Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

It is not specifically acknowledged in the Catechism. This is all that pertains to it in the CCC

2290 " The virtue of temperance disposes us to avoid every kind of excess: the abuse of food, alcohol, tobacco, or medicine. Those incur grace guilt who, by drunkenness or a love of speed, endanger their own and others' safety on the road, at sea, or in the air."
2291 "The use of drugs inflicts very grave damage on human health and life. Their use, except on strictly therapeutic grounds, is a grave offense. Clandestine production of and trafficking in drugs are scandalous practices. They constitute direct co-operation in evil, since they encourage people to practices gravely contrary to the moral law. "

The Church allows alcohol and tobacco in moderation. Alcohol is legal and marijuana is not. However, there is no reason if alcohol is legal that marijuana shouldn't be. We all know how bad alcohol is and it is worse than marijuana. Yet, alcohol is allowed in moderation as tobacco is.
Marijuana is not a drug, it is a plant like Tobacco. Tobacco is more of a drug than marijuana because of all the things added to it. Tobacco has many harmful chemicals added to it that kill you. Marijuana is natural. Also, tobacco is harmful to others and it endangers others because of second hand smoke which has been proven to be just as dangerous. Tobacco is not used for medicinal purposes. I just don't see how tobacco could be used in moderation at all and not marijuana. What does that mean? Two cigarettes a day??? That could still give you lung cancer, it is still doing harm to you no matter what and could endanger others if you live with someone because of the second hand smoke.

So, is marijuana allowed in moderation as those other substances? It seems as though it should be considering the other substances and how they can be bad for you. So marijuana being bad for you should not be an issue. Also, it being illegal should not be an issue because there are things that are legal that the Church is against like abortion, so in the same sense something illegal does not necessarily make it wrong if it is unjust. What is the Church's stance on marijuana in moderation? Thanks

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

The fact that marijuana is illegal is in fact an issue. We are obliged to follow civil law except where those laws conflict with God's law. You cite abortion as an instance where Catholics must not follow civil law, and you are correct. However, there is nothing in God's law saying that we are allowed to eat, drink, or smoke everything we can. The Church respects and upholds civil laws protecting the health of citizens, trusting the state as the competent authority in such matters. Therefore, we, with the Church, are obliged to follow civil law. Only when the Church's moral and religious authority disagrees with the state may we find exception to civil law.

God bless,

Raphael

PS-While the Church has not spoken explicitly about tobacco, you are right to point out its health risks as well. Some theologians consider tobacco smoking as a sin in light of what we now know it can do to a person's body. If so, this is another area where the moral authority of the Church trumps civil law. However, there has been nothing official, so none of us may judge absolutely.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Using tobacco is not a sin although I believe smoking cigarettes is a bad decision. The CCC speaks of tobacco use in the context of the virtue of temperance which suggests that the moderate use of tobacco is nothing of moral significance. The highly addictive properties of cigarettes generally lead to an excessive use of tobacco and an addiction which is obviously not a good thing but there is no sin in having a cigar from time to time or smoking a pipe whilst reading Chesterton by a fire. As with alcohol and other things (even food) the question of tobacco use is one of temperance and not intrinsic evils.
There is a document from a number of years ago addressed to health care workers which confirms this understanding of things in my opinion. Either way there is no condemnation of tobacco from the teaching authority of the Church and in fact the few mentions of tobacco that I've encountered suggest that the moderate use of the substance is of no moral significance, analogous to moderate alcohol consumption.

I must say these things are analogous because they are very different substances and when speaking of drugs – whether it is alcohol, nicotine, caffeine, THC, et cetera – the specifics are quite important in evaluating any moral dimension to the discussion.
While the Church has not spoken in detail about cigarettes, cigars, pipe, snuff, joints, bongs, hash or any such particulars, the principles are there for discerning particular situations and I think it is quite obvious that moderate tobacco use is perfectly acceptable and I would dare say that smoking a bowl of natural marijuana (the stuff that has very little THC) would not be a problem if it was legal. The illegal drug industry is evil and the junk they distribute is extremely potent so I am not saying that marijuana use is a light matter, it is clearly wrong, but I don’t think we should be too sweeping in statements about drugs since we just might end up condemning pints of beer, shots of booze or phat cigars.
Plenty of Popes have been fans of beer, wine and other drugs. In the 17th century the Pope condemned smoking in Church and a subsequent Pope virtually condemned tobacco but soon after you find Popes who used tobacco themselves. Indeed it wasn’t long before the Church completely overturned the condemnation of tobacco use. I guess even during the condemnation it was not uncommon to witness what one Pope describes as “the scandalous spectacle of dignitaries of the church hastening out in order to take a few clandestine whiffs in some corner away from spying eyes.”

There are plenty of great Catholics in history, and to this day, who enjoy tobacco in moderation or otherwise. I won’t name names, but a few years ago I was in the presence of a very well known and holy Catholic figure and I was a bit surprised when in the middle of our discussion he said we should go behind some cars so he could smoke a cigarette real quick without being caught. Hahaha
One of my favorite 20th century theologians was an excessive cigar smoker and a devout Franciscan priest. Some of my favorite Catholic authors were quite fond of the pipe and the pint. There is a certain modern Catholic philosopher that I am fond of whom I hear was inebriated more often than he was sober.
My point is not that excessive use of tobacco and alcohol is acceptable, quite the contrary, my point is that the moderate use of such things is perfectly within the limits of Catholic moral teaching. Again, I would argue that cigarettes are quite hard to justify, but having a cigar at the bachelor party or a pipe and a pint whilst winding down at the end of the day is not at all immoral, and abstaining from such things does not make one a better or more moral person. This is puritanical and fanatical in my opinion.

Other than this I don’t disagree with Raphael about the fact that conventional marijuana use would be sinful for Catholics for several reasons. I believe there would be exceptions such as medicinal marijuana or a puff of very mild bhang type marijuana whilst on holiday in India; I also wouldn’t see a problem with having a mild bhang tea to relax while visiting friends over in India. Similarly I don’t think having a warm mug of Mate de coca (a common drink which happens to contain cocaine) whilst touring South America would be any more morally significant than having some Starbucks coffee in the United States. Apparently Pope John Paul II enjoyed Mate de coca during his South American visit. Years ago a friend of mine sent me a couple kilograms of the tea and I enjoyed it quite frequently until I learned that it is illegal in the United States for some reason (only the decocainized form is legal which is like living in a country that only permits decaffeinated coffee – how sad).
None of these exceptions mean that I believe in taking lightly the horrendous problem of drugs in the world and in the United States, I just don’t believe in equating Catholic morality with puritanical or prohibitionary morality.

Perhaps it would be appropriate to move this thread to the debate board?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...