Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I must say that I agree with Ron Paul on many more issues than is the norm in a national election. He is not, however, as popular within the Republican party as a presidential candidate probably should be in order to win the white house. I know a lot of Catholics (Repubs and Dems alike) who support him, but I have a few questions.

Do life issues really trump everything else every time? Other Republican candidates such as Huckabee are pro capital punishment... while I know that this is not a non-negotiable issue, it is still a life issue. Would it be ethical to vote (in the primaries) for a candidate who is less pro-life than Paul, for the simple reason that they would have a greater chance of winning the national election? What if, in deciding, a voter would have to sacrifice his view on embryonic stem cell research, for example? If, theoretically, there were Republican candidates who were pro embryonic stem cell research but anti abortion, would it be moral to vote for one of them in a primary instead of Paul? Again, my logic is that they may have a greater chance of winning white house, and so the pro-life cause would be advanced as much as possible.

Posted

In my opinion, the life of children comes before these other issues. Before the death penalty, before gay marriage. I'm voting for Ron Paul. If a candidate wants gay marriage to be legalized, I don't really care. If a candidate wants the death penalty to remain legal, I don't really care. What I do care about are the lives of unborn children.

I don't think I could vote for a candidate who was pro life but supported embryonic stem cell research, that would be odd.

Posted

He is not popular in the Republican Party because he is not a Republican. He is a Libertarian running as a Republican.

Posted

[quote name='Kitty' post='1449582' date='Jan 23 2008, 12:35 AM']In my opinion, the life of children comes before these other issues. Before the death penalty, before gay marriage. I'm voting for Ron Paul. If a candidate wants gay marriage to be legalized, I don't really care. If a candidate wants the death penalty to remain legal, I don't really care. What I do care about are the lives of unborn children.

I don't think I could vote for a candidate who was pro life but supported embryonic stem cell research, that would be odd.[/quote]

Right, but I meant that maybe a candidate (Ron Paul) couldn't win a national election. Would a voter be justified in voting for a different candidate who might be able to win a national election, even if one or two of the non-negotiable issues were violated?

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1449585' date='Jan 23 2008, 12:49 AM']He is not popular in the Republican Party because he is not a Republican. He is a Libertarian running as a Republican.[/quote]

Right, but he still couldn't win. so back to the question...

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1449550' date='Jan 22 2008, 10:42 PM']I must say that I agree with Ron Paul on many more issues than is the norm in a national election. He is not, however, as popular within the Republican party as a presidential candidate probably should be in order to win the white house. I know a lot of Catholics (Repubs and Dems alike) who support him, but I have a few questions.

Do life issues really trump everything else every time? Other Republican candidates such as Huckabee are pro capital punishment... while I know that this is not a non-negotiable issue, it is still a life issue. Would it be ethical to vote (in the primaries) for a candidate who is less pro-life than Paul, for the simple reason that they would have a greater chance of winning the national election? What if, in deciding, a voter would have to sacrifice his view on embryonic stem cell research, for example? If, theoretically, there were Republican candidates who were pro embryonic stem cell research but anti abortion, would it be moral to vote for one of them in a primary instead of Paul? Again, my logic is that they may have a greater chance of winning white house, and so the pro-life cause would be advanced as much as possible.[/quote]


Is Ron Paul a viable candidate? I would say so, because it seems many people, if not most, support him. Too bad they won't vote for him because they have this impression that no one else will. I agree with Huckabee in supporting capital punishment. It's certainly not an issue a Catholic should feel reluctant about voting in support of.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1449591' date='Jan 23 2008, 12:19 AM']Right, but I meant that maybe a candidate (Ron Paul) couldn't win a national election. Would a voter be justified in voting for a different candidate who might be able to win a national election, even if one or two of the non-negotiable issues were violated?
Right, but he still couldn't win. so back to the question...[/quote]

No one can win if people won't vote for him, even if they agree with him ;). Regardless, in an election where one of two people are going to win, it is permissable to vote for the lesser of two evils.

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1449585' date='Jan 23 2008, 01:49 AM']He is not popular in the Republican Party because he is not a Republican. He is a Libertarian running as a Republican.[/quote]
he is a republican, he's the only Reagan-style republican left in the running. Ronald Reagan said that libertarianism was the heart and soul of the conservative movement, and was often himself described as a libertarian or a conservative interchangeably.

Posted

[url="http://www.ronpaul2008.com/press-releases/159/pro-life-activist-norma-mccorvey-%e2%80%98jane-roe%e2%80%99-of-roe-v-wade-endorses-ron-paul-for-president"]http://www.ronpaul2008.com/press-releases/...l-for-president[/url]

Norma McCorvey (the Roe of Roe v Wade) has endorsed Ron Paul as the only pro-life candidate who doesn't just talk but also acts.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1449585' date='Jan 23 2008, 12:49 AM']He is not popular in the Republican Party because he is not a Republican. He is a Libertarian running as a Republican.[/quote]
Yet another reason as a libertarian I have little love for the Libertarian Party. It gives detractors of libertarians the excuse to send a candidate with great values to a party that doesn't stand a chance. In the Libertarian Party, there is only one libertarian, and that is whoever you ask in the LP to define libertarianism. Paul is well in first place when it comes to being fiscally conservative, for small government, and for a strict constructionist view of the Constitution. If those aren't important to Republicans, then the Republican Party is no longer the party for conservatives.

