twf Posted February 23, 2004 Posted February 23, 2004 (edited) undercovera, I'll be praying for you as well. I think it's a miracle...the work of the Spirit...that you are willing to resist your sexual desires. There are many cases where homosexuals have later, with the help of Christ, married a member of the opposite sex, after confronting their sinful lifestyle. I'm not saying this will be the case with you...perhaps, like you said, God has celibacy in store for you (which is something the Apostle Paul spoke VERY high of, see 1 Corinthians 7). I disagree with Smeagol. It is true that God creates us, and that God would not creat us flawed...but because we live in a fallen world, and because we are the seed of sinful/fallen Adam...God allows corruptions (like cancer in an infant) to seep in, but always for a purpose (though it wouldn't happen at all in a perfect world). The Bible tells us that we are conceived in sin (Ps 51:5). We are not sinners when we are conceived, for we have not yet sinned...but we do inherit a sinful nature from Adam---a tendency to sin. (See Romans 5:12-20). We are born spiritually dead because of our first parents...we need to be regenerated by the Spirit when we receive the sacrament of baptism. Anyway, regarding the root of your homosexual tendencies, there is an interesting article you may want to read found at http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/...9n1_homosex.asp. (This isn't a Catholic site...it's Evangelical Protestant, but it's still a good article!) Edited February 23, 2004 by twf
Good Friday Posted February 23, 2004 Posted February 23, 2004 lundercovera writes: i don't just want lust, i want love. and i know that homosexual love is inherently disordered and unnatural and i could never seek it out, but my only temptation is not just lust, but desire for love. I know what you meant by this, but I wanted to clarify. Love is never disordered. Homosexual sex is disordered, but love can never be disordered. Even homosexual love is not disordered, in my opinion, as long as it is not expressed in a disordered way -- i.e. through homosexual sex. In other words, I believe it is entirely possible to love someone of the same sex romantically and those feelings not be disordered, provided that you don't express those feelings through disordered means. This is not to say that I'm encouraging a non-sexual homosexual relationship. Disordered or not, it would still be an occasion to sin and just not a good idea. I'm just saying that I don't think romantic love for someone of the same sex is inherently disordered, nor do I think the Church teaches that. The catechism does not refer to homosexual love as disordered, but it does refer to homosexual acts as disordered. There is a difference. I make this distinction because I believe that love is supernatural, and thus that the laws of nature don't necessarily apply to it. For instance, it is not natural for one to love God so much that one chooses to be celibate. The natural order is for one to be fruitful and multiply. In some sense, celibacy could be considered disordered, because it isn't in line with the natural order. Unlike homosexual sex, though, celibacy is an approved "disorder" because it can lead to greater love for God and humanity, and greater service to both. Homosexual sex never leads to these ends. I could be off on some of this, but it seems to me that it's best to refer to homosexual sex as disordered, but possibly not to refer to homosexual feelings of love as disordered. But I could be wrong. If I am, I submit to the authority of the Mystical Body of Christ, and I hope if someone knows me to be wrong on this they'll correct me.
