Veritas Posted January 14, 2008 Posted January 14, 2008 + [url="http://www.narth.com/docs/isminor.html"]http://www.narth.com/docs/isminor.html[/url] Let's also remember that disordered genetics are also a result of the fall! So, any claim that genetics = "God made me this way" is false.
Deb Posted January 14, 2008 Posted January 14, 2008 I am not sure what kind of results that study could use seeing as they just asked people two questions. Not very scientific. This one seems to cover a longer period of history of study and types of study: [url="http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/199706/homosexuality-biology"]http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/199706/homosexuality-biology[/url]
Semalsia Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 I don't see what difference it would make to you even if SSA had a major genetic contribution to it. Many mental disorders like depression, bipolar and schizophrenia are highly inheritable and run in families. I don't know how good this study is (and I tend to be suspicious of everything from narth), but I've seen figures like 30-40% genetic before. That seems to be the current consensus. I guess it shouldn't be too surprising. Not that it really matters since we know for certain that those with SSA didn't choose it and they can't change. Those are the two things important to remember. And even if SSA had nothing to do with genetics, people could still be born gay. Lots of things happen during the nine months in the womb and apparently even mother's milk has an effect on children's brain.
Veritas Posted January 15, 2008 Author Posted January 15, 2008 [quote name='Semalsia' post='1445796' date='Jan 14 2008, 08:40 PM']. I guess it shouldn't be too surprising. Not that it really matters since we know for certain that those with SSA didn't choose it and they can't change. Those are the two things important to remember. And even if SSA had nothing to do with genetics, people could still be born gay. Lots of things happen during the nine months in the womb and apparently even mother's milk has an effect on children's brain.[/quote] + Should we move this to debate, now? "We know for certain that those with SSA didn't choose it and they can't change" Actually, there's no such certainty of the kind. If anything, the evidence, especially for the latter, goes directly the opposite way.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Veritas' post='1445814' date='Jan 15 2008, 03:20 AM']+ Should we move this to debate, now? "We know for certain that those with SSA didn't choose it and they can't change" Actually, there's no such certainty of the kind. If anything, the evidence, especially for the latter, goes directly the opposite way.[/quote] The evidence for the latter involves individuals standing up and giving testimonies about how they realised that their 'gay identity' came from being abused as a child or having bad relationships with one parent or being afraid of their own gender. There are numerous such testimonies, but anecdotal evidence like this does not prove that homosexuality is somehow reversible. As these stories deal with individual situations, it's not really possible to make wider generalizations - especially as some of the testimonies are doubtful in authenticity, with their authors desperately wanting to believe that they are cured. I saw similar signs in a student who went on a hugely expensive program that claimed to be able to 'cure' dyslexia. I couldn't see any difference in his reading and spelling and short-term memory skills when the program was finished - the only change was a marginal improvement in his handwriting. I asked him about this, gently, and he replied, "My brain's been used to being dyslexic for so long that it has to relearn everything. But I am cured." (This was the excuse he had been given the program director.) Now he's often called upon to give his testimony on behalf of the organisation that effected this cure - even though his schoolwork remains half-illegible and is peppered with letter reversals, snatches of mirror-writing, and basic spelling errors. Yet he remains absolutely convinced that he is 'better', refusing all the extra tuition and support that his school routinely gives to students with his difficulties. For this reason I am extremely doubtful about 'cure' testimonies, especially when there is no consensus in the medical community on whether a cure for a particular condition actually exists. As yet, there is no empirical evidence to suggest that there is a cure - or even to suggest that homosexuality isn't primarily biological. The study that you cite is not rigorous enough. There are too many loopholes and weaknesses in methodology. The big ones are social desirability bias and a tendency to show demand characteristics. There is no guarantee that a person would give a truthful answer to either of those questions, which in themselves are not enough to establish the person's sexuality. [quote]"What same-sex sexual contact have you had in the last year?" and (in essence) "If there was no prospect of anyone finding out, and you were sexually propositioned by someone of the same sex you liked, what would be your chances of accepting?"[/quote] A person who said, "None," and, "None," could be a homosexual who hasn't had sex in a while and isn't the type to respond to propositions, even from people they 'like'. There are several possibilities. Yet it seems that the researchers have chosen to assume that such answers indicate heterosexuality. Secondly, the study doesn't say whether monozygotic or diozygotic twins were used, or a mixture of both. To be more accurate, they would need to run the same study with a group of diozygotic twins, followed by a batch of monozygotic twins, and even then there would still be problems with the methodology. Edited January 15, 2008 by Cathoholic Anonymous
Didacus Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 Sexual orientation can definately change over the span of one's life. The prison phenomena is proof of it; men commit homosexual acts while incarcerated, then return to heterosexual habits once released. This indicates a clear choice of action and the ability to change one's sexual habits and revert due to environment alone. I can believe a predisposition towards homoseuality, but not a direct genetic link. And the act, regardless of tendencies or prefernece always remains a personal choice.