Furthermore, he's won more races as a Republican than anyone else running for the nomination now. Sure he ran as the LP candidate in 1988, but he even says he ran to protest how the Republican Party was slipping away from being the party of small government and fiscal responsibility.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted (edited)

dl33t me kthxbai

Edited by 1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1449621' date='Jan 23 2008, 09:02 AM']he is a republican, he's the only Reagan-style republican left in the running. Ronald Reagan said that libertarianism was the heart and soul of the conservative movement, and was often himself described as a libertarian or a conservative interchangeably.[/quote]

I agree. He is the only TRUE republican. The republican party gets a lot of smack for being a party of bigotry and hatred, but its about small government, american sovriegnty, etc. Lets bring back the days of the good ole Barry Goldwater conservatism.

Posted

[quote name='Premed_Jakey' post='1449913' date='Jan 24 2008, 12:20 AM']I agree. He is the only TRUE republican. The republican party gets a lot of smack for being a party of bigotry and hatred, but its about small government, american sovriegnty, etc. Lets bring back the days of the good ole Barry Goldwater conservatism.[/quote]


That's all well and good, but can he win? And if he can't would it be morally acceptable to vote for a different candidate in the primaries?

Posted

it's not about who can win or not. it's about voting for the right candidate.

maybe he can win, maybe he can't. vote for him anyway, this is the primaries, you don't get points for voting for the one that wins. the republican convention needs to see as many delegates voting for Ron Paul as possible so they know there are still conservatives in their party.

voting for another candidate with more "viability" is no less futile in reality.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1449953' date='Jan 24 2008, 04:21 AM']it's not about who can win or not. it's about voting for the right candidate.

maybe he can win, maybe he can't. vote for him anyway, this is the primaries, you don't get points for voting for the one that wins. the republican convention needs to see as many delegates voting for Ron Paul as possible so they know there are still conservatives in their party.

voting for another candidate with more "viability" is no less futile in reality.[/quote]

I'm not interested in "points"... I just thought that perhaps you could use your vote to help a different candidate... one who is mostly in line with Catholic teaching (more than the other republicans), and who may lose the primaries simply because ron paul takes votes from him. the result of a split between people voting on moral issues is that a candidate who does not support traditional family values, etc. may win.

Posted (edited)

OK, let's add this to the mix. Suppose you have a choice between a person with a voting record that agrees with the non-negotiables 93% of the time and a person who, on a survey, says he agrees with the non-negotiables 100% of the time, but you ask yourself if he can be trusted to have the same position after he takes the oath of office because he has a past history of publicly opposing those non-negotiables about half the time.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

It should be remembered that Ron Paul is a text-book libertarian. Read about what libertarianism is first, and then make a sensible choice about Ron Paul.

Posted

Libertarians are out there on a whole host of issues from enforcing the borders to legalizing drugs that are currently illegal. Sure they are are for smaller government and personal responsibility. However, they are that to an extreme. There are things that government must do like provide for a common defense and they just won't.

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1451241' date='Jan 26 2008, 07:31 PM']Libertarians are out there on a whole host of issues from enforcing the borders to legalizing drugs that are currently illegal. Sure they are are for smaller government and personal responsibility. However, they are that to an extreme. There are things that government must do like provide for a common defense and they just won't.[/quote]

Yep.

I think a Ron Paul presidency would bring some positive change to the country, but also a lot of radical, revolutionary changes that even Paul's most enthusiastic supporters probably don't really want.

Again, Ron Paul is not the conservative choice; he is the [i]libertarian[/i] choice. There is a big difference there, once one moves past a superficial conception of libertarianism. There is a reason why so many young pro-death atheists are Ron Paul supporters, and it ain't because Paul is a conservative. They just want anarchy.

Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1449550' date='Jan 22 2008, 11:42 PM']I must say that I agree with Ron Paul on many more issues than is the norm in a national election. He is not, however, as popular within the Republican party as a presidential candidate probably should be in order to win the white house. I know a lot of Catholics (Repubs and Dems alike) who support him, but I have a few questions.

Do life issues really trump everything else every time? Other Republican candidates such as Huckabee are pro capital punishment... while I know that this is not a non-negotiable issue, it is still a life issue. Would it be ethical to vote (in the primaries) for a candidate who is less pro-life than Paul, for the simple reason that they would have a greater chance of winning the national election? What if, in deciding, a voter would have to sacrifice his view on embryonic stem cell research, for example? If, theoretically, there were Republican candidates who were pro embryonic stem cell research but anti abortion, would it be moral to vote for one of them in a primary instead of Paul? Again, my logic is that they may have a greater chance of winning white house, and so the pro-life cause would be advanced as much as possible.[/quote]

As far as the life issues are involved, Archbishop Burke gave a speech on Monday that I'm trying to track down. I saw him that night, but since he was busy (;)) I didn't bother him.

However, from what I was told, he said that Catholics can disagree about capital punishment and the war (at least to some extent), and so from that viewpoint it seems that we could support Huckabee even if he supports the death penalty.

I am still trying to see if I can find the text of his speech and will try to post what I can from it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...