RemnantRules Posted February 1, 2008 Posted February 1, 2008 Ok I really need some serious help with this one! Blessed Be God!!! First Thank You to those who will help me. I have a professor who is teaching Pop Music in American Culture and he gave us a handout with "Facts from the Good Old Days" I will will post the introduction then the "facts" he gives. I need help with finding out with sources if any of his statements that he presents are false. FYI, I have no idea why any of this has to do with the class, but at the end of this I'll let you know a little more about him. I use this handout in my graduate Medieval courses to teach real scholars how to separate “fact” from “urban legend.” There are many sites on the internet that will tell you that all of this is “urban legend”; unfortunately, many of these sites are posted by people with little or no qualifications in Medieval studies. In fact, most of the information below is true (trust me, UNT hired me as a Medieval scholar . . . . it’s what I do when not teaching the pop music course). Yeah, the first one really is true! A pre-Freudian slip? . . . . the 1631 edition of the King James’ Bible had the following typo: “Thou shalt commit adultery.” The Catholic priest officiating at the wedding practiced jus primae noctis - the first opportunity to “rock-&-roll” with the bride . . . . the first “official” opportunity, anyway. It’s only later, as you see in “Braveheart,” that the local lord also gets into the act. The defloration ritual - a “danger” rather than a privilege - was connected to Christian fears of demonic possession and hymeneal blood. “If one takes a wife, he does not sleep with her as the first man, but there are poor servants who do this and take the girl’s virginity, and for doing so the servants are paid. The vagina of the daughter is sorcered and poisoned, and it is dangerous to sleep with a daughter for the first time, but later on it is not dangerous at all.” Otto von Diemeringen, Strasbourg 1484. Despite the dangers of sex . . Pope Leo VII died of a heart attack during sex. Pope John VII was bludgeoned to death by angry husband . . . . while making love to the wife. Pope John XIII was also murdered by an irate husband. Pope Paul II died of a heart attack while being sodomized by a pageboy. Isn’t this the same church that excommunicated Galileo for supporting the findings of Copernicus? And which kept Galileo’s Dialogue (1632), based on Copernicus’ De Revolutionibus Orbium Coelestium (1543) - which described a heliocentric system in which the earth revolved around the Sun - on the Index Librorum Prohibitorum (list of banned books) until 1822? . . . . until the year after Missouri (the “show me” state) became the 24th state admitted to the Union? Ever wonder why the hood for the doctoral degree in music is “pink”? It’s because - in the Medieval world – “music” was considered the second-highest of the academic disciplines. “Red” was the color for the highest discipline - theology. God got red; we got pink. That’s why you see the Protestant minister (with a Ph.D.) wearing red trim on his/her vestment. It was a practice among early Christians to “tie a knot” when invoking the assistance of a particular saint so as to bind that saint to them until the saint had done their bidding. From the “Dark Ages” (which these people didn’t really call the “Dark” Ages or the “Middle” Ages) to the 18th century, at weddings it was considered bad luck for someone other than the happy couple to tie a knot, for fear that it would prevent a true union between the bride and the groom. For protection, 5 knots were tied in a cord and worn around the body (don’t monks wear “knotted” belts?). A cord with 40 knots might be kept as a protection against thieves (doesn’t this look like a rosary?). Why do Catholics genuflect (kneel on the right knee, in adoration) with the right knee? Because kneeling on the left knee would smack the sword of the Medieval knight onto the ground. “Friday the 13th, unlucky for some” (“some” being the Templars - thanks to King Philip the Fair who, with the support of Pope Clement V, ordered the arrest of the Templar Knights. The motivation seems to have been money; Philip the (not so) Fair owed a substantial loan to the Templars - a loan he preferred not to repay. Actually, Philip the “Fair” refers to his looks rather than to his behavior. It also appears that the modern system of Western European banking - with loans and credits - begins with the Templars (The Order of the “Poor” Knights of Christ and the Temple of Solomon . . . . who became filthy rich). Martin Luther’s “95 thesis” nailed to the door of the castle church in Wittenberg. While Luther did compile and circulate 95 arguments for discussion, there is no evidence to suggest that he actually nailed these to the door of the church. Read carefully the re-writing of history in the legend of Lady Godiva, where she is transformed from the original “Saint” Godiva who was willing to ride naked through the marketplace (accompanied by two knights, for protection) in order to save the poor . . . . . then to someone riding naked through the marketplace without need of an armed escort (because no good Christian would look at a naked woman) . . . . and who, by the 21st century, is some tramp-on-a-horse who causes on-lookers to go blind. Note that “c. 1075, Lady Godiva refers in her will to ‘the circlet of precious stones which she had threaded on a cord in order that by fingering them one after another she might count her prayers exactly.’” Hmm . . . .doesn’t sound like much of a whore. Note also that Texas has two exemptions, specifying those people who cannot be charged with violating “peeping Tom” laws: men over 50 years of age . . . . and men who have only one eye! The First Record of Lady Godiva (approx. 