nleyetn Posted January 16, 2008 Posted January 16, 2008 I'm a Harry Potter fan myself, but I also agree with the article. The series is a great fictional story with elements of good versus evil. The problem comes when you add in an element (magic) which can be confusing for the original target audience of Harry Potter, children. It looks like everybody here knows the difference between fictional magic, and witchcraft in the real world, but I think the article is talking about the dangers for those who read the series and don't understand that difference. Those who don't realize real world magic is an evil practice and all they know is magic looks cool and fun to them. As long as you can see the difference between the two and can enjoy the books for what they are, fiction, then there isn't really any problem. When I have kids someday, I won't introduce them to Harry Potter until they are teenagers and I know that they are aware of the difference between fictional magic and real world magic.
Paladin D Posted January 17, 2008 Posted January 17, 2008 It's interesting to see how many people are divided on this issue. The Vatican has repeatedly been against the Harry Potter books, granted it's not dogma, but wouldn't the [b][i]continuing[/b][/i] negative critism of the Harry Potter series raise questions of any sort to those who support these works? If it was just one press release, then fine... but this isn't the first time the Vatican (or a Vatican official) has directly targeted Harry Potter.
Ash Wednesday Posted January 17, 2008 Posted January 17, 2008 (edited) I don't have any problem with the Vatican's concerns, such as what then Cardinal Ratzinger observed about effects of erroneous concepts of magic might have the vulnerable and tender state of a young child's mind, particularly when being raised in the Catholic faith. I think the same concerns should go for ANY literature or media that will be used by a child. That's why I don't understand why Harry Potter itself gets singled out. I guess it's because people make such a big deal about it (too much either way, in my opinion). If your kid starts reading the wrong books and decides to dabble in the occult, then chances are the parents were slacking off with making sure their kids were well grounded in the faith. When I was an adolescent, I checked out a book at the library on astrology. What did my mom do? What any good christian mother would do. She explained to me that astrology was something that went against our beliefs. That had an impact on me. There's a lot of books and stories out there that deal with things like magic. For the most part, I view a lot of them as being fairly innocuous, so long as the parents are keeping a close eye on what their kids are reading or watching, and having discussions with them about these things. It seems to me that most kids that start dabbling with dark things as a result of what's going on (or not going on) in the home moreso than books that have fantasy and magic. But anyway, I would take the Vatican's concerns into account. But I still think Harry Potter is pretty overrated. Edited January 17, 2008 by Ash Wednesday
Apotheoun Posted January 17, 2008 Posted January 17, 2008 I enjoyed reading all seven of the Harry Potter books, and I do not see anything dangerous in them.
SanctitasDeo Posted January 17, 2008 Posted January 17, 2008 As I am not Catholic, the judgment of the Vatican would not be my primary source of direction about the Harry Potter books. Most of the continuing negative criticism I have seen is of the I-haven't-read-the-books-but-my-pastor-said type. Not that the pastor read the book either. It tends to be poorly-reasoned, a knee-jerk reaction based off popularity and the word magic (I say popularity because, as some other poster just said, there are dozens of books about magic out there, too many to really keep track of, and there is nary a word of protest about those). There is some truth to the idea that children should not read certain books before they are ready. I know that my sister still has not read the sixth or seventh book. My dad doesn't really want her to run into the idea of Horcruxes this early, I think, though the violence in the books also might have something to do with it. [quote]It seems to me that most kids that start dabbling with dark things as a result of what's going on (or not going on) in the home moreso than books that have fantasy and magic.[/quote] This seems true to me. It would honestly be hard to really start messing with the occult based just on what is in the Harry Potter books, or even most children's and Young Adult books. You would have to find more direction than that. And of course, there are places to get it, but as has been said, a parent who is paying attention to his kids and what they read, and is teaching them the Gospel is going to notice when they start reading Aleister Crowley.
