deals with.

[quote]Anyway, the life-teen minister and his "crew" complained about the music. Surprising isn't it?[/quote]
I love PM, but I most definitely get a strong "anti LIFE TEEN" vibe from most members. While I might agree with some arguments about the ministry, your comment is phrased in such as way that it sounds as though you're opinion of LIFE TEEN is heavily slanted due to your participation here. If I am wrong, I humbly apologize.

[quote]if we add an electric guitar, the accompaniment will definitely over power the voices and it's just going to get louder, more distracting, and more annoying during the Mass.[/quote]
as others have said, if the sound is adjusted correctly, the type of equipment does not have to drown out the vocals. Also, being that I am in a parish where volunteers often seem scarce and we find ourselves begging for help, I would suggest you accept any help that comes your way. Who knows what ideas Heather's brother might bring to the table?

[quote]I asked Heather...to tell her brother to tell the life-teen minister...that the choir will not have an electric guitar but if [he] has a problem with that, that he should come straight to us and not hide behind our "sister pastor"...or run around us and avoid us.[/quote]
This goes back to the natural leader comment. The phrasing here sounds like a middle school kid scared to say anything to the bully's face. If you are concerned or upset with the direction the music is heading (and it certainly sounds that way), then YOU should approach "Bob" rather than waiting for him to come to you. As another poster suggested, you should arrange a meeting with "Bob", the sister-pastor, your mom, and yourself to discuss the direction you are heading. Remember that God loved His enemies. :)

[quote]I would allow electric guitar for the entrance, offertory, and final hymn BUT we will chant the Gloria, Sanctus, Mortem Tuam, Amen, and the communion song.[/quote]
We found this to be a perfect compromise at our LIFE TEEN Mass as well. I have been to parishes where all the liturgical songs have been modified, and I must admit that I am too much of a Traditionalist for that as well. I agree with your idea of a compromise, and suggest you bring it up *compassionately* at the pre-arranged meeting that YOU schedule.

I certainly sympathize with your situation, but I think a meeting of the minds is in order. Keep in mind that the Mass is not about your personal opinions and tastes no more than it should be about Bob's opinions and tastes. Ultimately, you will have to decide whether or not to continue in the ministry if it winds up going a direction you feel is in error. But I affirm you in your decision to suggest an alternate option.

Posted

We shouldn't have to compromise when it comes to the Mass.

Posted

to esmith818:

[quote]I love PM, but I most definitely get a strong "anti LIFE TEEN" vibe from most members. While I might agree with some arguments about the ministry, your comment is phrased in such as way that it sounds as though you're opinion of LIFE TEEN is heavily slanted due to your participation here. If I am wrong, I humbly apologize.[/quote]
Well, i don't really come here often because I am always busy but when I do come here, I never got the feeling that this place was anti-lifeteen so I could've never gotten my opinion from here. lol. I don't dislike the idea of life-teen (waiting to get burned lol) but the way life-teen (in my parish) is getting youth to come (or i should say, stick to life-teen and not just a one time thing) is, I think, shallow and is starting to fail. Our youth minister's way of luring the youth in is by feeding them food and games. Although it's a pretty good idea and it worked great in the first couple months, it is now starting to dwindle. I should just PM you about this because this would be a whole different topic. lol.

[quote]as others have said, if the sound is adjusted correctly, the type of equipment does not have to drown out the vocals. Also, being that I am in a parish where volunteers often seem scarce and we find ourselves begging for help, I would suggest you accept any help that comes your way. Who knows what ideas Heather's brother might bring to the table?[/quote]
Don't get me wrong but I don't mind Heather's brother, Josh, joining the choir, My problem is the electric guitar. I also don't mind having volunteers as long as they come and ask us and not just tell us that the youth minster volunteered him/her to join our choir. :)

[quote]This goes back to the natural leader comment. The phrasing here sounds like a middle school kid scared to say anything to the bully's face. If you are concerned or upset with the direction the music is heading (and it certainly sounds that way), then YOU should approach "Bob" rather than waiting for him to come to you. As another poster suggested, you should arrange a meeting with "Bob", the sister-pastor, your mom, and yourself to discuss the direction you are heading. Remember that God loved His enemies.[/quote]
I love this comment. I like blunt, truthful comments. I never realized that I was pretty much doing what the youth minister was doing, hiding. Right now, I am just going to see what happens tomorrow then go on from there. But I am still planning on setting up a meeting with our sister-pastor, my mom, and the youth minister. Would it be ok to bring other people that are part of the music ministry (for example the old life-teen choir leader. He also dislikes rock concert during Mass) or should it just be strictly the four of us?

Thanks for all the advice PM people. I really appreciate it. :)

Posted

[quote name='doe-jo' post='1445042' date='Jan 12 2008, 06:51 PM']Would it be ok to bring other people that are part of the music ministry (for example the old life-teen choir leader. He also dislikes rock concert during Mass) or should it just be strictly the four of us?

Thanks for all the advice PM people. I really appreciate it. :)[/quote]


my thought would be not to bring other people in at first. the "sister-pastor" might feel teamed up on and get more defensive. btw...my dad's aunt is one of those "sister-pastors" in the diocese of san bernadino. it is so sad. they are so liberal...i will definitely be praying for you.

those nuns are very hard to move in these types of situations because they don't care about what the Church's teachings are. most of those nuns will also say that they are called to the priesthood so it is good to remember that going in. for you to persuade them you will need to 1.) not seem like an upset traditional Catholic (even if you are one.) im telling you...its all about method here. and 2.) show them from a reasonable standpoint that the youth want something more than electric guitar at Mass. tell them the youth could feel like in the effort to make Mass "cool" by adding drums and electric guitar, they feel they have become part of a cheap, copycat, unoriginal, parrot culture. if they want acoustic guitar fine. if they want more upbeat songs....sing Matt Maher songs or something. at least it will be Catholic music. but those types of "pastoral coordinators" will likely remain unmoved except by lots of prayer/fasting. my aunt is one and it is quite terrible to talk to her about anything regarding the Church. definitely praying for you!

Posted

oh yeah...i almost forgot. when i was involved with music ministry at my parish (i used to play acoustic guitar and do a small amount of back-up vocals for confirmation students) the priest would constantly send people to us that were all of a sudden part of the choir without asking/telling us. we almost always knew the people but it was a total mess and VERY frustrating. that went on for two years. the third year he tried to send us someone and we just told them no. then we went and talked to him and told him that if he wanted more people in the choir he could send them to us so we can interview them, try them out/see if they could sing and get along with us and tell them when practices would be held. if they couldn't make the necessary commitments then they would not be singing with us. in order for the music to not be a distraction you will really need a set group of people to be there...if they are always adding people without telling you it will be very difficult to play/sing well together. constant change just makes it very, very difficult to make beautiful music that will help bring people to Jesus and its really not fair to you who are trying to make things work.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...