1236) Having founded this monastery by the advice of his wife the noble countess Godiva, he [Leofric, the husband], at the prayer of a religious woman, placed monks therein, and so enriched them with lands, woods, and ornaments, that there was not found in all England a monastery with such an abundance of gold and silver, gems and costly garments. The countess Godiva, who was a great lover of God’s mother, longing to free the town of Coventry from the oppression of a heavy toll, often with urgent prayers besought her husband, that from regard to Jesus Christ and his mother, he would free the town from that service, and from all other heavy burdens; and when the earl sharply rebuked her for foolishly asking what was so much to his damage, and always forbade her ever more to speak to him on the subject; and while she on the other hand, with a woman’s pertinacity, never ceased to exasperate her husband on that matter, he a last made her this answer, [This is the important part] “Mount your horse, and ride naked, before all the people, through the market of the town, from one end to the other, and on your return you shall have your request.” On which Godiva replied, “But will you give me permission, if I am willing to do it?” “I will,” said he. Whereupon the countess, beloved of God, loosed her hair and let down her tresses, which covered the whole of her body like a veil, and then mounting her horse and attended by two knights, she rode through the market-place, without being seen, except her fair legs; and having completed the journey, she returned with gladness to her astonished husband, and obtained of him what she had asked; for earl Leofric freed the town of Coventry and its inhabitants from the aforesaid service, and confirmed what he had done by a charter. Roger of Wendover, Flowers of History The Catholic Retelling of the Tale (approx. 1572, from the original English) But Gaufride sayth that this gentle and good Lady did not onely for the freeing of the said Citie and satisfying of her husbands pleasure, graunt vnto her sayde Husband to ryde as aforesayde: But also called in secret manner (by such as she put speciall trust in) all those that then were Magistrates and rulers of the said Citie of Couentrie, and vttered vnto them what good will she bare vnto the sayde Citie, and how shee had moued the Erle her husband to make the same free, the which vpon such condition as is afore mencioned, the sayde Erle graunted vnto her, which the sayde Lady was well contented to doe, requiring of them for the reuerence of womanhed, that at that day and tyme that she should ride (which was made certaine vnto them) that streight commaundement should be geuen throughout all the City, that euerie person should shut in their houses and Wyndowes, and none so hardy to looke out into the streetes, nor remayne in the stretes, vpon a very great paine, so that when the tyme came of her out ryding none sawe her, but her husbande and such as were present with him, and she and her Gentlewoman to wayte vpon her galoped through the Towne, where the people might here the treading of their Horsse, but they saw her not, and so she returned to her Husbande from the place from whence she came, her honestie saued, her purpose obteyned, her wisdome much commended, and her husbands imagination vtterly disappointed. And shortly after her returne, when shee had arayed and apparelled her selfe in most comely and seemly manner, then shee shewed her selfe openly to the peuple of the Citie of Couentrie, to the great joy and maruellous reioysing of all the Citizens and inhabitants of the same, who by her had receyued so great a benefite. Richard Grafton, M.P. for Coventry The Legend of “Peeping Tom” (17th century) “One of the myth’s most interesting subplots involves the role of ‘Peeping Tom’. . . . who doesn’t even appear in the story until the seventeenth century. According to legend, the people of Coventry, as a gesture of respect and appreciation for Lady Godiva’s actions on their behalf, stayed indoors behind shuttered windows to preserve her modesty as she passed. Everyone, that is, except Tom, whose lustful curiosity compelled him to gaze at her and who was then, according to various versions of the legend, struck either blind or dead in punishment. Over time, Tom would become the scapegoat and bear the symbolic guilt for people’s desire to look at this naked woman.” Daniel Donoghue Professor of English and American literature and language, Harvard University END I know this is ALOT of things so any help will be MUCH appreciative. To conclude about him he has a PHD in Medieval Music Theory and was a seminarian. Here is a direct quote from his class reguarding these "facts" above: “I was in the seminary so like if you’re Catholic and your offended by any of this bring it on. I was in there! Umm so I would be happy to argue with you and your wrong! You’ve been brain washed. Look at History!...” I spoke with a friend he really helped me understand that I must respond back with love and humility, but I know I must stand up for my Church. Thank You again. God Bless Jason Gregory