XIX Posted January 19, 2008 Posted January 19, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1446902' date='Jan 17 2008, 01:41 AM']It's interesting to see how many people are divided on this issue. [color="#FF0000"]The Vatican has repeatedly been against the Harry Potter books, [/color]granted it's not dogma, but wouldn't the [b][i]continuing[/b][/i] negative critism of the Harry Potter series raise questions of any sort to those who support these works? If it was just one press release, then fine... but this isn't the first time the Vatican (or a Vatican official) has directly targeted Harry Potter.[/quote] Is this true?
Autumn Dusk Posted January 19, 2008 Posted January 19, 2008 [quote]The Vatican has repeatedly been against the Harry Potter books,[/quote] And in the 1700's the vatican was against the thought world being round.
Ash Wednesday Posted January 19, 2008 Posted January 19, 2008 (edited) Apparently Father Amorth, who is a chief exorcist of rome and apparently the Church's leading exorcist, has spoken out against them, which I find interesting. I think the key here, as far as how he and the pope feel -- is how appropriate or potentially harmful the books are for those who do not have a strong concept of what magic is and what it isn't -- I think the warnings are meant to address, in particular, the best interests of impressionable young children. So I think people ought to try to understand what it is Vatican officials are trying to say without taking offense or getting so defensive about it. It's not exactly authority or binding but there's nothing wrong with hearing them out. I'm trying to read the books myself and I'm not exactly riveted by them like others apparently are. I am feeling about as mildly engaged and ho-hum about them as I have watching the movies. Just kind of glad they are over with after each one ends. So I guess if I am able to have kids and they ask me for my opinion, I'll say "Well kids, I think Harry Potter is kind of boring, actually." Edited January 19, 2008 by Ash Wednesday
KnightofChrist Posted January 19, 2008 Author Posted January 19, 2008 Esteemed and dear Ms. Kuby! Many thanks for your kind letter of February 20th and the informative book which you sent me in the same mail. It is good, that you enlighten people about Harry Potter, because those are subtle seductions, which act unnoticed and by this deeply distort Christianity in the soul, before it can grow properly. I would like to suggest that you write to Mr. Peter Fleetwood, (Pontifical Council of Culture, Piazza S. Calisto 16, I00153 Rome) directly and to send him your book. Sincere Greetings and Blessings, + Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger ======================= Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger Vatican City May 27, 2003 Esteemed and dear Ms. Kuby, Somehow your letter got buried in the large pile of name-day , birthday and Easter mail. Finally this pile is taken care of, so that I can gladly allow you to refer to my judgment about Harry Potter. Sincere Greetings and Blessings, + Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger
XIX Posted January 19, 2008 Posted January 19, 2008 Yeah, that letter doesn't seem to say much except for "hey, this is an important issue, but you might wanna talk to this other guy about it." He also says that it's an important issue, which actually gives some credence to these extremely long Harry Potter debates--because he seems to think it's worth discussing. I think the exorcist's comments are more valid if you want to say that the Vatican is opposed to Harry Potter.
KnightofChrist Posted January 19, 2008 Author Posted January 19, 2008 [quote name='XIX' post='1447887' date='Jan 19 2008, 07:24 PM']Yeah, that letter doesn't seem to say much except for "hey, this is an important issue, but you might wanna talk to this other guy about it."[/quote] It says more than that. He states that the books have "[u]subtle seductions[/u], which act unnoticed and by this deeply distort Christianity." The Master of seduction is Satan, and he always does so in a subtle way.
RandomProddy Posted January 19, 2008 Posted January 19, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1447821' date='Jan 19 2008, 09:12 PM']And in the 1700's the vatican was against the thought world being round.[/quote] [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-sphere"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-sphere[/url] [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1447889' date='Jan 20 2008, 12:27 AM']It says more than that. He states that the books have "[u]subtle seductions[/u], which act unnoticed and by this deeply distort Christianity." The Master of seduction is Satan, and he always does so in a subtle way.[/quote] It's fiction!!!!!!! Edited January 19, 2008 by RandomProddy
hoosieranna Posted January 20, 2008 Posted January 20, 2008 [quote name='RandomProddy' post='1447893' date='Jan 19 2008, 05:37 PM']It's fiction!!!!!!![/quote] Thank you! I keep saying that, but it doesn't seem to sink in.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now