cmotherofpirl Posted February 3, 2008 Posted February 3, 2008 [url="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/02/03/nbenefit103.xml&CMP=ILC-mostviewedbox"]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml...C-mostviewedbox[/url]
Deb Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 The same holds true in the U.S., at least in Minnesota. I had a child support case and it took me a long time to figure out what was going on. Man and two wives and ten kids from another Country. They couldn't place them in an apartment big enough for them all so they had two apartments, right next to each other and wife number one lived with man and their kids and wife number two lived next door with their mutual kids. Each household got a full welfare grant. They were married prior to entering the U.S. so their marriages are considered valid. It does not work that way if they are culturally married in the U.S. Trippy
Justin86 Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1455056' date='Feb 4 2008, 10:08 AM']The same holds true in the U.S., at least in Minnesota. I had a child support case and it took me a long time to figure out what was going on. Man and two wives and ten kids from another Country. They couldn't place them in an apartment big enough for them all so they had two apartments, right next to each other and wife number one lived with man and their kids and wife number two lived next door with their mutual kids. Each household got a full welfare grant. They were married prior to entering the U.S. so their marriages are considered valid. It does not work that way if they are culturally married in the U.S. Trippy[/quote] Reason #59,827,439,048 why we should get rid of any form of welfare.
bdouglass Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 Insanity. The movement for Sharia Law in the UK marches on.
Deb Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1455093' date='Feb 3 2008, 08:40 PM']Reason #59,827,439,048 why we should get rid of any form of welfare.[/quote] Yes, you are right. We should have just left them all to continue living in the refugee camp they had been in for the last fifteen years. I mean after all, supporting them with our tax dollars? The nerve. They aren't Americans so they shouldn't be entitled to a better life. Let them die in the camps. It can save us money which we in turn can turn around and use for wars and stuff so we can kill people. Where have our priorities been? For the record, I think they should be receiving benefits for a family of thirteen instead of two separate families although the difference is not a lot.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 4, 2008 Author Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1455287' date='Feb 4 2008, 09:48 AM']Yes, you are right. We should have just left them all to continue living in the refugee camp they had been in for the last fifteen years. I mean after all, supporting them with our tax dollars? The nerve. They aren't Americans so they shouldn't be entitled to a better life. Let them die in the camps. It can save us money which we in turn can turn around and use for wars and stuff so we can kill people. Where have our priorities been? For the record, I think they should be receiving benefits for a family of thirteen instead of two separate families although the difference is not a lot.[/quote] Nobody said they had to live in a refugee camp, so get off your high horse. The US government should not be supporting a marriage that is illegal in this country.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='bdouglass' post='1455263' date='Feb 4 2008, 09:48 AM']Insanity. The movement for Sharia Law in the UK marches on.[/quote] Only two percent of Muslim men worldwide have more than one wife. Polygynous marriages are not as common as you might think, partly because of the Islamic requirement that all wives have to be treated equally (this is very expensive) and partly because polygamy no longer has any of the practical merits that it had over a thousand years ago. The only people whom this amendment will benefit are conmen and tricksters looking for novel ways of playing the system.
RandomProddy Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1455313' date='Feb 4 2008, 04:37 PM']Only two percent of Muslim men worldwide have more than one wife. Polygynous marriages are not as common as you might think, partly because of the Islamic requirement that all wives have to be treated equally (this is very expensive) and partly because polygamy no longer has any of the practical merits that it had over a thousand years ago. The only people whom this amendment will benefit are conmen and tricksters looking for novel ways of playing the system.[/quote] Whilst this is true, I share the distaste of some posters in this. Personally, I don't think we should be giving conmen and tricksters any kind of extra leeway in this. If I hadn't just gone on a retreat this weekend i'd probably be more convinced of the pointlessness of getting married in Britain.
Deb Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1455309' date='Feb 4 2008, 10:19 AM']Nobody said they had to live in a refugee camp, so get off your high horse. The US government should not be supporting a marriage that is illegal in this country.[/quote] That comment wasn't directed to you. I was just relating that specific situation and the refugee camp is where they came from. So, read the posts before you attack. Edited February 4, 2008 by Deb
MissScripture Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1455397' date='Feb 4 2008, 02:06 PM']That comment wasn't directed to you. I was just relating that specific situation and the refugee camp is where they came from. So, read the posts before you attack.[/quote] No one still said that they had to stay in a refugee camp. She just said that the US Government should not have to support a marriage that is illegal in this country.
HeavenlyCalling Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 (edited) The people of the United States should not have to support anyone. That is the responsibility of charitable organizations. Drug distribution is legal someplaces, should the taxpayers support addicts who got addicted were it was legal? Of course not. We should not have to give our money to someone who's lifestyle violates our laws. If someone wants to live in a polygamos marriage ( or a drugged stated as per my example ) they should move somewhere were it is an amazing thing called [i]legal[/i]. If I want to support refugess ( a noble cause ) I will do by donating to a charity that helps them, which is not the government. Edited February 4, 2008 by HeavenlyCalling
cathoholic_anonymous Posted February 4, 2008 Posted February 4, 2008 [quote name='HeavenlyCalling' post='1455492' date='Feb 4 2008, 11:12 PM']The people of the United States should not have to support anyone. That is the responsibility of charitable organizations. Drug distribution is legal someplaces, should the taxpayers support addicts who got addicted were it was legal? Of course not. We should not have to give our money to someone who's lifestyle violates our laws. If someone wants to live in a polygamos marriage ( or a drugged stated as per my example ) they should move somewhere were it is an amazing thing called [i]legal[/i]. If I want to support refugess ( a noble cause ) I will do by donating to a charity that helps them, which is not the government.[/quote] The trouble is that too many needy people would fall through the net if charitable organisations were solely responsible for their welfare, partly because clusters of many different charities all over the place could never be as effective in administrative terms as a central government and partly because the donations that these charities would require in order to fund their work would be HUGE. People just aren't generous enough to maintain that kind of system, especially as charitable giving is anonymous. The sad fact is that most people won't give enough unless they're made to give enough, i.e. through taxes. Personally, I don't have a problem with this, as I see it my duty as a citizen to help as many people as possible in the most effective way possible. Supporting people through charities still wouldn't reduce the number of swindlers out there, so that isn't really a valid concern.