Laudate_Dominum Posted February 1, 2008 Posted February 1, 2008 [quote name='RemnantRules' post='1453914' date='Feb 1 2008, 01:51 AM']A pre-Freudian slip? . . . . the 1631 edition of the King James’ Bible had the following typo: “Thou shalt commit adultery.”[/quote] Yeah, that's true but calling it a Freudian slip is incorrect. There were at least 1,500 misprints among the various printings of the King James Version in the seventeenth century. I guess there were a lot of sloppy compositors. This doesn't sound like a "scholarly" anti-Catholic but just a clown who enjoys sensational controversy. As you know the King James Bible isn't even Catholic so this certainly isn't anti-Catholic in the proper sense. [quote name='RemnantRules' post='1453914' date='Feb 1 2008, 01:51 AM']The Catholic priest officiating at the wedding practiced jus primae noctis - the first opportunity to “rock-&-roll” with the bride . . . . the first “official” opportunity, anyway. It’s only later, as you see in “Braveheart,” that the local lord also gets into the act.[/quote] Herodotus, Valerius Maximus and even the ancient Epic of Gilgamesh mention practices similar to [i]jus primae noctis[/i] in the ancient world so such a practice is possible in some primitive societies. The evidence for medieval [i]jus primae noctis[/i] is extremely asinine and modern scholars believe it was nothing more than a kind of legend. This "professor" is teaching rubbish and I don't know where he gets this weird idea about Catholic priests practicing [i]jus primae noctis[/i]. In any case a recent (and secular) scholarly study of the issue that I read (and which reflects scholarly consensus) shows how the "evidence" is just fables and legends and that there is no evidence for this practice in reality, even if some post-medieval people believed that this practice actually happened back then. For example Voltaire assumes that the medieval lords actually did such a thing and there is even art in honor of this mythical practice. It seems fair to assume that this legend took off in reformation and/or enlightenment propaganda. I'm sure this guy realizes that Braveheart is Hollywood and not history and that most of the details in that movie are fictional. [quote name='RemnantRules' post='1453914' date='Feb 1 2008, 01:51 AM']The defloration ritual - a “danger” rather than a privilege - was connected to Christian fears of demonic possession and hymeneal blood. “If one takes a wife, he does not sleep with her as the first man, but there are poor servants who do this and take the girl’s virginity, and for doing so the servants are paid. The vagina of the daughter is sorcered and poisoned, and it is dangerous to sleep with a daughter for the first time, but later on it is not dangerous at all.” Otto von Diemeringen, Strasbourg 1484.[/quote] You've got to be kidding me. Diemeringen wrote fictional accounts of world travel that were popular in the Middle Ages. This paraphrase comes from the travels of John of Mandeville and is describing "[i]a strange custom on an oriental island[/i]", there is nothing historical about this at all other than that such shocking myths can be found in some medieval literature when speaking of the practices of Indians and other exotic, far away peoples. This is a good example of what I mean when I say the "evidence" is legendary and fictitious rather than being real history. It is a medieval literary theme and not a real practice among medieval Europeans (although again, something like it has probably occurred in primitive societies) and it is certainly not a Catholic custom. *barf* Btw, to say that this is "[i]connected to Christian fears of demonic possession and hymeneal blood[/i]" is a bit irresponsible to say the least. This legend of an exotic oriental land does not mean that medieval Europeans "feared" hymeneal blood; the pagan sorcerers on this island apparently enchant and poison the vagina which is why it is dangerous. Further, the practice is described in this work of fiction as strange and horrible so how does one jump from this to the idea that it reflects a normal practice among Europeans? [quote name='RemnantRules' post='1453914' date='Feb 1 2008, 01:51 AM']“I was in the seminary so like if you’re Catholic and your offended by any of this bring it on. I was in there! Umm so I would be happy to argue with you and your wrong! You’ve been brain washed. Look at History!...”