Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey everyone,
The post by Farglefeezlebut has got me to thinking. What is lust?
I mean, I understand the general premise, but I don't understand the precise definition, and the CCC doesn't help.
I understand that things such as masturbation embody lust, but where does one draw the line between innocent thought like, "My, that girl is pretty", and lust?
Thanks, and pax Christ,
Mitch

Posted (edited)

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1445449' date='Jan 14 2008, 09:27 AM'].........where does one draw the line between [u][b]innocent[/b][/u] thought like, "My, that girl is pretty", and lust?[/quote]

Well, this is how Innocent draws the line between thoughts like "My that girl is pretty" and lust":
(okay, poor pun, :sweat: but I couldn't resist! )

When I think, "That lady is gorgeous," I'm most likely only admiring the beauty of the lady.

However, suppose that I notice that I get a hormonal kick out of dwelling on the physical beauty of the lady, and I decide that I like the pleasure sensations that occur within me when I contemplate her beauty (this realisation might be very explicit or it may be somewhat subconscious, but it is, for me, at least, never unconscious. I always know when I'm crossing the line.), and so I take conscious effort in beholding the physical perfections that make the particular lady desirable, for the sake of continuing to experience that hormonal kick, and not because I like that particular lady as a person, (sometimes, I try to fool myself by thinking that I also am admiring the lady as a person, but I know deep down that even if this is so, such an admiration takes second place to using her physical attractions as a stimulus for my pleasure.) then the act of the will I have done has crossed over from mere admiration to objectification and lust, because, in my mind, the lady and I are no longer considered in the relationship of "I-Thou" but as "I-it".

[Wow, the entire above paragraph was one single sentence! :blink: I should learn to write in shorter sentences! :sweat: ]

C.S. Lewis says in his book [i]The Four Loves[/i], ([url="http://www.archive.org/details/fourlovesthatour027870mbp"][color="#4B0082"][b]available for free online reading legally at the internet archive[/b][/color][/url], since the copyright has expired)

This passage from C.S. Lewis was very much helpful for me in understanding the nature of lust.

[quote]To the evolutionist Eros (the human variation)
will be something that grows out of Venus, a late
complication and development of the immemorial
biological impulse. We must not assume, however,
that this is necessarily what happens within the con-
sciousness of the individual. There may be those who
have first felt mere sexual appetite for a woman and
then gone on at a later stage to "fall in love with her."
But I doubt if this is at all common'Very often what
comes first is simply a delighted pre-occupation with
the Beloved a general, unspecified pre-occupation
with her in her totality. A man in this state really
hasn't leisure to think of sex. He is too busy thinking
of a person. The fact that she is a woman is far less
important than the fact that she is herself. He is full
of desire, but the desire may not be sexually toned.
If you asked him what he wanted, the true reply
would often be, "To go on thinking of her." He is
love's contemplative. And when at a later stage the
explicitly sexual element awakes, lie will not feel
(unless scientific theories are influencing Mm) that
this had all along been the root of the whole matter.
He is more likely to feel that the incoming tide of
Eros, having demolished many sand-castles and
made islands of many rocks, has now at last with a
triumphant seventh wave flooded this part of his
nature also the little pool of ordinary sexuality
which was there on his beach before the tide came in.
Eros enters him like an invader, taking over and re-
organising, one by one, the institutions of a con-
quered country. It may have taken over many others
before it reaches the sex in him; and it will reorganise
that too.
No one has indicated the nature of that reorgani-
sation more briefly and accurately than George Or-
well, who disliked it and preferred sexuality in its
native condition, uncontaminated by Eros., In Nine-
teen Eighty-Four his dreadful hero (how much less
human than the four-footed heroes of his excellent
Animal Farm!), before towsing the heroine, de-
mands a reassurance, "You like doing this?" he asks,
"I don't mean simply me; I mean the thing in itself."
He is not satisfied till he gets the answer, "I adore
it." This little dialogue defines the reorganisation.
Sexual desire, without Eros, wants [u]it, the thing in
itself[/u]; Eros wants [u]the Beloved[/u].

The [u]thing[/u] is a sensory pleasure; that is, an event
occurring within one's own body.! We use a most
unfortunate idiom when we say, of a lustful man
prowling the streets, that lie "wants a woman."
Strictly speaking, a woman is just what he does not
want. He wants a pleasure for which a woman hap-
pens to be the necessary piece of apparatus. How
much he cares about the woman as such may be
gauged by his attitude to her five minutes after frui-
tion (one does not keep the carton after one has
smoked the cigarettes). Now Eros makes a man
really want, not a woman, but one particular womana
In some mysterious but quite indisputable fashion
the lover desires the Beloved herself, not the pleasure
she can give. No lover in the world ever sought the
embraces of the woman he loved as the result of a
calculation, however unconscious, that they would
be more pleasurable than those of any other woman.[/quote]

Here C.S. Lewis uses the word "Eros" to describe the state of humans being in love, and he uses the word "Venus" to describe the sexual element of this love.

Edited by Innocent
Posted

So, if you have a physical sexual response to something, that is not lust but, if you dwell on that (whatever incited that response) to further that response, that is lust? Is the initial response sinful?

Posted

I would say yes to your first question and no to your second question. The first is almost on the level of a glandular reaction. It's the dwelling on it that gets you in trouble. At least from my experience. It's like the old saying that "it is not what happens to you that is important; it's what you do with what happens to you".

Myself, I tend to think of lust as being any inordinate desire, not just sexual desire.

