Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Infallibility And Primacy


Recommended Posts

Posted

I understand papal primacy to be the Pope's ability to govern the Church, a privilege that has evolved quite a bit from the early Church, while papal infallibility is the grace which protects the Pope's teaching authority as it was given by Christ to Peter.

This understanding came from a book I read entitled [u]Papal Primacy: From Its Origins to the Present[/u]. The book seemed to imply this. For example, the early church communities were often in charge of certain areas where Christians lived in the emires, but no one, not even the Bishop of Rome, could give a command to the other areas and expect the other to obey. Often times they sought the support of each others' decisions. However, the book also notes that whenever Rome quarreled with other churches on (what seems to have been) matters of faith and morals, it seemed to always have been the view that the rest of the churches adopted even when it lacked the superior thinkers of other churches.

[i]Basically, my question is this:[/i] is there a difference between papal primacy and papal infallibility?

Posted

I think that you answer your own question in stating it.

[quote name='pippo buono' post='1450192' date='Jan 24 2008, 05:01 PM']I understand papal primacy to be the Pope's ability to govern the Church, a privilege that has evolved quite a bit from the early Church, [i][b]while [/b][/i]papal infallibility is the grace which protects the Pope's teaching authority as it was given by Christ to Peter.[/quote]

And

[quote]...[u]but no one, not even the Bishop of Rome, could give a command to the other areas and expect the other to obey. [/u]Often times they sought the support of each others' decisions. However, the book also notes that whenever Rome quarreled with other churches on (what seems to have been) matters of faith and morals, it seemed to always have been the view that the rest of the churches adopted even when it lacked the superior thinkers of other churches.[/quote]


Concerning the underlined text, the Letter of Clement of Rome to Alexandria is an example when on "bishop" spoke with authority over and to another see. Even more importantly, the Ordinary Episcopal Magisterium, following the lead of an Eastern Bishop, transplanted to France, St. Irenaeus, eventually makes the issue of Roman primacy clear before the end of the 3rd Century of Christianity. And even before that, Tertullian, ironically, argues quite persuasively for the immaculate nature of the Roman See.

Let me know if this is not satisfactory.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...