[/quote] I can't believe this guy is serious. Ok, fine, take him up on that and "look at history," you may find that he's being absurd. I'm not sure what point he is trying to make with half that stuff anyway. The Lady Godiva thing is lame too. Um.., big deal. There are plenty of amusing legends in history, how is this supposed to shake my faith? Dumb. You can probably find a lot of stuff online if you don't have a good library nearby. [url="http://www.octavia.net/books/godgyfu/historicalgodiva.htm"]http://www.octavia.net/books/godgyfu/historicalgodiva.htm[/url] [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godiva"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godiva[/url] [url="http://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/britannia/anglo-saxon/flowers/godiva.html"]http://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encycl...ers/godiva.html[/url] I've encountered legends that are much more bizarre than that one. In one story a woman transforms into a hairy beast and runs off into the woods, her father puts up a reward for anyone who can bring her back. Every man who tried is killed and devoured by this hairy crazy lady. Finally a hero shows up who is able to tame her and turn her into a beautiful woman with his "wand and eggs"; gee, I wonder what those are? Well, when the beast woman asks his response is, "lie down with me here and I will show you." I know of plenty more ancient European legends that this guy would probably love. haha Oh, and he'd love to point out how Catholic monks copied these stories for us so that they survive to this day. Those naughty monks! Well, is an historian of ancient literature a pervert for studying such traditions? I don't think its fair to assume that scholarly monks who preserved strange stories did so because they had twisted fetishes; maybe they just respected the value of folk traditions and earthy humor. This is not the usual Q&A question and there is a lot of carp to comment on but I can't right now. Plus scanning over it there are some far out statements that I've never heard before and I can't answer (but they reek of bull imho). My point is that perhaps this thread would be more appropriate in Transmundane Lane?
Laudate_Dominum Posted February 1, 2008 Posted February 1, 2008 Here are some things to check out. [url="http://www.fibri.de/jus/Wettlaufer_HBE_2000.pdf"]http://www.fibri.de/jus/Wettlaufer_HBE_2000.pdf[/url] [i]The existence of a "right of the first night" in the Middle Ages was a disputed topic in the nineteenth century. Although most historians today would agree that there is no authentic proof of the actual exercise of the custom in the Middle Ages, disagreement continues about the origin, the meaning, and the development of the widespread popular belief in this alleged right and the actual prevalence of symbolic gestures referring to this right.[/i] [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_primae_noctis"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_primae_noctis[/url] [url="http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a5_181.html"]http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a5_181.html[/url] [url="http://www.snopes.com/weddings/customs/droit.htm"]http://www.snopes.com/weddings/customs/droit.htm[/url] [i]Whether Wallace married her is surely an academically sterile point. His only known wife lived long enough to present him with a daughter (which this girl manifestly did not). The episode in the film is fictional, invented to illustrate the effect of Gibson's introduction of jus primae noctis into Scotland, for many the most hilarious absurdity in his quite extraordinary masquerade... The idea that King Edward encouraged his colonial entrepreneurs with the rewards of jus primae noctis is ludicrous. We have no evidence that this custom ever existed in the British Isles at all (and even in continental Europe, where it may have had some meaning, it is believed to have been a form of taxation paid by a peasant groom for his right to enjoy his wife).[/i] [url="http://www.baronage.co.uk/bphtm-01/wallace3.html"]http://www.baronage.co.uk/bphtm-01/wallace3.html[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted February 1, 2008 Posted February 1, 2008 Shucks, I just noticed you already have this thread in Transmundane so I guess I'll move this one back to the Q&A and hopefully other Church Scholars will address some of the other points. There are a few others that I would mind commenting on too. Btw, I've heard that this book is good so if you are interested in history this might be cool. [url="http://www.amazon.com/Those-Terrible-Middle-Ages-Debunking/dp/0898707811/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1201857632&sr=1-1"]http://www.amazon.com/Those-Terrible-Middl...7632&sr=1-1[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted February 14, 2008 Posted February 14, 2008 Many popular myths are addressed here. [url="http://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/renaissance.html"]http://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/renaissance.html[/url] [url="http://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/medmyths.html"]http://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/medmyths.html[/url] Thanks to [url="http://www.danielmitsui.com/hieronymus/"]Daniel Mitsui[/url] for the source.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now