Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys, I've been debating with a Calvinist over on another forum, and I need some help with responding to what he said. I want to get into the actual Greek with him in regards to John 6:53, but the part I'm struggling with is where he argues that we would need to take the Eucharist 3-4 times a day to satisfy the requirements that the Church has set forward.

Thoughts, opinions, advice?

Here's his post, he doesn't use paragraphs so that parts not my fault =P

[quote]You said that the reality of the Eucharist is that Jesus is physically present during every mass and you worship him. Perhaps your reality is based upon the teachings of Roman Catholicism and not on the word of God. Jesus speaks of this issue in Matt 24:24-26– For false Christs and false prophets will arise and will show great signs and wonders, so as to mislead, if possible, even the elect. “Behold, I have told you in advance. “So if they say to you, ‘Behold, he is in the inner rooms, ‘ do not believe them. You also remain fixated on John 6:53 again as referring to actual eating and drinking. However John, to continually have Jesus present in you in that way, one would have to be partaking of the Eucharist several times a day due to the natural removal of bread and wine from the body. This again shows that the Eucharistic teaching of Rome is faulty. The biblical Apostolic teaching is that the believer is sealed with the Holy Spirit, meaning the Holy Spirit lives continually in the believer. This is exactly why in John 14:18 Jesus declares “I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you. Back to your comment about Jesus being physically present in the Mass and you worship him as he requires. Why then would Jesus say to Thomas “Because you have seen me , have you believed? Blessed are they who did not see, and yet believed.” I and innumerable others commonly referred to as Protestants do not need to think of Jesus being physically present in bread and wine to believe. The fact of the matter is that the New Testament does not give even a hint of the Roman teaching of the Eucharist, as to Jesus being physically present in the eucharist. Hebrews 1:8- When he had made purification of sins, he sat down at the right hand of the majesty on high. 7:27- Who does not need DAILY, like those high priests, to offer up sacrifices, first for his own sins and then for the sins of the people, because this he did ONCE for all when he offered up himself. 9:28 So Christ also, having been offered ONCE to bear the sins of MANY, will appear a SECOND TIME for salvation without REFERENCE TO SIN, to those who eagerly await him. The overwhelming biblical verdict is that Jesus Christ offered himself up one time and one time only for the sins of many. What Jesus Christ did, he did perfectly and there is no need for it to be repeated, no not repeated, just preached and remembered. Luke 22:19- NASB “This is my body which is given for you; do this in remembrance of me.”[/quote]

Posted

I can't help you much with the Greek, but this is what I got. It really helps a lot to teach yourself to recognize statements that aren't actually arguments, or are actually unrelated to the issue. I hope this helps you out.

[quote]You said that the reality of the Eucharist is that Jesus is physically present during every mass and you worship him. Perhaps your reality is based upon the teachings of Roman Catholicism and not on the word of God.[/quote]
This is just a plain old accusation. If God commanded that the Catholic church be built(which is ultimately the issue at the core of all Christian debating), then we are consentrating on the word of God BY following the teachings of Catholicism.

[quote]Jesus speaks of this issue in Matt 24:24-26– For false Christs and false prophets will arise and will show great signs and wonders, so as to mislead, if possible, even the elect.[/quote]
Jesus only spoke of this issue if your Lutheran opponent is right about Catholicism. Without conclusive proof for anyone's stance, these verses can be crudely applied to anyone, even to him.

[quote]“Behold, I have told you in advance. “So if they say to you, ‘Behold, he is in the inner rooms, ‘ do not believe them.[/quote]
Taken in context, this verse speaks of Christ's return, when everyone will see Christ because His presense will be obvious. People claiming that He is in the inner rooms would be people with their eyes closed because they can't see Christ out their own front window.

