Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Celibacy And Inheretince


Recommended Posts

Posted

Last night the CCD teacher for my 16 year old told the class that the Church mandated celibacy because they didn't want the property transfered to the families of the preists. Can someone give me a bit of background on where this is coming from. I think Matt 19 and 1 cor 7 have better explanations that should have been brought up. Why would the Church be worried since the preists don't own church property?

Posted

In my History class just this morning, my teacher said that celibacy was mandated around the 9th century in Western Europe because there was a feeling that the priests were becoming to worldly, and that having them be celibate would give them more time to concentrate on spiritual and churchly matters so they didn't have to worry about a family too. I don't know how correct she was, but spirituality seems a more likely reason than worrying about church property.

Posted

Pope Pelagius II in 580 said that it was okay to be married so long as the priests didn't hand over church property to wives or children. By the Lateran Councils in the 1100's it was more about chastity, but there were still areas where priests were married all the way up until the Council of Trent. Good thing for me since two of my direct ancestors were priests. They were good though, and didn't leave any church property to any of us.

Posted (edited)

[quote]To meet this, Otho decrees that any married clerk in possession of a benefice, loses all title to it [i]ipso jure[/i], and secondly, that all property in possession of such clerks or priests who have been clandestinely married before their promotion to Holy orders, is to go to the Church and none of it to their children. [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03481a.htm"]
Catholic Encyclopedia[/url][/quote]
As with most disciplines of the Church, there is typically a physical AND spiritual element to the practice (i.e. candles to light the dark catacombs, but also to represent the light of Christ overcoming the darkness of sin and death).

Technically speaking, it is historically accurate to say that there was a worldly reason priests were to remain celibate in addition to the spiritual aspect of being "married" to the Church and being a "father" to the parish.

However, IMHO, while a history professor might have reason to bring up the worldly reasons for celibacy in the early Church, I don't see how it is in a CCD instructors place to teach anything other than the religious aspect of the Church.

Edited by esmith818
LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='esmith818' post='1452260' date='Jan 28 2008, 11:05 PM']However, IMHO, while a history professor might have reason to bring up the worldly reasons for celibacy in the early Church, I don't see how it is in a CCD instructors place to teach anything other than the religious aspect of the Church.[/quote]

One good reason for the religious instructor to mention the worldly reasons is to ensure that the first time kids hear it isn't in their history class, which will most likely catch them off guard. How are you supposed to raise your hand in defense of something you were never prepared to defend?

Likewise, I think it would be worthwhile for the history teacher to mention the spiritual reasons because they affected the Church's decision. How can history be taught well while avoiding anything of spiritual significance?

Edited by LouisvilleFan

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...