beata_virgo_maria Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 My Psychology professor said that genetics can incline some men to be more effeminate, which puts boys more at risk of being preyed upon by men. (As a large percentage of men who have SSA were sexually abused as children or teens.) I'm not saying this is always the case, but this is what my professor said.
Deb Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 [quote name='Veritas' post='1445814' date='Jan 14 2008, 09:20 PM']+ Should we move this to debate, now? "We know for certain that those with SSA didn't choose it and they can't change" Actually, there's no such certainty of the kind. If anything, the evidence, especially for the latter, goes directly the opposite way.[/quote] I am more prone to go by the testimony of all the friends I have had over my life when they talked about their sexual preference and when it manifested. Every one of them (male and female) knew that they were attracted to the same sex when they reached the age of sexual awakening, some as young as eight or nine. As for homosexuality being a result of abuse, maybe in some cases it is. I have three cousins, all from the same family, father a deacon, mother a musician, all three brilliant and two are homosexual and one is a lesbian. Sure looks genetic to me. They could not even admit it to thei parents until they were out of the home due to the religious convictions of their parents. When you actually know people who spend most of their life trying to hide their SSA rather than be treated like dirt, you know that people don't ordinarily choose something that will bring them that much pain and agony. When you know people who commit suicide rather than try to live with their SSA, you know they couldn't just change it because society wanted them to. They have a cross to bear and we should be finding ways for them to live with themselves and abstain from sexual relationships as God requires all single people to do instead of trying to find ways to make them into something evil. God loves all of his children.
Old_Joe Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 saying something is based in genetics is like saying, "I can't help it. This is the way I was made." While that's somewhat true, it doesn't say much about freewill.
Deb Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 I think you are what you are then and then free will comes in to play in what you do with what you are.
Didacus Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1446036' date='Jan 15 2008, 01:08 PM']I think you are what you are then and then free will comes in to play in what you do with what you are.[/quote] All who are born in this world have a tendency to do evil; this is what we are. What we are though, does not exempt us from our moral obligation to do right and good, regardless of evil inclinations we have. Genetic or not is an inconsequential question. Even if it is genetic, does not justify the homosexual act or lifestyle.
Deb Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1446050' date='Jan 15 2008, 12:23 PM']All who are born in this world have a tendency to do evil; this is what we are. What we are though, does not exempt us from our moral obligation to do right and good, regardless of evil inclinations we have. Genetic or not is an inconsequential question. Even if it is genetic, does not justify the homosexual act or lifestyle.[/quote] I agree. I believe it is genetic and that it does not justify the homosexual act or lifestyle. I also believe that the heterosexual sexual urges are genetic and that the acting on those urges outside of marriage are just as unjustified. So, while there are probably a billion heterosexual sinful "acts" going on for every one thousand homosexual, everyone only seems to concentrate on the homosexuals. Maybe if there was as much media outlay, marches, debates and attention paid to pre-marital sex, that might diminish. So, is being heterosexual a choice or genetic?