[quote]You also remain fixated on John 6:53 again as referring to actual eating and drinking. However John, to continually have Jesus present in you in that way, one would have to be partaking of the Eucharist several times a day due to the natural removal of bread and wine from the body. This again shows that the Eucharistic teaching of Rome is faulty.[/quote]
Not really. Jesus commanded us to eat his flesh and drink his blood. He did not command us to have his flesh and blood in our stomachs at every moment of every day. The natural removal of the host and the wine says nothing about one's ability to eat and drink.

[quote]The biblical Apostolic teaching is that the believer is sealed with the Holy Spirit, meaning the Holy Spirit lives continually in the believer. This is exactly why in John 14:18 Jesus declares “I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you.[/quote]
This is just plain unrelated. Also note by the phrase "the biblical apostolic teaching" - he is assuming himself to be right to support his argument that he is right. This section is unrelated to the issue at hand, but keep an eye out for such assumptions in the future.

[quote]Back to your comment about Jesus being physically present in the Mass and you worship him as he requires. Why then would Jesus say to Thomas “Because you have seen me , have you believed? Blessed are they who did not see, and yet believed.” I and innumerable others commonly referred to as Protestants do not need to think of Jesus being physically present in bread and wine to believe.[/quote]
He is quite right here - you do not have to believe that the Eucharist is really His flesh and blood to believe in Him. That invalidated his own argument as being once again unrelated here. You don't have to see to believe. But God didn't command us just to believe. There is much more he wants us to do - we as Catholics believe that the Eucharist is another one of those things.

[quote]The fact of the matter is that the New Testament does not give even a hint of the Roman teaching of the Eucharist, as to Jesus being physically present in the eucharist.[/quote]
If this claim of his were actually true, then he would have been able to address your argument regarding John six. The only "refutation" of your argument that I see is his use of other bible verses. This only implies biblical contradiction and forces one to choose one verse over another - and he provides no motivation to choose his verse.

[quote]Hebrews 1:8- When he had made purification of sins, he sat down at the right hand of the majesty on high. 7:27- Who does not need DAILY, like those high priests, to offer up sacrifices, first for his own sins and then for the sins of the people, because this he did ONCE for all when he offered up himself. 9:28 So Christ also, having been offered ONCE to bear the sins of MANY, will appear a SECOND TIME for salvation without REFERENCE TO SIN, to those who eagerly await him. The overwhelming biblical verdict is that Jesus Christ offered himself up one time and one time only for the sins of many. What Jesus Christ did, he did perfectly and there is no need for it to be repeated, no not repeated, just preached and remembered. Luke 22:19- NASB “This is my body which is given for you; do this in remembrance of me.”[/quote]
This is all true. What his argument here does is assume that the Eucharist is considered another sacrifice every mass, which is of course not true. Christ made one sacrifice, but that one sacrifice is eternal(not infinite or everlasting). So the Eucharist at the mass is not a new sacrifice. It is the same one, or if you don't like that wording - the result of His only sacrifice.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='SaintOlaf' post='1454293' date='Feb 1 2008, 08:23 PM']Hey guys, I've been debating with a Calvinist over on another forum, and I need some help with responding to what he said. I want to get into the actual Greek with him in regards to John 6:53, but the part I'm struggling with is where he argues that we would need to take the Eucharist 3-4 times a day to satisfy the requirements that the Church has set forward.

Thoughts, opinions, advice?

Here's his post, he doesn't use paragraphs so that parts not my fault =P[/quote]

Well, I'm definitely no expert but a few points:

The Bible definitely does speak of the Eucharist. I'm no good with verses but it's in the gospels (John, in particular, I think). I know that Jesus very definitely commands that we eat His flesh and drink His blood. He was questioned about this and many of those listening walked away scandalized by the idea. I think it was Scott Hahn who pointed out that if he was only speaking allegorically or metaphorically, he probably would have clarified the point after the dissention that ensued from his proclomation, don't you think? But he clearly did not. Thus, we have every reason to believe He meant what He said when He told us to eat His flesh and drink His blood.