Guest lundercovera Posted February 23, 2004 Posted February 23, 2004 thanx for the insight nathan. But I could be wrong. If I am, I submit to the authority of the Mystical Body of Christ, i'm glad you're obedience is so strong! keep it up anyway, it's all kinda confusing. if i were to fall in love with a boy, i wouldn't want a non-sexual romantic relationship of course cuz it'd be a matter of sin. but if homosexual love isn't disordered, which it seems not to be because love would not be disordered, how is it to be expressed? a buddy type relationship, not romantic? is that what the Catechism means by "disinterested" friendships..? i wouldn't call celibacy "disordered" nor even "unnatural" rather "supernatural" or "extra-ordered" hehe now i'm makin up words. just because something isn't natural or in the natural order doesn't make it unatural, cuz with celibacy it is more of a hyperelevated form of the natural order, fathering many spiritual children, having a faith that is fruitful and multiplies among your congregation. it is keeping with the natural order on a higher level, so supernatural describes it better i think. a homosexual inclination is refered to as objectively disordered (CCC 2358) so i would venture to say homosexual romantic relationships would be disordered, but true love for one of the same sex is not disordered, but it is most often shown through disordered means. love for one of the same sex is a product of something disorderd that is beyond control, but the love itself cannot be disordered, it just should not be shown in a disordered way, ie by a romantic relationship. is that right? :cool:
Good Friday Posted February 24, 2004 Posted February 24, 2004 lundercovera writes: but if homosexual love isn't disordered, which it seems not to be because love would not be disordered, how is it to be expressed? "Greater love than this no man hath, that a man lay down is life for his friend." - John 15:13. I think that, at least in my case, the best way to express love for another man that I may feel for romantically is to be his friend in Christ, but to never allow myself to get close enough that either he or I would sin -- even if this meant eventually having to distance myself from him. All real love is rooted in sacrifice, and an authentic expression of this kind of love would also have to be rooted in sacrifice. At least, it seems that way to me. St. Paul tells us that "charity is patient, is kind: charity envieth not, dealeth not perversely, is not puffed up, is not ambitious, seeketh not her own, is not provoked to anger, thinketh no evil: rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth with the truth: beareth all things, believeth all things, hopeth all things, endureth all things" (1 Cor 13:4-7). (Sorry about the "eths," I prefer the Douay-Rheims Bible because I believe it's closer to the Vulgate. The downside is that it's very old, and has a lot of "eths" and such, but such is necessary until modern people decide to get as close to the Vulgate without the "eths"). Anyway, the point is that real love -- the supernatural kind of love, God's love, charity -- is not self-serving in any way. It's the kind of love that Jesus showed on the Cross. Real love embraces the Cross. Real love concerns itself with others before one's self. So basically, real love would not allow another person to become an occasion to sin, first of all because this objectifies the person, and second of all because it endangers not only your soul, but the other person's soul. Consider this: You have a friend that you're attracted to or have fallen in love with. You go to play basketball with said friend. He takes off his shirt, and this causes you to lust after him. This causes you to sin. Not only does this sin damage your soul and your relationship with God, but he (your friend) may also be somewhat culpable for having removed the shirt, especially if he knows how you feel. This may seem miniscule, but it isn't. Depending on how much you dwell on the lust, whether or not it's in passing or you let yourself focus on it, it is at least a venial sin and may be a mortal sin. In other words, you have either hurt your relationship with God (venial sin) or separated yourself from God (mortal sin). And depending upon his culpability, he may have committed at least a venial sin by leading you into temptation. Two relationships with God damaged. This is not love in the Catholic sense, though it may seem like love in the world's sense of the word. Real love would say things like this to you: "Maybe I shouldn't see him until I can get my feelings under control, since I don't want to hurt my relationship with God or his." If this isn't going through your head, then (in my layperson opinion), this is not real love in the Catholic sense, and it certainly isn't charity. Scripture and Tradition make clear that authentic love and authentic expressions of love are rooted in sacrifice. We see authentic expressions of love in the examples of St. Maximilian Kolbe, Bl. Mother Teresa, and of course Christ Himself is the greatest example. Real love concerns itself above all with yours and others' relationships with God, and second of all with the well-being of others -- the physical, mental, emotional and spiritual well-being of others. The true test, not just for homosexuals but for anyone, is whether or not what you feel is "love" is self-serving. If it's more self-serving than selfless, then it very likely is not really love. If it's a sacrificing kind of love, the kind of love that Christ, His Blessed Mother, and the saints have shown, then it probably is real love. There is a litmus test. Love doesn't have to be this abstract concept that brings on fluffy bunny feelings. I doubt Mother Teresa was having fluffy bunnies as she cared for lepers in Calcutta. Nevertheless, no one can deny that what she was doing was one of the highest forms of love. I believe that love is not just a feeling, but a state of being. To conclude, I think homosexual love should be expressed as any love should be expressed: in a sacrificial, selfless manner. I think any means of expressing love that is not sacrificial and selfless is a "disordered" expression of love -- and that doesn't just apply to homosexuals, but to everyone.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now