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 15, 2008 Posted January 15, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Didacus' post='1445988' date='Jan 15 2008, 01:25 PM']Sexual orientation can definately change over the span of one's life. The prison phenomena is proof of it; men commit homosexual acts while incarcerated, then return to heterosexual habits once released. This indicates a clear choice of action and the ability to change one's sexual habits and revert due to environment alone. I can believe a predisposition towards homoseuality, but not a direct genetic link. And the act, regardless of tendencies or prefernece always remains a personal choice.[/quote] The situation in prisons is not a sign of people's sexual preferences changing, but an example of the type of behaviour that some people adopt if they are placed in an extremely restrictive, monotonous, and often aggressive all-male environment. The way people behave in that kind of circumstance can't be taken as representative of what goes on in society at large. [quote name='Deb' post='1446060' date='Jan 15 2008, 06:35 PM']I agree. I believe it is genetic and that it does not justify the homosexual act or lifestyle. I also believe that the eterosexual sexual urges are genetic and that the acting on those urges outside of marriage are just as unjustified. So, while there are probably a billion heterosexual sinful "acts" going on for every one thousand homosexual, everyone only seems to concentrate on the homosexuals. Maybe if there was as much media outlay, marches, debates and attention paid to pre-marital sex, that might diminish.[/quote] Couldn't agree more. Edited January 15, 2008 by Cathoholic Anonymous
Didacus Posted January 16, 2008 Posted January 16, 2008 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1446228' date='Jan 15 2008, 07:33 PM']The situation in prisons is not a sign of people's sexual preferences changing, but an example of the type of behaviour that some people adopt if they are placed in an extremely restrictive, monotonous, and often aggressive all-male environment. The way people behave in that kind of circumstance can't be taken as representative of what goes on in society at large.[/quote] The prison example is not one met to reflect society but one demonstrating how the sexual act remains a choice and how 'sexual orientation' can be set aside.
Didacus Posted January 16, 2008 Posted January 16, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1446060' date='Jan 15 2008, 01:35 PM']I agree. I believe it is genetic and that it does not justify the homosexual act or lifestyle. I also believe that the heterosexual sexual urges are genetic and that the acting on those urges outside of marriage are just as unjustified. So, while there are probably a billion heterosexual sinful "acts" going on for every one thousand homosexual, everyone only seems to concentrate on the homosexuals. Maybe if there was as much media outlay, marches, debates and attention paid to pre-marital sex, that might diminish. So, is being heterosexual a choice or genetic?[/quote] Homosexual acts are sex outside of marriage and coumpounds with the sin of homoseuxality. It is a step up in gravity. that may be one of the factors explaining why it gets so much attention. another factor is that homosexuals tend to exhibit themselves and specifically their homosexuality. If you look for attention, good chance you'll eventually find it. I would like to point out that in the CCC it does state that a person's personal situation can deminish the guilt of sin. Many homosexuals, in my opinion, have their personal guilt diminished considerably since their temptations are strong and their culture strongly encourage this detrimental behavior. [quote]CCC 1860 Unintentional ignorance can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense. But no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man. The promptings of feelings and passions can also diminish the voluntary and free character of the offense, as can external pressures or pathological disorders. Sin committed through malice, by deliberate choice of evil, is the gravest.[/quote] If you consider homosexuality as a pathological disorder, or the result of unintentional ignorance, the guilt of the sin can be 'diminished or even removed'. (if a church scholar can confirm or correct my statement please do so). The Church absolutely doesn't seek to condemn homosexuals, but will forever state the Truth that homosexual acts are contrary to the universal natural law.
st-annes Posted January 16, 2008 Posted January 16, 2008 NARTH was discredited a long time ago. They aren't respected by the wider scientific community.
Veritas Posted January 16, 2008 Author Posted January 16, 2008 [quote name='st-annes' post='1446443' date='Jan 16 2008, 08:24 AM']NARTH was discredited a long time ago. They aren't respected by the wider scientific community.[/quote] + Neither is Catholicism! Thank God, we as Catholics don't go by secular criteria. And this "wider" "scientific" community, which undoubtedly includes the APA is so totally bogged in PFLAG and other homosexual activist groups, it really negates their opinion and commentary. Among Catholics and Christians, NARTH is widely respected and deserves and is worth of our consideration. If you aren't in line with Church teaching, you're not going to like it and I'm afraid that is what we are seeing in the attempt to discredit it above and elsewhere.