As far as the removal of the bread and wine from our bodies; I don't have a clear answer but Transubstatiation changes the bread and wine to the actual body and blood of Christ under the [i]appearance[/i] of bread and wine. So, it is not quite the same as consuming normal food. In any case, my understanding is that the auspices of bread and wine are just that and do not pass through us the same way normal physical matter does. I don't pretend to know for sure, but this is my own understanding of the teaching.

Good luck and definitely check out the defense directory which has much better information than I :)

ETA: Oh, and Christ is not resacrificed at every Mass. That's something else you should point out to him.

Edited by Tinkerlina
Posted

Christ is not said to be "physically present" in the eucharist, in the manner that you would take a bite out of his arm. He is sacramentally present, which is more than a physical prescence and more than a physical prescence. The Eucharist is his body, blood soul and divinity but sacramentally so. You will not see it spoken of as a physical prescence anywhere in the church teachings of the Catechism or councils or papal docements.

We must also be careful in this debate that we don't deny the symbolic and metaphorical components of the eucharist and of christ's words. I do agree that in a metaphorical sense one can speak of John 6 and eating his body and drinking his blood as about believing but the words are too literal to just mean that. The greek is to gnaw or chew when he says "unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood you shall not have life within you."

One should also recongize the parrallels between John 6 and Matt 26 (they were 1 year apart) as well for the benefit of those who try to separate the two. Both were near the passover, in both Peter expresses his faith and in both Judas betrayal is spoken of. In john 6 Jesus says "my flesh is true food...my blood is true drink" mt says "this is my body, this is my blood" and clearly John 6 points to the cross when he says "the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world. So John 6 cannot be separated from the last supper and the cross.

Hope that helps.

Posted

Oh and anotha thingy. The Mass is not a sacrificing of Christ over and over or again. It is the once for all sacrifice. but the once for all is eternal. Christ's sacrifice in all eternity was brought in to time and space on the cross a calvary. Malachi 1:11 speaks about a pure sacrifice from the rising to the setting of the sun, which is the eucharist. the mass is performed continuously somewhere in the world throughout the day taping in to christ's eternal but once for all sacrifcie. As an example let''s say I am going from minneapolis to denver and along the way I pick up someone in Iowa and drop them off in south dakota and pick up someone in south dakota and drop them off in nebraska. where I pick someone up and bring them to denver. That is more what the Eucharist is like, applying the grace from the cross, in the unbloody reee-presentation (not rep-resentation) of Christ's sacrifice. Not three trips to denver but one eternal trip to our salvation by his grace. Mal 1:11 was recognized by the early church fathers as applying to Christ's sacrifice as well.

Posted

[quote]You also remain fixated on John 6:53 again as referring to actual eating and drinking. However John, to continually have Jesus present in you in that way, one would have to be partaking of the Eucharist several times a day due to the natural removal of bread and wine from the body. This again shows that the Eucharistic teaching of Rome is faulty.[/quote]

The previous posts excellently present a counterargument. I have only a little to add.

First, I am certainly glad I don't have your bowels. Three or four times a day is just too much.

You are what you eat. When we eat, we assimilate that food into ourselves. This is a thing that the ancients, including the Jews and Early Church, understood.

Eat good food, you become healthy and strong. Eat diseased food, and you will become diseased. Spiritually, this is the core of Kosher Law, for you are changed by what you consume. As we now know, the Law of the Covenant of Moses was to instruct and prepare the Jews, and thereby all humanity, for the coming of Christ.

This is all a precursor. Christ gives us the full revelation. We are to "gnaw/chew" on the "meat/flesh" of the Son of man and drink of His blood. By eating and drinking His very flesh and blood, He becomes part of us, and we truly do become One Body in Jesus Christ.

The Jews knew Jesus meant what He said, that is why they left in John 6:66. It is no small wonder that the Early Church was derided from the beginning as "cannibals".

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...