Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Anyone Watch The Passion Interview


Recommended Posts

Posted

I did.

It seemed ok, I thought It'd be worse.

Although the lady who interviewed him looked to me like an Inquisitor, the way she skepticallu, unsmilingly kept glaring at him :ph34r:

Mel Gibson is :cool:

Posted

It was good but I didn't like the Traditional Catholic segment where is said he is a Roman Catholic b4 1960, but he was honest about his faith and conversion, and his reaction against anti-semetic allegations seemed to be fair and sound and now I don't have to listen to third person defenses anymore lol. Passion looks like it's gonna rock!

Posted

absolutely fantastic job by mel. answered all the tough questions truthfully and with poise.

the interview had me shook, i cant imagine what the movie is going to do to me. and i dont even get emotional at funerals.

stuff's gonna happen.

Posted

yep. It was interesting... in a good way

Posted

Well, I guess the bright side is that it was pretty clear that Mel thinks of himself a Roman Catholic. To the average non-Catholic, unless they studied, they wouldn't really know the difference between a Traditionalist Catholic and a Catholic anyway--so to them, he's simply a Catholic. When they see the film, they'll know that it was made by a Catholic--and hopefully, if they seek more after the film, they'll come home to the Catholic Church.

Posted

Just watching the trailer again makes me want to cry. I'm going to be devastated during the film (8 days for me). Thankfully we have Eucharistic adoration on Tuesdays (when I'll be seeing it). I have two papers do the next day, a test, a test and a quiz on Thursday and another quiz on Friday...but I'll be spending some serious reflection time in adoration after the movie.

Posted

To be honest, I wasn't impressed with him. First of all, while the average American might not notice, I certainly noticed that I'm not at all sure whether or not he's a schistrad or a Catholic. I think he should have been more honest about that.

My other problem with him was what he said about getting to Heaven. He said that Christianity was just the easier way, but that people of other faiths could get to Heaven. What he said is somewhat true, but it's not like the average American Buddhist can reject Christ and still stroll on into Heaven. That's not how it works. It seemed odd to me that a "Traditionalist Catholic" would so play down the doctrine of no salvation outside the Church, to the point that even a non-schistrad would think he sounded like a universalist.

I was left wondering whether or not he was a Catholic, a schistrad, a universalist, or "other." I don't think that's a good thing.

But I still think the movie will be great. I'm just not too fond of him.

Posted

Yeah. But then again, did you see how his Jewish actress was glaring at him as he was answering the question? What would you have done? Look at her and say she was going to hell? I think he reflected Catholic teaching fairly good, although, to me, it seemed like a post-Vatican II explanation of the doctrine rather than a pre-Vatican II... which he supposedly leans towards.

Oh well, maybe we should just take his "I'm a work in progress" statement at face value and pray that his spiritual growth leads him closer to embracing the Church in Her fullness.

Posted

You're right, praying for him is definitely what we should do. I just hope he doesn't speak a whole lot about the Faith unless he knows what he's saying and it's Catholic teaching. We've got enough people misrepresenting us.

But I do hope he grows in his faith, of course.

Posted

the way he explained "traditionalism" seems to be in line w/ Rome, whats the difference b/w the two? i'm not talking about just his view so much, or what he said just whats the difference b/w traditionalism and the Catholic Church?

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I like that -- work in progress. :)

Aren't we all!

I didn't get to see the interview, but I think it sounds like he's working through some stuff, discovering his own faith unique from the one he was raised on. We all do that to a certain extent (I mean at some point as an adult you say "this is my faith, I choose this freely")

Bless his heart.

Posted

i still think it was great, after being skeptical for awhile i'm happy to call him a fellow Christian and would likewise be happy to call him a fellow Catholic if i was myself, whether he's schismatic or not.

remember the last quote of the interview it was clutch. something like "Christ died for all people, for all cultures, for all time." or something like that.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

the way he explained "traditionalism" seems to be in line w/ Rome, whats the difference b/w the two? i'm not talking about just his view so much, or what he said just whats the difference b/w traditionalism and the Catholic Church?

Traditionalism is a valid part of the Catholic Church. The Pope has encouraged aspects of the traditionalist movement (ie., with the document Ecclesia Dei, the establishment of things such as The Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter, a pontifical institute, etc.)

The main thing about the traditionalist movement is that many aspects of Catholic tradition and culture have been obscured since the Council which should not have been (which is obvious from the Council documents themselves). There are different degrees of traditionalists though. Some feel the Church should restore the Tridentine Mass throughout the Church. Some feel a Tridentine Rite should be encouraged, other feel this is not necessary but that the novus ordo should be enriched with elements of the pre-Vatican II Mass. There are distinguished Cardinals and Bishops who are part of this movement.

The problematic groups are the schismatic traditionalists. They operate in defiance of the Church and often believe that the Church is off track. In the most extreme cases they deny the validity of Vatican II and even make outlandish claims such as that the last four popes were invalid. These are the groups that are not cool, but this should not give traditionalism in general a bad name.

The big question regarding Mel Gibson is whether or not he is a schismatic and is not in union with the Pope.

Posted (edited)

Well, I guess the bright side is that it was pretty clear that Mel thinks of himself a Roman Catholic. To the average non-Catholic, unless they studied, they wouldn't really know the difference between a Traditionalist Catholic and a Catholic anyway--so to them, he's simply a Catholic. When they see the film, they'll know that it was made by a Catholic--and hopefully, if they seek more after the film, they'll come home to the Catholic Church.

I don't think Diane Sawyer knows the difference or she might have asked the question about his union with the Papacy.

He did answer everything else very well. I loved the Schindler's List analogy.

Edited by socalscout
Posted

My sis who's in a non-denom. church was watching it at her house w/ a cousin and roommates. She actually called me all excitedly to ask if we were watching it! She thought he was doing great--I think so too.I was worried he'd be cornered into saying something that could be misconstrued.

VeraMaria noticed too how Diane Saywers looked at Mel Gibson w/ a skeptical look after each answer he gave her. The only time she smiled that I noticed (I missed the first few minutes) was at the end when she gave that supercorny "we at ABC learned a lot about each other too" or something like that line :rotfl:

I'm mostly glad I got to see more clips!

+JMJ+

Posted

The interview was severly edited, that was onvious to see. I am wondering about the other content. It seemed that Diane Sawyer was a little uncomfortable with Mel and Visa Versa. The greates part of the interview was definetelt the "work in progress" comment.

It seems as if Mel is committed to continual spiritual growth. And knowing that he acknowleges the Holy Spirit as a true presence, I hope he wil lead to to fuller communion and with the church today while still championing the beauty of the traditions.

It's those traditions which Mel is holding to while he is continual conversion. If what he says is true, it's probably safe to say that he will move closer to where we find ourself today, through contuinual study and meditaion of Christ and the Holy Spirit

Or at least we hope for that

Posted

I think Mel Gibson did very well, especially considering the interview was more like an interrogation.

Posted

I had to miss it because of my Knights of Columbus meeting. I did hear a clip from it on the radio this morning. It was when she asked him if he was anti-Semitic. I thought he answered that very well.

Posted

It was pretty well, but the part about the Vatican denying what the Pope said about the movie, made the Vatican look suspicious in the bad light.

I also recorded the entire interview, and it's on my PC right now in .wmv format.

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

It was.......

Interesting....Very well done...but....interesting....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...