Dismas Posted January 30, 2008 Posted January 30, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1452752' date='Jan 30 2008, 12:50 AM'] I'm not convinced.[/quote] I don't need to convince you. Experience and history will do that.
Aloysius Posted January 30, 2008 Posted January 30, 2008 Giuliani was already out of money by the time of the Florida primary. He needed to get a boost from Huckabee's pretty much out of money, it is entirely likely he will not be able to afford to make it through the rest of the states. Romney, McCain, and Ron Paul are the three who have the money to stay in the race to the end. This is going to be a brokered convention, folks, it's gonna be in large part about who the Huckabee delegates will be persuaded over to the side of. This caring about the people nonsense is hollow rhetoric. What degree of a role you want the Federal Government to have in people's lives is suddenly a measure of how much you care about them? Quite the contrary according to Catholic Social Justice Doctrines, which indicate that large and distant governments should not be involved with small local individuals because that will inevitably hurt their freedom. The lowest level that something can be done at, it should be done at. That means individuals and families should be responsible for as much as possible, then city and county governments, then state governments. The only reason for the federal government is to keep the peace and unity between the states and unite our policy outward to the world. I don't see how one can reconcile having the federal government involved in individual lives with Catholic Social Justice. ah well... that's a whole other subject, just thought I'd make my spiel against the idea that a pro-life democrat is what we should be looking for. I think there will be three candidates at the convention (possibly four if Huckabee can justify staying in without being able to pay any campaign staff). And God help the Grand Old Party if they don't (as they likely won't, but the hope is not totally absent) nominate Ron Paul.
XIX Posted January 30, 2008 Posted January 30, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1452783' date='Jan 30 2008, 08:32 AM']The lowest level that something can be done at, it should be done at. That means individuals and families should be responsible for as much as possible, then city and county governments, then state governments. The only reason for the federal government is to keep the peace and unity between the states and unite our policy outward to the world. I don't see how one can reconcile having the federal government involved in individual lives with Catholic Social Justice. ah well... that's a whole other subject, just thought I'd make my spiel against the idea that a pro-life democrat is what we should be looking for. I think there will be three candidates at the convention (possibly four if Huckabee can justify staying in without being able to pay any campaign staff). And God help the Grand Old Party if they don't (as they likely won't, but the hope is not totally absent) nominate Ron Paul.[/quote] Yeah. I've heard all of the rhetoric about how small government is better government, but I am almost completely unconvinced. Mostly because the rhetoric is almost entirely based on assertions, not arguments. Al, with all due respect, your post reads like this "Small government is better than big government, because..."
Aloysius Posted January 30, 2008 Posted January 30, 2008 Because people have a bigger say in local government, people have a bigger influence over local governments, people work on a fair and level playing field when they deal with a local government than when they must deal with a far and distant government. Whenever someone says: the Federal Government should do that, I ask "why stop there? why not have the U.N. make it a worldwide law?"... there is no good answer to that, it's the same principal. no, people are empowered when their local government is the thing which decides things. how much easier is it to run for public office on the local level? how much more does you vote count in a local election? tons. it's about respect for the dignity of the human person, giving him a fair say in things and keeping him on a level playing field. It's the Catholic principal of subsidarity: whatever CAN be done at the lowest possible level SHOULD be done at the lowest possible level. this is not my idea, this is not my argument, the is the social justice doctrine of the Catholic Church. actually, this isn't so much about small government vs. big government, but about local government vs. distant governments. I'm not saying Catholics ought to be libertarians, I'm saying they ought to believe in empowering the lower levels to deal with things which are in their realm to do and keep the larger distant governments at bay so that people have the power to actually engage their authorities on a fair playing field. I've said a lot more on the subject, and it is arguments drawing on the principals of subsidarity, the dignity of the human person, and the practical side of why things work better that way. This thread is about McCain and the three other candidates left in the running for the Republican nomination, of course.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now