Veritas Posted January 16, 2008 Author Posted January 16, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1446015' date='Jan 15 2008, 11:34 AM']When you know people who commit suicide rather than try to live with their SSA, you know they couldn't just change it because society wanted them to. They have a cross to bear and we should be finding ways for them to live with themselves and abstain from sexual relationships as God requires all single people to do instead of trying to find ways to make them into something evil. God loves all of his children.[/quote] There were obviously more factors here than SSA. I don't think anyone here has or desires to show ill-will towards those, who struggle with SSA -realizing that it IS objectively disordered and the act can never be accepted. The problem, so prevalent today, is this huge, huge momentous attempt to normalize deviant behaviour. Those who argue that there is "too much attention" on the homosexual agenda, are missing the secular agenda's progress in politics and in schools in particular to force individuals to support homosexual relationships in schools, housing, families, churches, etc. This, is very, very wrong and has very, very bad consequences for children -the children of these homosexual "couples" in particular. It is not compassionate to ignore these attempts. Because America has ignored them for so long, we have tons of youngsters talked into believing they are homosexuals because they have experienced normal and fleeting SSA as part of their pubescent development. It is, and will continue to be, exceedingly important to fight the homosexual agenda. This, is the problem. Not individuals who sincerely struggle with sin, just like the rest of us.
Veritas Posted January 16, 2008 Author Posted January 16, 2008 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1446228' date='Jan 15 2008, 06:33 PM']The situation in prisons is not a sign of people's sexual preferences changing, but an example of the type of behaviour that some people adopt if they are placed in an extremely restrictive, monotonous, and often aggressive all-male environment. The way people behave in that kind of circumstance can't be taken as representative of what goes on in society at large. Couldn't agree more.[/quote] + Well, actually, this points very much to the power of circumstance and environment in sexual orientation at large. Studies back this up: Many, many individuals, who identify themselves as "homosexuals" grew-up in unfit environments with just such a particular set of circumstances. The evidence suggests that reparative therapy goes a long way in undoing the damage of these environments. What does this mean? Change is very, very possible. The same way someone, who struggles with any sin or disorder has the hope to change and be healed. I think it is so amazing how much people want to limit the power of God!
Deb Posted January 16, 2008 Posted January 16, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Veritas' post='1446461' date='Jan 16 2008, 10:34 AM']There were obviously more factors here than SSA. I don't think anyone here has or desires to show ill-will towards those, who struggle with SSA -realizing that it IS objectively disordered and the act can never be accepted. The problem, so prevalent today, is this huge, huge momentous attempt to normalize deviant behaviour. Those who argue that there is "too much attention" on the homosexual agenda, are missing the secular agenda's progress in politics and in schools in particular to force individuals to support homosexual relationships in schools, housing, families, churches, etc. This, is very, very wrong and has very, very bad consequences for children -the children of these homosexual "couples" in particular. It is not compassionate to ignore these attempts. Because America has ignored them for so long, we have tons of youngsters talked into believing they are homosexuals because they have experienced normal and fleeting SSA as part of their pubescent development. It is, and will continue to be, exceedingly important to fight the homosexual agenda. This, is the problem. Not individuals who sincerely struggle with sin, just like the rest of us.[/quote] ...we have tons of youngsters talked into believing they are homosexuals? Please. [mod]personal attack - edited by Lil Red[/mod]when that hormonal urge hits, you kind of know who you want to be with. It is not all that hard to decipher. Experimentation is one thing but, long term sexual tendencies are pretty well obvious to a person. There is a difference between supporting gay couples, adoption, marriage etc than from having compassion for people who you are telling will never be allowed to have a loving, sexual, marital relationship with someone because they are defective. It is called mercy. Edited January 16, 2008 by Lil Red
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now