Deb Posted February 5, 2008 Posted February 5, 2008 From the USCCB on Forming Consciences: [font="TimesNewRomanMS"][left]The right to life implies and is linked to other human rights—to the basic goods that[/left] [left]every human person needs to live and thrive. All the life issues are connected, for erosion of[/left] [left]respect for the life of any individual or group in society necessarily diminishes respect for all[/left] [left]life. The moral imperative to respond to the needs of our neighbors—basic needs such as food,[/left] [left]shelter, health care, education, and meaningful work—is universally binding on our consciences[/left] [left]and may be legitimately fulfilled by a variety of means. Catholics must seek the best ways to[/left] [left]respond to these needs. As Blessed Pope John XXIII taught, “[each of us] [/font][font="Times-Roman"]has the right to life, to[/left] [left]bodily integrity, and to the means which are suitable for the proper development of life; these are[/left] [left]primarily food, clothing, shelter, rest, medical care, and, finally, [b]the necessary social services[/b][/font][font="TimesNewRomanMS"][b]”[/b][/left] [/font]
Deb Posted February 5, 2008 Posted February 5, 2008 [quote name='HeavenlyCalling' post='1455492' date='Feb 4 2008, 05:12 PM']The people of the United States should not have to support anyone. That is the responsibility of charitable organizations. Drug distribution is legal someplaces, should the taxpayers support addicts who got addicted were it was legal? Of course not. We should not have to give our money to someone who's lifestyle violates our laws. If someone wants to live in a polygamos marriage ( or a drugged stated as per my example ) they should move somewhere were it is an amazing thing called [i]legal[/i]. If I want to support refugess ( a noble cause ) I will do by donating to a charity that helps them, which is not the government.[/quote] I think you maybe should rethink your screen name. I certainly hope that in your life you do not find yourself injured, with no family and unable to work again. I hope you never have a severly handicapped child who outlives you, I hope you never go blind and find yourself alone. None of us have one iota of control about our lives past this second (and that second is gone) so we could all end up praying that there is still a safety net in this country that goes beyond reliance on the kindess of others. Kindness that seems to be slowly eliminating itself from society as a whole.
HeavenlyCalling Posted February 5, 2008 Posted February 5, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1455583' date='Feb 4 2008, 10:24 PM']I think you maybe should rethink your screen name. I certainly hope that in your life you do not find yourself injured, with no family and unable to work again. I hope you never have a severly handicapped child who outlives you, I hope you never go blind and find yourself alone. None of us have one iota of control about our lives past this second (and that second is gone) so we could all end up praying that there is still a safety net in this country that goes beyond reliance on the kindess of others. Kindness that seems to be slowly eliminating itself from society as a whole.[/quote] Thank you for saying this. I read back over my post and realized that it did sound very harsh. It certainly was not meant to sound like this, please understand that a faceless medium like the computer does not always translate my feelings as well as I would like. I simply meant to say that no one should be forced to pay for something that is not legal in the country that we live in, and there are many countries in the world in which it is legal, I dont think that it is fair to anyone involved. I do think the welfare sytem needs to be totally reformed and I have no problem supporting people who ligitimatly need help. However, too many people cheat the system in this day and age, and it is a topic that I get perhaps to passionate about. Again, please forgive the fact that my original post sounded much harder than it was meant to.
Deb Posted February 5, 2008 Posted February 5, 2008 [quote name='HeavenlyCalling' post='1455609' date='Feb 4 2008, 10:02 PM']Thank you for saying this. I read back over my post and realized that it did sound very harsh. It certainly was not meant to sound like this, please understand that a faceless medium like the computer does not always translate my feelings as well as I would like. I simply meant to say that no one should be forced to pay for something that is not legal in the country that we live in, and there are many countries in the world in which it is legal, I dont think that it is fair to anyone involved. I do think the welfare sytem needs to be totally reformed and I have no problem supporting people who ligitimatly need help. However, too many people cheat the system in this day and age, and it is a topic that I get perhaps to passionate about. Again, please forgive the fact that my original post sounded much harder than it was meant to.[/quote] Certainly understood. I have been there many times. It is very hard to translate ones feelings on a computer especially when one is passionate about them. I now understand what you were trying to convey. I also agree with a lot of it. I have worked in social services for 27 years and I have a constant love/hate relationship with the clients. So many deserving, many undeserving and many so lost that they could never make it in the world on their own. I am not sure where that family could have ended up. I believe they were Somalian refugees. I was freaked myself when I saw we had two wives involved. That is the only case I have seen in all the years that we have been taking in somalian refugees and hopefully it will not become a norm.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now