Posted

Actually I would say that dwelling on the first does not make it lust. What makes it lust is going in to the realm of seeing the other person as an object for gratification of our illicitly desires. One can be sexually aroused without lust and one can continue in that aroused state without lust but the arousal is derived from seeing the beauty of the other person and wanting to be a gift to them. Wanting to please them. If we take the focus off our ourselves when we are aroused and put the focus on the other person in true love (i.e. as defined by JPII having the best interests of the other in mind) then we do not sin. If our arousal leads only to a desire to please ourselves then it is sin.

I highly recommend you go to www.christopherwest.com for more info. Theology of the Body makes this clear.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1445615' date='Jan 14 2008, 01:21 PM']Actually I would say that dwelling on the first does not make it lust. What makes it lust is going in to the realm of seeing the other person as an object for gratification of our illicitly desires. One can be sexually aroused without lust and one can continue in that aroused state without lust but the arousal is derived from seeing the beauty of the other person and wanting to be a gift to them. Wanting to please them. If we take the focus off our ourselves when we are aroused and put the focus on the other person in true love (i.e. as defined by JPII having the best interests of the other in mind) then we do not sin. If our arousal leads only to a desire to please ourselves then it is sin.

I highly recommend you go to www.christopherwest.com for more info. Theology of the Body makes this clear.[/quote]

Thanks for the further defining. I have been meaning to read West's book but, have forty on my bookshelf ahead of it.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1445449' date='Jan 13 2008, 10:57 PM']Hey everyone,
The post by Farglefeezlebut has got me to thinking. What is lust?
I mean, I understand the general premise, but I don't understand the precise definition, and the CCC doesn't help.
I understand that things such as masturbation embody lust, but where does one draw the line between innocent thought like, "My, that girl is pretty", and lust?
Thanks, and pax Christ,
Mitch[/quote]
There are different kinds of lust but I suppose in the most general sense it can be described as simply inordinate desire. Since you are clearly referring to sexual lust it might be useful to consider a definition put forth in Pope John Paul II's Theology of the Body: sexual lust, or carnal concupiscence, "is an interior separation from the nuptial meaning of the body." This theme is discussed in the audience of September 10th 1980 and is a recurring subject of the theology of the body. I like the above mentioned audience in its discussion of this biblical passage:

[i]The soul heated like a burning fire will not be quenched until it is consumed; a man who commits fornication will never cease until the fire burns him up; to a fornicator all bread tastes sweet; he will never cease until he dies. A man who breaks his marriage vows says to himself: 'Who sees me? Darkness surrounds me, and the walls hide me; no one sees me. Why should I fear? The Most High will not take notice of my sins.' His fear is confined to the eyes of men; he does not realize that the eyes of the Lord are ten thousand times brighter than the sun; they look upon all the ways of men, and perceive even the hidden places. So it is with a woman who leaves her husband, and provides an heir by a stranger.[/i] - Sirach 23:17-22

:cool:

Posted

I'm just more confused than ever. There are those of us who will never get married. Celibate laypeople don't seem to be invited to the table, so to speak, in the greater scope of the discussion. I've been thinking about moving someplace where I can just be away from it all, so to speak, because you're treated like they don't know what to do with you if you're not part of one or two different groups.

Posted

All at once, things have been clarified and mudded up more :D
Thanks for the replies. I'll post a more detailed response along with some questions tomorrow.
Pax,
Mitch

Posted

st.-annes,

Actually I would disagree with you from a Theology of the Body perspective. In your singleness you radiate the glory of God by living the chaste life in expectation of the heavenly glory where we will neither be married nor given in marriage. In your singleness you are not divided between your husband/wife and God but can devote full time to doing his will on earth and learning about him so that you can help others to better understand him. Theology of the body is definitely for the celibate as well as the married. Celibacy is a higher calling of which "to some it has been given" Matt 19. God bless

Posted

So basically, it's natural to get...'questionable' thoughts about the opposite sex, but it's whether you dismiss or linger upon the thought that is the definitive factor?

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1446130' date='Jan 16 2008, 02:42 AM']So basically, it's natural to get...'questionable' thoughts about the opposite sex, but it's whether you dismiss or linger upon the thought that is the definitive factor?[/quote]

Like Bro. Ignatius Mary of the Catholic Support Group for Sexual Addiction Recovery used to say, "You can't stop birds from flying over your head, but you sure can stop them making nests in your hair!" :D

Posted

[quote name='Innocent' post='1446269' date='Jan 15 2008, 08:53 PM']Like Bro. Ignatius Mary of the Catholic Support Group for Sexual Addiction Recovery used to say, "You can't stop birds from flying over your head, but you sure can stop them making nests in your hair!" :D[/quote]
Well...I'll take that as a yes ;)

Posted

I have been reading Christopher Wests Good News About Sex and Marriage. One thing that jumped out at me right away was from Genesis 3:7

[quote]And the eyes of them both were opened: and when they perceived themselves to be naked, they sewed together fig leaves, and made themselves aprons.[/quote]
This is lust, the very first thing they encounter after falling is the sin of lust because if they didnt feel this shame why did the sew fig leaves together? To prevent each other from experiencing the lustful thoughts.

So if we apply this to our world and even today, what is probably the most wide spread sin? Lust.

I would personally define it as any thought given (of sexual origin) to another person that is detached from seeing them created in the image and likeness of God.

I think an example of each would be say, giving thought to a immodestly dressed woman as she enters the room (noticing certain body parts past the mere first glance).

The opposite would be gazing upon your wife or any other woman and thinking she is really beautiful and created in the image of God, body and soul.

Just some of my thoughts. By the way I used looking at a female in my examples simply because I am male and it would have been weird the opposite, but the same goes.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

There is nothing wrong with looking at someone and enjoying the view. However, starting to use your imagination to respond to that view is lust, because you are past looking and instead objectifying the person instead of seeing the creation of God.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...